Every year, managers, coaches and writers from around Major League Baseball award honors and trophies to the players—and every year, they screw up.
So Bleacher Report's Featured Columnists decided to do it ourselves. Instead of just complaining about the awards as they are announced as we would normally do on our own, we teamed up to hold our own mock awards vote.
On Monday, we kicked off Week 2 of our four-week-long results series with our picks for AL Comeback Player of the Year, then we followed that up yesterday with their counterparts in the NL. Today, we look at the best relievers in the American League.
The top five vote-getters are featured here with commentary from people who chose them. The full list of votes is at the end.
So read on, see how we did and be sure to let us know what we got wrong!
Featured writer: Lewie Pollis
Matt Thornton led all Junior Circuit relievers in FIP (2.14) and strikeout rate (12.0 K/9). FanGraphs’ WAR also says Thornton was the most valuable reliever in the league; his work in the late innings gave the White Sox 2.2 extra wins. But the most amazing thing about Thornton’s season isn’t what he did, but how he did it.
Thornton threw his fastball more than 90 percent of the time—the highest proportion of any pitcher with over 60 innings. As of September 17, when he was behind in the count, he had thrown a fastball every single time.
Batters know what’s coming, and they still swing and miss 28.8 percent of the time—the second-best mark in the league. If that’s not dominance, I don’t know what is.
Featured writer: Jeremiah Graves
Neftali Feliz is good. Like, we’re talking scary good.
As a rookie late last season, Feliz converted from a starter—and a pretty good one at that—to a middle reliever to help the Rangers down the stretch. In 2010, he began the season in the bullpen in the same role, but within a month old he’d already become the Rangers’ closer.
The 22-year-old handled the pressure of such a high-profile role on a contending ballclub well as, he saved 40 games whilst posting a 2.73 ERA, a 0.88 WHIP and striking out 71 batters in 69.1 innings of work. The club may revert him back to a starter next season, but this year he was the best reliever in the American League.
Featured writer: Dmitriy Ioselevich
You could make the argument that Rivera is the easy choice for this award. After all, he’s already won the award five times, including last year. But in 2010 he may have earned himself a sixth.
The man who will eventually go down as the best closer in baseball history (if he’s not already), had another superb campaign in the Bronx. Though he only recorded 33 saves, sixth in the AL, his peripherals were through the roof.
A 0.83 WHIP that was second in the league among qualifying relievers. A microscopic 1.80 ERA (fifth in the AL) and an adjusted ERA of 238 that led everyone. His WAR (wins above replacement player, 3.0) and RAR (runs better than replacement level, 19) were also league-leading among AL closers.
Featured writer: Evan Bruschini
As much as 2010 was the Year of the Pitcher, it was even more so “Year of the Relief Pitcher,” as 16 different firemen posted sub-2.00 ERAs in more than 45 games pitched.
The most notable among those was an otherwise quiet closer by the name of Joakim Soria. Despite playing for Kansas City, Soria has been a diamond in the rough, causing some to think the man they call “Mexecutioner” could be the next Mariano Rivera.
This season was just the latest example of the way Soria dominates. He posted a 1.78 ERA to go with a 1.051 WHIP, and although neither were career nor league bests, his 3.8 WAR, 1.2 higher than that of Tampa Bay’s Rafael Soriano or Cleveland’s Chris Perez is what puts him over the top.
Featured writer: Dan Hartel
Rafael Soriano of the Tampa Bay Rays led all American League relievers this year with 45 saves. His 1.73 ERA ranked fourth among AL relievers and third among closers, and his otherworldly 0.80 WHIP was just second behind Rays teammate Joaquin Benoit, and first among closers.
Batters hit just .170 against Soriano, also second in the AL to only Joaquin Benoit, and first among closers. he also managed to strike out 71 batters, sixth among all AL relievers and second in closers (only Jonathon Papelbon had more).
And, Soriano did all of this in the AL East, perhaps the best division in baseball. He was a combined 9-for-9 in save opportunities against the Yankees and Red Sox, posting a 0.77 WHIP and 1.38 ERA in 13 total appearances against the two division rivals.
When you take into account the eight blown saves by Red Sox closer Jonathan Papelbon, and the five by Yankees closer Mariano Rivera, the three blown saves Soriano committed in 2010 can be viewed as one of the biggest factors contributing to the Rays’ division championship.
1. Rafael Soriano, Rays—113 (20)
2. Joakim Soria, Royals—75 (7)
3. Mariano Rivera, Yankees—30 (1)
4. Neftali Feliz, Rangers—29 (1)
5. Matt Thornton, White Sox—6
T6. Andrew Bailey, Athletics—5
T6. Joaquin Benoit, Rays—5 (1)
7. Daniel Bard, Red Sox—4
8. Chris Perez, Indians—1
|AL Gold Gloves||October 25|
|NL Gold Gloves||October 26|
|AL Silver Sluggers||October 27|
|NL Silver Sluggers||October 28|
|AL Comeback Player of the Year||November 1|
|NL Comeback Player of the Year||November 2|
|AL Rolaids Relief Man of the Year||November 3|
|NL Rolaids Relief Man of the Year||November 4|
|AL Rookie of the Year||November 8|
|NL Rookie of the Year||November 9|
|AL Manager of the Year||November 10|
|NL Manager of the Year||November 11|
|AL Cy Young||November 15|
|NL Cy Young||November 16|
|AL Most Valuable Player||November 17|
|NL Most Valuable Player||November 18