B/R NFL 1000: Ranking the Top 70 Guards from 2014
Who is the best player in the NFL? Not based on the last 10 years or one game, but over the last year, who was the best? Good luck answering that one without starting a fight, right?
Well, that's what the NFL 1000 aims to do by scouting, grading and then ranking the best players at each position before putting them in order and breaking ties to come up with the top 1,000 players. No narratives, no fantasy football points, no "QBR"—this is cold hard scouting.
You can find rankings for all other positions on our B/R NFL 1000 main page.
The B/R 1000 metric is based heavily on scouting each player and grading the key criteria for each position. The criteria are weighted according to importance for a possible best score of 100.
Potential is not taken into consideration. Nor are career accomplishments.
Guards are judged on pass-blocking (50 points), run-blocking (45) and their value as a starter or backup (5).
In the case of ties, our team asked, "Which player would I rather have on my team?" and set the rankings accordingly.
Subjective? Yes. But ties are no fun.
Each player was scouted by me and a team of experienced evaluators (Dan Bazal, Cian Fahey, Dan Hope, Marshal Miller, Justis Mosqueda) with these key criteria in mind. The following scouting reports and grades are the work of months of film study from our team.
All statistics from Pro Football Focus. Players' heights, weights and seasons played from NFL.com.
Nos. 70-66
1 of 54
70. Jordan Devey, New England Patriots
Pass Block: 25/50; Run Block: 23/45; Starter: 3/5
Jordan Devey isn’t a small offensive lineman, yet he struggled to handle the strength of NFL-caliber defensive linemen. Being big in the NFL can be OK if you have the strength to create value, but if you’re that size, you’re always going to be limited in space, so you have very little value without the strength to succeed in tight areas.
69. Brian Winters, New York Jets
Pass Block: 25/50; Run Block: 25/45; Starter: 3/5
A torn ACL prematurely ended Brian Winters’ season. He had started six games but proved to be a major liability in pass protection during that time. It’s possible that Winters would have found his way to the sideline even if he had stayed healthy for the full year.
68. Zach Fulton, Kansas City Chiefs
Pass Block: 33/50; Run Block: 19/45; Starter: 2/5
Zach Fulton fits well in head coach Andy Reid’s offense. He is a comfortable mover in pass protection who needs to develop better technique and discipline. As a run-blocker, Fulton offers versatility but lacks consistency in different ways. Because of his skill set, he especially needs to improve at locating defenders in space on the second level.
67. Lance Louis, Indianapolis Colts
Pass Block: 26/50; Run Block: 25/45; Starter: 3/5
Lance Louis started at different times for the Indianapolis Colts in 2014, but there are very few teams he would have seen the field with. Louis is very slow off the snap and lacks the athleticism and consistency in his technique to battle opposing offensive linemen, be it in the running game or passing game.
66. Austin Howard, Oakland Raiders
Pass Block: 25/50; Run Block: 25/45; Starter: 4/5
Before signing with the Oakland Raiders as a free agent, Austin Howard was a right tackle for the New York Jets. He moved to guard for the Raiders and showed off decent athleticism both in pass protection and as a run-blocker. However, he lacks special physical traits and consistent technique.
Nos. 65-61
2 of 54
65. Ted Larsen, Arizona Cardinals
Pass Block: 20/50; Run Block: 32/45; Starter: 3/5
Ted Larsen can be an effective run-blocker at times, but that alone isn’t enough to mask his major issues as a pass protector. Larsen lacks the athleticism to compete with NFL-caliber offensive linemen consistently, and he can’t overcome that with good technique.
64. Vladimir Ducasse, Chicago Bears
Pass Block: 32/50; Run Block: 20/45; Starter: 3/5
Despite his sheer size, Vladimir Ducasse has failed to become an impact run-blocker in the NFL. He particularly struggled in 2014 in that area. Ducasse can still be effective in tight areas as a pass protector, but his poor technique and discipline limit him there also.
63. Patrick Omameh, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Pass Block: 26/50; Run Block: 26/45; Starter: 3/5
Because of his size and some physical talent, Patrick Omameh can’t be written off for the long term at this early stage of his career. However, the Buccaneers' starting right guard offered too few flashes of his ability in 2014 to be confident about his potential moving forward.
62. John Jerry, New York Giants
Pass Block: 35/50; Run Block: 18/45; Starter: 3/5
For as long as John Jerry has been in the league, he has simply lacked the explosiveness and athleticism to be an effective run-blocker. Because he’s not a special pass-blocker, that will always limit his value to NFL teams.
61. Cyril Richardson, Buffalo Bills
Pass Block: 24/50; Run Block: 29/45; Starter: 3/5
Richardson started a couple of games during his rookie season, but he repeatedly failed to make a positive impression. Most significantly, Richardson needs to show off an ability to drop back into his stances as a pass protector without being too aggressive in engaging his opponent.
Nos. 60-56
3 of 54
60. Dallas Thomas, Miami Dolphins
Pass Block: 31/50; Run Block: 22/45; Starter: 3/5
Because of the Miami Dolphins' injuries on the offensive line, Thomas played both guard spots and right tackle at different times during the season. As a right tackle, he was completely overwhelmed, as his athleticism was exposed. He was a subpar interior offensive linemen even if he was able to avoid completely collapsing.
59. Charlie Johnson, Free Agent
Pass Block: 27/50; Run Block: 26/45; Starter: 3/5
Being a former offensive tackle has done very little for Charlie Johnson during his years as the Minnesota Vikings' left guard. In 2014, nothing changed, as Johnson continued to struggle as a pass protector in space. He also struggled to make impact plays in the running game.
58. Weston Richburg, New York Giants
Pass Block: 32/50; Run Block: 21/45; Starter: 4/5
The New York Giants rookie played guard during his first season in the NFL, but he may wind up as a starting center over the long term. He has all the physical tools to be a high-quality starter, but he needs to refine his technique and become more consistent moving forward.
57. Todd Herremans, Indianapolis Colts
Pass Block: 25/50; Run Block: 28/45; Starter: 4/5
At 32 years of age, Todd Herremans’ decline may be terminal. The versatile player who can play both guard and tackle missed a lot of time in 2014, but he also struggled to impress when he was on the field at right guard.
56. Mike Pouncey, Miami Dolphins
Pass Block: 25/50; Run Block: 28/45; Starter: 5/5
Mike Pouncey is a physically talented player who moved to guard after missing the start of the season through injury. Pouncey didn’t look completely comfortable at his new position, as he was inconsistent throughout the season.
.jpg?w=256 "Colts Jaguars Football")
Nos. 55-51
4 of 54
55. Shelley Smith, Denver Broncos
Pass Block: 33/50; Run Block: 22/45; Starter: 3/5
Shelley Smith moved in and out of the Miami Dolphins' lineup this past season and struggled for the most part when he was on the field. A very weak run-blocker who can’t be trusted in space as a pass protector, Smith offered the Dolphins very little value in 2014.
54. Kraig Urbik, Buffalo Bills
Pass Block: 36/50; Run Block: 19/45; Starter: 3/5
Kraig Urbik has never been a superstar player, but he has served the Bills as a reliable starter over the years. That wasn’t the case in 2014, as he proved to be a major liability in the running game particularly.
53. Matt Tobin, Philadelphia Eagles
Pass Block: 24/50; Run Block: 31/45; Starter: 3/5
Matt Tobin was a spot starter for the Philadelphia Eagles in 2014. He is a young player with impressive physical traits but needs to learn how to use his hands and be more controlled in his stance. He should remain a backup for the foreseeable future.
52. Willie Colon, New York Jets
Pass Block: 43/50; Run Block: 16/45; Starter: 3/5
Willie Colon appears to be in decline. The once physically talented but unreliable offensive lineman lacked the same power in the run game that was evident in previous years. He can no longer punish defenders with powerful punches or move them off the line of scrimmage consistently.
51. Michael Ola, Chicago Bears
Pass Block: 34/50; Run Block: 25/45; Starter: 3/5
Michael Ola was a utility player for the Chicago Bears in 2014. He was never really given a chance to settle in one position, as he was moved between both guard positions and to right tackle. Ola is a young player with decent athleticism who needs to refine his technique over the coming years.
50. Rob Sims, Free Agent
5 of 54
Pass Block
Rob Sims is a longtime veteran who likely doesn’t have much time left in the NFL as a starting guard. His feet have slowed down and his upper body strength isn’t where it used to be as a pass protector. Sims’ technique isn’t as consistent as it was in the past, but when it is, he can still be effective.
Run Block
Sims simply lacks the explosiveness through contact and the overall athleticism to be an effective run-blocker. He is essentially a specialist pass-blocking guard but isn’t good enough as a pass-blocker to justify being somewhat of a liability in the running game.
Starter
After starting for the past five seasons in Detroit, Sims could return to the Lions and be a starter. He is a free agent, though, and even if the Lions don’t sign him, he will likely get an opportunity to start for an offensive line-needy team in 2015.
Overall
49. Hugh Thornton, Indianapolis Colts
6 of 54
Pass Block
Hugh Thornton always appears to be playing catch-up to his assignments in pass protection. He combines slow feet with inactive hands to negate any athleticism that he could potentially use to his benefit. Because of these factors, Thornton is often sluggish and off balance when he is forced to move from his initial stance.
Run Block
Thornton’s effort as a run-blocker is obvious. Once engaged with defenders, he works his feet rapidly to generate power and push them away from the line of scrimmage. He is less effective when asked to move into space, but not so much that he hampers what the offense can do.
Starter
At just 23 years of age, Thornton can still improve as a player. He will likely get the opportunity to compete for a starting spot with the Colts next season.
Overall
48. Fernando Velasco, Carolina Panthers
7 of 54
Pass Block
In 2013, Fernando Velasco proved to be a valuable replacement for Maurkice Pouncey at center in Pittsburgh. However, Velasco tore his Achilles toward the end of the year. That torn Achilles and his overall limited athleticism hurt his move to guard for the Carolina Panthers in 2014. This showed up a lot in pass protection, as Velasco seemingly didn’t have the athleticism to compete with opponents anymore.
Run Block
Velasco has never been a great run-blocker. He used to move relatively well in space and could engage opponents but either lacked the bulk or power to drive them off their spots. In 2014, he lacked the limited power that he had shown previously.
Starter
Velasco played three different positions for the Panthers in 2014, but he was a bit-part player who fell behind two rookie guards by the end of the season. Velasco is 30 years of age, so he is unlikely to be anything more than a versatile backup moving forward.
Overall
47. Jahri Evans, New Orleans Saints
8 of 54
Pass Block
At 31 years of age, Jahri Evans’ age is beginning to have an effect on his career. The mammoth offensive lineman can still be effective in pass protection if kept tight between his right tackle and center because of his length and strength, but he lacks the lateral quickness to be effective in space. It’s too easy for defensive tackles to get level with Evans then work past him now.
Run Block
Despite his decline in pass protection, Evans is still a very valuable run-blocker. His sheer size and power allow him to move defensive linemen off the line of scrimmage and seal running lanes. He can also advance to the second level and effectively locate defenders there to make important blocks.
Starter
Although he’s no longer one of the best guards in the NFL, Evans should still start for the Saints in 2015. He has three years left on his current contract.
Overall
46. Oday Aboushi, New York Jets
9 of 54
Pass Block
Oday Aboushi’s footwork and hand usage are impressive. He showed off more consistency in his technique as the season developed last year, and that allowed him to get the most out of his athleticism. Aboushi will likely never be good enough to be left alone in space against better defensive backs, but so long as his assignments are kept simple, he can be effective.
Run Block
Aboushi shows off good but not great athleticism as a run-blocker. He is a functional pulling guard who can advance to the second level with effectiveness. He understands positioning but needs to show off better leverage on a more consistent basis. Aboushi’s power at the point of contact is too often underwhelming, as he can get in good positions without hitting or moving defenders aggressively.
Starter
The Jets don’t have established options at the guard spots, so Aboushi should be able to compete for a starting spot moving forward.
Overall
45. James Carpenter, New York Jets
10 of 54
Pass Block
James Carpenter has the dimensions to take up space and be an effective pass-blocker when he plays with good technique. He needs to show more discipline and speed while dropping into his sets as well as quicker hand usage when engaged with defenders, but on the whole, he fits well in the Seahawks blocking scheme.
Run Block
Because of his sheer size, you would expect Carpenter to be a skilled run-blocker. However, he doesn’t carry a consistent mean streak and lacks the ability to engage and sustain defenders in blocks. Furthermore, he struggles to move in space when blocking even though he is comfortable moving laterally. Carpenter’s height can sometimes work against him as well.
Starter
Carpenter is the kind of player who is a viable starter, but he's not someone who should feel assured of his spot.
Overall
44. Amini Silatolu, Carolina Panthers
11 of 54
Pass Block
Amini Silatolu can be very stout in his stance while fending off pass-rushers, but inconsistency in his footwork causes him to lose his balance too often. Silatolu can show off quick, precise feet that allow him to maintain his balance well, but he can also display lead feet, which allow defensive linemen to push past him with ease.
Run Block
Balance is an issue for Silatolu in everything that he does. He is athletic enough to comfortably pull behind the line of scrimmage or advance to the second level, but he struggles to engage defenders at the point of contact. Too often he falls forward or falls down to the ground. Silatolu isn’t an exceptionally strong player, so he needs better control to be an effective run-blocker.
Starter
Silatolu has the talent to be a starter in the NFL, but a career that has been disrupted by injury and the emergence of two rookie guards could see him end up with another franchise in 2015.
Overall
43. Josh Kline, New England Patriots
12 of 54
Pass Block
Although his build would suggest otherwise, Josh Kline shows off some nimble feet for an offensive guard. Those feet and his impressive arm length allowed him to be a relatively effective pass protector in relief for starters in New England. Kline mostly showed good technique also, but he was too aggressive at times. He needs to learn how to sit back in his stance and only deliver aggressive punches when it makes sense to rather than recklessly.
Run Block
Kline plays tall as a run-blocker and lacks the power to drive defenders backward or knock them down in space. He is versatile with his movement without being an exceptional space-blocker. He could develop into a very good run-blocker, but at this early stage of his career, he needs to show more ability sustaining blocks and engaging defenders with lower pad level.
Starter
Kline is a backup at this point. The Patriots are always unpredictable, as Logan Mankins can attest to, but they also have a number of options upfront entering the offseason.
Overall
42. J.R. Sweezy, Seattle Seahawks
13 of 54
Pass Block
J.R. Sweezy is a narrow-vision pass-blocker. By that I mean he lacks the awareness to help those around him when he doesn’t have a defender in his face from the beginning of the play. Too often he shows off heavy feet and a lack of control in his sets to be an effective pass-blocker in space.
Run Block
Sweezy is a nasty, versatile run-blocker who plays with very impressive effort. He has the athleticism to get out in space and block faster defenders with his technique and fluidity. Fluidity is something that stands out with Sweezy. He can move in ways that many guards can’t, allowing him to win the leverage battle more often than he should. He lacks the explosiveness in tighter areas to be a dominant run-blocker, though.
Starter
Sweezy is one of the Seahawks' better offensive linemen, so he shouldn’t be going anywhere for the foreseeable future.
Overall
41. Andy Levitre, Tennessee Titans
14 of 54
Pass Block
Andy Levitre has become a football player who lacks control. Functional strength is his biggest issue, as he is too easily pushed off his spot or off balance when engaged with a defender. Levitre doesn’t have the footwork to recover his positioning in these situations.
Run Block
Levitre moves very comfortably in different directions. He can slide, pull or advance to the second level as easily as any fullback or tight end. However, once he locates and engages defenders, his lack of functional strength shows up again. He either struggles to sustain blocks or move defenders off the line of scrimmage.
Starter
Levitre could be replaced by the Titans if they were simply taking performance and contract into consideration. However, the Titans have too many other issues to address to focus on rebuilding the offensive line again. Injuries could be the cause for his struggles, so there is still a chance that he can turn his career around to where it was during his Buffalo days.
Overall
40. Ramon Foster, Pittsburgh Steelers
15 of 54
Pass Block
It was a good season for Foster. His physical limitations are always going to limit his ceiling both as a pass-blocker and a run-blocker, but his relatively quick feet, reliable technique and decent strength allowed him to become a valuable protector on Ben Roethlisberger’s blindside.
Run Block
Foster was largely just the other guy on Pittsburgh’s offensive line when it came to run blocking. David DeCastro and Maurkice Pouncey were regularly tasked with the tougher blocking assignments, while Foster was more effective in a simpler role. When playing with better leverage, he could be effective at sealing off running lanes and as part of double-teams, but the former college offensive tackle simply lacks the explosiveness to maul defenders.
Starter
Although he is not the best offensive lineman the Steelers boast, Foster is an experienced and established starter at left guard. Unless they invest heavily at left tackle and move Kelvin Beachum inside, Foster will be a starter in 2015.
Overall
39. Ben Jones, Houston Texans
16 of 54
Pass Block
With a wide frame and relatively quick feet, Ben Jones can be a very effective pass protector in space. He lacks consistency in everything he does, though, so his skill set has to take a hit. Most of his issues in pass protection come when he loses his technique. Hand placement is vitally important because although he is a thick body, his upper-body strength isn’t enough to overcome poor hand placement consistently.
Run Block
Graceful isn’t the word that comes to mind when Jones is moving in space, but he is somewhat effective within his role. He isn’t a great lateral mover, moving sideways well enough to just be effective in the Texans' zone runs. Jones doesn’t have the explosiveness to drive through defenders in the running game; instead, he is better at sealing off running lanes with his sheer width.
Starter
Jones has enough talent to be a starter in the NFL, but he lacked the consistency to assure himself of a starting spot in 2015. The Texans drafted Xavier Sua-Filo in the second round of last year’s draft; he will be expected to eventually take over for Jones at left guard.
Overall
38. Zane Beadles, Jacksonville Jaguars
17 of 54
Pass Block
Beadles shows good technique and consistency with his footwork in tight areas. He doesn’t play too tall and has the balance to set and reset when dealing with a defensive tackle’s initial surge. He moves relatively well in space but isn’t the kind of guard who should be repeatedly left alone in space against an athletic defensive lineman.
Run Block
The Jaguars regularly asked Beadles to move laterally in space while blocking in zone runs. He showed an ability to consistently get to his spot and locate defenders after pulls or on the second level; however, a lack of power hurt him at the point of contact. Beadles struggles to move defenders once engaged or explode through them aggressively after accelerating.
Starter
Although he initially struggled somewhat, Beadles improved as the season went on with his new team. He’ll never be one of the best guards in the league, but the Jaguars signed him to a long-term deal last offseason, so he’s not going anywhere any time soon.
Overall
37. Shawn Lauvao, Washington Redskins
18 of 54
Pass Block
Shawn Lauvao moves relatively well in space, but he’s not one of the quicker guards in the league. He lacks upper-body strength to anchor against bigger defensive tackles on his own and needs to show better footwork to create more consistent balance while engaged with opponents.
Run Block
In Washington’s offense, Lauvao’s lateral quickness was put under the microscope. He wasn’t an ideal fit in this scheme as he was beaten to his spots a bit too easily at times. More significantly, he showed off heavy feet and a lack of technique at the point of contact when trying to move defenders off the line of scrimmage or sustain blocks in space.
Starter
Lauvao is the kind of guard who can be effective if given enough help and used correctly. He won’t ever be an All-Pro talent, but he has just enough ability to stay on the field.
Overall
36. Ben Grubbs, Kansas City Chiefs
19 of 54
Pass Block
Ben Grubbs has been one of the more talented pass-blocking guards in the NFL over the past few years. He shows off excellent quickness and footwork to be effective in space. He complements that quickness with impressive strength, if not great size. However, Grubbs was inconsistent in 2014, as he struggled with his balance and found himself being too aggressive at the point of contact too often.
Run Block
Grubbs moves well laterally, and he advances to the second level of the defense comfortably. He needs to be more consistent locating and engaging defenders in space. In tight situations, Grubbs lacks the ability to sustain blocks and can’t move bigger defensive tackles off their spots. He is aggressive when initiating contact but lacks a punch to really impact defenders with his first hit.
Starter
Although he didn’t have the best season of his career in 2014, Grubbs is too talented to not be starting in 2015. The Chiefs should trust him to play through his inconsistencies.
Overall
35. Rodger Saffold, St. Louis Rams
20 of 54
Pass Block
As a former starting left tackle, Rodger Saffold has all the physical tools to be a very effective guard in pass protection. He shows off quick feet in space and the strength to anchor bull rushes from big defensive tackles. Saffold has some awareness issues and sometimes is too aggressive, but for the most part, he is a valuable pass protector.
Run Block
Even though he is a former offensive tackle, Saffold has the bulk and well-built frame to dominate any kind of opposing defensive lineman. He can be somewhat of a frenetic blocker in space, as he too often struggles to properly engage his assignments and concentrate his power through the defender while maintaining his balance.
Starter
Saffold was somewhat of a utility man in 2014. He played both guard spots and spent time at left tackle. The 26-year-old signed a five-year deal before the 2014 season, so his prime years should be spent starting for the Rams.
Overall
34. Joe Berger, Minnesota Vikings
21 of 54
Pass Block
Joe Berger isn’t an exceptionally strong player, but he doesn’t wilt under the pressure of a strong bull rush. He relies on active hands and disciplined feet to set and reset while being pushed backward incrementally. Berger doesn’t have the overall athleticism to be consistently effective when left in space, either, so his value as a pass protector is always going to be capped.
Run Block
The veteran is an energetic and aggressive run-blocker, but he lacks the control in space to consistently engage opponents on the second level. Without that control, his aggression can often work against him by creating momentum that drags him away from his assignment. In tighter areas, Berger needs to play with lower pad level.
Starter
Berger has the ability to be a starter in the NFL, but nothing is promised to him at this point.
Overall
33. Jack Mewhort, Indianapolis Colts
22 of 54
Pass Block
Jack Mewhort had a promising rookie season as a left guard in the NFL. He showed off some impressive athletic traits with his ability to shuffle laterally with haste in either direction. When engaged in tight areas, he showed stoutness with good hand usage. Mewhort was inconsistent with his technique, and he isn’t a great athlete, so he probably won’t ever be a great pass-protecting lineman.
Run Block
One of the more notable aspects of Mewhort’s play was how he struggled to sustain and disengage from blocks before advancing to the second level. Mewhort was an offensive tackle in college, and it shows in his run blocking. He doesn’t have the bulk or power to consistently drive through the point of contact.
Starter
The Colts lack quality offensive linemen. Mewhort is young, has shown flashes of potential and was recently selected in the second round of the draft. It would take an awful training camp showing ahead of next season for him to lose his starting spot.
Overall
32. Andrew Gardner, Philadelphia Eagles
23 of 54
Pass Block
Andrew Gardner has a tendency to play too tall in pass protection. He doesn’t gain any depth with his feet, and that creates a large surface area for shorter defensive linemen to aggressively attack. He does have impressive overall size and good length, which he can use effectively to collapse on or overpower his assignments.
Run Block
Gardner can look like a tight end at times with his movement in space, but his upper body appears to cause imbalance too often. Gardner leans too far forward and commits too much to his initial attack at the point of contact. This makes it easier for defenders to slip past him or brush him aside in space.
Starter
Gardner was a backup in 2014 who lined up at both tackle positions as well as right guard. He is unlikely to unearth a starting spot in Philadelphia next season.
Overall
31. Chris Chester, Atlanta Falcons
24 of 54
Pass Block
Chris Chester had an impressive year in pass protection. He has never had a spectacular pass-protecting skill set, but in 2014, he made good use of his hands and showed better footwork to get the most out of his limited athleticism.
Run Block
Chester was very inconsistent as a run-blocker in 2014. As he has done throughout his career, he showed off impressive movement ability both at the line of scrimmage and leaking onto the second level. However, his power and strength at the point of contact continued to make him vulnerable against bigger, stronger defensive linemen.
Starter
Chester has a very good chance of taking over a starting role now with the Falcons. He's an ideal fit for the type of offensive line Scott Pioli is trying to build in Atlanta.
Overall
30. Ryan Wendell, New England Patriots
25 of 54
Pass Block
Ryan Wendell has very heavy feet, which make him susceptible past both shoulders in pass protection. If defensive linemen hesitate initially before accelerating to either side of him in space, he really struggles to shift his weight and prevent them from penetrating the pocket. Wendell is better against bull rushes in tighter areas, but his pass protection on the whole is a problem.
Run Block
While he may be a problem in pass protection, Wendell is a perfect fit in the Patriots rushing attack. He has the versatility to pull behind the line of scrimmage in either direction or advance to the second level at different angles when the Patriots look to trap defenders in the backfield. He shows controlled aggression at the point of contact and can fluidly adjust to what is happening around him when moving forward.
Starter
Wendell won’t be assured of his starting spot moving forward, but as the incumbent at right guard, he should be the favorite to retain his position. He has one year left on his deal with the Patriots.
Overall
29. Louis Vasquez, Denver Broncos
26 of 54
Pass Block
The fact that the Denver Broncos moved Louis Vasquez to right tackle midway through the season tells you what the Denver Broncos think of Vasquez’s pass-blocking skill set. The offensive lineman has a versatile skill set because of his refined technique and impressive athleticism. He shows off the foot quickness and hand placement to contain and counter athletic defensive linemen as well as the power to hold up against bull rushes.
Run Block
For as good as Vasquez is at mirroring opponents in pass protection, his athleticism comes up short as a run-blocker. He doesn’t show off the lower-body power to drive through contact in tight and lacks the ability to locate defenders in space before engaging them in blocks.
Starter
Vasquez is arguably the Broncos’ most talented offensive lineman, but he was too inconsistent in 2014. He'll be asked to do more in 2015 with Manny Ramirez gone via trade and Ryan Clady out with an injury, putting more pressure on his versatility.
Overall
28. Manuel Ramirez, Detroit Lions
27 of 54
Pass Block
Manuel Ramirez played center for the first half of the season before moving to right guard out of necessity. Despite the transition, Ramirez showed off comfort and discipline in all facets of his pass protection at right guard. He rarely lunged forward recklessly, instead sitting back on his stance and relying on relatively quick hands to punch his opponent. While he lacks great physical skills, Ramirez did show some impressive lateral quickness as he shuffled to mirror defenders in space.
Run Block
Ramirez doesn’t have any standout traits as a run-blocker. He struggles to consistently win leverage battles with defenders who line up directly across from him and is inconsistent locating defenders in space after pulling or on the second level. He can deliver a heavy blow to his opponents but lacks the control to maintain positioning and drive through the defender at the point of contact.
Starter
Ramirez has the skill set to play center or guard for the Detroit Lions, who acquired him in a draft-day trade. That ability, plus his experience and leadership, will come in handy as Jim Caldwell looks to bolster his offensive line.
Overall
27. Justin Blalock, Free Agent
28 of 54
Pass Block
Justin Blalock does an excellent job of getting his hands on his assignment quickly. He understands how to sustain blocks with his upper body while his feet work in tandem to prevent his assignment from penetrating the pocket. Blalock struggles to adjust and pick up secondary rushers from either side because he lacks lateral quickness, and his overall strength isn’t enough to compensate for poor leverage.
Run Block
Blalock shows off impressive movement skills and understood how to initially position himself best within the Atlanta Falcons' blocking scheme. However, once in position, he lacks the explosiveness to move defenders away from the football.
Starter
At 31 years of age, Blalock had two years left on his contract before being released. With legitimate starter talent, it's a bit of a surprise to see Blalock still on the free-agent market.
Overall
26. Trai Turner, Carolina Panthers
29 of 54
Pass Block
Trai Turner plays right guard like a mammoth. He uses his size, length and strength to dominate opponents in pass protection once engaged. Despite his strength, Turner doesn’t rush to engage defenders, instead sitting back in his stance while using his hands to repel any bull rushes. Turner must get his hand on his defenders; otherwise, they can highlight his lack of quickness in space.
Run Block
Although he is exceptionally strong with impressive size, Turner lacks the movement skills and explosiveness to be an effective run-blocker. Too often he loses his balance forward when attempting to push defenders downfield or clean out running lanes. He is much better at establishing position to seal off running lanes from more advantageous positions.
Starter
Turner is a talented player who probably won’t ever develop into an impressive run-blocker, but his value as a pass protector should keep him in the Panthers starting lineup over the coming seasons.
Overall
25. Mike Pollak, Cincinnati Bengals
30 of 54
Pass Block
Mike Pollak is a sound assignment pass protector who shows excellent awareness whether he is picking up blitzes or giving help after being left free. He plays with consistently good hand placement and footwork but lacks the athleticism to truly dominate against opposition of higher caliber.
Run Block
Although a versatile and consistent guard who can be effective in tight situations or when asked to pull to either side of the field, Pollak simply lacks the power to explode through defenders. He is better at sealing and sustaining blocks to help establish running lanes from favorable starting positions.
Starter
Pollak may be one of the best backups in the NFL, and he could persuade the Bengals to let Clint Boling leave in free agency so he can become the team’s starting left guard. However, that is not a guarantee, so the veteran still can’t be sure of his future.
Overall
24. Jon Asamoah, Atlanta Falcons
31 of 54
Pass Block
Jon Asamoah primarily relies on his length and upper-body strength to be an effective pass-blocker. Asamoah has strong, quick hands that allow him to keep defensive linemen at bay in tight situations. His lateral quickness isn’t exceptional, but he is capable of setting and resetting his feet effectively while engaged with defenders in space.
Run Block
Despite showing impressive upper-body strength in pass protection, Asamoah appears to lack the lower-body power to drive through blockers in the running game. Furthermore, when he is asked to pull across the formation or advance onto the second level, he struggles to control his aggression to effectively locate and engage defenders.
Starter
The Falcons signed Asamoah to be a starting guard on a relatively unimpressive offensive line. He should be an important piece of the line as they continue to try to improve it moving forward.
Overall
23. Ronald Leary, Dallas Cowboys
32 of 54
Pass Block
Ronald Leary is a problem in pass protection. Too often, Leary engages with his assignment prematurely and is too aggressive. He makes it easy for the defender to knock him out of the way before chasing after the quarterback. Leary has good athleticism, but his technique is too sloppy for him to be effective.
Run Block
Although he is the least celebrated of the Cowboys offensive linemen, Leary is an ideal fit in the team’s run-blocking scheme. He moves laterally with ease and has impressive acceleration and control when pulling behind the line of scrimmage. He understands how to engage and drive through defenders without being too aggressive.
Starter
Because of his struggles in pass protection, Leary can’t be assured of his starting spot moving forward. Expect to see Leary compete with newcomer La'el Collins throughout camp for the No. 1 left guard spot.
Overall
22. Gabe Jackson, Oakland Raiders
33 of 54
Pass Block
One of the first things that stands out with Gabe Jackson in pass protection is his footwork. Jackson has very active feet that allow him to constantly set and reset when engaged with defensive linemen in space. He combines that with excellent hand usage to get the most out of his athleticism.
Run Block
Although he is a strong player, Jackson struggles to move defenders in the running game. He delivers a strong punch on initial contact but is incapable of consistently sustaining blocks. Most significantly, Jackson slips off blockers and fails to impact defenders in space because he allows his forward momentum to drag his upper body forward too often.
Starter
Jackson needs to develop better technique and control as a run-blocker, but his value as a pass protector makes him one of the Raiders’ best offensive linemen. The rookie should have a long career as a starter ahead of him.
Overall
21. Clint Boling, Cincinnati Bengals
34 of 54
Pass Block
Clint Boling is a well-rounded pass-blocker without any great strengths or weaknesses. He is inconsistent against bull rushes as he struggles to compete with defenders who initially win the leverage battle. Boling has decent size and technique to be a valuable member of the Bengals' pass-blocking unit.
Run Block
Boling has impressive strength at the point of attack in space. He pulls across the formation comfortably and shows controlled aggression to hit and sustain blocks. Boling struggles more in tight but still has enough strength to be effective at times.
Starter
Boling is back with the Bengals after re-signing as a free agent. He should immediately be inserted as a starter on an offensive line expecting an influx of youth after 2015.
Overall
20. Chance Warmack, Tennessee Titans
35 of 54
Pass Block
Chance Warmack is an exceptionally strong football player. He comfortably anchors against bull rushes and shows off the upper-body strength to push defenders to the ground when they’re overly aggressive. Warmack shows good feet to keep his balance in pass protection but struggles with hand placement and quickness.
Run Block
At this early stage of his career, Warmack is a good run-blocker. However, his skill set suggests he should be a great run-blocker. He has the ideal size and athleticism to pull in space, slide laterally and advance to the second level. He needs to be more consistent with his technique in tight situations, and playing on a better offensive line will allow him to show off his strengths more often.
Starter
Warmack was a highly thought of draft prospect who hasn’t yet lived up to his potential. In spite of that, he is still some years away from his projected prime and will remain a key starter for Tennessee. The Titans will feel encouraged by how he finished the season.
Overall
19. David DeCastro, Pittsburgh Steelers
36 of 54
Pass Block
David DeCastro is a physically gifted guard who shows off active feet and good hand usage to prevent defensive linemen from getting into his chest. DeCastro has good awareness in picking up assignments and the ability to set and reset his feet to be effective in space against good athletes.
Run Block
Along with Le'Veon Bell and Maurkice Pouncey, DeCastro was a key figure for the Steelers running game in 2014. DeCastro and Pouncey were regularly asked to make difficult blocks in space, advancing to the second level or pulling out into the flat. In tight, he showed off impressive but somewhat inconsistent power. DeCastro has a mean streak that can sometimes make him too aggressive.
Starter
DeCastro has the opportunity to become a staple of this offensive line for many years to come. He is the most talented guard the Steelers have had since Alan Faneca.
Overall
18. Alex Boone, San Francisco 49ers
37 of 54
Pass Block
Alex Boone is an oversized guard because he is a converted offensive tackle. As a converted tackle, his skill set allows him to be very effective in space as a pass-protecting guard. He uses his length and lateral quickness to counter quicker defensive linemen while still having the strength to combat bigger defensive tackles. Boone struggled during the first half of the season after holding out in the offseason, but he returned to form during the second half.
Run Block
Like most of the 49ers' offensive linemen, Boone is comfortable pulling behind the line of scrimmage in either direction. He can also effectively advance to the second level to make blocks in space. However, his length works against him when trying to establish leverage and exert his power against bigger defensive tackles in tight situations.
Starter
Boone held out from training camp in search of a new deal that he ultimately got. He is under contract for next season, and it’s very unlikely that the 49ers would consider moving on from him since he is in the prime of his career.
Overall
17. Larry Warford, Detroit Lions
38 of 54
Pass Block
Larry Warford is a very impressive athlete. He has the quick feet and strong upper body to fight defensive tackles in tight or set and reset in space to keep them away from his quarterback. Although his hands are strong, his placement could be more consistent to get the most out of his physical gifts. Warford also shows off impressive awareness and is a very impressive pass-blocker on the whole.
Run Block
Although he is strong and moves comfortably, Warford struggles to locate defenders in space when asked to move. He has the ability to deliver a powerful punch to his opponents but struggles to sustain blocks. Warford has good size and is an impressive physical talent, but he is too reckless as a run-blocker and lacks the control to be consistently effective.
Starter
Warford was a third-round pick for the Lions just two years ago, and he has done nothing but exceed expectations since stepping on the field.
Overall
16. Andrew Norwell, Carolina Panthers
39 of 54
Pass Block
Andrew Norwell is a big-bodied, energetic guard who has decent athleticism in pass protection. He needs to improve his footwork so that he can better anchor against bigger defenders, but he showed off good resilience against bull rushes during his rookie season. Norwell also needs to improve his awareness to avoid drawing himself out of position, but on the whole, this past year was a positive beginning to his career in Carolina.
Run Block
Despite his size, Norwell is comfortable pulling and turning to clamp down on defenders when the ball is snapped. His pad level could improve, but he shows off the tenacity and power to push defenders away from running lanes. Sometimes his aggressiveness can work against him, but he shouldn’t be considered a reckless run-blocker.
Starter
Because he was an undrafted free agent in 2014, Norwell’s status as a starter in Carolina can’t be assured just yet. He clearly has the talent to hold onto the position, though.
Overall
15. Logan Mankins, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
40 of 54
Pass Block
After being traded from the New England Patriots to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during the preseason, it was no surprise that Logan Mankins took some time to adjust. During the first half of the season, he struggled in pass protection in particular. Part of his poor play was unfamiliarity with his teammates, but it also reflected his declining physical skills. Mankins is a technically sound player, but he struggles when left in space with better athletes.
Run Block
Mankins still moves relatively well, and he can deliver an effective blow at the point of contact after pulling across the formation. He doesn’t have the same consistent impact on running plays that he had during his prime, but he carries the same controlled aggression on the field.
Starter
When the Buccaneers traded for Mankins, they picked him up with three years left on his contract. They didn’t acquire him for just one season, so there’s no reason to think that he won’t be a starter in Tampa Bay moving forward.
Overall
14. Mike Iupati, Arizona Cardinals
41 of 54
Pass Block
Mike Iupati’s value isn’t at its highest when he is asked to protect the passer. His wide, heavy frame comes with slow feet that make it difficult for him to adjust and reset his feet when battling defenders in space. He has a tendency to be too aggressive at times also, allowing his opponents to get to his chest or knock him backward because he is off balance.
Run Block
For as long as he has been in the NFL, Iupati’s primary value has come in the running game. He plays with a controlled aggression that allows him to punish opponents and push them off their spots regardless of his assignment. He can pull to either side of the field and locate defenders in space comfortably.
Starter
Iupati is a very talented player who got to showcase his strengths more in previous years when the 49ers focused on building their offense by running the ball. By asking Colin Kaepernick to throw more without play action on early downs this year, the 49ers put more pressure on their left guard in pass protection. In Arizona, he'll be put to the test in pass protection in Bruce Arians' downfield passing scheme.
Overall
13. John Greco, Cleveland Browns
42 of 54
Pass Block
John Greco isn’t a great athlete. Instead, he relies on his technique to be effective. He sets his feet well to absorb bull rushes against bigger defensive tackles, but a lack of arm strength can be exposed even after he gets good placement with his hands. Greco can be effective in space against lesser athletes, but he will be exposed if tasked with accounting for better interior pass-rushers.
Run Block
Greco’s run-blocking ability is what made him a good fit in Kyle Shanahan’s offense. He isn’t a spectacular athlete, but he shows good strength and body control while moving laterally. This allows Greco to pass defenders off before sealing the edge or push defenders to the sideline to clear running lanes for his running backs.
Starter
In Kyle Shanahan’s offense, Greco was a valuable starter. That doesn’t mean he will remain a valuable starter for long in Cleveland. He is a good, not great, guard who needs the offense to play to his strengths or he could very easily tumble down these rankings.
Overall
12. Brandon Linder, Jacksonville Jaguars
43 of 54
Pass Block
Brandon Linder is an agile offensive linemen with impressive upper-body strength and consistent technique. He understands how to set his feet quickly and accurately to best get the most out of his balance. Linder has good size and uses that to anchor against bigger defensive linemen, but he is built in such a way that he doesn’t struggle when left in space.
Run Block
While his length benefits him in pass protection, it becomes somewhat of a hindrance for Linder’s ability to be a positive run-blocker. He does a good job getting his pads low quickly, but shorter defensive linemen are always more likely to get the leverage advantage at the snap. Linder is able to move relatively well laterally, but he struggles when locating defenders on the second level and can slip off blocks trying to be too aggressive.
Starter
The rookie had a tough beginning to his season, as his own individual adjustment to the league coupled with changing pieces around him caused a lot of inconsistency. However, once the Jaguars offense as a whole settled, Linder quickly established himself as one of its most valuable pieces.
Overall
11. Kevin Zeitler, Cincinnati Bengals
44 of 54
Pass Block
Kevin Zeitler plays with a wide base in pass protection that allows him to set and reset while controlling his assignment with long, strong arms. Zeitler has the athleticism to be effective in space and the size to withstand bull rushes from bigger defensive linemen.
Run Block
As a run-blocker, Zeitler moves relatively well and has the power to deliver impact blocks. However, he too often struggles at the point of contact in space. Zeitler slips off blocks too easily and loses his balance when trying to deliver a heavy blow in space. He is still a very valuable run-blocker with good consistency overall.
Starter
Zeitler is a former first-round pick who should be approaching the prime of his career with the Cincinnati Bengals.
Overall
10. Orlando Franklin, San Diego Chargers
45 of 54
Pass Block
Orlando Franklin bounces between guard and tackle, but in 2014, he spent his time at left guard. Franklin uses his experience at tackle—and the fact that he’s built like a tackle—to his advantage. His power and length allow him to knock pass-rushers off their feet, and from there he finishes with patience and vision. Franklin allowed just one sack in 17 games.
Run Block
Poor leverage keeps Franklin’s score down here, but he was at times a truly elite run-blocking guard. In Denver's win over the Kansas City Chiefs in Week 13, Franklin dominated as an individual and combination blocker in the run game. His forward momentum and hand placement make him tough to counter for defenders trying to get to the ball-carrier.
Starter
Franklin has been a bit up and down at times, but at guard he looked like a legitimate Pro Bowl talent.
Overall
9. Josh Sitton, Green Bay Packers
46 of 54
Pass Block
Last year’s top-ranked guard, Josh Sitton still comes in with the best pass-blocking score of any guard. Sitton went an entire season—plus two playoff games—without allowing a sack, and he only let up four quarterback hits and six hurries in that same 18-game stretch. Sitton is built like a tackle and uses his length, agile feet and impressive patience to earn the honor of the NFL’s best pass-blocking guard.
Run Block
Sitton’s run blocking took a step back in 2014, as he struggled to own defenders in one-on-one situations. The Detroit Lions gave him fits in both meetings, and the Philadelphia Eagles gave him his worst performance of the year. Sitton has the agility, but his power looked less effective at the point of impact.
Starter
A 2008 draft pick in the fourth round, Sitton has been incredibly consistent. Among the NFL’s best guards, Sitton is a clear-cut Pro Bowler.
Overall
8. Brandon Brooks, Houston Texans
47 of 54
Pass Block
A lack of quickness will always be an issue for Brandon Brooks, but his length and power allow him to produce as a blocking guard, and in 2014, he improved substantially with better technique and leverage. As a 16-game starter, he allowed zero sacks and only two quarterback hits all season long.
Run Block
Brooks’ power is the base of his run blocking. His 335-pound frame allows him to drive block and move defenders off their spots. At the point of attack, he can swallow up defenders and let runners cut off his back. Brooks is an impressive mover in the Texans blocking scheme but is limited at the second level slightly.
Starter
A former third-round pick, Brooks has found his home at right guard and is quickly making his case to be one of the best young players in the game there.
Overall
7. Zack Martin, Dallas Cowboys
48 of 54
Pass Block
Zack Martin came to Dallas and immediately solidified the offensive line, allowing zero sacks in his first year. The former Notre Dame left tackle brought that same ability to his starting spot at right guard—where Dallas often left him in space with center Travis Frederick to help left guard Ronald Leary. Martin moves well, has solid length and shows rare technique with hand placement and balance.
Run Block
The Cowboys had the NFL’s leading rusher in Martin’s first year, and he received plenty of credit for that in the press. Martin is a mean run-blocker and will look to finish blocks on the ground. He’s strong enough to be a drive-blocker but will get his back bent at times and will want to learn to play with better hand placement when locking on to defenders.
Starter
Martin is one of the NFL’s bright spots on the offensive line, and his future includes many Pro Bowl trips and All-Pro awards.
Overall
6. Kelechi Osemele, Baltimore Ravens
49 of 54
Pass Block
In his second year as a true guard, Kelechi Osemele emerged as a balanced, talented player in both the pass and run game. Osemele allowed just two sacks and three hits all season long (including two playoff games) and showed that his college experience at tackle has allowed him to excel on an island and as a combination blocker on the left side.
Run Block
Osemele is a powerful mauler in the run game who uses his 6’5”, 330-pound frame to lock down and move defenders. Playing in Gary Kubiak’s zone-blocking scheme, Osemele made massive improvements. He’s agile enough to move, pull and trap but also has the pure strength to lock horns with a defender and drive block.
Starter
If you need a young left guard, it’s tough to find many options better than Osemele. He’s a potential blue-chip player in Baltimore.
Overall
5. Kyle Long, Chicago Bears
50 of 54
Pass Block
Kyle Long started 16 games in 2014 and allowed zero sacks. Equally impressive, he allowed just two quarterback hits during that time. And this isn’t on a star-studded line like Dallas' or Cleveland's. Long’s athleticism, length and toughness make him the best pass-blocking right guard in the NFL. And it’s important to remember that playing right guard means he’s often on an island—and he plays it like a left tackle. Long’s punch is both powerful and well-timed, and physically, he’s amazingly gifted.
Run Block
Long has an athletic, powerful release and gets to the second level without issue. He can get pushed back off his spot if his initial pop doesn’t stick. He’s a good combination blocker, but that’s one area where he and his center can improve together.
Starter
Long is among the most physically gifted guards in the NFL, and it wouldn’t be a surprise to see him top this list in 2016.
Overall
4. T.J. Lang, Green Bay Packers
51 of 54
Pass Block
T.J. Lang is an ideal mix of power and toughness, and he shows enough agility to move well in space while still having the foundation to drop anchor and stop bull-rushers. His production as a pass protector improved in 2014—allowing just three sacks (the same as 2013) while decreasing his number of hits and hurries allowed. With improved punch timing, Lang could shoot even higher up the board.
Run Block
Lang saw his score improve in 2014 as a run-blocker, as he showed improved power between the tackles and better agility to seal off and reach outside defenders. His body control was better, too, showing balanced footwork and better leverage at the point of attack.
Starter
The ideal right guard for Green Bay, Lang has the power and agility needed to fuel the run game and keep Aaron Rodgers upright in pass protection.
Overall
3. Joel Bitonio, Cleveland Browns
52 of 54
Pass Block
A second-round pick out of Nevada, Joel Bitonio was All-Pro caliber as a rookie. He allowed one sack in 16 games at left guard, and while he did surrender 11 hurries, Bitonio showed the balance and punch of an offensive tackle playing guard. His length at 6’4” makes him an ideal blindside guard and allows the Browns to slide their protection with ease.
Run Block
The loss of Alex Mack had a huge affect on the Browns offensive line, but Bitonio thrived as the season wore on. He’s powerful and has the meanness needed to be an intimidating blocker. Look at his Week 5 game against the Tennessee Titans, and you see the ceiling for Bitonio, who has the upside of being the best left guard in football.
Starter
A steal in Round 2, Bitonio looks to be the future of the NFL at left guard. He has the look of a perennial All-Pro.
Overall
2. Evan Mathis, Free Agent
53 of 54
Pass Block
Evan Mathis has long been one of the more productive guards in the NFL, and in 2014, he was once again while only starting nine games due to injury. Mathis has the length to reach defenders in the passing game and the balanced footwork to slide, mirror or get depth to protect the pocket. His punch is both strong and well-timed, which allowed him to keep quarterbacks off the ground, surrendering just two sacks in 2014.
Run Block
Mathis is a solid mover with the agility and strength to attack defenders. He’s at his best in space and shows excellent balance with fluid movements and the power to lock up defensive linemen or linebackers.
Starter
Mathis’ reign as a top guard goes to three years straight with our No. 2 overall guard ranking. He’s consistently one of the best players in the game, which makes his release from the Philadelphia Eagles a bit of a surprise. He should be highly sought after on the free agent market.
Overall
1. Marshal Yanda, Baltimore Ravens
54 of 54
Pass Block
Marshal Yanda is an accomplished, talented pass protector with the production to back up his reputation. Yanda allowed just two sacks in 2014 but also kept Joe Flacco from getting hit (just five allowed) or hurried (just 13 allowed). He uses his eyes well but is exceptional with his footwork, timing and punch strength. A lack of length is the only thing holding Yanda down, but he’s in the elite category.
Run Block
A finisher and a mauler in the run game, Yanda is a good enough athlete to work in a man-blocking scheme or a zone scheme like the one used in 2014. Yanda has exceptional balance and quickness off his spot. He can pull and trap with ease and has the power to lock up and dump defenders.
Starter
Yanda was a steal in the third round in the 2007 draft and has emerged as one of the best and most consistent guards in the NFL. His balance and versatility as a blocker are both rare.
.jpg?w=480 "Colts Jaguars Football")
.png?w=480)
.jpg?w=600 "Post-June 1 Trade Candidates ☎️")
.JPG?w=600 "TO Talks Cowboys Relationship")
.jpg?w=600 "Taylor Heinicke Retiring")
.jpg?w=600 "49ers OC Hypes Mike Evans 🤩")