If he's healthy enough to play at the end of the season and into the playoffs, he should.
Shut him down. The Bulls have only 14 games left on their regular-season schedule...The Bulls look like a one-and-done team without Rose; with him, still rusty and maybe on a slightly longer minutes leash, they could push it to the second round. That is not worth it.
That's far too pessimistic an approach.
Should Rose play, if he's able?
Rose and the Bulls have been incredibly conservative and patient in their approach to his ACL injury, which is certainly laudable. In this day and age when athletes like Adrian Peterson are recovering from similar injuries in record time with fantastic results, it would be easy to press the issue.
Rose hasn't pressed, and the Bulls have been supportive of his decision. Both parties have shown wisdom in this process, but if he's ready to play, there's no reason to hold him back.
Rose recently told ESPNChicago.com's Nick Friedell, "Nobody knows but God," regarding when he'll return to action.
According to Friedell's report, Rose is battling through some general soreness, and he hasn't experienced any setbacks related to his knee injury from last year.
Neither Rose nor the Bulls has offered any timetable for his return, and in the end, he may not play at all the rest of the season or in the playoffs. That said, it would be illogical for the team to shut him down if he is healthy enough to return.
Even if Rose is rusty—even if he takes a handful of games to work out the kinks—the Bulls are a better team with him than without him.
Can the Bulls make a deep run with Rose back in the lineup?
Aschburner doesn't seem to think the Bulls have any chance to make a deep run in the playoffs no matter if he plays or not, but that by no means precludes the team from proving him wrong.
If Rose, his doctors and the team deem him ready to play, he needs to play.
Any other course of action would be unacceptable.
Follow me on Twitter @JesseReed78