The 2008 All-Former New York Mets Team

Dan SiegelSenior Analyst IApril 14, 2008

What does one do when the New York Metropolitans just got done getting slapped around by the Brew Crew and then is stuck watching a Yankees-Rays game on a Monday evening?

Go through all of the MLB rosters and search for former Mets and see where everybody is, of course, and then make a team out of it. 

This exercise does have its purpose.

Are the 2008 Mets better than the 2006 and 2007 versions?

Did the trade of those fine prospects work out?

What about the prospects the Mets got back after dealing a veteran?

The criterion was that the players had to be on a 40-man roster or disabled list as of this past weekend.  Free agents or players mulling retirement were not considered.

The players did not have to suit up for the Mets at any point.  As long as they were Met property at some point, there are eligible.

The team is assembled for 2008 only.  Guys like Carlos Gomez and Phil Humber, whose best years may be well ahead of them are not on there.

Players were kept at their position as indicated by with the exception of the shortstop position, which had no former Mets listed (at least to this writer’s knowledge).

More thought was given to finding the best offensive player at each position rather than trying to construct a logical lineup or consider where offense could be sacrificed for defense.

And without further adieu, the 2008 former Mets…

The bench:

C – Johnny Estrada

IF/Utility – Marco Scutaro

IF/Utility – Jeff Keppinger

OF – Gary Matthews, Jr.


The starting position players:


C – Paul LoDuca

1B – Mike Jacobs

2B – Kaz Matsui

SS – Ruben Gotay (listed as 2B)

3B – Melvin Mora

LF – Jay Payton

CF – Mike Cameron

RF – Cliff Floyd/Xavier Nady (platoon)


The starting rotation:


LHP - Scott Kazmir

RHP - A.J. Burnett

LHP - Tom Glavine

LHP - Mike Hampton

RHP - Brian Bannister


The bullpen:


Setup Man – Heath Bell

Righty Specialist – Chad Bradford

Closer – Jason Isringhausen

Middle Relief – Matt Lindstrom

Middle Relief – Dan Wheeler

Long Man – Darren Oliver

Lefty Specialist – Royce Ring


There you have it folks, the 2008 former Mets.


The real 2008 Mets have a much stronger starting lineup, offensively and defensively than the formers. 


The bench is fairly comparable, possibly with the formers having the edge considering that one of Nady or Floyd would be on the bench also (of course one could be in left and one in right, with Payton on the bench).


The starting rotation for the formers features four guys who are dealing with, or probably will deal with, injuries throughout the year in Kazmir, Burnett, Glavine, and Hampton. 


Bannister, aside from the injury that ended his Met tenure, has been healthy and effective for Kansas City.  If all five were healthy, it would be solid. 


Sound familiar?


The bullpen for the formers is not overwhelming, but not horrible either. 


Heilman at his best, Sosa at his best, and a healthy Sanchez are a better setup crew than the formers.  Bradford is more reliable at this point in his career than Joe Smith, but health is always a question for Bradford. 


Ring is not nearly as good as Feliciano, but what should the Mets have expected in return for an ineffective, over-the-hill Robert Alomar.


Closers are closers. Can’t live with ‘em, wish we could do without  ‘em.



    Jay Bruce Has Some Tricks Up His Sleeve

    New York Mets logo
    New York Mets

    Jay Bruce Has Some Tricks Up His Sleeve

    New York Post
    via New York Post

    Turner (Broken Wrist) Likely Out Until May

    MLB logo

    Turner (Broken Wrist) Likely Out Until May

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report

    Why Young Players May Increasingly Jump at Long-Term Offers

    MLB logo

    Why Young Players May Increasingly Jump at Long-Term Offers

    Buster Olney

    Machado Explains His Move to Shortstop

    MLB logo

    Machado Explains His Move to Shortstop

    Jerry Crasnick