NFL
HomeScoresDraftRumorsFantasyB/R 99: Top QBs of All Time
Featured Video
NFL Draft Winners 📊
Tyron Smith (No. 77) was an important part of the Dallas Cowboys' victory.
Tyron Smith (No. 77) was an important part of the Dallas Cowboys' victory.Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

NFL1000: Ranking the Top 1000 Players from Week 8

Doug FarrarNov 3, 2016

The Dallas Cowboys and Philadelphia Eagles played an overtime thriller Sunday night, and it wasn't Dak Prescott or Carson Wentz who most informed this week's version of the NFL1000. Instead, it was the two left tackles involved—Dallas' Tyron Smith and Philly's Jason Peters—who came out on top in Dallas' 29-23 win. As our offensive tackles scout Duke Manyweather asserts, Smith was dominant against one of the better defensive fronts in the league.

Smith did allow a sack and a handful of pressures, but he just bowled people over in the run game, making the Eagles defenders look like high school kids at times. When Smith is on, there's little question he's the best in the business, and he earned his spot at the top of the NFL1000 list this week. Peters was nearly as good and wound up at the sixth overall spot.

Washington's Trent Williams is right up there with Smith and Peters—he ranked fifth overall this week—but the Redskins will have to attempt their playoff push without him for the next four games, as the NFL suspended Williams on Tuesday for violating the league's policy on substances of abuse. It's Williams's second such suspension in his career—the previous suspension happened in 2011—and backup Ty Nsekhe will have to roll in Williams' place. Make no mistake, this is a big loss.

Better news came for the Carolina Panthers, who had been waiting all season for their front four to put it together. Through most of their 2-5 start to the season, the defending NFC champs have seen different running backs gash their defense, and the team's sack and pressure totals have declined.

But in Carolina's 30-20 win over the Arizona Cardinals, Star Lotulelei and that front four went to town on Carson Palmer and his crew. Lotulelei was particularly great, amassing three sacks, three quarterback hurries and three stops. That performance game him the NFC Defensive Player of the Week award and ranked him second overall on the Week 8 NFL1000 list.

Part of Bleacher Report's NFL1000 player rating methodology that matters is the ability to look at our grades from week to week (as you, dear reader, can) and suss out which patterns are turning into trends and which are flukes in the relatively small sample size of an NFL season.

There are many ways to dissect and learn from what the NFL presents on the field every week, and the NFL1000 goes as deep as any to tell you just what's going on out there.

With a 17-person crew of experienced evaluators, we'll comb through the game tape each week to bring you concise, clear evaluations of every player in the NFL. We'll tell you which rookies are rising and which undrafted players are coming out of nowhere to make an impact. We'll tell you which players are rising and falling in performance and why.

There is no predetermined narrative with these grades. No mysterious "clutch factor." No tweaked-out quarterback ratings that defy explanation. Our grades are based on pure scouting, and lots of it. We grade the key criteria for each position based on a series of attributes and add in a score for positional importance.

In the case of a tie, our scouts ask, "Which player would I want on my team?" and adjust accordingly.

Is it a subjective process? Of course—that's what scouting is, and as we like to say, ties are no fun.

Each player is evaluated and graded by our crack team of scouts, who possess more than 100 combined years of experience in playing, front-office work, coaching and media. Cian Fahey, John Middlekauff, Alex Kirby, Mark Schofield, Duke Manyweather, Ethan Young, Joe Goodberry, Justis Mosqueda, Charles McDonald, Zach Kruse, Derrik Klassen, Jerod Brown, Ian Wharton, Kyle Posey, Mark Bullock, Chuck Zodda and Doug Farrar have watched tape for months to bring you these grades, and we'll be bringing you player grades based on the game action every week.

Here are the NFL1000 player grades for Week 8 of the 2016 NFL season.

All advanced stats are courtesy of Pro Football Focus.

All cornerback statistics obtained through self-charting by Ian Wharton and Kyle Posey.

Methodology

1 of 22

The NFL1000 team of scouts was given a series of important attributes to grade for every player in its positional review. Using a grading scale starting at 0 and going up to anywhere from 10 to 40 based on the position and the attribute, our scouts have graded each player based on their own expertise and countless hours of tape review over the years. Our evaluators received specific positional assignments based on their proven fields of expertise. 

  • Doug Farrar: Lead scout
  • Cian Fahey: Quarterbacks
  • John Middlekauff: Running backs/fullbacks
  • Alex Kirby: Wide receivers/tight ends
  • Mark Schofield: Wide receivers/tight ends
  • Duke Manyweather: Offensive tackles
  • Ethan Young: Offensive guards/centers
  • Joe Goodberry: AFC defensive ends
  • Justis Mosqueda: NFC defensive ends
  • Charles McDonald: Defensive tackles
  • Zach Kruse: 3-4 outside linebackers
  • Derrik Klassen: 4-3 outside linebackers
  • Jerod Brown: Inside linebackers
  • Kyle Posey: Cornerbacks
  • Ian Wharton: Cornerbacks
  • Mark Bullock: Safeties
  • Chuck Zodda: Special teams

We observe and grade every NFL player with snaps in offensive and defensive roles based on a multitiered process that marks specific attributes per position. As we're combing through All-22 footage to assess each performance, there are additional factors we consider.

We adjust for opponent based on the obvious notion that the cornerback we're grading is doing a better job if he's shutting down Antonio Brown than if he's negating the efforts of a seventh-round rookie receiver.

We'll also adjust for players with multiple responsibilities in the course of a game and over the course of time. Think of guys such as J.J. Watt and Michael Bennett on the defensive line—how they seamlessly switch from gap to gap. Or how cornerbacks such as Chris Harris Jr. and Tyrann Mathieu dominate outside and in the slot. Or how receivers such as Doug Baldwin and Larry Fitzgerald bedevil those cornerbacks from multiple field positions.

That's more important than ever in today's NFL, and we pay attention to it.

We will not adjust for injuries. If a player is underperforming because of an injury, that's part of his performance, fair or unfair, and we'll grade him accordingly.

Grading any player is a subjective process, but with a series of attributes per position and a specific direction as to what to grade and how, we'll make it as definitive as possible.

Top 50 Overall from Week 8

2 of 22

Injuries have affected the NFL career of San Diego Chargers linebacker Melvin Ingram to a degree, which delayed the process I expected to see when he came out of South Carolina in the 2012 draft. Back then, he was the best defensive player in his class, capable of generating pressure from any gap. Now, fully healthy and with a fellow first-round line partner in Joey Bosa, Ingram has become that kind of player again.

Defensive coordinator John Pagano uses him as an edge weapon more often, but he'll have stretches of games where he is just about unblockable. His game Sunday against the Denver Broncos, in which he had a sack, two quarterback hits and three quarterback hurries, was one of his best—and puts him third in this week's NFL1000.

Khalil Mack, another AFC West pass-rusher, hasn't always played his best football this season, but he was as good as advertised against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers with 11(!) total pressures.

One of the reasons the Chicago Bears were able to upset the Minnesota Vikings on Monday night was the play of linebacker Jerrell Freeman and multigap pass-rusher Pernell McPhee. The 2-6 Bears might be on the wrong side of the playoffs this season, but defensive coordinator Vic Fangio can still get things done when he has the horses. It's starting to look better in the Windy City from that standpoint.

Here, without further ado, is the top 50 for Week 8's NFL1000.

Top 50 Overall from Week 8
RankPlayerPos.TeamNFL1000 ScoreLWMoving
1Tyron SmithLTDAL87NR
2Star LotuleleiDTCAR86NR
3Melvin Ingram3-4 OLBSD8524
4Khalil Mack4-3 DEOAK84166
5Trent WilliamsLTWAS847
6Jason PetersLTPHI8322
7Jerrell FreemanILBCHI8241
8Aaron RodgersQBGB822
9David BakhtiariLTGB8242
10Bradley RobyCBDEN81576
11Pernell McPhee3-4 OLBCHI81854
12Joe ThomasLTCLE8111
13Von Miller3-4 OLBDEN80169
14Bobby WagnerILBSEA8010
15Wil LutzKNO80470
16Jonathan StewartRBCAR79NR
17Derek CarrQBOAK79472
18Darian StewartFSDEN7935
19Tyler EifertTECIN79602
20Michael CrabtreeWROAK79193
21Bryan BulagaRTGB7975
22Shawn WilliamsSSCIN79267
23Todd DavisILBDEN79309
24Ezekiel ElliottRBDAL79NR
25Marcus MariotaQBTEN79637
26Calvin PryorSSNYJ79268
27DeMarco MurrayRBTEN7972
28Luke KuechlyILBCAR79NR
29Graham GanoKCAR79NR
30Cordy GlennLTBUF7957
31Adrian PhillipsSSSD79689
32Kareem JacksonCBHOU79899
33Devin McCourtyFSNE7965
34Brian CushingILBHOU79365
35Pat McAfeePIND79426
36Zach StriefRTNO7858
37Tom BradyQBNE7854
38Marcus GilchristFSNYJ7885
39Tony JeffersonSSARI7812
40A.J. GreenWRCIN78149
41Matt RyanQBATL78276
42Geno AtkinsDTCIN78302
43Taylor LewanLTTEN7818
44T.J. WardSSDEN7836
45Stephen GostkowskiKNE78944
46Whitney Mercilus3-4 OLBHOU78305
47Su'a CravensILBWAS78172
48Brandon BrooksOGPHI77203
49Calais Campbell3-4 DEARI7777
50Cam NewtonQBCAR77NR

Quarterbacks

3 of 22

The obvious question this week is, how did Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers rank above Oakland Raiders signal-caller Derek Carr?

Carr had a historic outing against the Buccaneers, becoming the third quarterback in league history to have 500 passing yards, four touchdowns and no interceptions in a contest. His No. 2 overall ranking this week shows he played well, so receive the following criticisms through that prism.

Carr missed too many downfield throws to open receivers and was responsible for his fumble early in the game when he was oblivious to the arriving hit in the pocket. In the fourth quarter, before throwing his game-tying touchdown, Carr missed Michael Crabtree for a long touchdown opportunity and threw a pass Brent Grimes would have intercepted if Crabtree hadn't interfered with the cornerback just before the ball arrived. Officials didn't flag Crabtree on the play, but his interference was obvious.

Carr's historic production was the result of a good performance combined with defensive backs who couldn't cover his receivers and his outrageous 59 pass attempts.

Rodgers had a statistically significant outing also. He threw four touchdowns and completed over 70 percent of his passes against the Atlanta Falcons. The Packers signal-caller pipped ahead of Carr because he didn't fumble and didn't have any passes that should have been intercepted. He also showed more consistency with his ball placement on downfield throws.

Matt Ryan had another strong outing playing across from Rodgers. He and offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan are in sync, which the game-winning touchdown throw to Mohamed Sanu highlighted. Shanahan called a Cover 2 beater that worked perfectly, and Ryan executed it on time with a precise pass the defense had no chance of deflecting.

Tampa Bay's Jameis Winston, who played against Carr's Oakland Raiders, had a game that has become too typical for him. The Bucs quarterback did most things at a high level. That wasn't noticable unless you were watching closely, though, because his accuracy, like during his rookie year, sabotaged the rest of his performance. In this game, he repeatedly missed Mike Evans when he was comfortably open downfield. Evans (6'5") is a huge receiver with the athleticism to move at high speed and the skills to adjust to the ball in the air. Winston shouldn't be missing him as often as he is.

Speaking of missing receivers, Jacksonville's Blake Bortles had a disastrous display against the Tennessee Titans on Thursday night, and the Jaguars fired Greg Olson as their offensive coordinator Saturday. It's hard to see how a coaching change will make a difference when Bortles has trouble throwing the ball to open receivers or reading simple coverages. He's a disaster at this stage of his career.

Only Andy Dalton outdid Bortles. The Cincinnati Bengals quarterback was lucky not to throw six interceptions against Washington in London. He repeatedly missed big plays when A.J. Green was open deep, and he was fortunate Josh Norman dropped three interceptions. Had the Bengals even gotten average play from the position, they would have been comfortable victors. Instead, they settled for a tie.

Grading Scale

Acc: Accuracy (Graded out of 25)

Arm: Arm Strength (Graded out of 25)

Press: Pressure/run threat (Graded out of 20) (Pressure weighted at 15, run threat at 5)

Dec: Decision-Making (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Quarterback Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamAccArmPressDecPosOvr
1Aaron RodgersGB202116151082
2Derek CarrOAK182314141079
3Marcus MariotaTEN182115151079
4Tom BradyNE202015131078
5Matt RyanATL201815151078
6Cam NewtonCAR152416121077
7Drew BreesNO182014141076
8Carson PalmerARI162113151075
9Andrew LuckIND152214121073
10Jay CutlerCHI162213121073
11Kirk CousinsWAS151814131070
12Nick FolesKC161613151070
13Tyrod TaylorBUF142014121070
14Jameis WinstonTB101815151068
15Philip RiversSD141814121068
16Sam BradfordMIN151911131068
17Alex SmithKC151812121067
18Russell WilsonSEA151810131066
19Carson WentzPHI151712111065
20Dak PrescottDAL131814101065
21Trevor SiemianDEN15181391065
22Matthew StaffordDET141912101065
23EJ ManuelBUF161810101064
24Brock OsweilerHOU141712111064
25Ryan FitzpatrickNYJ131711111062
26Josh McCownCLE131710111061
27Blake BortlesJAX1016991054
28Andy DaltonCIN1016981053

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

TOP NEWS

NFL Draft Football

Running Backs

4 of 22

From a production standpoint, it was not a great week for NFL running backs. Some of the top players had bye weeks (Le'Veon Bell and Todd Gurley), while others continued to miss time with serious injuries. The Kansas City Chiefs announced they placed Jamaal Charles on injured reserved for the second straight year, and it looks like his career might be in serious jeopardy. Also, Arian Foster retired as arguably one of the greatest undrafted free-agent running backs ever.

One of my highest-graded players this season, David Johnson, had a tough time getting anything going on the ground against the Panthers. He finished with 24 yards on 10 carries. He was able to continue his dominance in the passing game, however, adding 84 yards on seven catches. The Panthers welcomed back star running back Jonathan Stewart, who helped get the offense rolling with two touchdowns.

DeMarco Murray might have all but wrapped up the 2016 Comeback Player of the Year Award against the Jaguars on Thursday Night Football. He was excellent both inside and outside the tackles while showing he might be the most physical back in the league and finished with 123 yards rushing and a touchdown. He also might be the best trade acquisition for any general manager in the offseason; no team got more for less in a deal this season.

Melvin Gordon was really good against the Denver Broncos, rushing for 111 yards. He may never live up to being a high first-round pick, but he is becoming a consistent player.

Philly's Darren Sproles turned back the clock against the Cowboys, while the Detroit Lions' Theo Riddick returned from injury with a bang against the Houston Texans. Even though both runners are smaller at 5'6" and 5'9", respectively, they showed Sunday they pack a punch on contact and are two complete football players.

Spencer Ware's concussion was the biggest injury news of the weekend. The Chiefs catch a break because they face the 2-5 Jaguars in Kansas City.

Grading Scale

In: Inside Running (Graded out of 25)

Out: Outside Running (Graded out of 25)

Rec: Receiving (Graded out of 20)

Blk: Blocking (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Running Back Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamInOutRecBlkPosOvr
1Jonathan StewartCAR20181718679
2Ezekiel ElliottDAL19181818679
3DeMarco MurrayTEN21191617679
4Jordan HowardCHI19171817677
5Derrick HenryTEN19161816675
6David JohnsonARI17171916675
7Darren SprolesPHI19171716675
8Theo RiddickDET17181816675
9Melvin GordonSD18181716675
10Duke Johnson Jr.CLE17171816674
11Latavius MurrayOAK17171716673
12Giovani BernardCIN18171616673
13Tim HightowerNO17171616672
14Alfred BlueHOU19161516672
15Devontae BookerDEN18161616672
16Devonta FreemanATL17151716671
17C.J. ProsiseSEA15171815671
18Bilal PowellNYJ18171515671
19Jeremy HillCIN18161516671
20Spencer WareKC17151616670
21Robert KellyWAS17161516670
22Mike GillisleeBUF17141716670
23Matt ForteNYJ17151616670
24James WhiteNE15161716670
25Jalen RichardOAK18161515670
26Frank GoreIND16141717670
27Christine MichaelSEA17161516670
28Charcandrick WestKC16171615670
29LeGarrette BlountNE17151516669
30DeAndre WashingtonOAK18151515669
31Lamar MillerHOU15171516669
32T.J. YeldonJAX17141516668
33Ryan MathewsPHI16151516668
34Chris ThompsonWAS15161615668
35Terron WardATL15161614667
36Reggie BushBUF14151616667
37Isaiah CrowellCLE15141616667
38Daniel LascoNO16141516667
39Matt AsiataMIN15141616667
40Mark IngramNO15141516666
41Alfred MorrisDAL17141415666
42Zach ZennerDET17141415666
43Travaris CadetNO14141615665
44Robert TurbinIND14141615665
45Jacquizz RodgersTB16141514665
46Fozzy WhittakerCAR13161515665
47Knile DavisGB15141514664
48Kenjon BarnerPHI14151514664
49Chris IvoryJAX14131516664
50Andre EllingtonARI14131615664
51Jonathan GrimesHOU16131415664
52Don JacksonGB13141414661

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Doug Martin—injury
  • Jamaal Charles—injury
  • Eddie Lacy—injury
  • Adrian Peterson—injury
  • LeSean McCoy—injury
  • Ty Montgomery—inactive
  • Le'Veon Bell—bye
  • Carlos Hyde—bye
  • Jay Ajayi—bye
  • Todd Gurley—bye

Fullbacks

5 of 22

The best fullback in the league, Baltimore's Kyle Juszczyk, had a bye, but the position still had a solid Week 8.

Oakland's Jamize Olawale continues to be one of the more underrated players in the NFL. He was solid against Tampa and allowed the Raiders to be physical and versatile on offense. The franchise has one of the better running games in the league because its fullback can do it all.

Aaron Ripkowski was huge for the Packers since they were missing so many running backs with injuries Sunday. He had a career-high six carries and played well against the Falcons as a lead blocker.

Mike Tolbert had his best game of the season, as the return of Jonathan Stewart greatly aided him. Houston's Jay Prosch dominated the Lions as a lead blocker and has established himself as one of the more physical players in the league.

Grading Scale

Blk: Blocking (Graded out of 50)

Run: Running (Graded out of 25)

Rec: Receiving (Graded out of 15)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Fullback Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamBlkRunRecPosOvr
1Jamize OlawaleOAK451710476
2Aaron RipkowskiGB441810476
3Derek WattSD441611475
4Mike TolbertCAR441510473
5Jay ProschHOU45159473
6Andy JanovichDEN45159473
7Keith SmithDAL43169472
8John KuhnNO43169472
9Patrick DiMarcoATL43159471
10James DevelinNE44158471
11Jalston FowlerTEN44158471
12Anthony ShermanKC44158471
13Jerome FeltonBUF421410470
14Will TukuafuSEA43148469
15Michael BurtonDET43148469

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Zach Line—insufficient snaps
  • Kyle Juszczyk—bye

Wide Receivers

6 of 22

Dez Bryant made his return to the Cowboys lineup Sunday night and provided an instant boost to the offense, catching four passes for 113 yards and a pivotal touchdown. He was effective on vertical routes and particularly on back-shoulder throws.

In a big matchup between the Packers and Falcons, Mohamed Sanu played a starring role for the victors. The Atlanta wideout was impressive throughout the game and pivotal on the game-winning drive.

In London, Jamison Crowder had a big day for Washington. He ran solid routes all game long and showed good skill after the catch.

Meanwhile, in the AFC, A.J. Green faced off against Josh Norman and came away with nine catches for 121 yards. Had it not been for a few errant passes from Dalton, the total could've been much higher.

In another overtime game Sunday, Michael Crabtree came up big down the stretch for Oakland. He had eight catches for 108 yards and was a big part of Derek Carr's record-setting day. Teammate Amari Cooper had a bigger statistical day with 12 catches for 173 yards, but he dropped a wide-open pass down the sideline at the end of regulation that would've set up Oakland for a chip-shot field goal that likely would've saved the team from playing an extra quarter of football.

Grading Scale

Route: Route Running (Graded out of 25)

Hands: Hands (Graded out of 25)

YAC: Yards After Catch (Graded out of 20)

Blk: Blocking (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Wide Receiver Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamRouteHandsYACBlkPosOvr
1Michael CrabtreeOAK23231410979
2A.J. GreenCIN24221310978
3Dez BryantDAL21211312976
4Amari CooperOAK21191511975
5Mohamed SanuATL19201413975
6Terrelle Pryor Sr.CLE22201311975
7Julian EdelmanNE21201510975
8Jamison CrowderWAS20201412975
9J.J. NelsonARI19191412973
10Larry FitzgeraldARI18191413973
11Alshon JefferyCHI18201313973
12Demaryius ThomasDEN21201211973
13Seth RobertsOAK19181314973
14Jordy NelsonGB18201312972
15DeAndre HopkinsHOU21191211972
16Jeremy MaclinKC17171613972
17Brandon MarshallNYJ22191210972
18Quincy EnunwaNYJ21181212972
19Andrew HawkinsCLE20201210971
20Emmanuel SandersDEN20201111971
21Danny AmendolaNE18191312971
22Rishard MatthewsTEN18201113971
23Pierre GarconWAS19181312971
24T.Y. HiltonIND19181410970
25Stefon DiggsMIN18191212970
26Michael ThomasNO19181212970
27John BrownARI17191212969
28Kelvin BenjaminCAR17181312969
29Travis BenjaminSD20181210969
30Robert WoodsBUF19171211968
31Tyler BoydCIN19171211968
32Golden TateDET18171311968
33Will Fuller VHOU19181111968
34Donte MoncriefIND19191110968
35Chris HoganNE18171212968
36Willie SneadNO18171212968
37Dontrelle InmanSD19181210968
38Julio JonesATL18161212967
39Brandon LaFellCIN18161113967
40Cole BeasleyDAL18171211967
41Marvin JonesDET17171212967
42Davante AdamsGB17171311967
43Allen HurnsJAX18171310967
44Tyreek HillKC17171410967
45Adam ThielenMIN16171312967
46Taylor GabrielATL16181112966
47Jeff JanisGB17171211966
48Doug BaldwinSEA17161212966
49Mike EvansTB18161211966
50Tajae SharpeTEN17171310966
51DeSean JacksonWAS17171211966
52Justin HunterBUF2115119965
53Ted Ginn Jr.CAR16171211965
54Trevor DavisGB16171112965
55Phillip DorsettIND16181210965
56Marqise LeeJAX17161310965
57Chris ConleyKC16161212965
58Brandin CooksNO17161211965
59Brandon ColemanNO16161212965
60Jordan MatthewsPHI16161212965
61Tyrell WilliamsSD19161110965
62Adam HumphriesTB16161311965
63Cameron MeredithCHI16151212964
64Ricardo LouisCLE18161110964
65Terrance WilliamsDAL16161211964
66Jordan NorwoodDEN17151112964
67Anquan BoldinDET16151113964
68Geronimo AllisonGB16161211964
69Allen RobinsonJAX17161210964
70Cordarrelle PattersonMIN16161211964
71Jermaine KearseSEA17161111964
72Russell ShepardTB15171112964
73Kendall WrightTEN16171210964
74Ryan GrantWAS16161211964
75Brittan GoldenARI16161111963
76Devin FunchessCAR16161111963
77Philly BrownCAR15151212963
78Robby AndersonNYJ17161110963
79Nelson AgholorPHI15151212963
80Josh HuffPHI15151311963
81Justin HardyATL16141112962
82Brandon TateBUF16151210962
83Josh BellamyCHI16151111962
84Rashard HigginsCLE15171110962
85Brice ButlerDAL15151112962
86Braxton MillerHOU15161210962
87Dorial Green-BeckhamPHI15151112962
88Tyler LockettSEA16151111962
89Deonte ThompsonCHI15151111961
90Lucky WhiteheadDAL14141113961
91Jordan TaylorDEN16141111961
92Cody LatimerDEN15151111961
93Jaelen StrongHOU14161012961
94Andre HolmesOAK14151211961
95Johnny HoltonOAK13131313961
96Paul RichardsonSEA15151111961
97Cecil ShortsTB16141111961
98Michael FloydARI15141111960
99Jordan PaytonCLE15151011960
100Charone PeakeNYJ15151110960
101Andre JohnsonTEN14161011960
102Aldrick RobinsonATL14141111959
103Andre RobertsDET14141111959
104Bryan WaltersJAX15141110959
105Charles JohnsonMIN14141111959
106Maurice HarrisWAS14141111959
107Bennie FowlerDEN15131110958
108Arrelious BennJAX13141210958
109Albert WilsonKC14131111958
110Freddie MartinoTB14141110958
111Walt PowellBUF1514109957
112De'Anthony ThomasKC14131110957
113Matthew SlaterNE13131110956
114James WrightCIN13131010955
115Devin StreetIND15111010955

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Jaron Brown—injury
  • Eddie Royal—injury
  • Kevin White—injury
  • Randall Cobb—injury
  • Vincent Jackson—injury
  • Josh Doctson—injury
  • Tavon Austin—bye
  • Kenny Britt—bye
  • Brian Quick—bye
  • Odell Beckham Jr.—bye
  • Sterling Shepard—bye
  • Victor Cruz—bye
  • Torrey Smith—bye
  • Jeremy Kerley—bye
  • Quinton Patton—bye

Tight Ends

7 of 22

Eric Ebron returned to the lineup for Detroit, and while the Lions fell to the Texans, Ebron was impressive. He caught seven passes for 79 yards and made an impact as a blocker. Elsewhere, other big names fell back a bit, including Dallas' Jason Witten and Carolina's Greg Olsen. Witten caught the game-winning touchdown in overtime, but he only had two catches for 16 yards.

It was a great day for the tight end position in the AFC, as Travis Kelce came up big for coach Andy Reid and the Chiefs in Indianapolis on a day when quarterback Alex Smith was out for much of the game. Kelce, who finished with 101 yards receiving and a touchdown, terrorized the Colts secondary all game long, and it had no answer for him.

New England's Rob Gronkowski and Martellus Bennett continued their reign of terror as the best tight end duo in the game, this time on the road against head coach Rex Ryan’s Buffalo Bills. They picked apart the secondary with seam routes and on back-shoulder throws down the sideline.

Finally, after bringing in nine catches for 102 yards and a touchdown, Cincinnati's Tyler Eifert looks like he never missed a single rep in practice. Though the game ended in a tie, Eifert's return to the lineup made the Bengals look like a brand-new offense. Through some crisp, creative route running, he’s already put opponents on notice that he’s just as dangerous as he’s always been.

Grading Scale

Route: Route Running (Graded out of 20)

Hands: Hands (Graded out of 25)

YAC: Yards After Catch (Graded out of 20)

Blk: Blocking (Graded out of 25)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Tight End Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamRouteHandsYACBlkPosOvr
1Tyler EifertCIN18231418679
2Travis KelceKC18211416675
3Rob GronkowskiNE18201318675
4Martellus BennettNE16191519675
5Jordan ReedWAS16201616674
6C.J. FiedorowiczHOU16191219672
7Antonio GatesSD17201217672
8Vernon DavisWAS15181419672
9Charles ClayBUF17161022671
10Eric EbronDET16191317671
11Ryan GriffinHOU16191218671
12Clive WalfordOAK16171319671
13Virgil GreenDEN15181219670
14Zach MillerCHI15181218669
15Delanie WalkerTEN16181217669
16Cameron BrateTB14181218668
17Gary BarnidgeCLE14181118667
18Jimmy GrahamSEA14171218667
19Kyle RudolphMIN13151319666
20Austin HooperATL14161217665
21Zach ErtzPHI14181116665
22Hunter HenrySD14171117665
23Anthony FasanoTEN11141123665
24Julius ThomasJAX15181114664
25Tyler KroftCIN12161019663
26Geoff SwaimDAL13161216663
27Stephen AndersonHOU13161216663
28Phillip SupernawTEN13141119663
29Greg OlsenCAR14141216662
30Ryan HewittCIN12141020662
31Jason WittenDAL13151117662
32Coby FleenerNO13151216662
33Kellen DavisNYJ12141119662
34Brandon BostickNYJ12151118662
35Mychal RiveraOAK13171115662
36Nick O'LearyBUF12131020661
37Seth DeValveCLE12141019661
38Jermaine GreshamARI13151215661
39Jack DoyleIND12141118661
40Logan PaulsenCHI12151116660
41Marcedes LewisJAX12151017660
42Demetrius HarrisKC14151015660
43Sean McGrathSD11131119660
44Nick VannettSEA12151116660
45Ben BrauneckerCHI12151115659
46Randall TelferCLE12141017659
47John PhillipsDEN11141117659
48Richard RodgersGB12141116659
49Erik SwoopesIND12151115659
50Rhett EllisonMIN11141117659
51Brent CelekPHI12141116659
52Levine ToiloloATL11141116658
53Josh HillNO14151112658
54Trey BurtonPHI12141115658
55Ifeanyi MomahARI11141116658
56Brandon WilliamsSEA11141116658
57Luke StockerTB11141116658
58Ed DicksonCAR11141115657
59Khari LeeDET11141115657
60Justin PerilloGB11141115657
61Brandon MyersTB11141115657
62Niles PaulWAS11141115657
63Jeff HeuermanDEN10131016655
64James O'ShaughnessyKC10131015654
65Ben KoyackJAX10131013652

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Jacob Tamme—insufficient snaps
  • Troy Niklas—injury
  • Jared Cook—injury
  • Luke Willson—injury
  • Lance Kendricks—bye
  • Larry Donnell—bye
  • Will Tye—bye
  • Vance MacDonald—bye
  • Garrett Celek—bye
  • Jordan Cameron—bye
  • Dion Sims—bye
  • Jesse James—bye
  • Dennis Pitta—bye
  • Crockett Gillmore—bye
  • Maxx Williams—bye

Left Tackles

8 of 22

As discussed earlier, Tyron Smith was the top performer at left tackle in Week 8. The Cowboys' All-Pro was solid from the opening snap against the Eagles on Sunday Night Football but surrendered a sack to Marcus Smith on the first drive, which seemed to ignite a fire in the Pro Bowler. Smith was dominant in both pass protection and in the running game, and he finished many plays with knockdowns. 

Trent Williams earned the top spot in Week 7 and saw his ranking slip one spot. Last week, we mentioned Washington's All-Pro tackle had been on a tear all season—and that theme held true Sunday. Ironically, it was not clear until late in the week whether Williams would be available to play because of a knee injury he suffered on the second-to-last play of Week 7's game versus the Detroit Lions.

Much to the chagrin of the Redskins, the NFL announced Tuesday that Williams would be suspended the next four games for violating the league's policy on substance abuse. He will be eligible to return to competition in Week 14 versus the Eagles.

Keeping with the theme of NFC East left tackles, Philadelphia's Jason Peters grabbed the third slot in our rankings. He played a tremendous game versus the Cowboys and continues to display the freaky physical traits that have taken him from being an undrafted free agent out of Arkansas to becoming one of the elite offensive linemen in all of football.

David Bakhtiari of the Green Bay Packers also turned in another solid performance versus the Atlanta Falcons. He is becoming one of my favorite offensive tackles to study, specifically in terms of his pass-protection mastery.

Grading Scale

Pass: Pass Protection (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Blocking (Graded out of 25)

Power: Power (Graded out of 20)

Agl: Agility (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Left Tackle Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPassRunPowerAglPosOvr
1Tyron SmithDAL20231818887
2Trent WilliamsWAS20181919884
3Jason PetersPHI19192017883
4David BakhtiariGB20181620882
5Joe ThomasCLE21171520881
6Cordy GlennBUF19201715879
7Taylor LewanTEN19191616878
8Jake MatthewsATL19181616877
9Andrew WhitworthCIN19191515876
10Donald PennOAK19181615876
11Taylor DeckerDET18181615875
12Duane BrownHOU18181615875
13Eric FisherKC17181516874
14Jared VeldheerARI18181415873
15Mike RemmersCAR18181613873
16Terron ArmsteadNO19161514872
17Russell OkungDEN17161516872
18Kelvin BeachumJAX16181415871
19King DunlapSD17181413870
20Donovan SmithTB16171514870
21Charles Leno Jr.CHI16161514869
22John WetzelARI17151514869
23Ryan CladyNYJ16171414869
24Nate SolderNE14171415868
25Jake LongMIN15151514867
26Anthony CastonzoIND14171314866
27Chris HairstonSD16171212865
28George FantSEA16161213865

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Luke Joeckel—injury
  • Matt Kalil—injury
  • Bradley Sowell—injury
  • Michael Oher—injury
  • Branden Albert—bye
  • Greg Robinson—bye
  • Ronnie Stanley—bye
  • Alex Lewis—bye
  • Ereck Flowers—bye
  • Alejandro Villanueva—bye
  • Joe Staley—bye

Right Tackles

9 of 22

Green Bay's Bryan Bulaga was the top performer at right tackle. Through eight weeks, he has been outstanding and should be in strong consideration for the player's vote for the Pro Bowl.

New Orleans' Zach Strief has also had a solid eight weeks and continues to be impressive. He's second in our rankings and plays the position with the physical edge it's meant have.

Tennesse's Jack Conklin has been solid all season, but the rookie was impressive against the Jaguars. He showed tremendous strength, power and physicality in the running game and was stout in pass protection by picking his spots closely to set and pass-protect aggressively.

Washington's Morgan Moses turned in another all-around stout performance both in pass protection and in the running game against the Cincinnati Bengals. With Williams suspended four weeks, Washington will depend on Moses to be a major anchor. You have to wonder if the Redskins will consider shifting Moses to left tackle and install swing tackle Ty Nsekhe into the right tackle slot. Nsekhe has game experience at both tackle spots this season. 

Grading Scale

Pass: Pass Protection (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Blocking (Graded out of 25)

Power: Power (Graded out of 20)

Agl: Agility (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Right Tackle Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPassRunPowerAglPosOvr
1Bryan BulagaGB20191716779
2Zach StriefNO19201715778
3Jack ConklinTEN19201615777
4Morgan MosesWAS18181617776
5Ryan SchraederATL18191616776
6Bobby MassieCHI19181516775
7Eric WinstonCIN18171616774
8Riley ReiffDET17201614774
9Demar DotsonTB18171516773
10Daryl WilliamsCAR19171515773
11Halapoulivaati VaitaiPHI18171615773
12Austin PasztorCLE18171515772
13Mitchell SchwartzKC17181614772
14Breno GiacominiNYJ18181514772
15Jordan MillsBUF17171614771
16Jermey ParnellJAX17171416771
17Ty NsekheWAS17171515771
18D.J. HumphriesARI17171514770
19Donald StephensonDEN17161416770
20Marcus CannonNE17161614770
21Chris ClarkHOU17181314769
22Austin HowardOAK16171613769
23Ben IjalanaNYJ16171514769
24Cedric OgbuehiCIN16151416768
25Garry GilliamSEA15171415768
26Doug FreeDAL15171514768
27Joe BarksdaleSD17161314767
28Joe ReitzIND15161514767
29Cornelius LucasDET15151413764
30T.J. ClemmingsMIN12141412759

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Derek Newton—injury
  • Andre Smith Jr.—injury
  • Menelik Watson—injury
  • Lane Johnson—suspension
  • Ja'Wuan James—bye
  • Ricky Wagner—bye
  • Marshall Newhouse—bye
  • Bobby Hart—bye
  • Trenton Brown—bye
  • Marcus Gilbert—bye
  • Chris Hubbard—bye
  • Rob Havenstein—bye

Offensive Guards

10 of 22

You know it's a strange week in guard play when you are writing about the stellar performances of Brian Winters and Brian Schwenke. The Brians put forth arguably the best tape of their careers this past weekend for the New York Jets and Titans, respectively.

While the weak opposing fronts of Cleveland and Jacksonville made life way easier on these guys, it was hard to ignore the consistent nature of their play from top to bottom. Winters was particularly impressive in pass protection, showing off a level of hand usage and placement I hadn't seen from him previously.

On the other end of the spectrum, Arizona's Mike Iupati (who has had a great year until his recent injuries) struggled. He's been noticeably banged up the last couple of weeks, and a tough Panthers front exposed that Sunday. The Cardinals have a lot of injuries right now, especially up front, so they need Iupati to get healthy before Carson Palmer gets killed. 

Grading Scale

Pass: Pass Protection (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Blocking (Graded out of 25)

Power: Power (Graded out of 20)

Agl: Agility (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Offensive Guard Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPassRunPowerAglPosOvr
1Brandon BrooksPHI19171717777
2Brandon ScherffWAS18181716776
3Kelechi OsemeleOAK17191814775
4Brian WintersNYJ20161715775
5Andrus PeatNO17191517775
6Brian SchwenkeTEN18191714775
7Trai TurnerCAR17181814774
8Richie IncognitoBUF17181814774
9Ali MarpetTB18151716773
10Andrew NorwellCAR16181715773
11James CarpenterNYJ17181714773
12Ronald LearyDAL19161614772
13Clint BolingCIN18141716772
14Larry WarfordDET17161715772
15Shaq MasonNE15171617772
16Zack MartinDAL18151714771
17D.J. FlukerSD16181713771
18Kevin PamphileTB18161614771
19Mark GlowinskiSEA14181616771
20Joe ThuneyNE16141518770
21Alex BooneMIN17141616770
22Stefen WisniewskiPHI17161614770
23Josh KlineTEN16171614770
24Max GarciaDEN18151713770
25Orlando FranklinSD15181713770
26Jeff AllenHOU16161614769
27John MillerBUF16161614769
28John GrecoCLE16151714769
29T.J. LangGB16141715769
30Joe HaegIND16141517769
31Zach FultonKC16161613768
32Jahri EvansNO14171713768
33Ted LarsenCHI16151614768
34Laurent Duvernay-TardifKC16151416768
35Gabe JacksonOAK15161713768
36Lane TaylorGB16131517768
37Michael SchofieldDEN16151614768
38Chris ChesterATL15151614767
39Kevin ZeitlerCIN16131615767
40Eric KushCHI14161614767
41Jonotthan HarrisonIND15151713767
42Germain IfediSEA13171713767
43Alvin BaileyCLE15141515766
44Xavier Su'a-FiloHOU13161713766
45Spencer DrangoCLE14151515766
46Parker EhingerKC14151613765
47Andy LevitreATL14151514765
48A.J. CannJAX14131614764
49Graham GlasgowDET12151614764
50Shawn LauvaoWAS13151612763
51Patrick OmamehJAX14141513763
52Denzelle GoodIND13151512762
53Earl WatfordARI13141513762
54Brandon FuscoMIN13131513761
55Mike IupatiARI12141511759

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Joshua Garnett—bye
  • Zane Beadles—bye
  • Justin Pugh—bye
  • John Jerry—bye
  • John Urschel—bye
  • Ryan Jensen—bye
  • David DeCastro—bye
  • Ramon Foster—bye
  • Laremy Tunsil—bye
  • Jermon Bushrod—bye
  • Rodger Saffold—bye
  • Cody Wichmann—bye
  • Allen Barbre—injury
  • Kyle Long—injury
  • Jack Mewhort—injury
  • Josh Sitton—injury
  • Joel Bitonio—injury
  • Laken Tomlinson—insufficient snaps
  • Evan Mathis—injury
  • Senio Kelemete—insufficient snaps

Centers

11 of 22

Center has been a wild ride this year, as players continue to move up and down the weekly rankings. One player who hasn't moved around much, though, is Cameron Erving, who came in dead last again this week.

It seems like there are two or three reps every week where Erving is blown off the ball, which can't happen at the NFL level. Those bad reps end up being drive-killing losses, and having a couple of these every game kills the offense. 

Grading Scale

Pass: Pass Protection (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Blocking (Graded out of 25)

Power: Power (Graded out of 20)

Agl: Agility (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Center Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPassRunPowerAglPosOvr
1Greg ManczHOU18211715677
2Justin BrittSEA16201716675
3Rodney HudsonOAK19161716674
4Matt SlausonSD17191616674
5Travis FrederickDAL18171715673
6Joe HawleyTB19171714673
7Ryan KalilCAR16191714672
8Travis SwansonDET18161616672
9Wesley JohnsonNYJ18171615672
10Spencer LongWAS16181714671
11Matt ParadisDEN17161715671
12Ryan KellyIND17161616671
13Joe BergerMIN17161714670
14Max UngerNO17181613670
15Gino GradkowskiCAR15201612669
16Alex MackATL17151516669
17Mitch MorseKC16151417668
18Brandon LinderJAX18131615668
19A.Q. ShipleyARI17161415668
20Cody WhitehairCHI16141516667
21Russell BodineCIN16151614667
22Jason KelcePHI16151515667
23JC TretterGB14151615666
24David AndrewsNE15151613665
25Ben JonesTEN14161315664
26Eric WoodBUF14141613663
27Cameron ErvingCLE12141414660

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Tim Barnes—bye
  • Jeremy Zuttah—bye
  • Maurkice Pouncey—bye
  • Weston Richburg—bye
  • Mike Pouncey—bye
  • Daniel Kilgore—bye
  • Nick Mangold—injury

3-4 Defensive Ends

12 of 22
Derek Wolfe (No. 95)
Derek Wolfe (No. 95)

It was a good week for 3-4 defensive ends. The usual suspects are near the top, but I'd like to focus on Derek Wolfe in Denver. The Broncos' talented defense often overshadows him, and he may have started the year slowly. But against the Chargers, Wolfe showed he's still a premier defensive lineman in the NFL.

The 26-year-old had a handful of pressures and a run stop, and his biggest plays came when he hurried quarterback Philip Rivers and forced a bad pass that turned into an interception. He then ended the 27-19 victory with a complete beating of the Chargers right guard and hurried Rivers into a poor throw.

Impact plays are great, but when they come at the perfect time, they get a higher score. It might also be time to start noticing how good Akiem Hicks is for the Chicago Bears. He's a big guy who can clog the run, plus he has the athleticism to rush the passer. He's a bright spot on a bad Bears team. 

Grading Scale

Snap: Snap Explosion (Graded out of 15)

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 30)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

3-4 Defensive End Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamSnapRushRunTklPosOvr
1Calais CampbellARI13212016777
2Mike DanielsGB13192115775
3Derek WolfeDEN12192214774
4Joey BosaSD14172114773
5Ziggy HoodWAS13172014771
6Emmanuel OgbahCLE12142215770
7Jadeveon ClowneyHOU13171914770
8Chris L. BakerWAS11171915769
9Josh MauroARI12151915768
10Robert NkemdicheARI13161814768
11Akiem HicksCHI12171814768
12Jared CrickDEN10171914767
13Jaye HowardKC10152114767
14Chris JonesKC12181713767
15Jurrell CaseyTEN11171813766
16Adolphus WashingtonBUF10142014765
17Carl NassibCLE12171712765
18Ricky Jean-FrancoisWAS11161813765
19Mitch UnreinCHI11151814765
20Jonathan BullardCHI12151714765
21Leger DouzableBUF9151914764
22Cornelius WashingtonCHI11161614764
23Billy WinnDEN9132113763
24Corey LiugetSD10151813763
25Tenny PalepoiSD9141914763
26Anthony LanierWAS10151714763
27Frostee RuckerARI11151713763
28Xavier CooperCLE11141812762
29Antonio SmithHOU10151713762
30Denico AutryOAK10141813762
31Jamie MederCLE8122014761
32Karl KlugTEN12131712761
33Angelo BlacksonTEN9141813761
34Mike PennelGB10131614760
35Arthur JonesIND9121712757
36DaQuan JonesTEN9121612756
37Christian CovingtonHOU7121612754

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Kendall Langford—inactive
  • Henry Anderson—inactive
  • J.J. Watt—injury
  • Allen Bailey—injury
  • Timmy Jernigan—bye
  • Lawrence Guy—bye
  • Cameron Heyward—bye
  • Stephon Tuitt—bye
  • Ricardo Mathews—bye
  • DeForest Buckner—bye
  • Arik Armstead—bye
  • Quinton Dial—bye

4-3 Defensive Ends

13 of 22

In a dominant performance, Oakland's Khalil Mack earned an elite score. This was the game we've been waiting for, and Mack delivered with two sacks, seven hurries and five stops against Tampa Bay.

In the NFC, Seattle-style Cover 3 defenses are producing some of the best pass-rushing units in the conference. During his second season in the league, Atlanta's Vic Beasley made his move. On Sunday, his teammate Adrian Clayborn added two sacks against Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers, while Beasley spied the passer for long stretches of the game.

With Seattle's missing Michael Bennett, who is still out with a knee injury, Frank Clark entered the starting lineup. You could make the case that both Cliff Avril and Clark (a second-year player like Beasley) are better pure pass-rushers than Bennett is at defensive end.

Elsewhere, Brandon Graham continued his career year, as he's on pace to set his personal single-season sack record under new Philadelphia defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz. Detroit's Kerry Hyder was able to generate pressure again as the Lions' top defensive end, while Ezekiel Ansah looks like a shell of his 2015 self.

Dallas' Tyrone Crawford, naturally a defensive tackle, had by far his best performance of his season in the win over the Eagles and showed why the $45 million man is hanging on the edge this year.

Tampa Bay's Noah Spence, who used a speed rush to influence the Raiders' passing game, and the Carolina trio of Charles Johnson, Kony Ealy and Wes Horton were the other breakouts this week. In the Panthers' first six weeks of the season, their starting defensive line recorded just 2.5 sacks, while that same group posted five against the Arizona Cardinals on Sunday.

There were a lot of shifting narratives revolving around the position this week, but none may be bigger than Carolina's finally clicking up front. 

Grading Scale

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 25)

Snap: Snap Explosion (Graded out of 20)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

4-3 Defensive End Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamRushRunSnapTklPosOvr
1Khalil MackOAK25151818884
2Vic BeasleyATL23131715876
3Cliff AvrilSEA24131615876
4Frank ClarkSEA22141615875
5Adrian ClaybornATL23131515874
6Brandon GrahamPHI23131614874
7Kerry HyderDET23141414873
8Noah SpenceTB22121615873
9Tyrone CrawfordDAL19141417872
10Charles JohnsonCAR22111515871
11Trey FlowersNE22141214870
12Lorenzo MauldinNYJ20141414870
13Dwight FreeneyATL21121613870
14Brandon CopelandDET20131514870
15Armonty BryantDET22121414870
16Danielle HunterMIN21121514870
17Cameron JordanNO21131414870
18Wes HortonCAR21111514869
19Kony EalyCAR21121414869
20DeMarcus LawrenceDAL20111515869
21Ezekiel AnsahDET20121514869
22Everson GriffenMIN20121514869
23Connor BarwinPHI20121415869
24Vinny CurryPHI19131415869
25Marcus SmithPHI20121415869
26Jabaal SheardNE19141314868
27Muhammad WilkersonNYJ20151213868
28Brooks ReedATL18121416868
29David IrvingDAL19121415868
30Devin TaylorDET20121414868
31Brian RobisonMIN20121414868
32Cassius MarshSEA19121415868
33Mario AddisonCAR19121414867
34Jack CrawfordDAL19121414867
35Paul KrugerNO21121313867
36Chris LongNE18141214866
37Kasim EdebaliNO19121314866
38Darryl TappNO20121313866
39Robert AyersTB19121314866
40William GholstonTB19121314866
41Carlos DunlapCIN20131212865
42Malliciah GoodmanSEA18121413865
43DaVonte LambertTB18111414865
44Howard JonesTB18121314865
45Benson MayowaDAL19101314864
46Sheldon RichardsonNYJ19141012863
47Will ClarkeCIN16131212861
48Dante FowlerJAX15121312860
49Michael JohnsonCIN15141111859
50Chris SmithJAX14131113859
51Yannick NgakoueJAX15111312859
52Margus HuntCIN15121111857

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Jared Odrick—inactive
  • Michael Bennett—injury
  • Mario Williams—bye
  • Cameron Wake—bye
  • Andre Branch—bye
  • Jason Jones—bye
  • William Hayes—bye
  • Robert Quinn—bye
  • Ethan Westbrooks—bye
  • Eugene Sims—bye
  • Olivier Vernon—bye
  • Jason Pierre-Paul—bye
  • Romeo Okwara—bye
  • Owa Odighizuwa—bye

Defensive Tackles

14 of 22

Star Lotulelei takes the top spot in this week's defensive tackle rankings. He had his best game of the season and arguably the best game of his career. He made his presence felt against a struggling Cardinals offense, as he routinely beat up their interior. His teammate, Kawann Short, also had a strong showing against the run this week, as the Panthers defense shut down Arizona's offense.

Marcell Dareus played his first snaps of the season, but Kyle Williams had the better game between the two of them. Williams played a key role in keeping the Patriots rushing attack under wraps while providing solid disruption as an interior pass-rusher. Williams may not be a household name, but he's one of the more talented, consistent defensive tackles in the league. 

Geno Atkins had one of his stronger games this season in the Bengals' thrilling tie against Washington. His play this year has been a bit spotty, so it was great to see him disturb Washington's offensive line en route to logging two tackles and one sack.

Grading Scale

Snap: Snap Explosion (Graded out of 25)

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 25)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 15)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Defensive Tackle Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamSnapRushRunTklPosOvr
1Star LotuleleiCAR19232215786
2Geno AtkinsCIN19201814778
3Kyle WilliamsBUF18172015777
4Kawann ShortCAR18181915777
5Fletcher CoxPHI19161814774
6Brandon MebaneSD17152114774
7Nick FairleyNO18161814773
8Marcell DareusBUF17161914773
9Leonard WilliamsNYJ17151915773
10Dontari PoeKC16201812773
11Terrell McClainDAL17161813771
12Grady JarrettATL17141814770
13Linval JosephMIN18141813770
14Gerald McCoyTB17151813770
15Kenny ClarkGB17161613769
16Khyri ThorntonDET17171513769
17Danny SheltonCLE17141812768
18Malcom BrownNE17161612768
19Letroy GuionGB15151812767
20Malik JacksonJAX17161512767
21Tyrunn WalkerDET15161612766
22Hassan RidgewayIND17151512766
23Rodney GunterARI16141711765
24Corey PetersARI15151513765
25Courtney UpshawATL14161414765
26Will SuttonCHI15131812765
27Maliek CollinsDAL16141612765
28A'Shawn RobinsonDET15161611765
29Sen'Derrick MarksJAX19141510765
30Vincent ValentineNE17151412765
31Abry JonesJAX15161412764
32Alan BranchNE16141512764
33David OnyemataNO17131611764
34Al WoodsTEN15131712764
35Kyle LoveCAR16151411763
36Stephen PaeaCLE16151411763
37Zach KerrIND16131611763
38Jarran ReedSEA15141512763
39David ParryIND14151610762
40Tom JohnsonMIN16131412762
41Ahtyba RubinSEA14141611762
42Tyson JacksonATL11141613761
43Paul SoliaiCAR14121612761
44Steve McLendonNYJ14131611761
45Darius LathamOAK14121612761
46Domata PekoCIN14131511760
47Cedric ThorntonDAL17121410760
48Beau AllenPHI14141312760
49Pat SimsCIN15121510759
50Tyson AlualuJAX14141311759
51Shamar StephensMIN15121411759
52Sylvester WilliamsDEN14131311758
53Tyeler DavisonNO13151310758
54D.J. ReaderHOU15111410757
55Jihad WardOAK13121510757
56Tony McDanielSEA14131310757
57Akeem SpenceTB14131211757
58Jonathan BabineauxATL13121410756
59Matt CatapanoNYJ14111410756
60Dan WilliamsOAK12111412756
61Vince WilforkHOU14111310755
62Sealver SiligaSEA12111310753
63Cullen JenkinsWAS1312129753
64Justin EllisOAK11111310752
65Destiny VaeaoPHI1212109750

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Roy Miller—injury
  • Vernon Butler—injury
  • Clinton McDonald—injury
  • Haloti Ngata—injury
  • Bennie Logan—injury
  • Sharrif Floyd—injury
  • Eddie Goldman—injury
  • Stacy McGee—inactive
  • Ra'Shede Hageman—inactive
  • Corbin Bryant—insufficient snaps
  • John Jenkins—insufficient snaps
  • Brandon Williams - Bye
  • Aaron Donald - Bye
  • Ndamukong Suh - Bye
  • Johnathan Hankins - Bye
  • Damon Harrison - Bye
  • Vince Wilfork - Bye
  • Javon Hargrave - Bye

3-4 Outside Linebackers

15 of 22

There may not be a more underrated pass-rusher in the NFL than San Diego's Melvin Ingram, who finished as Week 8's top 3-4 outside linebacker. His box-score numbers (three tackles, one strip-sack) don't jump off the page, but he was unblockable for long stretches against the Broncos. Ingram's ability to impact the game in all three phases—rushing the passer, defending the run and dropping into coverage—is rare for the position.

The rest of the top three in Week 8 includes Pernell McPhee, who was a wrecking ball against the Vikings on Monday night, and Von Miller, the most consistent edge-rusher in the NFL. Another notable standout was Bears rookie Leonard Floyd, who finished as the sixth overall 3-4 outside linebacker after registering his third sack in the last two games. Kansas City's Dee Ford led the NFL in Week 8 with 3.5 sacks. 

Grading Scale

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 25)

Cvg: Coverage (Graded out of 15)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 25)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

3-4 Outside Linebacker Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamRushRunCvgTklPosOvr
1Melvin IngramSD28161221885
2Pernell McPheeCHI2816920881
3Von MillerDEN27141021880
4Whitney MercilusHOU2615920878
5Leonard FloydCHI24161018876
6John SimonHOU2017922876
7Dee FordKC2712820875
8Willie YoungCHI23161018875
9Markus GoldenARI2414820874
10Shane RayDEN2216919874
11DeMarcus WareDEN2514918874
12Tamba HaliKC2414918873
13Shaquil BarrettDEN2116918872
14Shaq LawsonBUF23131017871
15Ryan KerriganWAS24121017871
16Chandler JonesARI2213918870
17Jerry HughesBUF2015918870
18Trent MurphyWAS2114918870
19Derrick MorganTEN2411918870
20Akeem AyersIND20141017869
21Julius PeppersGB23101018869
22Kyle EmanuelSD22121017869
23Nick PerryGB2113918869
24David BassTEN22121017869
25Kareem MartinARI2113917868
26Joe SchobertCLE19131018868
27Robert MathisIND2412815867
28Brian OrakpoTEN21111017867
29Lorenzo AlexanderBUF1913918867
30Cam JohnsonCLE2310917867
31Preston SmithWAS20121016866
32Lerentee McCrayBUF1712920866
33Erik WaldenIND2013916866
34Sam AchoCHI1914915865
35Frank ZomboKC2210916865
36Jayrone ElliottGB1811918864
37Kyler FackrellGB2010916863
38Datone JonesGB199917862
39Tourek WilliamsSD1812915862
40Aaron WallaceTEN1910916862
41Dadi NicolasKC1910915861
42Brandon SpikesBUF1515518861

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Alex Okafor—injury
  • Clay Matthews—injury
  • Justin Houston—injury
  • Kevin Dodd—injury
  • Jerry Attaochu—injury
  • Terrell Suggs—bye
  • Za'Darius Smith—bye
  • Matt Judon—bye
  • Elvis Dumervil—bye
  • James Harrison—bye
  • Jarvis Jones—bye
  • Arthur Moats—bye
  • Anthony Chickillo—bye
  • Ahmad Brooks—bye
  • Eli Harold—bye
  • Aaron Lynch—bye
  • Tank Carradine—bye

4-3 Outside Linebackers

16 of 22

This week was void of any superstar performances like Nigel Bradham's in Week 7, but there were a handful of solid showings around the league. 

Through most of this season, Carolina's Thomas Davis hasn't looked quite like himself. He's been good, yes, but it was starting to look like Davis wasn't the same as he once was. This week was a revival. In unison with the rest of the Panthers front, Davis looked alive against the Arizona Cardinals. Other than as a blitzer, Davis was a force in all phases of the game and made it tough for the Cardinals offense to sustain success on any given drive. It was refreshing to see Davis look like the stud we all know he is.

On Sunday Night Football, Dallas's Sean Lee took center stage. Lee made a handful of important run stops against the Philadelphia Eagles, including a tackle for loss on 3rd-and-short in the second half. All throughout the night, Lee was rallying to the ball in run defense and after short receptions. It was not a perfect performance by any stretch, but it was the quality of play that Dallas needed from Lee to slow down the Eagles offense.

The surprise performnce of the week is from the Jets' Julian Stanford. Playing in place of an injured Darron Lee, Stanford pulled his weight for the Jets defense. Stanford did not have too much of an impact on passing downs, but he was shockingly sturdy in the run game. He played his assignments well and did a good job of making clean tackles. Stanford had a nice week not just by backup player standards, but by any standards.

Grading Scale

Cvg: Coverage (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 25)

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 15)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 25)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

4-3 Outside Linebacker Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamCvgRunRushTklPosOvr
1Thomas DavisCAR2022721676
2Lavonte DavidTB1920922676
3Sean LeeDAL1921722675
4Dont'a HightowerNE20201118675
5Bruce IrvinOAK18211118674
6K.J. WrightSEA1821821674
7Nigel BradhamPHI1820920673
8Julian StanfordNYJ1820720671
9De'Vondre CampbellATL1917918669
10Shaq ThompsonCAR1619721669
11Rob NinkovichNE17191017669
12Vontaze BurfictCIN1719818668
13Anthony BarrMIN1617919667
14Craig RobertsonNO1518919667
15Karlos DansbyCIN1418919666
16Justin DurantDAL1618718665
17Vincent ReyCIN1517718663
18Damien WilsonDAL1617717663
19Jordan JenkinsNYJ1816815663
20Mychal KendricksPHI1517717662
21Antwione WilliamsDET1616716661
22Mike CatapanoNYJ1516915661
23Philip WheelerATL1516716660
24Chad GreenwayMIN1416717660
25Brock CoyleSEA1517715660
26Dannell EllerbeNO1714715659
27Daryl SmithTB1315916659
28Myles JackJAX1713715658
29Josh BynesDET1214915656
30Telvin SmithJAX1414713654
31Dan SkutaJAX1413714654
32Malcolm SmithOAK1313814654

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Jaylon Smith—injury
  • Darron Lee—injury
  • DeAndre Levy—injury
  • Mark Barron - Bye
  • Josh Forrest - Bye
  • Donald Butler - Bye
  • Keenan Robinson - Bye
  • Devon Kennard - Bye

Inside Linebackers

17 of 22

Inside linebacker play has regressed to the mean nearly halfway through the 2016 season. With so many teams employing multiple players to perform the variety of tasks needed, they're often swapped out, creating a small group of upper-echelon players who stay on the field regardless of down or distance. These players routinely sit toward the top of the rankings due to their versatility and the flexibility that a complete skill set allows a defense. 

Players such as Chicago's Jerrell Freeman or Seattle's Bobby Wagner afford their teammates comfort in knowing that there is a three-down hard-hitting linebacker patrolling the middle of the field. Freeman exemplified the benefits of a three-down linebacker this week in an upset win over the Minnesota Vikings on Monday Night Football.

Freeman was stout against the run and looked comfortable dropping into coverage or coming forward to make plays on running backs out of the backfield. As a result, Chicago cruised to a comfortable home victory against one of the best teams in the NFC.

The up-and-down nature of many players has top performers from recent weeks sitting at the bottom of the charts following their showings over the weekend. Kwon Alexander looked lost as the Tampa Bay Buccaneers fell to the Oakland Raiders in overtime, and Jacksonville's Paul Posluszny, who has had an impressive few weeks, fell tremendously in an ugly Thursday night loss to the Tennessee Titans.

Grading Scale

Pass: Pass Defense (Graded out of 25)

Run: Run Defense (Graded out of 35)

Rush: Pass Rush (Graded out of 15)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 15)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Inside Linebacker Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPassRunRushTklPosOvr
1Jerrell FreemanCHI22311112682
2Bobby WagnerSEA19321013680
3Todd DavisDEN2131912679
4Luke KuechlyCAR20301112679
5Brian CushingHOU20311012679
6Su'a CravensWAS22261311678
7Benardrick McKinneyHOU19291112677
8Deone BucannonARI2130911677
9Jordan HicksPHI22271011676
10Preston BrownBUF19281112676
11Deion JonesATL2226912675
12Danny TrevathanCHI2028912675
13Eric KendricksMIN19271112675
14Jatavis BrownSD2227910674
15Joshua PerrySD1830911674
16Jamie CollinsNE20261111674
17Elandon RobertsNE1829912674
18Perry RileyOAK18261112673
19Sean SpenceTEN2126911673
20Will ComptonWAS1927911672
21D'Qwell JacksonIND1730910672
22Avery WilliamsonTEN18261111672
23Joe ThomasGB2225811672
24Derrick O. JohnsonKC1828910671
25Corey NelsonDEN19251011671
26Korey ToomerSD1927910671
27Nate StuparNO2124811670
28Zach BrownBUF1926910670
29Demario DavisCLE1727812670
30Mason FosterWAS17251011669
31Ramik WilsonKC1726911669
32Blake MartinezGB1826810668
33Wesley WoodyardTEN1725911668
34Jake RyanGB1527811667
35Edwin JacksonIND15241111667
36David HarrisNYJ1526910666
37Anthony HitchensDAL1624811665
38Kevin MinterARI162688664
39Rey MaualugaCIN162399663
40Chris KirkseyCLE172388662
41Tahir WhiteheadDET162398662
42Paul PoslusznyJAX1622810662
43Kwon AlexanderTB152088657

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Brandon Marshall—injury
  • Justin March—injury
  • Denzel Perryman—insufficient snaps
  • Nick Kwiatkoski—insufficient snaps
  • Antonio Morrison—insufficient snaps
  • Cory James—insufficient snaps
  • Zach Orr—bye
  • C.J. Mosley—bye
  • Alec Ogletree—bye
  • Kiko Alonso—bye
  • Kelvin Sheppard—bye
  • Ryan Shazier—bye
  • Lawrence Timmons—bye
  • Vince Williams—bye
  • Gerald Hodges—bye
  • Michael Wilhoite—bye
  • Nick Bellore—bye

Cornerbacks

18 of 22

Considered an unheralded free-agent signing after the initial wave of big names came off the market, Casey Heyward has continued to outperform expectations with the San Diego Chargers. He performed well yet again in Week 8, as he was tasked with covering the Denver Broncos wide receivers and emerged with an interception. Just as important for his grade, he was consistently in position to force a tough catch. 

Another top AFC performer was Malcolm Butler from the New England Patriots. Butler isn't always the most consistent player quarter to quarter, but his play against the Buffalo Bills was among his best this season. In 37 coverage snaps, Butler did not allow a reception on six targets. He maintained great positioning in press, off-man and the slot with his impressive length and balance.

On the other end of the spectrum, the New York Jets had a rough week. Against the Cleveland Browns, the Jets cornerbacks struggled to contain Terrelle Pryor and Co. from producing. Aging veteran Darrelle Revis couldn't keep up with the explosive Pryor, and his teammates likewise struggled. Revis allowed eight completions on 14 targets, which is not counting the screens thrown his way.

Slot cornerback Marcus Williams allowed a touchdown to Andrew Hawkins, which has only further raised questions as to why he's in the slot and not playing in a more natural boundary role. Veteran Buster Skrine suffered an injury early, and the only positive from this position group in Week 8 was Darryl Roberts serving as a solid replacement in his absence.

Washington's prized free agent, Josh Norman, had an active day against the Cincinnati Bengals in London. Bengals quarterback Andy Dalton targeted him an outlandish 12 times. He commited five penalties, even though Cincinnati declined two of them. So while the stat sheet might look goodNorman yielded four catches on 12 targetshe was the beneficiary of a few underthrows, where he was beat. He finished the game with four blown coverages and allowed two first downs, one being a 40-yard bomb. He also missed a tackle. On a positive note, Norman was able to break up three passes, though you could argue all three of them should have been interceptions.

In a losing effort, Minnesota's Xavier Rhodes mostly fared well against a stud receiver in Alshon Jeffery. While it's natural to remember the long catch he gave upwhich he was right in position for—he was in position to make a play on each of his nine targets on the night. Like Norman, Rhodes got his hands on three passes and could've easily intercepted two of them. The fact that he was only beaten once after mostly shadowing Jeffery all game is a testament to his skills in coverage.

Not many players give Seattle's cornerbacks trouble. One is a superb athlete in DeShawn Shead; the other is Richard Sherman, who is as good as it gets. That said, New Orleans Saints wideout Michael Thomas had his way with them, which might have affected both players' aggressiveness for the rest of the game. The duo gave up 11 catches on 18 targets, six of which went for first downs. Seattle is typically able to leave both of these guys on an island, but on Sunday, they did not make the plays we usually see them make.

The Saints received a surprising performance from B.W. Webb, who was targeted five times and only allowed one catch that went for a minimal gain. Though he played his share of underneath zone, Webb had a good day in coverage.

Grading Scale

Cvg: Coverage (Graded out of 30)

React: Reaction/Recovery (Graded out of 30)

Slot: Slot (Graded out of 20)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 10)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Cornerback Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamCvgReactSlotTklPosOvr
1Bradley RobyDEN2424186981
2Kareem JacksonHOU2223196979
3Marcus PetersKC2224175977
4Malcolm ButlerNE2323175977
5Xavier RhodesMIN2223166976
6Brandon FlowersSD2221186976
7A.J. BouyeHOU2021177974
8Patrick RobinsonIND2021176973
9Robert AlfordATL2021166972
10Joe HadenCLE1920186972
11Jamar TaylorCLE2022165972
12B.W. WebbNO2021166972
13Chris Harris Jr.DEN1920176971
14Orlando ScandrickDAL1818177969
15Johnson BademosiDET1820166969
16Philip GainesKC1819176969
17Terence NewmanMIN1920165969
18Brian PooleATL1817168968
19Ronald DarbyBUF2019164968
20Ladarius GunterGB1918166968
21Casey HaywardSD1818185968
22Patrick PetersonARI2018155967
23Tyrann MathieuARI1819165967
24Brandon CarrDAL1818166967
25Morris ClaiborneDAL1817167967
26Vontae DavisIND1817176967
27Micah HydeGB1718166966
28Jalen RamseyJAX1718166966
29Captain MunnerlynMIN1717176966
30Leodis McKelvinPHI1818165966
31Johnathan JosephHOU1718156965
32D.J. HaydenOAK1717175965
33Nolan CarrollPHI1718165965
34Brent GrimesTB1618166965
35C.J. GoodwinATL1718155964
36Darius ButlerIND1716175964
37Richard ShermanSEA1818145964
38Jason McCourtyTEN1715176964
39Bashaud BreelandWAS1717165964
40Desmond TrufantATL1617156963
41Adam JonesCIN1617156963
42Demetri GoodsonGB1617156963
43David AmersonOAK1618155963
44Quandre DiggsDET1616165962
45Prince AmukamaraJAX1617155962
46Steven NelsonKC1618154962
47Darryl RobertsNYJ1517156962
48Brice McCainTEN1517165962
49Josh NormanWAS1618154962
50Stephon GilmoreBUF1617145961
51Robert McCainCAR1517155961
52Daryl WorleyCAR1516147961
53Aaron ColvinJAX1616155961
54Eric RoweNE1616155961
55Darrelle RevisNYJ1615165961
56Nevin LawsonDET1615155960
57Justin ColemanNE1614156960
58Valentino BlakeTEN1616145960
59Logan RyanNE1415156959
60TJ CarrieOAK1615154959
61Kendall FullerWAS1516154959
62Cre'von LeBlancCHI1514155958
63Marcus WilliamsNYJ1415146958
64Jeremy LaneSEA1414156958
65Nickell Robey-ColemanBUF1414164957
66Dre KirkpatrickCIN1515144957
67Lorenzo DossDEN1314165957
68Rashaan MelvinIND1515144957
69DeShawn SheadSEA1514145957
70Tramon WilliamsCLE1413155956
71Jalen MillsPHI1414145956
72Justin BethelARI1314145955
73Marcus CooperARI1213147955
74De'Vante BausbyCHI1414135955
75Trae WaynesMIN1413145955
76Ken CrawleyNO1513144955
77Steve WilliamsSD1314145955
78Tharold SimonARI1413135954
79Tracy PorterCHI1413135954
80Josh ShawCIN1213136953
81Vernon HargreavesTB1312143951
82Quinton DunbarWAS1113135951
83Jude Adjei-BarimahTB1112125949

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Kevin A. Johnson—injury
  • Sean Smith—injury
  • Perrish Cox—injury
  • Aqib Talib—injury
  • Buster Skrine—injury
  • Jimmy Smith - Bye
  • Tavon Young - Bye
  • Lamarcus Joyner - Bye
  • Bobby McCain - Bye
  • Byron Maxwell - Bye
  • Janoris Jenkins  Bye
  • Eli Apple - Bye
  • Ross Cockrell - Bye
  • Artie Burns - Bye
  • Tramaine Brock - Bye
  • Rashard Robinson - Bye

Free Safeties

19 of 22

Tashaun Gipson appeared poised to be a strong free-agent acquisition for the Jaguars this offseason. However, he's played poorly so far as a pure free safety. He was responsible for the deep middle of the field on Kendall Wright's long touchdown catch, but he may have never saw the route. Wright ran right past him into the end zone, and Gipson never looked close to getting back to save the touchdown.

Later on, he matched up in the slot against Wright, who sold him a fake inside before cutting outside on a deep out. Gipson got turned around and had to take extra steps to locate Wright and get back outside. To his credit, Gipson recovered and contested the catch, but he couldn't stop the completion. The Jaguars have a number of issues with their team right now, but Gipson needs to improve. 

The Cardinals must be pleased with how D.J. Swearinger has performed at free safety. He looks transformed from his previous stints in the NFL. He was alert early on against the Panthers, making an excellent read on a pass to Kelvin Benjamin. He broke on it quickly and nearly had an interception. He'll perhaps believe he should have had the pick, but getting a pass breakup is a win for a defensive back.

Before signing with the Cardinals, Swearinger struggled to stay disciplined in coverage assignments. Against Carolina, however, he looked comfortable and at home at free safety, staying on top of deep routes to Benjamin, Devin Funchess and tight end Greg Olsen at various points throughout the game.

Where the Cardinals will have to be careful is how he defends the run. He played it aggressively, even from the deep safety spot, and often found himself in good positions. But he tried to rip the ball out and force a fumble too frequently, conceding extra yards in the process. There is a time to try to create a turnover, but there is also a time to wrap up and stop the opposition from getting extra yards. The Cardinals will need to make sure Swearinger is ready to make the simple play without taking away from his instincts to be aggressive.

Grading Scale

Cvg: Coverage (Graded out of 30)

Rec: Recovery (Graded out of 30)

Slot: Slot/LB (Graded out of 10)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Free Safety Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamCvgRecSlotTklPosOvr
1Darian StewartDEN2524715879
2Devin McCourtyNE2425616879
3Marcus GilchristNYJ2424616878
4D.J. SwearingerARI2524515877
5George IlokaCIN2524614877
6Glover QuinDET2423616877
7Ha Ha Clinton-DixGB2325615877
8Jairus ByrdNO2424615877
9Adrian AmosCHI2422616876
10Byron JonesDAL2324615876
11Rodney McLeodPHI2325614876
12Dwight LowerySD2323616876
13Earl ThomasSEA2226515876
14Tre BostonCAR2324515875
15Kevin ByardTEN2223616875
16J.J. WilcoxDAL2322516874
17Justin SimmonsDEN2221616873
18Clayton GeathersIND2122616873
19Duron HarmonNE2322515873
20Vonn BellNO2121616872
21Ricardo AllenATL2122516872
22Andre HalHOU2122615872
23Reggie NelsonOAK2122516872
24Kentrell BriceGB2121516871
25Harrison SmithMIN2122614871
26Corey GrahamBUF2120516870
27Robert BlantonBUF2021615870
28Corey MooreHOU2220515870
29Ron ParkerKC2021516870
30Anthony HarrisMIN2022515870
31Bradley McDougaldTB2223413870
32T.J. GreenIND1922515869
33Will BlackmonWAS2122414869
34Ibraheim CampbellCLE2120415868
35Tashaun GipsonJAX1619515863

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Rashad Johnson—inactive
  • Lardarius Webb—bye
  • Maurice Alexander—bye
  • Cody Davis—bye
  • Isa Abdul-Quddus—bye
  • Darian Thompson—bye
  • Nat Berhe—bye
  • Mike Mitchell—bye
  • Eric Reid—bye

Strong Safeties

20 of 22

Bills safety Jonathan Meeks won't be happy with his performance against New England. With regular starter Aaron Williams inactive after suffering an injury in Week 7, Meeks had a chance to impress and earn more reps. But the Bills coaching staff only gave Meeks five of a possible 68 snaps, largely because he was at fault for touchdowns on two of them.

He gave up an out route to Danny Amendola in the end zone for a touchdown in the first quarter. On the next series, Tom Brady connected with Chris Hogan on a 53-yard score. It looked like cornerback Stephon Gilmore was at fault, but he immediately turned and yelled at Meeks as if he was expecting help on the coverage. Meeks didn't see another snap after that. 

Shawn Williams had an impressive week for the Bengals against a Washington offense stacked with weapons, making a number of plays in coverage that stood out. In the first quarter, he initially bit on a play-action fake, but he managed to recover and sink back to take away a post route to tight end Jordan Reed in the end zone. Later on, he took up a good position in the end zone that gave him the ability to drive on slant routes to either Reed or DeSean Jackson. Kirk Cousins spotted him there and had to throw the ball away.

Williams also stayed on top of Jackson on a number of play-action passes designed to get the speedy receiver open deep. He maintained discipline, resisting the urge to bite on the run fake and instead played his assignment and read his keys. Washington failed to find Jackson on a deep ball as a result.

Williams was, however, lucky to get away with some plays against Washington. He was called for unnecessary roughness early in the game after deliberately diving into Jackson, who was clearly down on the ground and had already given himself up. He got away with a late hit on Cousins after coming free on a blitz. Cousins turned to his right and threw a bubble screen quickly off the snap. Williams had clear sight of the throw as he burst through the line of scrimmage. It might have been hard for him to stop his momentum, but he could have made more of an effort to avoid Cousins instead of diving into him and landing a huge late hit. He was fortunate not to get called for a penalty.

It was a theme that continued throughout the game. Williams played well, but the late hits weren't necessary; they were dumb. He got away with it on more than one occasion, but he could have easily have been called for multiple roughness penalties and allowed Washington a free 15 yards each time.

Grading Scale

Cvg: Coverage (Graded out of 25)

Rec: Recovery (Graded out of 25)

Slot: Slot/LB (Graded out of 20)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 20)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Strong Safety Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamCvgRecSlotTklPosOvr
1Shawn WilliamsCIN22211614679
2Calvin PryorNYJ21201616679
3Adrian PhillipsSD20211616679
4Tony JeffersonARI19211616678
5T.J. WardDEN19221516678
6Daniel SorensenKC20191616677
7Eric BerryKC19211516677
8Keanu NealATL20201515676
9Morgan BurnettGB20211415676
10Malcolm JenkinsPHI20191615676
11John CyprienJAX19191615675
12Harold Jones-QuarteyCHI20191415674
13Karl JosephOAK19181516674
14Da'Norris SearcyTEN19181516674
15Daimion StaffordTEN18191615674
16Patrick ChungNE19181515673
17Donte WhitnerWAS20171515673
18Duke IhenachoWAS18191515673
19Jayron KearseMIN18191415672
20Barry ChurchDAL18181515672
21Kenny VaccaroNO18181416672
22Derrick KindredCLE16191515671
23Will ParksDEN17181416671
24Eddie PleasantHOU17171516671
25Jaylen WatkinsPHI17181515671
26Kurt ColemanCAR16181515670
27Tavon WilsonDET16171615670
28Kelcie McCraySEA16181415669
29Mike AdamsIND17161415668
30Rontez MilesNYJ16171415668
31Chris ConteTB18151415668
32Tracy HowardCLE16171315667
33Rafael BushDET15171415667
34Miles KillebrewDET15161415666
35Keith TandyTB14151416665
36Jonathan MeeksBUF14141315662

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Aaron Williams—inactive
  • Quintin Demps—inactive
  • Andrew Sendejo—inactive
  • Jahleel Addae—inactive
  • Kam Chancellor—inactive
  • Eric Weddle—bye
  • Anthony Levine—bye
  • T.J. McDonald—bye
  • Reshad Jones—bye
  • Landon Collins—bye
  • Robert Golden—bye
  • Sean Davis—bye
  • Antoine Bethea—bye
  • Jaquiski Tartt—bye

Kickers

21 of 22

Who is that at the top of the kicker leaderboard in Week 8? New Orleans rookie Wil Lutz had the league's strongest performance, going 4-of-4 on field goals including a 51-yarder and making his only extra-point attempt. Lutz has shown a big leg all year, but this kind of performance goes a long way toward giving him the confidence needed to build the consistency required of NFL kickers.

After starting the year just 4-of-7 on field goals, he has now made seven of his last eight attempts, and he's 22-of-22 on the year for extra points as well. He appears to be developing well, but beware the often bumpy path that young kickers take on their journey upward. 

New England's Stephen Gostkowski returns to the top five after back-to-back weeks with missed extra points that raised a number of questions. He showed stronger technique this week but had some balance issues on his last kick of the day, though it still found its way through the uprights. Also bouncing back was Dallas' always-reliable Dan Bailey, who spent just one week outside of the top five and might only have one or two more misses the entire rest of the season.

On the other end of the spectrum, Cincinnati's Mike Nugent continues to struggle, missing his only field-goal attempt and going just 3-of-4 on extra points. While Gostkowski has the track record to warrant additional patience, Nugent has been a slightly below-average kicker since 2012, and there are free-agent options who could be attractive at low cost to the Bengals. Should Nugent continue to struggle, this could be an easy area for Cincinnati to bolster heading into a potential run at the playoffs.

Washington's Dustin Hopkins also struggled in back-to-back weeks, with two more misses on field-goal attempts this week after missing one in Week 7--granted, one of those was from 55 yards. Hopkins is likely to bounce back, though the power he is showing on his long kicks is cause for concern, as he has been short on two attempts from 55 and 56 yards this season. Hopkins has a strong leg, so there may be something sapping his power at this point.

Grading Scale

Pwr: Kick Power (Graded out of 40)

Acc: Kick Accuracy (Graded out of 40)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 10)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Kicker Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamPwrAccTklPosOvr
1Wil LutzNO33386380
2Graham GanoCAR33385379
3Stephen GostkowskiNE33375378
4Caleb SturgisPHI33365377
5Dan BaileyDAL32356376
6Ryan SuccopTEN31365375
7Brandon McManusDEN32335373
8Matt BryantATL30345372
9Cody ParkeyCLE31335372
10Steven HauschkaSEA31335372
11Connor BarthCHI30325370
12Mason CrosbyGB31315370
13Nick FolkNYJ30325370
14Nick NovakHOU28325368
15Jason MyersJAX32285368
16Blair WalshMIN31295368
17Chandler CatanzaroARI31285367
18Adam VinatieriIND30285366
19Cairo SantosKC30275365
20Matt PraterDET29255362
21Dan CarpenterBUF29235360
22Josh LamboSD31205359
23Roberto AguayoTB30215359
24Sebastian JanikowskiOAK27195354
25Dustin HopkinsWAS27195354
26Mike NugentCIN28145350

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Greg Zuerlein—bye
  • Andrew Franks—bye
  • Robbie Gould—bye
  • Chris Boswell—bye
  • Phil Dawson—bye
  • Justin Tucker—bye

Punters

22 of 22

The Colts' Pat McAfee slides into the top spot in the Week 8 punter rankings, largely due to outstanding ball placement. McAfee has been a victim of his own success this year, putting up good numbers but not standing out the way he has in the past. This is the kind of performance we used to see from him nearly every week, and it is possible he is just rounding into form now. He punted seven times in week 8 and averaged 49.6 yards per punt. He is still going to finish the year as a top- 10 punter, but more performances like this could put him in consideration for top-five or top-three placement. 

Green Bay's Jacob Schum comes in second this week with some massive hang time and distance numbers. Schum has been below average for Green Bay this year as Tim Masthay's replacement, so his Week 8 performance comes as a surprise. He's likely to regress back to the middle of the pack or worse, as nothing in his history suggests he can perform as he did Sunday on a weekly basis.

Also appearing in the top five this week are Houston's Shane Lechler and Carolina's Andy Lee as well as Denver rookie Riley Dixon. Lechler has heated up in recent weeks after struggling to start the season, and Lee continues to flash top-10 numbers. Dixon, on the other hand, has been all over the place, with a number of bottom-five finishes to go with several top-five performances as well.

There are a few strange names near the bottom of this week's list, with Tennessee's Brett Kern and Detroit's Sam Martin finding themselves there rather than near the top, where they typically reside. This is likely a short-term stay for both, as they're too talented to linger down there for long, but neither showed much in the way of distance, while their ball placement and hang time were average.

Minnesota's Jeff Locke ends up as the worst-rated punter of the week because his ball placement was not NFL-caliber. Punters today have to be able to move the ball from sideline to sideline, and while Locke did show average hang time and distance, his directional ability was limited. A short-distance touchback also hurt him on accuracy as well.

Grading Scale

Dist: Kick Distance (Graded out of 20)

Hang: Kick Hang Time (Graded out of 20)

Acc: Kick Accuracy (Graded out of 45)

Tkl: Tackling (Graded out of 5)

Pos: Positional Value (Graded out of 10)

Ovr: Top Possible Score of 100

Punter Rankings Week 8
RankPlayerTeamDistHangAccTklPosOvr
1Pat McAfeeIND1615423379
2Jacob SchumGB1918323375
3Shane LechlerHOU1916343375
4Andy LeeCAR1815333372
5Riley DixonDEN1714353372
6Bryan AngerTB1418343372
7Britton ColquittCLE1514353370
8Dustin ColquittKC1616323370
9Chris JonesDAL1216353369
10Thomas MorsteadNO1517293367
11Ryan QuigleyARI918333366
12Matt BosherATL1617273366
13Tress WayWAS1313343366
14Pat O'DonnellCHI1313323364
15Kevin HuberCIN1912273364
16Ryan AllenNE1113343364
17Marquette KingOAK1513303364
18Donnie JonesPHI1513303364
19Brad NortmanJAX1318263363
20Drew KaserSD1916223363
21Jon RyanSEA1514263361
22Brett KernTEN716313360
23Sam MartinDET1113273357
24Colton SchmidtBUF1010283354
25Lachlan EdwardsNYJ1313223354
26Jeff LockeMIN1513193353

Notable Omissions/Not Graded This Week

  • Johnny Hekker—bye
  • Matt Darr—bye
  • Brad Wing—bye
  • Jordan Berry—bye
  • Bradley Pinion—bye
  • Sam Koch—bye
NFL Draft Winners 📊

TOP NEWS

NFL Draft Football
NFL Draft Football
Eagles Draft Football

TRENDING ON B/R