We all know who the greatest players of all time are. Willie Mays, Henry Aaron, Walter Johnson. These are the elite, the legends of the game. And they are deserving of the praise they are given. However, there are players who are not worthy of the praise they receive. They are just not as good as some people think. This list features some of them.
Some of the players on this list are not as good as their reputation would have you believe. Some are unjustifiably compared to Hall of Famers and legends, some had just one or two great seasons and some are average players rescued by postseason success. Some are flat-out bad.