Featured Video
2027 World Series Odds Are Here šŸ‘€

SF Giants: Could Roger Kieschnick and Nick Noonan Provide Help from Fresno?

Matt David
Jun 1, 2018

The Giants will spend the next few days drafting guys that I've never heard of. Ā Those guys will flail away in the minor leagues for a few years until they either disappear forever or become the September call-up I've never heard of. Ā Due to injury and incompetence this season, the line between Fresno and San Francisco has been blurred, especially in the infield. Ā 

Joaquin Arias, Charlie Culberson, Conor Gillaspie and Eric Hacker have all had a cup of tea with the big team. Ā Other guys, like Brandon Crawford, Manny Burris, Brett Pill and Hector Sanchez, are Giants farmhands who've been forced into significant roles due to lack of depth at their respective positions. Ā Is there anyone left? Ā Or has the farm system been sufficiently raided? Ā 

When glancing down the Fresno roster, a few things pop out. Ā First, Todd Linden? Ā Like, the Todd Linden? Was not expecting that. Ā Secondly, there are a few guys having stellar first halves. Ā It's likely that at some point they will be forced into service at the major league level. Ā Unless, of course, you think that Theriot guy is the future. Ā I just don't see it. Ā 

Roger Kieschnick and Nick Noonan. Ā Names that might ring a bell for Giants scouting nerds everywhere. These top picks, who have weaved their way through the system, are approaching their "best by" Ā date, and may be able to contribute this year. Ā 

Roger Kieschnick: Age 25, Outfielder

1 of 2

Kieschnick was drafted in the third round of the 2008 draft, the same draft that produced current regulars Buster Posey and Brandon Crawford, and to a lesser extent Conor Gillaspie. Ā Unlike his comrades, however, Kieschnick has been unable to avoid the injury bug. Ā He suffered from constant lower back problems over the last two seasons, and recently was sent back to the DL after injuring his shoulder tracking down a fly ball. Ā 

Before the injury, however, Kieschnick was finally showing major league potential. Ā Through 51 games, he was hitting .319/.390/.623 with 14 HR and 12 doubles. Ā By far the most polished power threat in the system, Kieschnick could provide a skill that the major league club is severely lacking. Ā On the downside, he's averaged about a strikeout every four at bats throughout his career, a weakness that could keep him from everyday playing time down the road. Ā 

To get a good gauge of Kieschnick's potential, look no farther than Giants eternal fourth outfielder Nate Schierholtz, a left-handed bat with solid pop and average defense. Ā While a Nate Schierholtz comparison won't blow anyone's socks off, an extra outfield bat off the bench could prove valuable if any of the three current starters were to go down. Ā And though Kieschnick has no experience at first base, the position isn't exactly locked down. Ā Bruce Bochy would likely start Tim Flannery at first if he showed he could hit. Ā 

The current outfield is packed with the emergence of Gregor Blanco, but look for Kieschnick to make a debut sometime this season in the event of an injury; September at the latest. Ā Ā 

Nick Noonan: Age 23, Infielder

2 of 2

Opportunities abound if you are a middle infielder in the Giants' system. Ā I'm hoping for open tryouts so I can give it a shot myself.Ā  Nick Noonan, a career .259 hitter before 2012, picked the right time to get hot. Ā With Freddy Sanchez still suffering setbacks, Manny Burris likely winding down his Giants career and Ryan Theriot a less than stellar fill-in, second base remains wide open.

I'm willing to keep the jury out on Brandon Crawford at shortstop, but his spot is less than secure. Ā Heck, even first base is an open competition. Ā Anyone and everyone welcome to apply. Ā 

In his first full year at Fresno, Noonan seems to finally be getting it. Ā He's hitting .305 with 28 RBI in 50 games. Ā Once compared by Baseball America to Phillies superstar Chase Utley, Noonan is finally crawling back onto the prospect map. Ā With the low threshold for success at second base this season, the Giants may be willing to give Noonan a look before dealing more prospects for a midseason acquisition. Ā 

Originally thought to be a power/speed type, Noonan has shown a curious lack of both over the last three years. Ā His defense remains solid however, and with more confidence, he could become an offensive improvement over the current Theriot/Burris combination. Ā 

Noonan seems a more likely option than Kieschnick at this point, if only because of the lack of competition. Ā In either case, you never know who might make an impact at the big league level. Ā Look for these two guys to get the next chance. Ā