Was Matt Harvey's Effort the Most Dominant Near-Perfect Game in MLB History?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Was Matt Harvey's Effort the Most Dominant Near-Perfect Game in MLB History?
Nick Laham/Getty Images

There have been some pretty dominant pitching performances over the years.

From shutouts, to no-hitters to perfect games, there have been performances that have truly made us stop and think to ourselves, was this the best ever? After Tuesday night's performance against the Chicago White Sox, Mets pitcher Matt Harvey has put himself in to that conversation.

As a former team mate of Harvey's at Fitch High School in Groton, Connecticut, I, along with the entire area, had the opportunity to see some of the most dominating performances the state of Connecticut had ever seen. But Harvey's performance on Tuesday night makes his dominance as a teenager look like child's play (no pun intended).

The real question now is whether or not Harvey's near-perfection was the most dominating near-perfect game in MLB history? Harvey has his fair share of supporters as made evident by the firestorm that erupted on Twitter after the game:

Gooden has been a big supporter of Harvey's all season, but tonight made just about everyone in the world a true believer of the tremendous talent the right-hander truly has:

Again, most everyone knew about the talent that Harvey had, but where exactly does this rank amongst other near-perfect games? Well, thanks to ESPN and the Elias Sports Bureau  Harvey's game can be measured amongst only two other performances since 1900 where a pitcher went nine or more innings with one or fewer hits and 12 or more strikeouts:

Pool/Getty Images

But there is something that puts Harvey above the two great performances by Ryan and Johnson. The Elias Sports Bureau goes on to point out that Harvey is the only pitcher in the modern era to pitch nine innings with at least 12 strikeouts while allowing no walks and only one hit, only to wind up with a no-decision.

Those names belong to two of the greatest pitchers of all time, so being included in that company alone is a testimony of just how impressive Harvey was on Tuesday. Many will try and site Yu Darvish's performance against the Houston Astros this season as one of the best near-perfect games of all-time, but even Darvish's performance doesn't quite measure up to Harvey's.

Rick Yeatts/Getty Images

Sure, Darvish had more strikeouts than Harvey, but Darvish was facing a Houston Astro's team that may go down as one of the worst teams in MLB history. Secondly, Darvish was up 3-0 in the 7th inning, 5-0 in the 8th inning and 7-0 in the final frame. Finally, Darvish was pulled after giving up a hit in the bottom of the ninth with 111 pitches (78 strikes).

Harvey on the other hand was facing a very dangerous lineup in the Chicago White Sox, and at no point had a lead. Harvey wasn't just trying to make history, he was trying to keep a very silent Mets offense in the game. As for pitch count, Harvey finished with 105 pitches (76 strikes) and was able to finish his ninth inning.

When it comes down to it, Harvey just pitched one of the three greatest near-perfect games in major league history. Sure, he didn't come out with the victory, but that was never part of Harvey's mentality. He has always been team first, and would have been much more upset about losing the game than losing his perfect game.

Was Matt Harvey's Performance the Greatest Near-Perfect Game in MLB History?

Submit Vote vote to see results

At this point, all everyone can do is just sit back and think of just how special Harvey's performance was on Tuesday night. There is one person who won't be, however; Matt Harvey. He'll be too busy thinking about how he can be better, and how he can help his team win on Sunday against the Pirates.

Follow New York Mets from B/R on Facebook

Follow New York Mets from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

New York Mets

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.