CFB
HomeScoresRecruitingHighlights
Featured Video
Fan After Skenes Ks Shohei 😶

South Carolina Football: Thumbs Up and Thumbs Down for the Matchup Against ECU

Alex RobertsSep 4, 2011

There are lessons to be learned every week in college football, and that is some of the beauty of the sport. 

There are players who will step up and players who will step down every week. As the team grows and improves, the weekly drama will change. 

This week's thumbs up/thumbs down segment seemed pretty easy to me. These South Carolina players really earned their appending directions this week. 

Thumbs Up: Stephen Garcia

1 of 10

While he wasn't the prettiest passer I had ever seen, and it certainly wasn't his best performance, his gritty runs and rallying ability led this team to victory. 

Bravo, Garcia.

Thumbs Down: Connor Shaw

2 of 10

Shaw was leading a nice drive to open the game—and then he fumbled.

From then on, he looked like a deer in headlights.

He had two really nicely-thrown balls that hit the receiver Jason Barnes in the hands that he dropped.  If Barnes would have made those catches, the story this morning may have been about how great Connor Shaw was. 

We will never know.

Thumbs Up: Alshon Jeffery

3 of 10

Alshon did his usual, catching five passes for 92 yards. He looked faster and stronger. 

With a bit more consistent quarterback play, he will have a huge year.

TOP NEWS

Colorado v Kansas State

Deion Gives Health Update

COLLEGE FOOTBALL: JAN 01 College Football Playoff Quarterfinal at the Allstate Sugar Bowl Ole Miss vs Georgia

Projecting 2026's Top QBs 🔮

2026 Texas Tech Spring Football Game

CFB Coaches Give Sorsby Scouting Report

Thumbs Down: Jason Barnes

4 of 10

Jason Barnes couldn't catch a cold standing naked in the Arctic. 

Thumbs Up: Marcus Lattimore

5 of 10

With 23 carries for 117 yards and three touchdowns, Lattimore begins his Heisman campaign on the right foot. 

Thumbs Down: Turnovers

6 of 10

No way the team fumbles this many times again, right?

Right?

Thumbs Up: Antonio Allen

7 of 10

What a huge game for the senior safety. Allen played lights out and even returned a fumble for a score. 

Thumbs Down: Stephon Gilmore

8 of 10

What has happened to Stephon Gilmore? He looked terrible in this game on coverage and even worse as the punt returner. 

Thumbs Up: The Defensive Line

9 of 10

The defensive line was incredible. Clowney was a machine, Devin Taylor was amazing, Melvin Ingram had an interception and the consistent rotation of solid players kept them fresh. 

Kudos. 

Thumbs Up: Bruce Ellington

10 of 10

Bruce Ellington played like a star football player and will be a great addition to the team. 

As always, feel free to like Alex Roberts on Facebook. 

Fan After Skenes Ks Shohei 😶

TOP NEWS

Colorado v Kansas State

Deion Gives Health Update

COLLEGE FOOTBALL: JAN 01 College Football Playoff Quarterfinal at the Allstate Sugar Bowl Ole Miss vs Georgia

Projecting 2026's Top QBs 🔮

2026 Texas Tech Spring Football Game

CFB Coaches Give Sorsby Scouting Report

Texas Tech Sorsby Gambling Football

Brendan Sorsby Gets Injunction vs. NCAA (AP)

Kentucky Missouri Football

Breaking News

Knicks Player's Warning to Wemby
Bleacher Report7h

Knicks Player's Warning to Wemby

TRENDING ON B/R