2011 Fantasy Projections, No. 85: Why Reds' Brandon Phillips Is Overrated

Nick Kappel@@NickKappelAnalyst IIIMarch 16, 2011

GOODYEAR, AZ - MARCH 03:  Brandon Phillips #4 of the Cincinnati Reds ends up on his head while catching a pop fly against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Goodyear Ballpark on March 3, 2011 in Goodyear, Arizona.  (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images)
Norm Hall/Getty Images

Our 2011 fantasy baseball projections will be released one-by-one until the top 100 players have been revealed. These rankings consider past achievements, current performance and expected future results based on standard 5×5 H2H settings.

Last July, I featured an article on Brandon Phillips.

At the time of publication (July 3), Phillips was batting .309 with 10 HRs, 10 steals and was tied for the league lead in runs with 62.

Yet, despite his hot-hitting ways, I nominated Phillips as a prime sell-high option.

In the remaining 74 games, Phillips hit just .238 with five HRs and four steals.

How was I able to predict this sudden in-season decline?

Phillips’ .335 BABIP certainly stood out, but his career month-by-month trends have uncovered him as a first-half player.

  • April: .258 batting average
  • May: .294
  • June: .280
  • July: .250
  • August: .288
  • September: .229

Not only did the numbers point to an in-season slump, but recent history suggests a big picture decline as well. 

HR/FB rate:

  • 2007: 15.9 percent (30 HRs)
  • 2008: 13.2 percent (21 HRs)
  • 2009: 11.6 percent (20 HRs)
  • 2010: 10.0 percent (18 HRs)

Stolen base efficiency:

  • 2007: 32-of-40 (80 percent)
  • 2008: 23-of-33 (69 percent)
  • 2009: 25-of-34 (73 percent)
  • 2010: 16-of-28 (57 percent)

Since his 2007 30/30 campaign, Phillips’ power and stolen base efficiency has declined precipitously.

Also working against Phillips this season is his projected spot in the Reds’ lineup.

Currently, he’s penciled in as the leadoff batter opposed to the cleanup spot, where he’s hit in recent seasons. Yet, his career splits indicate leadoff is the absolute worst place for Phillips to hit.

  • No. 1: 360 at-bats, 32.7 AB/HR, 6-for-11 steals (55 percent)
  • No. 2: 513 at-bats, 32.1 AB/HR, 19-for-27 steals (70 percent)
  • No. 4: 1,351 at-bats: 25.0 AB/HR, 58-for-79 steals (73 percent)

While Phillips is clearly most comfortable hitting in the middle of the lineup, Joey Votto, Scott Rolen and Jay Bruce are projected to occupy the three, four and five holes.

However, this profile would be incomplete without all the facts, and it just so happens there are a few positive signs. 

Contact Rate:

  • 2008: 77.9 percent
  • 2009: 80.6 percent
  • 2010: 81.9 percent

Swinging Strike Rate:

  • 2008: 11.6 percent
  • 2009: 9.8 percent
  • 2010: 9.3 percent

Even though his power/speed combo is on the decline, Phillips has shortened his swing in recent years, leading to lower strikeout totals and better contact rates. This explains why he’s been able to maintain a .275 batting average in each of the last two seasons (career .267).

Even so, Phillips’ sub-20/20 line and .270 average doesn’t warrant his current 33 ADP on Mock Draft Central or his 37 Yahoo! Composite ranking. In fact, Phillips' 2010 line (100/18/59/16/.275) doesn’t match up against that of Kelly Johnson (93/26/71/13/.284), whose current ADP is 111, 78 spots lower than Phillips.

While most are projecting a bounce back season from the soon-to-be 31-year-old, his trends over the last four seasons suggest otherwise.

He’s the 10th-ranked second baseman on my 2011 big board, No. 85 overall.

2010 stats 687 100 18 59 16 .275
3-year average 647 85 20 78 21 .271
2011 FBI Forecast 670 95 18 60 15 .272



Fantasy Baseball Insiders’ 2011 Big Board:

Latest from Fantasy Baseball Insiders:

30 Teams in 30 Days Fantasy Preview:

MLB Trades: Fantasy Impact:


    Marlins' Straily, Mattingly Suspended for Throwing at Posey

    MLB logo

    Marlins' Straily, Mattingly Suspended for Throwing at Posey

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report

    Judge, Andujar HR, Yanks Top M's for Sweep

    MLB logo

    Judge, Andujar HR, Yanks Top M's for Sweep

    via ESPN.com

    Revisiting Every Team's Biggest Offseason Mistake

    MLB logo

    Revisiting Every Team's Biggest Offseason Mistake

    Zachary D. Rymer
    via Bleacher Report

    Soto's Clutch 2-Run Double Lifts Nats Over O's

    MLB logo

    Soto's Clutch 2-Run Double Lifts Nats Over O's

    via MLB