2024 Offseason Report Cards for Every NFL Team
The 2024 NFL draft is in the past, organized team activities are set to begin, and training camps aren't all that far away. Soon, we'll be turning the page on the offseason entirely.
While free-agent signings and trades will continue to trickle through the transaction wire, teams have largely built their foundations for the coming season. That makes this a perfect time to take a big-picture look at how teams have fared thus far in the offseason.
Hirings, firings, contract extensions, signings, draft picks and trades will all be considered here. As we did with our 2023 offseason report cards, we'll also include an "extra-credit project" for each team that can improve its overall grade. This could be a particularly savvy move, smart hire or sensible offseason strategy.
Last year, for example, the Houston Texans earned bonus points for finding offensive and defensive centerpieces in the draft.
We have yet to see how moves will impact the 2024 season and beyond, so grades are based on the information we have. Teams that appear to have significantly improved their front offices and/or rosters will receive higher grades than those that overspent, lost key contributors or failed to address significant needs.
Arizona Cardinals
1 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: C Evan Brown, DL Bilal Nichols, DT Justin Jones, CB Sean Murphy-Bunting, QB Desmond Ridder, OT Jonah Williams, LB Mack Wilson, LB Krys Barnes, G Elijah Wilkinson
Key Draft Additions: WR Marvin Harrison Jr., DL Darius Robinson, CB Max Melton, RB Trey Benson
Key Departures: WR Marquise Brown, DT Leki Fotu, CB Antonio Hamilton, OT D.J. Humphries, WR Rondale Moore, LB Ezekiel Turner
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C-
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Getting Help for Kyler Murray
Overall Grade: B-
The Arizona Cardinals may have a defensive-minded coach in Jonathan Gannon, but he's looking to build his team around quarterback Kyler Murray.
"Since we came in here and started from scratch, everything we've asked of him he's went above and beyond," Gannon said, per CBS Sports' Jeff Kerr. "If you watched the tape, you know why I'm convicted."
The Cardinals took some swings at improving Murray's supporting cast this offseason, which was critical as he looks to return to Pro Bowl form.
Betting on Jonah Williams at left tackle is risky. He's never settled in as a dependable starter, especially in pass protection. However, taking Ohio State receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. with the fourth overall pick was a slam-dunk move.
Harrison was the top-ranked overall prospect on the Bleacher Report Scouting Department's final big board, and he should instantly give Murray an elite No. 1 perimeter target. Along with rookie running back Trey Benson, veteran running back James Conner and tight end Trey McBride, Harrison will help give Arizona a potent offense.
The Cardinals didn't completely ignore its 25th-ranked defense from last season, though. New additions like Sean Murphy-Bunting, Mack Wilson and rookie Darius Robinson should help Gannon's defense get on the right track.
Arizona suffered minimal losses, and the list of departures didn't feature a player who will be impossible to replace.
With $27.8 million in cap space remaining, it's fair to wonder if the Cardinals should have done more, but the roster is better on paper than it was a year ago. Most importantly, Arizona has done a solid job of setting up Murray for success.
Atlanta Falcons
2 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: QB Kirk Cousins, CB Antonio Hamilton, WR Ray-Ray McCloud, WR Darnell Mooney, WR Rondale Moore
Key Draft Additions: QB Michael Penix Jr., DL Ruke Orhorhoro, Edge Bralen Trice
Key Departures: Edge Bud Dupree, C Matt Hennessy, WR Van Jefferson, WR Mack Hollins, CB Jeff Okudah, WR Cordarrelle Patterson, QB Desmond Ridder, TE Jonnu Smith
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A-
Draft Grade: D
EC Project: Finding a Quarterback
Overall Grade: C+
Only time will tell if hiring Raheem Morris over Bill Belichick was the right move for the Atlanta Falcons. However, Belichick would have likely clashed with the current front office.
Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer reported on NBC Sports Boston that team president Rich McKay had many in the front office believing they would lose their jobs if Belichick was hired.
Morris is a seasoned coach with head coaching experience, so it's hard to be overly critical of the move. It's a lot easier to be critical of Atlanta's overall plan at quarterback.
In free agency, the Falcons added Kirk Cousins on a four-year, $180 million deal. That's a lot of money for a 35-year-old quarterback coming off a torn Achilles, but it made sense. Atlanta had the league's 11th-ranked defense last season and an offense loaded with skill-position players, but it won only seven games because of poor quarterback play.
The Falcons didn't make a lot of other significant moves early in free agency, but they filled their biggest need. That should be enough to make them a major player in the NFC South.
The confusing part came in the draft, when the Falcons used the eighth overall pick on Washington quarterback Michael Penix Jr. There's nothing wrong with having a long-term plan at quarterback, but signing Cousins was a win-now move. Drafting Penix over, say, an elite pass-rushing prospect, doesn't help the Falcons win now.
With Bud Dupree gone and Calais Campbell still unsigned, selecting an edge-rusher at No. 8 would have made sense. It's not as if Penix fell to the Falcons in Round 2 and the value was too great to ignore. They actively passed on a top prospect who could help them win now to grab the 87th-ranked overall prospect on the B/R Scouting Department's final big board.
Still, Atlanta's roster looks to be on par with last year's team, except with a notable upgrade at quarterback. That makes the offseason a net positive and should make the Falcons playoff threats in 2024.
Baltimore Ravens
3 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: RB Derrick Henry, OL Josh Jones, WR Deonte Harty, DT Justin Madubuike, CB Arthur Maulet, DE Brent Urban, Edge Kyle Van Noy
Key Draft Additions: CB Nate Wiggins, OT Roger Rosengarten, Edge Adisa Isaac
Key Departures: LB Patrick Queen, Edge Jadeveon Clowney, RB Gus Edwards, S Geno Stone, OT Morgan Moses, OG John Simpson, OG Kevin Zeitler, CB Ronald Darby
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C-
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Hiring From Within to Fill DC Vacancy
Overall Grade: B-
The Baltimore Ravens didn't enter the offseason with a ton of cap flexibility, yet they still managed to add star running back Derrick Henry and retain standout defensive lineman Justin Madubuike.
Still, Baltimore lost some significant 2023 contributors, including pass-rusher Jadeveon Clowney, linebacker Patrick Queen, guard John Simpson and guard Kevin Zeitler. The Ravens also traded starting tackle Morgan Moses to the New York Jets.
The Ravens' free-agency plan can be chalked up to cap management—retaining everyone wouldn't be possible—but we see franchises manipulate the cap every offseason to maintain or improve rosters. General manager Eric DeCosta could have done more to ensure that the Ravens don't fall off in 2024.
On a positive note, Baltimore did potentially fill some of its needs in the draft. Cornerback Nate Wiggins should quickly forge a formidable duo with Marlon Humphrey, while Roger Rosengarten will likely replace Moses at right tackle immediately.
However, the Ravens are still left with some question marks, specifically on the offensive interior. Of course, having Henry in the same backfield as Lamar Jackson might make Baltimore's offense so dynamic that it doesn't matter. A lot will hinge on Henry's production at age 30 and the Ravens rookies' ability to make an immediate impact.
We'll give Baltimore credit for promoting inside linebackers coach Zach Orr following the departure of defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald, who left to become the Seattle Seahawks' head coach. The Ravens ranked 25th in total defense in 2021, the year before they hired Macdonald. This past season, they ranked sixth in total defense and first in points allowed.
Orr should maintain some continuity defensively, which should at least keep the Ravens in the playoff picture.
.jpg?w=256 "Vikings Cowboys Football")
Buffalo Bills
4 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR Curtis Samuel, WR Mack Hollins, LB Nicholas Morrow, DL Austin Johnson, Edge Dawuane Smoot, S Mike Edwards, WR Marquez Valdes-Scantling, Edge A.J. Epenesa, DT DaQuan Jones, S Taylor Rapp
Key Draft Additions: WR Keon Coleman, S Cole Bishop, DL DeWayne Carter, RB Ray Davis
Key Departures: WR Stefon Diggs, S Jordan Poyer, C Mitch Morse, WR Gabe Davis, Edge Leonard Floyd, LB Tyrel Dodson, CB Dane Jackson, DT Tim Settle, DT Poona Ford, S Micah Hyde
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C-
Draft Grade: B
EC Project: Making the Tough Financial Decisions
Overall Grade: C+
Did the Buffalo Bills improve in free agency? They did not. Parting with standouts like Jordan Poyer, Micah Hyde, Mitch Morse, Gabe Davis, Leonard Floyd and Stefon Diggs weakened the roster, at least in the short term.
However, parting with pricey veteran talent inevitably becomes a necessary evil when teams are trying to chase a Super Bowl with an expensive quarterback.
General manager Brandon Beane had several years to build around Josh Allen and a team-friendly contract. However, Allen's cap hit jumped from $18.6 million last year to $30.4 million this season. It will further balloon to $60.7 million in 2025.
It was time for Buffalo to start trimming the financial fat.
Fortunately, Beane was able to begin reloading through the draft. Rookie receiver Keon Coleman is a very different player than Diggs, but he still has the potential to be a No. 1 target in the Bills offense.
As an overall unit, Buffalo's new-look receiving group—Coleman, Khalil Shakir, Curtis Samuel, Dalton Kincaid, Dawson Knox and Marquez Valdes-Scantling—might be more potent than last year's group. Pairing rookie Ray Davis with 2023 breakout star James Cook could give the Bills an elite rushing attack, too.
The Bills are transitioning a bit on defense. However, they did retain players like A.J. Epenesa, Taylor Rapp and DaQuan Jones while adding the likes of Mike Edwards, Cole Bishop and DeWayne Carter. A significant drop-off shouldn't be expected.
The Bills should again be an AFC threat in 2024, and they're now better positioned to keep contending over the next few years.
Carolina Panthers
5 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge Jadeveon Clowney, S Jordan Fuller, G Robert Hunt, WR Diontae Johnson, G Damien Lewis, DL A'Shawn Robinson
Key Draft Additions: WR Xavier Legette, RB Jonathon Brooks, LB Trevin Wallace
Key Departures: S Vonn Bell, C Bradley Bozeman, Edge Brian Burns, CB Donte Jackson, LB Frankie Luvu, TE Hayden Hurst
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B-
Draft Grade: C+
EC Project: Giving Bryce Young Support
Overall Grade: B
The Carolina Panthers' gamble for quarterback Bryce Young last year didn't pay immediate dividends. They gave up a package including star receiver DJ Moore and what wound up becoming the No. 1 pick in the 2024 draft for Young, who posted a dismal 73.7 passer rating as a rookie.
Helping Young turn it around must be Carolina's top priority. Fortunately, the Panthers did a much better job of supporting him this offseason than they did last year.
Last season, Young's supporting cast included wide receiver Adam Thielen and not much else. Adding wideouts Diontae Johnson and Xavier Legette and running back Jonathon Brooks will give Young more weapons to target, while new guards Damien Lewis and Robert Hunt should bolster his pass protection.
The Panthers didn't make a ton of changes defensively, though they did rank fourth in yards allowed last season. If Young and the offense substantially improve, Carolina could quickly emerge as a competitive team.
Although the Panthers' roster still looks underwhelming overall, their grade gets a major boost from the hiring of new head coach Dave Canales, who has a proven track record of helping quarterbacks improve. He helped make journeyman backup Geno Smith a Pro Bowler in 2022 and helped Baker Mayfield reach the Pro Bowl last season.
Canales might not make Carolina an instant contender, but he should help Young improve. The Panthers also retained defensive coordinator Ejiro Evero, which should create some continuity on that side of the ball.
Evero's presence should allow Canales to focus entirely on the offense and on ensuring that Young avoids the dreaded bust label in Year 2.
Chicago Bears
6 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR Keenan Allen, C Ryan Bates, S Kevin Byard III, TE Gerald Everett, C Coleman Shelton, RB D'Andre Swift, CB Jaylon Johnson, WR Dante Pettis
Key Draft Additions: QB Caleb Williams, WR Rome Odunze, OT Kiran Amegadjie
Key Departures: G Dan Feeney, QB Justin Fields, RB D'Onta Foreman, WR Darnell Mooney, DL Justin Jones, QB Nathan Peterman
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A+
Draft Grade: A
EC Project: Properly Supporting the QB
Overall Grade: A+
The Chicago Bears jettisoned quarterback Justin Fields this offseason before replacing him with No. 1 overall pick Caleb Williams. While the USC product was widely regarded as the top quarterback in the 2024 class—and a much better prospect than Fields was in 2021—simply swapping quarterbacks won't guarantee success.
Fields showed flashes of top-end potential during his three seasons, but he never fully blossomed. The Bears didn't provide him with a great supporting cast, and the quarterback never seemed to fit with former offensive coordinator Luke Getsy.
Chicago seems to have learned from its mistakes. We'll have to see how new offensive coordinator Shane Waldron meshes with Williams, but the supporting cast is better than anything Fields ever had.
Signing D'Andre Swift, adding tight end Gerald Everett and trading for Pro Bowl wideout Keenan Allen will give Williams an impressive group alongside DJ Moore, Cole Kmet and Khalil Herbert. Chicago further upgraded its skill-position corps by using the ninth overall pick on Washington receiver Rome Odunze. The Bears also bolstered their offensive line by trading for Ryan Bates and signing Matt Pryor and Coleman Shelton.
The stage is set for Williams to have an immediate chance to succeed. That could be enough to make Chicago a legitimate playoff contender in 2024.
The Bears defense showed growth throughout the 2023 season, especially after the addition of pass-rusher Montez Sweat. While Chicago did little to improve that side of the ball this offseason, retaining star cornerback Jaylon Johnson was big.
Everything will depend on Williams being as good as advertised, but it's hard not to love what the Bears have done over the past few months.
Cincinnati Bengals
7 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: OT Trent Brown, DT Sheldon Rankins, S Vonn Bell, TE Mike Gesicki, S Geno Stone, RB Zack Moss, G Cody Ford, TE Tee Higgins, WR Trenton Irwin, TE Drew Sample
Key Draft Additions: OT Amarius Mims, DL Kris Jenkins, WR Jermaine Burton
Key Departures: OT Jonah Williams, DT DJ Reader, RB Joe Mixon, CB Chidobe Awuzie, TE Irv Smith, S Nick Scott, WR Tyler Boyd
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B-
Draft Grade: B
EC Project: Not Being Complacent with the O-Line
Overall Grade: B-
The Cincinnati Bengals aren't likely to have a stronger roster in 2024 than they had last season. But if quarterback Joe Burrow can get and stay healthy, that shouldn't be a problem.
Burrow is an elite signal-caller who covers up a lot of issues in Cincinnati. Even though he was hampered by a calf injury early last season and eventually suffered a season-ending wrist injury, the Bengals still won nine games.
Most of Cincinnati's moves were of the replacement variety. The Bengals lost defensive tackle D.J. Reader but signed Sheldon Rankins and drafted Kris Jenkins. They signed Zack Moss before trading starting running back Joe Mixon. They lost right tackle Jonah Williams but signed Trent Brown and drafted Amarius Mims.
Doubling down on the tackle spot was the smartest thing the Bengals have done this offseason. Williams was never a high-level starter, and the Bengals didn't overpay to keep him. Brown is serviceable, but he's 31 years old and has a notable injury history.
Mims is a raw prospect, but he has a tremendous amount of physical upside.
"He glides in his pass sets with the range, length and natural power of a future high-level NFL pass-protector, but he needs to be coached up with his positional leverage, footwork and sustain skills," Brandon Thorn of the B/R Scouting Department wrote.
The Bengals have been tinkering with their offensive line for several years now, and they're wise to keep throwing darts at the unit. Burrow has been sacked a whopping 148 times in 52 regular-season games and has twice landed on injured reserve.
Giving Tee Higgins the franchise tag will buy Cincinnati time to figure out his future and the future of extension-eligible receiver Ja'Marr Chase. Promoting quarterbacks coach Dan Pitcher should maintain some offensive cohesion in the wake of coordinator Brian Callahan's departure to the Tennessee Titans.
The Bengals should be as good as they've been over the past few years. If they can finally protect Burrow properly, they could be even better.
Cleveland Browns
8 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR Jerry Jeudy, DT Quinton Jefferson, LB Jordan Hicks, RB D'Onta Foreman, QB Tyler Huntley, LB Devin Bush, QB Jameis Winston, G Michael Dunn, DT Shelby Harris, DT Maurice Hurst, S Rodney McLeod Jr.
Key Draft Additions: DL Mike Hall Jr., IOL Zak Zinter, WR Jamari Thrash
Key Departures: QB Joe Flacco, LB Anthony Walker Jr., LB Sione Takitaki, TE Harrison Bryant, C Nick Harris
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B
Draft Grade: B-
EC Project: Working on a Budget
Overall Grade: B
The Cleveland Browns entered the offseason with limited cap space, due in no small part to Deshaun Watson's $63.8 million cap hit. However, general manager Andrew Berry was able to retain players and address needs on a budget.
While the Browns didn't make a ton of headline-grabbing additions, they did strengthen the receiver room by acquiring Jerry Jeudy via a trade with the Denver Broncos. They also added some quarterback depth by adding Tyler Huntley and Jameis Winston. Given the injury issues Cleveland had last season, that upgraded depth shouldn't be discounted.
The Browns also added linebacker Jordan Hicks, running back D'Onta Foreman and defensive lineman Quinton Jefferson while retaining the likes of Michael Dunn, Shelby Harris and Maurice Hurst.
Though Berry wasn't equipped with a first-round pick—also due to the acquisition of Watson—he did solid work over draft weekend. Rookie defensive tackle Mike Hall Jr could make an immediate impact, while guard Zak Zinter figures to be an eventual replacement for either Joel Bitonio or Wyatt Teller.
Cleveland's losses have been minimal. While it would have been nice to re-sign Joe Flacco after he guided the Browns to an unlikely 2023 playoff berth, the additions of Winston and Huntley provide plenty of insurance.
Really, the only questionable move the Browns made was replacing offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt with fired Buffalo Bills coordinator Ken Dorsey. The offense was more than functional despite starting five different quarterbacks in 2023, though head coach Kevin Stefanski is the play-caller.
Cleveland faces a daunting 2024 schedule, and getting back to the postseason won't be easy. If the Browns can mostly stay healthy, though—especially if star running back Nick Chubb can return to some semblance of his pre-injury form—they can make it happen.
Dallas Cowboys
9 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: RB Ezekiel Elliott, LB Eric Kendricks, RB Rico Dowdle, OT Chuma Edoga, CB Jourdan Lewis
Key Draft Additions: OT Tyler Guyton, Edge Marshawn Kneeland, IOL Cooper Beebe
Key Departures: Edge Dorance Armstrong, C Tyler Biadasz, DL Neville Gallimore, WR Michael Gallup, DL Johnathan Hankins, RB Tony Pollard, OT Tyron Smith
Free Agency, Trade Grade: F
Draft Grade: B-
EC Project: Drafting to Fill Immediate Needs
Overall Grade: F
The Dallas Cowboys won 12 games in 2023 but fell flat in the postseason. Their reward for winning the NFC East was an embarrassing home loss to the Green Bay Packers in the Wild Card Round.
Although team owner Jerry Jones declared that the Cowboys are "all-in" on the 2024 season, this team is not better than it was a few months ago. In fact, it's decidedly worse.
Dallas was virtually inactive early in free agency. It re-signed role players like running back Rico Dowdle and cornerback Jourdan Lewis, but it also watched key contributors like Tyron Smith, Dorance Armstrong, Jonathan Hankins and Tony Pollard walk out the door.
The Cowboys' lone acquisition before the draft was linebacker Eric Kendricks. Dallas did bring back Ezekiel Elliott following the draft, but that's hardly an inspiring addition after he averaged a career-low 3.5 yards per carry with the New England Patriots last year.
The best thing we can say about the Cowboys' offseason is that they drafted to fill obvious needs. Rookie tackle Tyler Guyton and rookie guard Cooper Beebe should immediately vie for starting spots, while Marshawn Kneeland should step in as a rotational third pass-rusher.
The draft wasn't perfect. Guyton is an inexperienced prospect who must transition from right to left tackle, while Beebe needs to learn to play center. However, the Cowboys at least targeted players who might contribute right away. Last year, Dallas took fliers on true projects like Mazi Smith and Luke Schoonmaker, both of whom rarely saw the field as rookies.
Dallas did add a seasoned defensive coordinator in Mike Zimmer to replace the departed Dan Quinn. However, it hasn't gotten contract extensions done with Dak Prescott, Micah Parsons or CeeDee Lamb.
It certainly doesn't feel like the Cowboys are "all-in" on 2024, or on winning anything of note in the foreseeable future.
Denver Broncos
10 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge John Franklin-Myers, CB Levi Wallace, LB Cody Barton, WR Josh Reynolds, S Brandon Jones, QB Zach Wilson, FB Michael Burton, WR Lil'Jordan Humphrey, TE Adam Trautman
Key Draft Additions: QB Bo Nix, Edge Jonah Elliss, WR Troy Franklin
Key Departures: QB Russell Wilson, WR Jerry Jeudy, C Lloyd Cushenberry III, S Justin Simmons, LB Josey Jewell, DT Jonathan Harris, TE Chris Manhertz
Free Agency, Trade Grade: D+
Draft Grade: C+
EC Project: Turning the Page on Russell Wilson
Overall Grade: C
The Denver Broncos seemed to gel in the middle of the 2023 season, and they went on to win eight games after a 1-5 start. In retrospect, though, the in-season turnaround might not have been a net win for Denver.
The Broncos made the difficult decision this offseason to move on from Russell Wilson and his hefty contract, which left them with a $53 million dead cap hit. They made successive cap-saving moves like releasing Justin Simmons and trading Jerry Jeudy.
Denver managed to bring in a few replacement players in free agency, though none of them are likely to move the needle. General manager George Paton then made the bold decision to use the 12th overall pick on Oregon quarterback Bo Nix—who was ranked 61st on the B/R Scouting Department's final big board—as Denver didn't have a second-round pick and was out of range for one of the draft's top quarterback prospects.
Nix will likely compete with Jarrett Stidham and trade acquisition Zach Wilson for the starting quarterback job. There's no guarantee that the battle will yield an immediate upgrade over Wilson, though.
In all, it feels like the Broncos are destined to take a step back in 2024. However, ripping off the proverbial Band-Aid with Wilson's contract was probably the right call. His first season in Denver was a disaster, and while he improved in 2023, it never felt like he and head coach Sean Payton were going to mesh. Payton benched Wilson for Stidham last season even though the Broncos were still in wild-card contention.
Next season, Wilson's dead-cap hit will fall to a more manageable $32 million. That should give the Broncos a reasonable chance of actually improving the roster then.
Detroit Lions
11 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge Marcus Davenport, CB Carlton Davis, DL DJ Reader, G Kevin Zeitler, K Michael Badgley, G Graham Glasgow, CB Emmanuel Moseley, WR Donovan Peoples-Jones
Key Draft Additions: CB Terrion Arnold, CB Ennis Rakestraw Jr., OT Giovanni Manu
Key Departures: S C.J. Gardner-Johnson, G Jonah Jackson, DL Benito Jones, WR Josh Reynolds, S Tracy Walker III
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A+
Draft Grade: A-
EC Project: Improving the Pass Defense
Overall Grade: A
Watching the Detroit Lions transform under general manager Brad Holmes and head coach Dan Campbell has been fascinating.
Two years ago, the Lions made a late surge as an explosive offensive team that had to overcome a bad defense. While Detroit couldn't completely transform that defense in the 2023 offseason, it put a lot of effort into improving against the run.
Detroit ranked 19th in total defense last season, but it was able to complement its third-ranked offense with the league's second-ranked run defense. The result was a trip to the NFC Championship Game and a strong effort that nearly got the Lions to the Super Bowl.
While Detroit couldn't finish the job against Brock Purdy and the San Francisco 49ers in the NFC title game, it will be better equipped this year. Holmes did with the pass defense this offseason what he did with the run defense last year.
New additions like Marcus Davenport, trade acquisition Carlton Davis and rookies Terrion Arnold and Ennis Rakestraw Jr. should help Detroit field a pass defense that is at least average, if not better than average. That would be a big upgrade after it ranked 29th in net yards per pass attempt allowed in 2023.
The Lions did lose receiver Josh Reynolds, but after re-signing Graham Glasgow, replacing Jonah Jackson with Kevin Zeitler, re-signing kicker Michael Badgley and retaining wideout Donovan Peoples-Jones—who had 839 receiving yards in his last full season with the Browns—there isn't a glaring need on this roster.
After locking up both Jared Goff and Amon-Ra St. Brown with long-term deals, the Lions are poised to challenge for the franchise's first Super Bowl in 2024 and for the foreseeable future.
Green Bay Packers
12 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: RB Josh Jacobs, K Greg Joseph, S Xavier McKinney, CB Corey Ballentine, RB AJ Dillon, CB Keisean Nixon, LB Eric Wilson
Key Draft Additions: OL Jordan Morgan, LB Edgerrin Cooper, S Javon Bullard, RB MarShawn Lloyd
Key Departures: OT David Bakhtiari, LB De'Vondre Campbell, RB Aaron Jones, S Jonathan Owens, G Jon Runyan, S Darnell Savage
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B-
Draft Grade: B
EC Project: Adding Pieces to Win Now
Overall Grade: B
The Packers reached the 2023 postseason as the NFL's youngest team, thanks in no small part to a late-season surge from quarterback Jordan Love. While Love had his ups and downs early, he was playing like a top-10 quarterback by the end of the year.
If that was a sign of things to come, the future in Green Bay will be very bright.
Preparing for the future is typically the approach for the Packers and general manager Brian Gutekunst. Green Bay has traditionally used a draft-and-develop approach and rarely makes free-agent splashes. However, Gutekunst recognized that the Super Bowl window is opening and added a few potential difference-makers in Josh Jacobs and Xavier McKinney.
Jacobs has a notable injury history and might not be a clear upgrade over Aaron Jones, whom the Packers released this offseason. However, he led the league in rushing yards in 2022 and has a tremendous amount of upside. Meanwhile, McKinney is an ascending star at safety who should immediately boost the back end of the defense.
In the draft, Gutekunst seemed to focus on both the present and the future. Jordan Morgan may need some time to develop, but he can become the long-term replacement for David Bakhtiari. Javon Bullard should quickly form a strong safety tandem with McKinney, while linebacker Edgerrin Cooper and running back MarShawn Lloyd might contribute right away.
Green Bay didn't experience a ton of roster turnover this offseason, but even incremental improvement could have the Packers knocking on the door of the Super Bowl. If Love can build on his 2023 success, the Packers could be poised to kick it in.
Houston Texans
13 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: EDGE Danielle Hunter, WR Stefon Diggs, LB Azeez Al-Shaair, CB Myles Bryant, RB Joe Mixon, DL Denico Autry, CB C.J. Henderson, CB Jeff Okudah, DT Foley Fatukasi, WR Noah Brown, CB Desmond King II, RB Dare Ogunbowale, TE Dalton Schultz
Key Draft Additions: CB Kamari Lassiter, OT Blake Fisher, S Calen Bullock, TE Cade Stover
Key Departures: RB Devin Singletary, DT Maliek Collins, iOL Michael Deiter, LB Blake Cashman, EDGE Jonathan Greenard, DT Sheldon Rankins, LB Denzel Perryman
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A-
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Taking Advantage of Stroud's Rookie Contract
Overall Grade: A-
The Houston Texans were the biggest surprise in the NFL last season. After winning only 11 total games between 2020 and 2022, the Texans went 10-7, won the AFC South and then blew out the Cleveland Browns in the Wild Card Round.
Two key factors led to Houston's sudden turnaround. For one, new head coach DeMeco Ryans showed his players what it takes to win. Secondly, quarterback C.J. Stroud and pass-rusher Will Anderson Jr. both shined as rookies en route to Pro Bowl nods.
Stroud's rapid rise was the biggest surprise, as rookie quarterbacks don't always find immediate success. He had arguably the best rookie campaign we've seen from a quarterback in recent memory.
The Texans' Super Bowl window is now open, as they'll have Stroud on a rookie contract for at least the next two seasons. (He'll be extension-eligible in 2026.) General manager Nick Caserio wasted little time in maximizing the value of Stroud's rookie contract this offseason.
Houston added several quality veterans, including Danielle Hunter, Stefon Diggs, Joe Mixon, Azeez Al-Shaair, and Denico Autry. The Texans also found some potential earlier contributors in the draft despite trading away their first-round pick.
Rookie corner Kamari Lassiter, rookie tackle Blake Fisher, and rookie safety Calen Bullock could all see significant roles this season. Tight end Cade Stover should give Stroud yet another capable pass-catcher.
None of this means that the Texans should be considered the new Super Bowl favorites. There's a good chance that at least a few of the moves don't work out—we all remember how the Philadelphia Eagles 2011 "dream team" panned out. Still, we have to applaud Houston's aggressive approach.
Indianapolis Colts
14 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: DT Raekwon Davis, QB Joe Flacco, S Julian Blackmon, CB Kenny Moore II, WR Michael Pittman Jr., RB Trey Sermon
Key Draft Additions: Edge Laiatu Latu, WR Adonai Mitchell, IOL Matt Goncalves
Key Departures: QB Gardner Minshew II, RB Zack Moss, Edge Jacob Martin
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C+
Draft Grade: A
EC Project: Keeping the Team Together
Overall Grade: B
The Indianapolis Colts didn't do a lot to upgrade their roster in free agency. They didn't get worse, either, which was the entire point.
The Colts won nine games last season despite playing most of it with backup quarterback Gardner Minshew II. Had Minshew and Tyler Goodson connected on a fateful 4th-down pass against Houston in the season finale—or if had Minshew simply handed it off to Jonathan Taylor—Indy would have been playoff-bound.
The assumption is that second-year quarterback Anthony Richardson will be fully recovered from his season-ending shoulder injury and will provide an upgrade over Minshew. If the talented dual-threat can continue building on the flashes he showed in his four-game 2023 debut, that might be enough to make Indianapolis a serious postseason threat.
Therefore, the approach of general manager Chris Ballard was logical. He retained key pieces like Michael Pittman Jr., Kenny Moore II and Julian Blackmon while letting almost no critical talent exit.
Replacing Minshew with Joe Flacco has its risks—Flacco and Richardson are very different players, which could lead to schematic changes if Richardson misses time—but it did fit the budget. Minshew went on to sign a two-year, $25 million deal with the Las Vegas Raiders.
The Colts waited until the draft to try actively improving the roster, and they may have done just that. Laiatu Latu has the potential to be a difference-making pass-rusher right away, while Adonai Mitchell should partner with Pittman and Josh Downs to provide a potent receiver trio.
With $25.7 million in cap space remaining, the Colts could have done more work in free agency, and their 28th-ranked scoring defense remains a potential problem. If Richardson takes off in Year 2, however, the rest of the AFC South should be on notice.
Jacksonville Jaguars
15 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR Gabe Davis, C Mitch Morse, S Darnell Savage, CB Ronald Darby, DT Arik Armstead, Edge Josh Allen, OL Blake Hance, RB D'Ernest Johnson
Key Draft Additions: WR Brian Thomas Jr., DL Maason Smith, CB Jarrian Jones
Key Departures: WR Calvin Ridley, S Rayshawn Jenkins, DT Foley Fatukasi, CB Darious Williams, Edge K'Lavon Chaisson, CB Tre Herndon
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C+
Draft Grade: B-
EC Project: Improving the Defense
Overall Grade: B-
Like the Colts, the Jacksonville Jaguars came excruciatingly close to reaching the postseason in 2023. Some inconsistent play by quarterback Trevor Lawrence, and the series of injuries that hampered him, are likely most fans' lasting impressions.
However, Jacksonville may have suffered even more from a lackluster defense that wasn't playoff-caliber. The Jags ranked 16th in yards per carry allowed, 26th in passing yards allowed, 22nd in total defense and 17th in points allowed.
Ideally, Lawrence will be healthy and back to Pro Bowl form in 2024. That's why an offseason plan centered around improving the defense was sensible.
The Jaguars did use their first-round pick on wideout Brian Thomas Jr., but after losing Calvin Ridley in free agency, they had to do something to provide Lawrence with a viable No. 1 receiver. Thomas, Gabe Davis and Mitch Morse are all additions who can help Lawrence get back on track.
However, most of Jacksonville's additions will aid the other side of the ball.
The defensive makeover started with giving pass-rusher Josh Allen the franchise tag and ultimately extending him. That ensured that Jacksonville's top defensive talent would remain in place. From there, the Jags added the likes of Ronald Darby, Arik Armstead, Darnell Savage, rookie defensive lineman Maason Smith and rookie corner Jarrian Jones.
These additions still aren't likely to give Jacksonville a top-five defense. However, the team didn't enter free agency with a glut of cap space, and general manager Trent Baalke did solid work with what he had.
If Jacksonville's defense can be even average, and Lawrence can be the player he was in 2022, the Jaguars should present a challenge in the AFC South.
Kansas City Chiefs
16 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR Marquise Brown, TE Irv Smith, QB Carson Wentz, RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire, DL Chris Jones, DL Derrik Nnadi, LB Drue Tranquill
Key Draft Additions: WR Xavier Worthy, OT Kingsley Suamataia, TE Jared Wiley
Key Departures: CB L'Jarius Sneed, OT Donovan Smith, LB Willie Gay Jr., S Mike Edwards, WR Marquez Valdes-Scantling, OG Nick Allegretti
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C+
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Knowing Where to Invest in Veteran Talent
Overall Grade: B
Fans may be buzzing about the Kansas City Chiefs' additions of Marquise Brown and rookie first-round pick Xavier Worthy. The two pass-catchers should bring back the sort of speed in the passing game that Kansas City has lacked since trading Tyreek Hill.
Considering the Chiefs have won two Super Bowls since sending Hill to the Miami Dolphins, it is an exciting development.
However, the real win for Kansas City this offseason comes from general manager Brett Veach's approach to roster building. He got another long-term deal done with defensive tackle Chris Jones and extended tight end Travis Kelce, meaning that Kansas City's core of Jones, Kelce and Patrick Mahomes isn't going anywhere.
Veach understands that a perennial Super Bowl contender with an older core can't afford to pay everyone. He's done a good job of identifying where to spend and where to replace talent. (Having Andy Reid and Steve Spagnuolo handling the coaching certainly helps.)
Trading cornerback L'Jarius Sneed, for example, couldn't have been an easy decision. However, Sneed went on to sign a four-year, $76.4 million deal with Tennessee. That would have been hard for the Chiefs to justify with promising young corners like Trent McDuffie and Jaylen Watson on the roster.
Kansas City also has yet to re-sign 2023 starting left tackle Donovan Smith. Given Smith's up-and-down play last season, the Chiefs probably weren't interested in overpaying early in free agency. Rookie Kingsley Suamataia will now have a chance to develop into Kansas City's long-term left tackle.
Because the Chiefs have Mahomes, Jones, Kelce, Reid and Spagnuolo, they continue to find ways to win with a constantly morphing roster. They were more of a defensive-oriented team in 2023. They might go back to having a track-meet offense in 2024.
Kansas City's roster will be different this season, even if it isn't markedly better or worse. Regardless of how the roster looks, it'll be a major surprise if the Chiefs don't embark on another deep playoff run.
Las Vegas Raiders
17 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: DT Christian Wilkins, WR Michael Gallup, QB Gardner Minshew II, RB Alexander Mattison, TE Harrison Bryant, IOL Cody Whitehai, RB Ameer Abdullah, DL Adam Butler, C Andre James
Key Draft Additions: TE Brock Bowers, IOL Jackson Powers-Johnson, IOL Delmar Glaze
Key Departures: RB Josh Jacobs, OG Greg Van Roten, G/T Jermaine Eluemunor, CB Amik Robertson, DT Bilal Nichols, TE Austin Hooper, DT Jerry Tillery
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B+
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Recognizing Antonio Pierce's Impact
Overall Grade: A-
The Raiders kicked off their offseason by hiring an experienced general manager in Tom Telesco and removing the interim tag from head coach Antonio Pierce. Both of those decisions should have a significant impact on the 2024 season.
Telesco did a good job of bringing in impact veterans like Christian Wilkins and newly minted Pro Bowl quarterback Gardner Minshew II before targeting value in the draft. While Las Vegas didn't need a new tight end one year after taking Michael Mayer in Round 2, landing Brock Bowers—the second-ranked overall prospect on the final B/R big board—at No. 13 was a steal. The Raiders came back in Round 2 and landed a first-round-caliber talent in Jackson Powers-Johnson.
Minshew will have to beat out incumbent Aidan O'Connell for the starting job, but he showed in 2023 that he can at least get a team to the cusp of the postseason. On paper, the Raiders appear poised to make some noise in the AFC West.
The challenge will be getting past Kansas City and the new-look Los Angeles Chargers in the division. The tough, physical and gritty identity Pierce forged over the second half of last season can help there.
"Our resume is on the grass and is on the film," Pierce told The Rush with Maxx Crosby podcast (h/t Carter Landis of Raiders Today). "When we watch that, it should be that of a team that's physical, playing with extreme effort, passionate, a love for the game, playing for one another."
The Raiders became a cohesive team under Pierce last season. That allowed them to close the year with wins over all three divisional foes.
Las Vegas may still lack the overall talent to win its division. However, it won't be an easy out, and a playoff push is more realistic than some might think.
Los Angeles Chargers
18 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: RB Gus Edwards, TE Hayden Hurst, C Bradley Bozeman, RB J.K. Dobbins, LB Denzel Perryman, CB Kristian Fulton, TE Will Dissly, WR DJ Chark Jr., Edge Bud Dupree, QB Easton Stick
Key Draft Additions: OT Joe Alt, WR Ladd McConkey, LB Junior Colson
Key Departures: RB Austin Ekeler, WR Keenan Allen, WR Mike Williams, LB Kenneth Murray, LB Eric Kendricks, C Will Clapp, DT Austin Johnson, TE Gerald Everett
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B-
Draft Grade: A-
EC Project: Landing Jim Harbaugh
Overall Grade: A-
The Los Angeles Chargers landed arguably the most coveted head coaching prospect this offseason in Jim Harbaugh. The reigning college national champion—along with new general manager Joe Hortiz—has already put his stamp on the roster.
Harbaugh has a long history of building his teams around a good running game, sound defense and strong play along the offensive and defensive lines. While the pieces aren't all in place yet, things are taking shape.
Out are veteran receivers Keenan Allen and Mike Williams, along with running back Austin Ekeler. The Chargers weren't willing to sacrifice pass-rushing talent, though. Instead, they reworked the contracts of Joey Bosa and Khalil Herbert before adding Bud Dupree.
Ekeler will be replaced by a more physical running back committee led by Gus Edwards and J.K. Dobbins, while first-round rookie Joe Alt will help solidify the offensive line. Alt and Rashawn Slater could form one of the league's best tackle tandems as early as this season.
While the passing game may not be as potent as it has been in recent years, better protection will aid quarterback Justin Herbert. New receivers DJ Chark Jr. and rookie Ladd McConkey will at least give Harbert some viable targets.
The Chargers still haven't fully addressed a defense that ranked 17th against the run, 30th against the pass and 28th overall last season. Considering L.A. entered the offseason significantly over the cap, though, the transformation has been impressive.
Will Harbaugh be able to guide the revamped roster to the postseason in 2024? That remains to be seen. But his plan is in place, and it's worth noting that his plan has worked quickly in the past.
In Harbaugh's last NFL stint, he guided the San Francisco 49ers to the Super Bowl in his second season.
Los Angeles Rams
19 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: G Jonah Jackson, S Kamren Curl, CB Tre'Davious White, CB Darious Williams, G Kevin Dotson, WR Demarcus Robinson
Key Draft Additions: Edge Jared Verse, DL Braden Fiske, RB Blake Corum, S Kamren Kinchens
Key Departures: DT Aaron Donald (retirement), S Jordan Fuller, C Coleman Shelton, QB Carson Wentz, DL Jonah Williams
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A
Draft Grade: A
EC Project: Reloading the Defensive Front
Overall Grade: A
While the Los Angeles Rams' 2023 turnaround wasn't as stunning as Houston's, it was unexpected. L.A. dealt with a variety of key injuries in 2022 and purged veteran talent last offseason. However, the Rams were right back in the playoffs by the end of last season.
Veterans like Aaron Donald, Matthew Stafford and Cooper Kupp largely stayed healthy in 2023, while young stars like Puka Nacua, Kobie Turner and Kyren Williams helped round out an impressive roster. Although L.A. lost Donald to retirement this offseason, it is poised to potentially go even deeper this year.
General manager Les Snead had a clear vision in both free agency and the draft. By re-signing Kevin Dotson and adding Jonah Jackson, he built a powerful offensive line that can keep giving the Rams a balanced and potent offense.
Incoming players like Darious Williams, Kamren Curl and Tre'Davious White, meanwhile, should bolster a pass defense that ranked 20th in yards allowed last season.
The Rams then used a first-round selection—their first since 2016—on UCLA pass-rusher Jared Verse. Verse, rookie defensive lineman Braden Fiske and Turner should help the Rams replicate the pass rush they had with Donald in the lineup.
No player is single-handedly capable of replacing Donald's impact. But by improving their overall defensive front, the Rams may still be a scary sight for opposing quarterbacks.
Kamren Kinchens will further boost the secondary, while Blake Corum will pair with Kyren Williams behind that offensive front to give L.A. a potentially lethal ground game. With Stafford, Kupp, Nacua and Demarcus Williams back and leading the passing attack, the Rams suddenly look like one of the most complete teams in the NFC.
Miami Dolphins
20 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: CB Kendall Fuller, C Aaron Brewer, S Jordan Poyer, LB Jordyn Brooks, TE Jonnu Smith, DT Teair Tart, LB Anthony Walker Jr., WR Odell Beckham Jr., WR Braxton Berrios, OL Isaiah Wynn
Key Draft Additions: Edge Chop Robinson, OT Patrick Paul, RB Jaylen Wright
Key Departures: DT Christian Wilkins, S DeShon Elliott, CB Xavien Howard, EDGE Andrew Van Ginkel, LB Jerome Baker, OG Robert Hunt, WR Cedrick Wilson Jr., EDGE Emmanuel Ogbah
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C
Draft Grade: C+
EC Project: Adding Even More Offensive Speed
Overall Grade: C
The Miami Dolphins didn't exactly improve in free agency. If anything, they got significantly worse.
Miami cut longtime starting cornerback Xavien Howard and lost two key pieces in Robert Hunt and Christian Wilkins. Most of the Dolphins' subsequent moves were of the replacement variety, and many of them will result in downgrades.
Cornerback Kendall Fuller, for example, is a quality starter and a cheaper alternative than Howard, but he isn't necessarily better. Defensive tackle Teair Tart isn't the difference-maker along the defensive front that Wilkins is, either.
Jordyn Brooks and Anthony Walker Jr. might adequately replace Andrew Van Ginkel and Jerome Baker, but the Dolphins made some sacrifices. Losing defensive coordinator Vic Fangio also hurts, as his replacement, Anthony Weaver, will bring experience but not continuity.
What's more, the Dolphins might not see a significant boost from their rookie class. Pass-rusher Chop Robinson has loads of upside but may need time to develop into an impactful player.
"The Penn State product also has a lot more traits than production right now, making him more of a project," Matt Holder of the B/R Scouting Department wrote. "He has made a handful of impactful plays via sacks and tackles for loss, but the consistency play in and play out just isn't there right now."
Second-round pick Patrick Paul is another project and may initially be little more than insurance behind Terron Armstead.
On a positive note, head coach Mike McDaniel will have some new options if his plan is to simply overwhelm opponents with raw offensive speed. Rookie Jaylen Wright should find an early role in an already dangerous backfield rotation, while Odell Beckham Jr. can still make the occasional big play.
The Dolphins spent big money to put high-end veterans around Tua Tagovailoa and his rookie contract. Now that Tagovailoa is on his fifth-year option and eyeing a lucrative extension, keeping the team together is becoming a challenge.
Minnesota Vikings
21 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: LB Blake Cashman, QB Sam Darnold, Edge Jonathan Greenard, CB Shaquill Griffin, RB Aaron Jones, DL Jonah Williams, DL Jonathan Bullard, TE Johnny Mundt, OT David Quessenberry
Key Draft Additions: QB J.J. McCarthy, Edge Dallas Turner, CB Khyree Jackson
Key Departures: QB Kirk Cousins, Edge Marcus Davenport, LB Jordan Hicks, Edge Danielle Hunter, K Greg Joseph, WR K.J. Osborn, LB D.J. Wonnum
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B
Draft Grade: A-
EC Project: Not Overpaying for Cousins
Overall Grade: B+
Will the Minnesota Vikings return to playoff contention in 2024? That depends on a few factors. Injuries were a major issue last season, and the Vikings' playoff chances were essentially sunk when Kirk Cousins went down with a torn Achilles.
Replacing Cousins won't be easy, but the 35-year-old was expensive in free agency, is coming off a serious injury and has only delivered one playoff win in six years with the franchise. Minnesota deserves credit for not overpaying to maintain the status quo.
Letting Cousins walk allowed the Vikings to bring in some quality free agents, like edge-rusher Jonathan Greenard and running back Aaron Jones. They did have to replace players like Danielle Hunter and Jordan Hicks, but they've done a solid job of doing so.
Letting Cousins go would have been an even bigger win had it directly led to an extension for star receiver Justin Jefferson. For now, though, Jefferson, Jordan Addison, T.J. Hockenson (when recovered from ACL and MCL injuries) and Jones will provide rookie quarterback J.J. McCarthy with a strong supporting cast.
Will McCarthy quickly adjust to the NFL, win the starting job over Sam Darnold and give Minnesota a quality offense in 2024? That's the other big factor that could make or break the Vikings' playoff chances this year.
Still, with players like Greenard and rookie pass-rusher Dallas Turner in the fold, the defense should take another positive step under coordinator Brian Flores this season. If McCarthy and/or Darnold do play well, the Vikings should put pressure on the Detroit Lions and Green Bay Packers in the NFC North.
New England Patriots
22 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: WR K.J. Osborn, LB Sione Takitaki, RB Antonio Gibson, TE Austin Hooper, OT Chukwuma Okorafor, QB Jacoby Brissett, WR Kendrick Bourne, S Kyle Dugger, TE Hunter Henry, OL Mike Onwenu, Edge Josh Uche
Key Draft Additions: QB Drake Maye, WR Ja'Lynn Polk, OT Caedan Wallace
Key Departures: OT Trent Brown, TE Mike Gesicki, LB Mack Wilson, WR DeVante Parker, DB Jalen Mills, QB Mac Jones
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C-
Draft Grade: A
EC Project: Not Trading Out of the No. 3 Spot
Overall Grade: B
There's plenty to unpack regarding the New England Patriots' offseason, starting with their decision to move on from longtime head coach Bill Belichick. While Belichick only delivered one postseason berth after the departure of Tom Brady, moving on is still a risk.
Fortunately, the Patriots had a succession plan in place and promoted Jerod Mayo immediately after Belichick's departure. That should provide a lot of continuity along with some potentially refreshing changes.
New England's overall foray into free agency wasn't overly inspiring. The Patriots had plenty of cap space, yet the talent-starved offense didn't get many high-end upgrades. However, the Patriots did retain key players like Hunter Henry, Kyle Dugger, Mike Onwenu and Josh Uche while turning the page on quarterback Mac Jones.
The Jones trade set the stage for the Patriots to draft their quarterback of the future at No. 3 overall, which they did by taking North Carolina's Drake Maye.
While Maye could require some time to develop, the Patriots have a solid mentor/bridge option in Jacoby Brissett. Maye's upside is tremendous, and it made him the top-ranked quarterback prospect on the final B/R big board—even ahead of No. 1 overall pick Caleb Williams.
"Maye has the skill set to fit in any system and develop into a star," Derrik Klassen of the B/R Scouting Department wrote.
Credit the Patriots for staying put and flipping the switch on Maye, even with lucrative trade offers on the table. According to Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer, the Vikings offered both of their first-round picks plus a 2025 first-round pick to move up from No. 11, while the Giants offered a 2025 first-round pick to move up from No. 6.
Only time will tell if Mayo is a worthy successor to Belichick, if Maye is truly the best quarterback from this class and if New England can be more competitive in 2024 than it was in 2023. However, the pieces are in place for a promising new era.
New Orleans Saints
23 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: LB Willie Gay, QB Nathan Peterman, WR Cedrick Wilson Jr., Edge Chase Young
Key Draft Additions: IOL Taliese Fuaga, CB Kool-Aid McKinstry, QB Spencer Rattler
Key Departures: LB Zack Baun, CB Lonnie Johnson, DL Malcolm Roach, WR Michael Thomas, QB Jameis Winston, CB Isaac Yiadom
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C
Draft Grade: A
EC Project: Hiring Klint Kubiak as Offensive Coordinator
Overall Grade: B
The New Orleans Saints entered the offseason staring down a substantial cap deficit. The fact that they didn't significantly deconstruct their roster was impressive, though general manager Mickey Loomis has a history of kicking contracts down the road.
The Saints approached the draft with a roster that looked a lot like it did a year ago, and they're currently facing a 2025 cap deficit of $98.1 million.
They did fare well in the draft, which might allow them to better contend in 2024. First-round rookie Taliese Fuaga has the talent and ability to play tackle or guard, and he'll likely get his first shot at starting at the left tackle spot.
"Yeah, so we want to take a look at him on the left side and see how he does over there," head coach Dennis Allen told reporters. "I think we're pretty confident that he can play right tackle. So getting him some work over on the left side."
If Fuaga can solidify the left tackle spot it would be huge, as 2022 first-round pick Trevor Penning hasn't developed as anticipated. The Saints also got a first-round-caliber talent in cornerback Kool-Aid McKinstry, who should further boost their 10th-ranked pass defense. Spencer Rattler will be a developmental prospect and depth behind quarterback Derek Carr.
While the Saints didn't do much to shake up the roster, they're shaking up the offense by replacing longtime offensive coordinator Pete Carmichael with Klint Kubiak. Carr didn't quite seem to gel with Carmichael's system, and Kubiak should bring some fresh ideas after last overseeing a dynamic offense as the 49ers' passing game coordinator.
Whether Carr returns the Saints to Pro Bowl form remains to be seen. However, this was a team that ranked ninth in scoring and eighth in points allowed last season while winning nine games. Even minor offensive improvement could put New Orleans back in the postseason.
New York Giants
24 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge Brian Burns, OT Jermaine Eluemunor, QB Drew Lock, WR Isaiah McKenzie, DB Jalen Mills, DL Jordan Phillips, WR Allen Robinson, G Jon Runyan, RB Devin Singletary, DB Darnay Holmes, LB Isaiah Simmons
Key Draft Additions: WR Malik Nabers, S Tyler Nubin, CB Andru Phillips, TE Theo Johnson
Key Departures: RB Saquon Barkley, S Xavier McKinney, DL A'Shawn Robinson, QB Tyrod Taylor, DL Jihad Ward
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B+
Draft Grade: B-
EC Project: Upgrading the Offensive Supporting Cast
Overall Grade: B+
A year ago, the New York Giants tried to run it back with a roster that made the 2022 playoffs. That plan crashed and burned, in part because of injuries. Saquon Barkley wasn't at 100 percent all year, and quarterback Daniel Jones played poorly before suffering a season-ending ACL tear.
This offseason, general manager Joe Schoen took a wholly different approach and made some bold additions. Barkley and standout safety Xavier McKinney are out, but Jones is back—along with a vastly improved supporting cast.
The Giants brought in Drew Lock to provide insurance behind Jones, but the most noteworthy offensive additions include Jermaine Eluemunor, Jon Runyan and rookie first-round pick Malik Nabers.
Nabers should quickly become the true No. 1 receiver whom the Giants have lacked since the prime days of Odell Beckham Jr. New York added more pass-catching depth in the form of Allen Robinson, Isaiah McKenzie and rookie tight end Theo Johnson.
Johnson's presence could be very important, as 2023 trade acquisition Darren Waller continues to consider retirement. Whether it's Jones or Lock as the Week 1 starter, New York's quarterback should be in a promising situation.
The Giants also addressed a defense that ranked 27th overall and 26th in points allowed last season. The team parted ways with coordinator Don Martindale, but new defensive coordinator Shane Bowen will oversee an improved unit that now includes Brian Burns, Jalen Mills, Tyler Nubin and Andru Phillips.
The Giants needed some change. While they didn't use the draft to make one at the game's most important position, they should enter 2024 as a more formidable squad.
New York Jets
25 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge Haason Reddick, WR Mike Williams, OT Tyron Smith, OT Morgan Moses, OG John Simpson, CB Isaiah Oliver, P Thomas Morstead, K Greg Zuerlein
Key Draft Additions: OT Olumuyiwa Fashanu, WR Malachi Corley, RB Braelon Allen
Key Departures: OG Laken Tomlinson, S Jordan Whitehead, Edge Bryce Huff, DT Quinton Jefferson, OT Mekhi Becton
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B+
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Rebuilding the Offensive Line
Overall Grade: B+
The New York Jets essentially had their 2023 campaign end in Week 1 when quarterback Aaron Rodgers suffered a torn Achilles. Despite boasting a potent defense and talented offensive skill-position players like Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall, the Jets rarely performed like a competent team.
That was largely due to poor quarterback play, though a disastrous offensive line certainly didn't help. As a group, Jets quarterbacks were sacked 64 times in 2023.
New York's 2024 campaign hinges on Rodgers getting and staying healthy. Therefore, improving the offensive line was the single biggest priority of the offseason. The Jets attacked the position group with gusto, adding Tyron Smith, Morgan Moses and John Simpson before the draft.
General manager Joe Douglas then used a first-round pick on Penn State's Olumuyiwa Fashanu, one of the top line prospects in the draft.
"His ability to thrive on an island in pass protection right away with the tools, runway and flashes necessary to make improvements as a run-blocker indicates a franchise-caliber blind-side protector who can at least be average in the run game," Thorn wrote.
Adding Fashanu was smart. While Smith is a quality left tackle when healthy, the 33-year-old has struggled to stay on the field in recent years. The last thing the Jets can afford is to lose Rodgers to an injury because their left tackle is out with one.
The Jets made other interesting additions as well, like trading for pass-rusher Haason Reddick and adding Mike Williams, Malachi Corley and Braelon Allen to the offensive skill-position group.
Improving Rodgers' protection was critical, though. The Jets didn't ignore that, either.
Philadelphia Eagles
26 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: RB Saquon Barkley, LB Zack Baun, LB Oren Burks, WR Parris Campbell, DB C.J. Gardner-Johnson, OL Matt Hennessy, Edge Bryce Huff, WR DeVante Parker, LB Devin White, Edge Brandon Graham, CB Avonte Maddox
Key Draft Additions: CB Quinyon Mitchell, CB Cooper DeJean, Edge Jalyx Hunt
Key Departures: S Kevin Byard III, DL Fletcher Cox (retirement), C Jason Kelce (retirement), QB Marcus Mariota, Edge Haason Reddick, RB D'Andre Swift, WR Quez Watkins, WR Olamide Zaccheaus, G Sua Opeta
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A
Draft Grade: A+
EC Project: Reforging the Defense
Overall Grade: A+
Though the Eagles won 11 games last season and made the postseason, they made wholesale changes to both the roster and the coaching staff this offseason.
Head coach Nick Sirianni is back, along with core players like Jalen Hurts, A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith. However, the Eagles learned that they were ill-prepared for losing their offensive and defensive coordinators in 2023. They rectified the situation by hiring Kellen Moore and Vic Fangio, respectively.
The Eagles also took some swings at improving the offense this offseason, adding running back Saquon Barkley, who is elite when healthy, and adding Parris Campbell and DeVante Parker for receiver depth. But most of their changes came on defense.
Philly's offense was potent enough in 2023, but its defense finished the year ranked 26th in yards allowed and 30th in points allowed. The Eagles were routed in the Wild Card Round because they couldn't consistently cover or tackle on the back end.
Players like Zack Baun, C.J. Gardner-Johnson, Bryce Huff, Devin White, rookie corner Quinyon Mitchell and rookie safety Cooper DeJean should improve the defense significantly. Having Fangio—whose scheme is very similar to the one Jonathan Gannon ran during the Eagles' 2022 Super Bowl run—should further boost that side of the ball.
Philadelphia lost two key pieces when center Jason Kelce and defensive tackle Fletcher Cox retired. It lost a few more through free agency and the trade market. Yet the 2024 Eagles should more closely resemble the 14-win squad of two years ago than the poor facsimile we saw toward the end of last season.
Pittsburgh Steelers
27 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: QB Russell Wilson, QB Justin Fields, LB Patrick Queen, CB Donte Jackson, WR Quez Watkins, DT Dean Lowry, S DeShon Elliott, WR Van Jefferson, DL Montravius Adams
Key Draft Additions: OL Troy Fautanu, IOL Zach Frazier, WR Roman Wilson, LB Payton Wilson
Key Departures: QB Kenny Pickett, WR Diontae Johnson, QB Mitch Trubisky, CB James Pierre, OT Chukwuma Okorafor, DT Armon Watts, LB Mykal Walker
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A-
Draft Grade: A+
EC Project: Making Bold Moves at QB
Overall Grade: A+
The Pittsburgh Steelers are in postseason contention almost every year, but they haven't won a playoff game since 2016. While they often avoid making knee-jerk changes, they shook things up quite a bit this offseason.
The Steelers hired Arthur Smith as offensive coordinator—they fired Matt Canada in-season—before signing Russell Wilson to be their 2024 starting quarterback. Wilson wasn't great with the Denver Broncos in 2023, but he was better than what Pittsburgh had at quarterback.
Kenny Pickett, whom the Steelers traded to the Eagles this offseason, threw only 13 touchdowns in 25 games over the past two seasons. Wilson threw twice that many in 15 games last year.
The Steelers also traded for 2021 first-round pick Justin Fields. While Wilson has the inside track on the starting job, Fields will provide valuable depth and perhaps a change-of-pace or gadget option on offense.
However, the Wilson-Fields tandem shakes out, the Steelers should see improved quarterback play in 2024.
Completely reshuffling the quarterback room was a bold decision, but it wasn't very risky. Wilson signed on a one-year deal at the league minimum, while Fields will carry a cap hit of just $3.2 million on the final year of his rookie deal. If the experiment doesn't work out, the Steelers can try again in 2025 with no real financial fallout.
General manager Omar Khan didn't stop there, though. He helped boost the defense by signing Patrick Queen and trading for Donte Jackson before filling three critical needs in the draft.
Troy Fautanu and Zach Frazier should be early starters at tackle and center, respectively. Roman Wilson should give Pittsburgh a reliable slot receiver and a replacement for Diontae Johnson.
Khan also took a third-round flier on linebacker Payton Wilson, a first-round-caliber talent who slid because of injury concerns. Getting him was another low-risk, high-reward move.
At worst, the Steelers will be relevant in 2024. At best, they could be serious threats in the AFC race.
San Francisco 49ers
28 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: LB De'Vondre Campbell, QB Joshua Dobbs, DL Jordan Elliott, Edge Leonard Floyd, LB Ezekiel Turner, DL Yetur Gross-Matos, CB Rock Ya-Sin, CB Isaac Yiadom, WR Chris Conley, OL Jon Feliciano
Key Draft Additions: WR Ricky Pearsall, CB Renardo Green, IOL Dominick Puni
Key Departures: DL Arik Armstead, LB Oren Burks, QB Sam Darnold, Edge Clelin Ferrell, Edge Randy Gregory, DL Javon Kinlaw, WR Ray-Ray McCloud, G Matt Pryor, Edge Chase Young
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C+
Draft Grade: B
EC Project: Reloading the Defensive Front Seven
Overall Grade: B
The San Francisco 49ers, who lost the Super Bowl in overtime, didn't have a lot of weaknesses last season. On paper, they have virtually none after reloading their defensive front seven in free agency.
Losing players like Arik Armstead, Oren Burks, Javon Kinlaw and Chase Young left the 49ers needing to reload the front end of their defense. However, it could turn out to be a positive thing for San Francisco, which struggled against the run at various points last season.
The 49ers finished eighth in total defense but only 14th in yards per carry allowed. They surrendered at least 130 rushing yards in all three of their playoff contests. While there's no guarantee that additions like De'Vondre Campbell, Jordan Elliott, Yetur Gross-Matos and Leonard Floyd will instantly upgrade the front seven, there was little sense in maintaining the status quo.
San Francisco's offensive core remains intact and could be even better after adding Ricky Pearsall and Dominick Puni in the draft. Puni can potentially upgrade the offensive interior, while Pearsall will give quarterback Brock Purdy another dynamic playmaker.
And no, the Pearsall pick doesn't necessarily mean that the 49ers will trade Brandon Aiyuk before the start of the season.
"The Pearsall pick [in the draft] really made everyone scratch their heads and go, 'Maybe they really are trading Brandon Aiyuk,'" NFL Network's Ian Rapoport said on Total Access (beginning at the 15-second mark). "It doesn't seem like that is in the cards."
What the Pearsall pick might do is allow San Francisco to lean less heavily on running back Christian McCaffrey in 2024. He had a league-high 339 touches last season, and if a bigger emphasis on the passing game leaves McCaffrey fresh for the postseason, it'll be a big win.
It would have been nice to see the Niners do more to solidify their secondary—which had issues with top quarterbacks like Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes last season—but they should again be among the early NFC favorites.
Seattle Seahawks
29 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: LB Jerome Baker, LB Tyrel Dodson, OT George Fant, C Nick Harris, DT Johnathan Hankins, QB Sam Howell, S Rayshawn Jenkins, G Laken Tomlinson, CB Artie Burns, TE Noah Fant, DL Leonard Williams
Key Draft Additions: DL Byron Murphy II, IOL Christian Haynes, LB Tyrice Knight
Key Departures: LB Jordyn Brooks, LB Devin Bush, TE Will Dissly, DL Mario Edwards, QB Drew Lock, LB Bobby Wagner
Free Agency, Trade Grade: C
Draft Grade: B
EC Project: Finding a Young, Up-and-Coming Coach
Overall Grade: C+
The Seattle Seahawks largely used free agency to retain noteworthy contributors like Artie Burns, Noah Fant and 2023 trade acquisition Leonard Williams. They did add a few significant pieces, like Jerome Baker and Johnathan Hankins, but they pretty much lost as much as they gained.
Trading for Sam Howell might give Geno Smith more competition at quarterback, but on paper, Howell is merely replacing Drew Lock.
Draft weekend was a different story. Rookie defenders Byron Murphy II, and Tyrice Knight should help bolster the front seven right away, while Christian Haynes should instantly upgrade Seattle's much-maligned offensive interior.
The big unknown about Seattle's offseason is the decision to move on from head coach Pete Carroll. While Carroll is 72 years old and missed the playoffs in two of the last three years, he continually kept the Seahawks in the hunt. Parting with such a stabilizing force could prove to be a mistake.
At least the Seahawks didn't go with a retread head coach or an underwhelming candidate. New head coach Mike Macdonald may lack experience, but helped make Baltimore's defense arguably the best in the league in 2023. He has also surrounded himself with an impressive staff, one that includes former University of Washington offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb.
Seattle's offense may or may not be better than last year's unit, but it shouldn't be worse. A defense that ranked 30th overall should be markedly better. Most importantly, if Macdonald pans out, the 36-year-old could be Seattle's head coach for the next decade or two.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
30 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: Edge Randy Gregory, CB Bryce Hall, G Sua Opeta, S Jordan Whitehead, S Antoine Winfield Jr., WR Mike Evans, QB Baker Mayfield, LB Lavonte David
Key Draft Additions: OL Graham Barton, Edge Chris Braswell, S Tykee Smith, WR Jalen McMillan
Key Departures: Edge Shaquil Barrett, CB Carlton Davis, G Nick Leverett, G Aaron Stinnie, LB Devin White
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A
Draft Grade: A-
EC Project: Keeping the Core Intact
Overall Grade: A
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers have spent recent offseasons focused on keeping the proverbial band together. Most assumed that wouldn't work in 2023, as Baker Mayfield was coming in to replace the retired Tom Brady.
However, Mayfield had a bounce-back campaign, helped lead Tampa to its third straight division title and made the Pro Bowl as an alternate. Once again, general manager Jason Licht is ready to run it back.
Mayfield will be back, along with wideout Mike Evans, linebacker Lavonte David and safety Antoine Winfield Jr. The latter recently became the league's highest-paid defensive back in terms of annual value.
While the Bucs did lose a few notable players—including Devin White, Shaquil Barrett and Carlton Davis, whom they traded to the Lions—they may actually have a stronger roster than they did a few months ago.
Randy Gregory and Bryce Hall will help replace Barrett and Davis, while Jordan Whitehead should team with Winfield to form an elite safety tandem. Rookie Graham Barton should stabilize the center position, while Chris Braswell should further improve the pass rush.
Don't discount the third-round addition of Jalen McMillan, who can further boost an already impressive receiver group.
"His well-rounded athletic profile, route-running chops and reliable hands will allow him to be productive from day one, both from the slot and outside," Klassen wrote.
Tampa did lose offensive coordinator Dave Canales to the rival Panthers, but they brought in a familiar face to aid in Mayfield's continued development. Liam Coen was the Rams' coordinator when Mayfield had a five-game stint in L.A.
That should help Mayfield continue growing alongside Evans, McMillan, Chris Godwin, Rachaad White and the rest of Tampa's offensive group. If the offense is better than the 23rd-ranked unit we saw in 2023, the Bucs might not be ready to relinquish the division.
Tennessee Titans
31 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: CB L'Jarius Sneed, WR Calvin Ridley, RB Tony Pollard, C Lloyd Cushenberry III, CB Chidobe Awuzie, LB Kenneth Murray, WR Tyler Boyd
Key Draft Additions: OT JC Latham, DL T'Vondre Sweat, LB Cedric Gray
Key Departures: RB Derrick Henry, LB Azeez Al-Shaair, C Aaron Brewer, DL Denico Autry, CB Sean Murphy-Bunting, S K'Von Wallace
Free Agency, Trade Grade: A
Draft Grade: C
EC Project: Putting More Pieces Around QB Will Levis
Overall Grade: B
The Tennessee Titans appear ready to go all-in with 2023 second-round pick Will Levis at quarterback. They didn't bring in any real quarterback competition this offseason, and instead focused on upgrading the supporting cast.
It started when the Titans hired former Bengals offensive coordinator Brian Callahan as their new head coach. In Cincinnati, Callahan helped develop Joe Burrow into a star and helped oversee one of the league's most explosive offenses.
It remains to be seen how responsible Callahan was for the Bengals' success. Burrow is a special talent, and head coach Zac Taylor was the play-caller.
Callahan will be joined by his father, Bill Callahan, who is arguably the best offensive line coach in the league. It's a move that shouldn't be overlooked—and a classy act by the Browns for not blocking it.
While Tennessee probably overpaid a bit for Calvin Ridley and Tony Pollard, they'll help Brian Callahan implement his offense. So will former Bengals receiver Tyler Boyd. Trading for standout cornerback L'Jarius Sneed was another move that made plenty of sense for the rebuilding Titans.
Tennessee's draft decisions were more curious, however. Rookie tackle JC Latham has plenty of upside, but Penn State's Olumuyiwa Fashanu was available and arguably a cleaner left tackle prospect. Using a second-round pick on big-bodied run-stuffer T'Vondre Sweat was also a questionable decision considering the Titans ranked seventh in yards per carry allowed last season.
Tennessee should be better equipped to accentuate Levis' strengths this season, though. If the second-year signal-caller can establish himself as the long-term answer in 2024, the season should be considered a success.
Washington Commanders
32 of 32
Key Additions/Re-Signings: G Nick Allegretti, Edge Dorance Armstrong, C Tyler Biadasz, S Jeremy Chinn, RB Austin Ekeler, Edge Dante Fowler Jr., LB Frankie Luvu, QB Marcus Mariota, LB Bobby Wagner, WR Jamison Crowder, OT Cornelius Lucas
Key Draft Additions: QB Jayden Daniels, DL Jer'Zhan Newton, CB Mike Sainristil
Key Departures: LB Cody Barton, QB Jacoby Brissett, G Saahdiq Charles, S Kamren Curl, CB Kendall Fuller, RB Antonio Gibson, K Joey Slye
Free Agency, Trade Grade: B
Draft Grade: B+
EC Project: Adding Experience to Front Office and Roster
Overall Grade: B+
Hiring a retread head coach doesn't always work. However, the Washington Commanders could have done much worse than adding former Cowboys defensive coordinator and former Falcons head coach Dan Quinn.
Quinn knows what it takes to win in the NFC East, and he can show his players what is required to turn around a franchise. Atlanta won only 10 games in the two years before Quinn was hired. By his second season, the Falcons were in the Super Bowl.
Yes, Quinn's team lost Super Bowl LI in epic fashion, but he seems to have learned from that experience.
"We have seen him in a brutally difficult position, go through it, get through it and get back on the horse and say, 'I want another crack at this,'" one source told ESPN's John Keim.
Along with Quinn, the Commanders added Kliff Kingsbury, who also has head-coaching experience, as offensive coordinator. To the roster, they added seasoned veterans like Bobby Wagner, Keenan Allen, Zach Ertz, Nick Allegretti, Tyler Biadasz and Dorance Armstrong. Each of them has had some level of individual and/or team success.
It's an influx of talent and experience that should help change the culture of a franchise that just hasn't had a lot of sustained success.
Washington capped its offseason by taking former LSU quarterback Jayden Daniels with the second overall pick. Daniels is a talented prospect with a high ceiling and a pro-ready floor. Adding him to an offense that features Terry McLaurin, Jahan Dotson, Brian Robinson Jr., Ertz and Ekeler should quickly create fireworks in Washington.
Will the Commanders become instant playoff contenders? Possibly not. They'll still (likely) be rolling with a rookie quarterback, and rebuilding a defense that ranked dead last in 2023 will be a process. However, Washington very much appears to be on a positive track.
*Cap and contract information via Spotrac.
.jpg?w=480 "Vikings Cowboys Football")
.jpg?w=480 "Raiders Football")
.jpg?w=480 "NFL Draft Football")
