I felt that I should include a coach because coaches are part of the team too.
But everyone hated Arians, right? No, that's not true.
Arians wasn't the worst offensive coordinator the team has ever had (I'd give that to Ron Erhardt), but he might be the most polarizing. There were people, like myself, that felt like the offense massively underachieved and had obvious holes (red-zone offense, play selection) during his tenure.
Here's why he's overrated. At the start of every season, a lot of analysts would get behind him and say he was the guy and that this was the year. It just never really was. 2011 was the perfect time for a breakout and the team finished 12th in offense. With all that talent, they were not even top 10.
I wish him the best of luck (pun intended) in Indianapolis, but I felt he was always overrated here by people who kept waiting for the offense to just explode into greatness.