The determination of Ron Roenicke's crew would prove to be all for naught, as Tony La Russa and company crushed Brewer pitching on their way to a 12-3 victory, evening the series at one game a piece heading into Game 3 in St. Louis, which is set for 8:05 PM ET on Wednesday.
Here are five observations from Monday night's 12-3 Cardinals victory over the Brewers.
This season Shaun Marcum transformed into the dependable starter the Brewers sought to attain in the offseason. Leading all major league starters with a 2.21 ERA on the road, Milwaukee's steady right-hander has been a huge success for Ron Roenicke and company this season.
Yet, Marcum's postseason failures have nearly undermined his regular-season accolades.
In two playoff starts for the Brewers, Marcum has given up 12 earned runs, 14 hits and four walks in just 8.2 innings of work.
The good news is he'll likely have at least one more shot at redemption before this best-of-seven NLCS is over. The bad news is that he has lost the confidence of many Brewers fans, and potentially his own manager.
With the addition of Francisco Rodriguez, the Brewers' bullpen ranked third in baseball with a 3.08 ERA.
Monday night clearly showed Milwaukee's flaws out of the 'pen. Between Kameron Loe and Marco Estrada, the two combined to give up six earned runs in just 2.1 innings pitched.
Granted, Estrada would go on to strike out three batters in two innings of work; Loe, however, would allow six hits and four earned runs in just 0.1 innings pitched.
Milwaukee's revamped bullpen has been a staple in their success all season long, but if their performance last night is anything of what's to come in the near future, the Brewers are in serious trouble.
After largely under-performing during the Cardinals' NLDS bout with the Philadelphia Phillies, Albert Pujols manifested his career successes at Miller Park by going 4-for-5 with a home run and a career postseason-high five RBI against the Brewers.
But, in all fairness, this shouldn't come as a surprise.
In 79 career games at Miller Park, Pujols is batting .331 with 19 HR and 54 RBI, along with 15 IBB (intentional walks) and .597 OPS.
If the Cardinals are able to push this best-of-seven series back to Milwaukee for Games 6 and 7, the Brewers had better hope they don't leave anything over the plate for the St. Louis slugger, because he might just power the Cardinals into the World Series.
While St. Louis' romping of Milwaukee on Monday night may go down as Albert Pujols' best postseason effort to date, let us not forget what Lance Berkman, Matt Holliday and the rest of the Cardinals lineup was able to do.
Excluding Pujols' extraordinary effort, Tony La Russa's lineup managed eight runs on 13 hits against Brewers pitching, with six RBI to boot.
Needless to say, Monday night was a exemplary illustration of just how lethal La Russa's lineup can be when at full strength.
We're just two games into this series, and it's clear that neither team has established any kind of consistency.
In Game 1, it was Milwaukee who slugged (Ryan Braun, Prince Fielder and Yuniesky Betancourt accounted for a home run) their way over the Cardinals, despite Jaime Garcia on the bump for St. Louis, who has traditionally been known for his road successes.
On Monday night, it was St. Louis who broke out of its offensive shell in superb fashion, scoring 11 runs on 16 hits against Brewer pitching, tying up the NLCS at one game a piece.
If these first two contests are at all indicative of what's to come, we may be in for a historically wild series between these two bitter rivals.