Now that his career as a Philadelphia Eagle is officially over, maybe it is now time to ask: Was Donovan McNabb the greatest Philadelphia Eagle of all time?
Obviously, it all depends on who you ask: some in Philly would have you believe that title belongs to Jon Runyan, Brian Dawkins, Keith Jackson, Mike Quick, or even Ron Jaworski.
Meanwhile, for others the answer is clear: McNabb may not have won a Super Bowl, but never in the history of the Philadelphia Eagles franchise—a history than goes back to the Great Depression—has the team experienced the level of success it experienced with McNabb.
Count me in the latter group.
Here is the complete list of the greatest players in the history of every team in the NFL.
You can read my baseball list here.