Bobby Parnell is not the answer in the 9th for 2012
Sandy Alderson went on the air in the middle of a telecast a few weeks ago and basically stated the Mets are facing plenty of issues for a closer next year. For all of those who held on to the belief that Bobby Parnell is the man for the future, now's the time to let go.
The Mets will not be looking to fill this void for the next 10 years in one signing this offseason, though. The team has several outstanding and young options to take the reigns of closer in the ninth inning for the next several years. They just need someone to handle it for the next year or two.
They have players like Dale Thayer, Rhiner Cruz, Josh Edgin, Nick Carr, Ryan Fraser and Jack Leathersich all coming up in the system in the next year to three years.
The Mets have options for the long-term. It's the short-term that they really have a problem with. After looking at the list of potential free agents and available veteran closers, I see five players that jump out at me. I must specify that this list is in no particular order.
A reunion with the Mets could be interesting
First up is the prodigal son. Bell came up with the Mets and played with them for three years until they unwisely traded him with Royce Ring for two no-names in November of 2006. Bell had another great year with San Diego amidst trade rumors. He posted a 2.44 ERA and had 43 saves.
He is 34 years old and will be hitting the age where closers begin to go into decline in a few years. Alderson will be looking to save money, especially if they re-sign Reyes to a huge deal. This will be his last big contract. That works against the Mets. He'll be looking to cash in.
If the numbers get lower and lower for Bell and the process takes longer and longer, he may debate a return to the team that dealt him. He has long been known as anti-Mets. Wouldn't you be if they brought you up as an amateur just to trade you for a can of beans?
I believe Alderson's ties to the Padres can help convince Bell that the Mets administration is different now and worth forgiving them for their past transgressions. Alderson also knows that a name like Bell would put fans in the seats in 2012 for what otherwise will be probably another building year.
Octavio Dotel once another former Met than can be intriguing
Like Bell, Dotel was signed as an amateur free agent by the Mets. He joined the organization in 1993. He was dealt with a handful of players, including Roger Cedeno, in December of 1999 to the Astros for Mike Hampton and Derek Bell when the Mets were building a World Series contender for 2000.
Dotel is another player that developed into a closer after leaving New York. He has been used more as a setup man in recent years but can close out games. Due to his age (38), he would be a cheaper option as well.
He's not the sexy name like Bell or Papelbon would be, but in Queens, he would be a difference-maker at the box office.
Joe Nathan brings experience on the big stage and a big price tag too
A name that baseball fans know but haven't heard in a few years, Nathan has 261 career saves. He missed all of 2010 but recorded 14 saves this season on his road to a comeback. The Twins will most likely not be paying him the $12.5 million to pick up the option on him, thus making him a free agent.
The Mets can get an experienced closer at a cheap cost in a incentive-laden contract while he proves his health. Sound familiar?
Nathan is this offseason's Jason Isringhausen. That worked out well for the Mets last year. This is the type of deal Alderson usually seems more comfortable with. He's a winner either way.
One way, Nathan succeeds and the team does well; the other way, Nathan is not himself or doesn't recover well enough, and it's not much money spent. Like Izzy, it's a chance worth taking for the Mets in a short-term situation.
Matt Capps is a pitcher that can rebound well
The former Pittsburgh Pirates standout was less than outstanding in a limited role this year for the Minnesota Twins. He posted a 4.25 ERA with 15 saves in 65.1 innings pitched.
He will be looking to rebound from these numbers, but he will not get the deal he would like as a result of them. He is still young at 28 years old.
He will be needing a small contract where he can do well in order to earn a larger contract a year or two later. That is the perfect scenario for the Mets. They underpay for a talented pitcher at the back end of their bullpen.
When his contract is over, they go even younger and more dominant. It's a win-win for Alderson.
Madson could be a great option for a longer-term than the other closers here
The Phillies reliever has only known one team in his career. He will be commanding a lot of money for his services next year. He has shown he can pitch middle relief, set-up and close out games too.
This season alone, he did all three for the Phillies. His 32 saves after Brad Lidge went down will bring him a closer's ransom in the off season.
If Alderson wants to make a statement this offseason, he would be a good start. That's not Alderson's style, but Madson has said good things about the Mets and wants to test the market.
While there will be interest from several teams, the Mets could land him in the right scenario. Other closers like Papelbon, Broxton and K-Rod (remember him?) will be dominating the market early on for those teams in need of a good closer.
Madson will have to wait for his contract. That can play well into the Mets hands and help the contract be a lot less than Madson would want.
That would most likely force him to settle for a one or two-year deal just to have somewhere to play next season, thereby giving the Mets a steal on the market.