Chris McIntosh (22nd overall, T) 24 games, 13
Ron Dayne (11th overall, RB) 983 carries, 3722 yards, 28 TD 2000-2007
Trung Candidate (31st overall, RB) 240 carries, 1095 yards, 7 TD 2000-2003
William Green (16th overall, RB) 568 catches, 2109 yards, 9 TD 2002-2005
Andre Woolfolk (28th overall, DB) 96 tkl, 3 INT 2003-2006
Marcus Tubbs (23rd overall, DT) 38 tkl, 7 sacks 2004-2006
Chris Perry (26th overall, RB) 177 carries, 606 yards, 2 TD, 2004-2008
I tried avoiding guys from 2006, but I ended up using quite a few. I pretty much ruled out using players who have been in the league for three years or less because it is unfair, as they haven't really had a chance to prove themselves yet. Four years is my bare minimum for this list.
I tried avoiding second round picks, because generally a bust is not a second rounder, as you put much more money into a first round pick. The position that the first round pick is is usually more important and will have more of an impact than your second round pick.
Please, if you don't agree with something, comment and tell me (there's a reason I didn't put David Carr, if you are wondering).