Bottomline, is we don't know. They have proven they are top 10 team, and can beat anyone on any given Saturday, but is that enough? Could they run the table in the SEC, like Alabama, probably not, but who knows? This is the best argument for a playoff. If you think Boise State is good enough to win, they can prove it. If you don't, they can be proved wrong.
If College Basketball used this same system, would anyone say that Butler should have been in the National Championship Game? Probably not, but they got the chance to prove they belonged. We should give Boise State a chance to prove they belong, but not just let them in because they win 1 big game a year.