Michigan Football: Gardner Was Great Against Minnesota, Can't Replace Robinson

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Michigan Football: Gardner Was Great Against Minnesota, Can't Replace Robinson
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images
Devin Gardner was great, but Denard Robinson is Denard Robinson.

He's just over 70 percent of the Michigan Wolverines' offense, a two-time preseason Heisman candidate, an All-American, and Big Ten Offensive Player of the Year.

He can't be replaced.

Despite a praiseworthy debut as a starter Saturday against Minnesota, Devin Gardner can't simply assume the role of Denard Robinson, the unquestioned and unmatched force behind Michigan's offense for the past three seasons.

Gardner completed 12 of 18 passes for 234 yards, threw a pair of touchdowns (ran for one) and made Robinson-like plays while the real Robinson rested his right elbow on the sidelines during the Wolverines' 35-13 trouncing of the Gophers in Minneapolis.

It wasn't expected, but it was welcome. Gardner wasn't supposed to burst on the scene as a star quarterback during his first collegiate start; he was supposed to simply manage the game and give Michigan a dual-threat while Robinson sat out Saturday.

Should Gardner take over as quarterback?

Submit Vote vote to see results

Sure, Gardner impressed. But he's not Michigan's answer on offense; he's not the Missing Link, nor is he better-suited as quarterback than as receiver. There is a reason why he didn't earn the starting job, and it's because Robinson is a better overall athlete, an athlete who provides plenty of fireworks each week.

But after Gardner's thrilling debut, college football followers began filling message boards with pro-Gardner comments, saying that he should be the quarterback. Radio shows, TV, pundits across several media platforms are pouring it on thick about how Gardner rocketed to instant stardom.

That's not only a superior example of a knee-jerk reaction, but it's also too laughable of an idea to entertain.

Devin Gardner was impressive Saturday in a win over Minnesota.

Replace Robinson? Right now? Really?

Gardner was great, but let's be honest here: He's an insurance plan while Robinson recovers. That's it.

The Wolverines are still in great shape in the Big Ten Legends Division race. Nebraska's last-second win over Michigan State didn't help their cause, but the Wolverines (6-3, 4-1) aren't exactly scrambling to stay afloat.

Pulling "Shoelace" for Gardner wouldn't only change the way the offense ran—probably not too much, though—it would take the best athlete on the field out of his element. There is no reason to work in Robinson—who has had a record-setting and shattering career—so that Gardner fits better, no matter how dazzling of a first time Gardner had.

It's the other way around, Michigan works around Robinson.

 

Follow Bleacher Report's Michigan Wolverines football writer Adam Biggers on Twitter @AdamBiggers81

Load More Stories

Follow Michigan Wolverines Football from B/R on Facebook

Follow Michigan Wolverines Football from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Michigan Wolverines Football

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.