Becoming a superstar is not supposed to be easy. It's supposed to be a title reserved for the very few players who are the best in baseball.
Whether due to longevity, steroids, postseason heroics or even because the media hyped a player up, there have been numerous times throughout Major League Baseball's history where a player gets way too much credit for his accomplishments.
In one way or another, every player on this list is overrated. They were thrust into super-stardom even though many of them had no business even being regarded as a star.
Here are 50 MLB superstars who weren't that super.