Biggest Winners and Losers

B/R's Official CFB Top 25

Nick Saban Comparing Denard Robinson to Cam Newton Is Just Saban Being Saban

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Nick Saban Comparing Denard Robinson to Cam Newton Is Just Saban Being Saban
Leon Halip/Getty Images

Alabama head coach Nick Saban made some waves earlier this week when he compared Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson—his Week 1 opponent, if you hadn't heard—to former Auburn QB and Heisman Trophy winner Cam Newton.

Yes, we can see you cringing and balking already, readers.

But while Saban didn't come right out and say "their skill sets are exactly the same and we will prepare for them the exact same way," what he did say (per al.com) was close enough that comparisons are being invited here:

"Offensively, they have probably as significant a player as we've played against maybe since Cam Newton in terms of the quarterback position, in terms of what he can do in the game, in the offense and how the offense is sort of built around and features him as a player.

Who would you rather have at quarterback?

Submit Vote vote to see results

Now, as Barrett Sallee at the SEC Blog pointed out, the limited scope of the comparison that Saban specifically mentioned is accurate: The Michigan offense features Denard Robinson and is pretty well-built around him (especially if RB Fitz Toussaint isn't going to play, but if we're all being honest with ourselves, he will).

Sallee also pointed out that despite being dual-threat QBs, Robinson and Newton are much, much different as actual players—to the point where it's nearly impossible to make a serious comparison of the two.

But, of course, the analogy breaks down under close scrutiny, because every comparison between two things eventually breaks down if you look hard enough for differences—and let's be honest, you don't have to look too hard past "is a heavily-used quarterback" to find differences between Robinson and Newton.

Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

No, this was just Nick Saban being Nick Saban: an overly cautionary head coach who wants to remind everyone that'll listen to him that Alabama is in for a serious challenge on Saturday.

For all you can say about Saban and his fiery temper, when it comes to press conferences, he isn't anywhere near the same guy we see on the sidelines every weekend (or especially that players see during practice over the course of the week). He's calm, smart and measured with his words, ever careful not to say something that doesn't merit saying.

Further, the fact that he brought up Newton is more of a dog whistle of sorts than something to be taken as a face-value comparison.

Remember, Saban only faced Newton as a starting quarterback once: a No. 9 Alabama vs. No. 2 Auburn showdown where the Tide opened up a 21-0 lead then watched helplessly as Newton led Auburn back on a furious rally to take the game and solidify its spot in the SEC Championship (and then the BCS Championship). 

Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

So what Saban's saying as much as anything else is that Alabama needs to worry about playing a full game and not letting up on its pressure on Robinson for the entire 60 minutes. He's seen one do-everything QB crush him with a comeback once, and he's not interested in seeing it happen again.

Load More Stories

Follow Michigan Wolverines Football from B/R on Facebook

Follow Michigan Wolverines Football from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Out of Bounds

Michigan Wolverines Football

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.