Fantasy Football: Week 9 NFL Player Breakdowns By Matchup

Keet Bailey@@KeetBaileyCorrespondent IINovember 3, 2010

Jamaal Charles ran wild in Week 8.
Jamaal Charles ran wild in Week 8.Jamie Squire/Getty Images

Week 8 of fantasy football lacked explosive stars and great matchups, as the usual top performers were held fairly in check. However, there were still some huge game-breakers (see: Detroit Lions), and there is always promise for a turnaround in the next week.

Week 9 brings more optimism and even better fantasy matchups. Read on to see all of the fantasy matchups and player breakdowns for this week, along with player ratings:


New York Jets @ Detroit Lions

QB Mark Sanchez: Sanchez hasn’t done much for a few weeks now, and I don’t see him doing much more this week. **

RB Shonn Greene: Greene is getting touches here and there, but not enough to warrant a start unless you’re desperate. **

RB LaDainian Tomlinson: This matchup isn’t the greatest with the Lions defensive line playing so well. However, you don’t want to sit LT yet. ****

Santonio Holmes: Holmes hasn’t eclipsed the 50-yard mark in three games this year. He’s not a bad Flex option, however. ***

WR Braylon Edwards: With Keller, Holmes and Cotchery seeing more targets, I’m inclined to sit Edwards.  **

WR Jerricho Cotchery: He’s seeing more targets, but be cautious starting him. **

TE Dustin Keller: Keller should find the end zone once this week. Not a bad play here. ***

New York Defense: It’s no secret that their defense is very good. But the Lions offense is no joke. They aren’t a bad play, but there could be better options. **** 

Key Note: Kris Jenkins (NT) for the Jets is out for the season.

QB Matthew Stafford: This may be the week to sit Stafford. We saw what the Jets did to Aaron Rodgers last week. ***

RB Jahvid Best: Best should see more receptions out of the backfield. But he’s not a fantastic play here. ***

RB Kevin Smith: Kevin Smith has some value now with Best ailing. However, he should be sat this week. **

WR Calvin Johnson: Calvin Johnson is a safe play nearly every week. Keep him plugged in. ****

WR Nate Burleson: Burleson is becoming a better Flex play each week. That should change here, although against a tough Jets defense, it’ll be a tough play. ***

TE Brandon Pettigrew: Pettigrew is a nice play against the Jets who have struggled with TEs. ****

TE Tony Scheffler: Put Scheff back on the bench for now. Stafford prefers his WRs to his TEs. **

Detroit Defense: This defense is improving each week. This may not be a terrible play if they can shut down the running game. ***


New England Patriots @ Cleveland Browns

QB Tom Brady: Despite the Browns shutting down Drew Brees, I don’t believe lightning will strike twice. Get Brady in your lineup. ****

RB Fred Taylor: Taylor will probably be out again. They don’t need to rush him with the Law Firm running well last week. *

RB BenJarvus Green-Ellis: This is a good matchup for BJGE. Get him in. ****

RB/WR Danny Woodhead: He’s not a bad play in Flex PPR leagues. Limited rushes, however.

WR Deion Branch: Branch is ailing with a hamstring injury, but should be better this week. ***

WR Wes Welker: Welker doesn’t have a bad matchup here, but hasn’t deserved any better than your Flex spot. ***

WR Brandon Tate: Tate had a nice week against Minnesota and if Branch is limited in the game, he could be a nice option against a weak Browns secondary. ***

TE Rob Gronkowski: Gronkowski is hit or miss in the red zone. Sit until further notice. **

TE Aaron Hernandez: Hernandez continues to see receptions and yardage.  ***

Patriots Defense: The Browns offense still isn’t generating many points, and we’re still unsure who’s starting at QB. The Pats defense isn’t a terrible play this week. ***

QB Seneca Wallace: If Wallace can practice this week, he’ll most likely start. Delhomme most likely will sit another week. **

QB Colt McCoy: If McCoy does get the start, we still don’t recommend him on your roster. *

RB Peyton Hillis: Hillis should stay in your lineup. He’s getting a ton of touches. ****

RB Mike Bell: Bell isn’t going to see enough touches to warrant a fantasy start. *

WR Brian Robiskie: Robiskie shouldn’t be rostered. *

WR Mohamed Massaquoi: Mo Mass is still questionable, but shouldn’t be rostered either way. *

WR Chansi Stuckey: For deep leagues, Stuckey isn’t a bad Flex play. He’s seeing a good number of receptions. ***

WR Josh Cribbs: Cribbs doesn’t see enough receptions to warrant a start. *

TE Ben Watson: Watson has some value in deeper leagues as he’s seeing a good number of targets. ***

TE Evan Moore: He sees red zone looks. But the Browns aren’t in the red zone much. **

Cleveland Defense: The Cleveland defense played well against New Orleans, but don’t expect another two-touchdown day for that defense. **

Key note: Jake Delhomme and Seneca Wallace are both questionable with ankle sprains. Mohamed Massaquoi is questionable for Sunday’s matchup against the Patriots.

Chicago Bears @ Buffalo Bills

QB Jay Cutler: Cutler just isn’t on top of his game. The Bills secondary isn’t bad. He’s a QB2 this week, at best. ***

RB Matt Forte: His rushing stats won’t excite anybody, but he’s getting touches and yards while finding ways to score. ****

RB Chester Taylor: Taylor’s value is limited still. *

WR Devin Hester: The occasional return touchdown isn’t worth risking to keep starting a guy who doesn’t get very many passes his way. **

WR Johnny Knox: Knox is one of the best Flex plays in the league. ****

WR Devin Aromashodu: Aromashodu doesn’t see enough receptions to warrant a start. *

TE Greg Olsen: Inconsistent is Olsen’s middle name. There are many better TEs. **

Chicago Defense: The Bears defense is a nice sleeper this week, but don’t sleep on the Bills. ***

QB Ryan Fitzpatrick: Fitzpatrick made some mistakes and didn’t have a big day. He could be coming back to earth, but he’s not a bad QB2 this week. ***

RB C.J. Spiller: He had ten touches against Kansas City. He’s becoming a bigger role, but still shouldn’t be started yet. **

RB Fred Jackson: Jackson is a middle of the road Flex option this week. ***

WR Lee Evans: Evans is seeing consistent catches now. We want to see him get into the end zone more, however. ***

WR Steve Johnson: Johnson has scored in five straight games. Keep him in while he’s hot . ****

TE Shawn Nelson: Fitzpatrick doesn’t go to his TEs often. *

Buffalo Defense: They struggle against the run and will have to force Cutler to make mistakes. ***


New Orleans Saints @ Carolina Panthers

QB Drew Brees: Brees should rebound nicely as his last game against the Panthers wasn’t fantastic. ****

RB Pierre Thomas: Thomas will probably sit for another week and come back after the bye. *

RB Ladell Betts: Betts should stay benched. He had just four touches against Pittsburgh, and Chris Ivory is coming into his own. *

RB Chris Ivory: Despite a slight concussion, Ivory should be a go against Carolina. He’s a risky Flex play, but has value. ***

WR Marques Colston: Colston has been solid for the last few weeks. I like him to keep it up. ****

WR Lance Moore: Moore is a solid Flex play this week. He keeps seeing receptions in the red zone. ***

WR Devery Henderson: He only sees two to three carries a game. Pass. **

WR Robert Meachem: Meachem has put together a few solid weeks. He’s not a bad Flex play. ***

TE Jeremy Shockey: Shockey is losing receptions to David Thomas and Jimmy Graham. **

New Orleans: The Saints defense is a good start this week against a struggling Panthers offense. ****

QB Matt Moore: This isn’t a good week to start Moore. Surprisingly, he is the best option for Carolina. **

RB DeAngelo Williams: Williams could be out longer than expected as he’s struggling to walk around right now. *

RB Jonathan Stewart: As good a matchup as Stewart had last week, I’m losing faith. Keep him on the bench until he does something productive. **

WR Steve Smith: Even though Matt Moore played poorly in Week 8, Smith had a nice game. Keep him in, but stay cautious. ***

WR David Gettis: Gettis did not record a reception in Week 8. With Smith back, Gettis could be limited in receptions. **

WR Brandon LaFell: LaFell did record a touchdown in Week 8. He could be a sleeper in very deep leagues. ***

TE Jeff King: Jeff King has almost no fantasy value. *

TE Dante Rosario: Neither he or King has great value. *

Carolina Defense: I wouldn’t trust this defense with my snack pack, let alone my fantasy team. *


Miami Dolphins @ Baltimore Ravens

QB Chad Henne: Henne has done most of his damage on the road. However, this isn’t the best week for him, although he should be able to get to 250 yards. ***

RB Ronnie Brown: Brown can get the yardage, but he’s getting 15 carries a week. Not bad for a Flex option, however. ***

RB Ricky Williams: Williams is seeing more touches in the red zone. Not a bad Flex start against a struggling Ravens rush defense. ***

WR Brandon Marshall: Marshall can make plays out of nowhere and should be kept in the lineup. ****

WR Davone Bess: Bess is finding catches left and right. He should be plugged into your Flex, especially in PPR leagues. ****

WR Brian Hartline: Hartline continues to see receptions. Keep him in your Flex. ***

TE Anthony Fasano: Fasano is a nice TE for deep leagues. He generally catches around four balls a game. ***

Miami Defense: The Miami defense is improving, and they are my sleeper this week against the Ravens. ***

QB Joe Flacco: Flacco is a mediocre QB2 this week against a slightly improved secondary. ***

RB Ray Rice: Rice is seeing the touches and producing. Keep him in. ****

RB Willis McGahee: McGahee has medium goal-line value at best. **

WR Anquan Boldin: Keep plugging Boldin in, as he’s finding ways to reward fantasy owners. ****

WR Derrick Mason: Mason isn’t a bad PPR guy in deeper leagues.***

WR TJ Houshmandzadeh: He’s not getting enough looks from Flacco to warrant any starts. *

TE Todd Heap: He has three touchdowns in his last two contests. He’s slowly seeing more receptions in the red zone. However, he’s still playing injured. ***

Baltimore Defense: Right now, it’s hard to trust a Ravens D that seems to be giving up more points than they should be. ***


Tampa Bay Buccaneers @ Atlanta Falcons

QB Josh Freeman: Freeman isn’t a bad QB2 this week against the Falcons secondary. ***

RB Carnell Williams: Just seven touches in Week 8. Get him back on the bench. **

RB LaGarette Blount: Blount is looking like the man in Tampa Bay now. I like the matchup this week. ****

WR Mike Williams: Williams is turning into a very respectable Flex WR. ****

WR Michael Spurlock: Inconsistent number of catches makes me not want to roster him. *

WR Sammie Stroughter: Zero catches in Week 8. No reason to put him in the lineup. *

TE Kellen Winslow: Winslow seems to be struggling, with Freeman finding Mike Williams more. Winslow may need to be played on a strictly matchup basis, and this is a good one. ****

Tampa Bay Defense: Matt Ryan and Roddy White are hot. Don’t play this defense in Week 9. **

QB Matt Ryan: Ryan is developing into a respectable QB1 in deeper formats and a very good QB2. Get him in this week. ****

RB Michael Turner: Turner rebounded pretty well against Cincinnati. I like him against the Bucs this week. ****

RB Jason Snelling: Snelling is a great handcuff, but he’s not reliable enough to start. **

WR Roddy White: White is the No.1 fantasy wideout. Keep him in every week. *****

WR Michael Jenkins: Jenkins isn’t a bad Flex play in deeper leagues. I like the matchup this week, however. ***

WR Brian Finneran: With Jenkins back in the lineup, it’s time to get Finneran out of your lineup. *

TE Tony Gonzalez: Gonzalez is inconsistent. The matchup against Tampa Bay is favorable, however. ***

Atlanta Defense: This isn’t a bad week to start Atlanta’s defense, but be cautious. ***


San Diego Chargers @ Houston Texans

QB Philip Rivers: Rivers still produces weekly, and against this secondary, he should be a top five QB1. *****

RB Ryan Mathews: Mathews finally got in the end zone for the second time this year. He’s a risky play this week. ***

RB Mike Tolbert: Tolbert bounced back and showed that he still has some value. It’s just tough predicting his yards, although he keeps finding the end zone. ***

WR Malcolm Floyd: We’ll keep you updated on Floyd. If he plays, he’s a great start.  ***

WR Legedu Naanee: Naanee will most likely be out against the Texans. *

WR Patrick Crayton: Crayton isn’t a bad option being the No.1 or No. 2 receiver, at worst. Not a bad Flex in deeper leagues. ***

TE Antonio Gates: We will keep you up to date with Gates as he has an injury on both feet and could miss time. If he plays, he's a great start each week. *****

San Diego Defense: I think the Chargers will get to Schaub this week, but will struggle with Foster. Mediocre play. ***

Key note: Buster Davis went on the IR as of November 2nd.

QB Matt Schaub: Schaub has to go against a tough defense and I think he gets roughed up this week. ** 

RB Arian Foster: I’d keep Foster in the lineup as he keeps producing regardless of defense. ****

WR Andre Johnson: There’s a small chance Johnson sits this week. If he plays, he’s a good start. ****

WR Kevin Walter: Walter is just not getting it done. Consider benching until he learns how to hold onto the ball. **

WR Jacoby Jones: Jones isn’t worth a start unless another receiver goes down. *

TE Owen Daniels: Daniels had a nice Week 7, but Week 8 was a different story. There are better plays this week. **

Texans Defense: One of the worst pass defenses against the top passing offense in the league does not bode well for the Texans Defense. *


New York Giants @ Seattle Seahawks

QB Eli Manning: I like Eli to have a big game this week against a mediocre secondary. ****

RB Ahmad Bradshaw: Bradshaw is still getting the touches, and even though Seattle’s rush defense is stingy, I like Bradshaw. ****

RB Brandon Jacobs: He’s getting all the red zone scores and has had a touchdown in four consecutive games. Not a bad Flex play. ***

WR Steve Smith: Smith proved me wrong against the Cowboys, and it looks as if we should start getting him in the Flex spot more often. ***

WR Hakeem Nicks: Nicks is the top red zone target in New York. Keep him in. ****

WR Mario Manningham: Manningham isn’t a bad Flex play in deep leagues. The matchup is favorable. ***

TE Kevin Boss: There are still many better options at tight end. *

TE Travis Beckum: He’s still seeing barely one reception a game. *

New York Defense: This is an excellent week to start the Giants hard-nosed defense. ****

QB Matt Hasselbeck: I’m sitting Hasselbeck this week against the Giants, who are murdering quarterbacks. *

RB Marshawn Lynch: Lynch should be sat for the second week in a row. **

RB Justin Forsett: Forsett isn’t a terrible Flex play, as he tends to get touches. But this week could be bad for him. **

WR Mike Williams: Williams is seeing the targets, but Hasselbeck’s throwing is off. Bench him this week. **

WR Deon Butler: I’m not a fan of the matchup, although Butler should see four to five receptions. **

WR Golden Tate: Tate isn’t involved with the Seattle offense enough to even roster. *

TE Jon Carlson: Carlson isn’t seeing the receptions to warrant a start, but he’ll be utilized more this Sunday. ***

Seattle Defense: No thanks to this defense against the high-scoring Giants. **


Arizona Cardinals @ Minnesota Vikings

QB Derek Anderson: Anderson will most likely get the start, but he needs to be sat regardless. *

QB Max Hall: Even if Hall plays, he’s a terrible option any week. *

RB Beanie Wells: This isn’t a great matchup for Wells. While he’s getting the carries, the Cards generally play from behind. **

RB Tim Hightower: He had two touches in Week 8, and I doubt he’ll see any more than six or seven in a game going forward. **

WR Larry Fitzgerald: Fitzgerald is hard to shy away from as he still finds ways to produce somehow. It’s just not what you want to see each week.  ***

WR Steve Breaston: Breaston had a very nice comeback game in Week 8. But I’d sit him this week even against a struggling secondary. **

WR Andre Roberts: Roberts’ value is very limited with Breaston back.

TE Ben Patrick-:Just say no to Patrick. *

Arizona Defense: You shouldn’t even have them on your roster.  *

QB Brett Favre: Favre just can’t get the ball into the end zone or limit turnovers. The matchup is good, but losing Moss sure doesn’t help. ***

QB Tarvaris Jackson: If Favre doesn’t play for some reason, Jackson may not be a bad start against this weak defense.

RB Adrian Peterson: You shouldn’t sit AP any week. *****

WR Percy Harvin: Harvin may miss some practice, but he should be ready for the game and should be started weekly. ****

WR Bernard Berrian: Berrian may see a few more targets, but he didn’t do anything even before Randy Moss was in Minny. *

WR Greg Camarillo: He didn’t get targeted once in Week 7 or 8. Keep him benched. *

TE Visanthe Shiancoe: Shiancoe saw a few more receptions, but isn’t a reliable TE option until Minnesota can throw the ball successfully. **

Minnesota Defense: This is a great matchup for Minnesota, despite their struggling secondary. ****


Kansas City Chiefs @ Oakland Raiders

QB Matt Cassel: He hasn’t thrown an interception since Week 3, but his struggles to surpass 200 yards and more than one touchdown a week make him a weak QB2 option. **

RB Jamaal Charles: There’s no reason not to keep plugging Charles in. He just needs to find the end zone more. ****

RB Thomas Jones: Jones still is producing and should find the end zone this week. ****

WR Dwayne Bowe: Bowe only had 16 yards, but he had a touchdown. I expect him to end his touchdown streak this week. ***

WR Dexter McCluster: McCluster should be back for Week 9, but he won’t make an impact in this game. **

TE Tony Moeaki: Moeaki has been good for a few receptions and making plays downfield. He’s a sleeper TE. ***

Kansas City Defense: With Oakland scoring as they are, I don’t expect KC to shut them down enough for a solid fantasy start. **

QB Bruce Gradkowski: The Raiders will likely let Gradkowski get back to 100 percent sitting this week and for the bye. *

QB Jason Campbell: Campbell is playing well right now, but this matchup isn’t as favorable. **

RB Darren McFadden: McFadden should be in weekly going forward. ****

RB Michael Bush: Bush is still seeing touches and isn’t a bad Flex play. ***

WR Darrius Heyward-Bey: Holy cow, he made some plays. One game isn’t enough to make him roster-worthy, still. **

WR Louis Murphy: Murphy will be out Week 9 and back Week 11. *

WR Jacoby Ford: Ford will work the slot a bit. Value is extremely limited. *

TE Zach Miller: Miller should be started every week. He’s that good. *****

Oakland Defense: Their defense has been playing well. They are a solid sleeper start for Week 9. ***


Indianapolis Colts @ Philadelphia Eagles

QB Peyton Manning: Manning is a guy you start every week.  *****

RB Joseph Addai: It’s unlikely that Addai plays again, but if he does, you should still bench him as he won’t be close to 100 percent. *

RB Donald Brown: Brown still isn’t 100 percent and he isn’t producing. *

RB Mike Hart: Hart may have to sit this week as well after injuring his ankle in the fourth quarter. We’ll keep you posted. *

RB Javarris James: He’s not a sexy pickup, as he shouldn’t be. But he could be the man starting on Sunday. **

WR Reggie Wayne: Wayne is one of the most reliable receivers. Keep him in the lineup. ****

WR Pierre Garcon: Garcon should be started every week when healthy. ****

WR Blair White: White did not get targeted once in Monday night’s matchup. Proceed with caution. *

WR Anthony Gonzalez: Gonzo fared reasonably well. He’s still not on the same page as Manning, but he should still see receptions. ***

TE Jacob Tamme: Tamme did register a touchdown and had 64 yards. He looks to be a solid contributor in Peyton’s offense. ***

Indianapolis Defense: The Colts defense is still just mediocre. I don’t care for the matchup this week. **

Key Note: Dallas Clark is out for the season with a wrist injury. Austin Collie is out for at least three weeks with a hand surgery.

QB Michael Vick: Vick started practicing and should be the starter for Sunday’s matchup against the Colts. If he indeed does start, get him back in. ****

QB Kevin Kolb: If Vick starts, obviously bench Kolb. But if he doesn’t, Kolb has a solid matchup. ***

RB LeSean McCoy: Shady McCoy needs to stay in your lineup. ****

WR DeSean Jackson: We’ll keep you up-to date-with Jackson, as he could play this week. If he does, get him back in the lineup. ****

WR Jeremy Maclin: Maclin should be in your lineup barring injury. He’s making plays in the short field, and down the field. ****

WR Jason Avant: If Jackson sits, Avant makes for a solid Flex play. Otherwise, sit him. ***

TE Brent Celek: Celek has been quite disappointing. If Vick comes back, it may be time to sit him as Indy hasn’t given much up to tight ends. **

Philadelphia Defense: This will probably be a high-scoring matchup. I’d sit Philly’s defense this week. **


Dallas Cowboys @ Green Bay Packers

QB Jon Kitna: Kitna threw four interceptions in Week 8, but three were on the receivers. This matchup isn’t the greatest, however. **

RB Felix Jones: Jones bruised his forearm, but should still play. I’m not liking the Cowboys RBs at all right now, however. **

RB Marion Barber: Barber is more of a red zone guy, but you can’t rely on the ‘Boys runners. **

WR Miles Austin: Austin will continue to produce even with Kitna. *****

WR Dez Bryant: Surprisingly enough, I’m starting to warm up to Bryant and Kitna, plus he offers a nice return game. ****

WR Roy E. Williams: Williams will remain invisible with Kitna at QB. **

TE Jason Witten: Get Witten in the lineup as Kitna will throw to him quite a bit. ****

Dallas Defense: I won’t trust this defense after they allowed Garrard to put up five touchdowns on them. **

QB Aaron Rodgers: Rodgers had a bad Week 8, but he should bounce back nicely here.  *****

RB Brandon Jackson: Jackson isn’t a bad Flex RB, but that’s about it. ***

RB John Kuhn: Kuhn isn’t seeing the carries to warrant a start. *

WR Greg Jennings: Jennings should continue to produce. ****

WR Donald Driver: Driver will be out for Week 9. Bench him. *

WR James Jones: Jones will have to fill in for Driver, who’s sitting against the Cowboys. ***

TE Andrew Quarless: Quarless didn’t catch one pass in Week 9 and injured his shoulder. Bench him. *

Green Bay Defense: The Cowboys could surprise them, but Green Bay isn’t a bad start, although risky. ****

Key Note: Jermichael Finley is out for the season with a torn meniscus. Ryan Grant is done for the season, as are Justin Harrell, Nick Barnett and Morgan Burnett.

Pittsburgh Steelers @ Cincinnati Bengals

QB Ben Roethlisberger: Keep Ben in against a struggling Cincy secondary. ****

RB Rashard Mendenhall: Mendenhall keeps making plays. I like the matchup. ****

RB Mewelde Moore: Moore will spell Mendenhall here and there, but his value is very limited. *

WR Hines Ward: Get Ward in the lineup as Ben will still find him. ****

WR Mike Wallace: Wallace keeps scoring, and averaged over 25 yards a catch. Get him in. ****

TE Heath Miller: I like Miller a lot more than I did at the beginning of the year. ***

Pittsburgh Defense: Pittsburgh’s defense should be started every week. They make plays regardless. *****

QB Carson Palmer: Palmer is a risky play each week, and this matchup does not bode well for the struggling QB . **

RB Cedric Benson: I expect Benson to be very limited in his production against the Pittsburgh defense. **

RB Bernard Scott: Let’s keep Scott on the bench until he gets more involved with the offense, or at least gets in the red zone. *

WR Chad Ochocinco: Ochocinco may not be a bad play this week, but T.O. is better.  ***

WR Terrell Owens: Keep plugging Owens in. He’s finding ways to make plays. ****

WR Jordan Shipley: Shipley only has value in very deep PPR leagues. *

TE Jermaine Gresham: Gresham is still going to see quite a few targets each game. ***

Cincinnati Defense: Bench this defense until the secondary can stop somebody. *


Have a fantasy football question? Send your question or concern to and have your question answered live on the NFL Soup Weekly Dish Radio Show!

Follow us on Twitter at @NFLSoup@NFLSoupTaylor@NFLSoupKeet and @NFLSoup_Kevin.


    Report: Eagles' Owner Criticized Trump in Private Meeting

    NFL logo

    Report: Eagles' Owner Criticized Trump in Private Meeting

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Brady's Agent Says He'll Play in 2018

    NFL logo

    Brady's Agent Says He'll Play in 2018

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Carroll: 'May Be Place For' Kap on Seahawks

    NFL logo

    Carroll: 'May Be Place For' Kap on Seahawks

    Scott Polacek
    via Bleacher Report

    Final 1st-Round Mock Draft

    NFL logo

    Final 1st-Round Mock Draft

    Doug Farrar
    via Bleacher Report