Super Bowl 2011: Will Aaron Rodgers Outplay Ben Roethlisberger?

Thomas CopainCorrespondent INovember 8, 2016

Super Bowl 2011: Will Aaron Rodgers Outplay Ben Roethlisberger?

0 of 12

    Jamie Squire/Getty Images

    So it's almost here—Super Bowl XLV.

    Soon our televisions, computer screens and possibly our newspaper pages will be filled with news coming out of Dallas.  Soon, we'll have Media Day and all the madness that comes with it, and all the hype and hyperbole leading up to the six-hour pregame show and the actual kickoff.

    You can guess one of the biggest questions and debates surrounding Super Bowl week will be who is the better quarterback, Aaron Rodgers or Ben Roethlisberger?

    Rodgers is on fire entering the Super Bowl, while Roethlisberger is making his third Super Bowl appearance and looking to win his third ring.

    Both are two of the better quarterbacks in the game, but will Rodgers outplay Roethlisberger Sunday?

Reason Why No. 5: Rodgers Has The Big Mo

1 of 12

    Andy Lyons/Getty Images

    During the Playoffs, Rodgers has been on fire.  Save for the National Football Conference Championship Game, he's been pretty close to perfect.  He's completing more than 70 percent of his passes, leads all playoff quarterbacks in passing yards and has six touchdown passes.  He's been dissecting defenses with precision and his confidence has grown with every throw, as has the Packers'. 

Reason Why Not No. 5: Roethlisberger Hasn't Had To Be Great

2 of 12

    Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

    Roethlisberger's passing numbers haven't been superb, but they haven't been awful either—possibly because they haven't had to be.  Rashard Mendenhall is the second leading rusher in the Playoffs (behind Green Bay's James Starks), and while Pittsburgh's offensive numbers are down, it's because they've faced two much better defenses in the Ravens and Jets than what Green Bay has faced.

Reason Why No. 4: A-Rod's Personal Good Luck Charm

3 of 12

    Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images

    If you look at where the Packers' season turned around, you can look to the last five games—or rather, when Joe Buck became the Packers' personal play-by-play man.  Buck has called all three playoff games and the last two regular season games for the Packers.  The Packers won all five and Rodgers was phenomenal in four of them. 

    And Fox is broadcasting the Super Bowl, which means Buck will call the game. Coincidence.  I think not.

Reason Why Not No. 4: Roethlisberger's Supreme Salad

4 of 12

    Nick Laham/Getty Images

    Ben Roethlisberger vs. Aaron Rodgers might be the battle of who has the better beard.  While Rodgers has a very full beard that works for someone like him, Roethlisberger's beard is a great fit for someone who is the Steelers' quarterback.  Not to mention, for someone who played with a broken nose, seeing that sight with that beard is a very intimidating look.

Reason Why No. 3: Rodgers Won't Be Asked Any Questions About His Offseason

5 of 12

    Nick Laham/Getty Images

    Regardless of what you think about Roethlisberger and what allegedly happened in the offseason in Georgia, he's had to deal with those questions all season.  That's only going to become more and more amplified during Super Bowl week.  Columnists are already lining up the pro and anti-Roethlisberger columns, and even though he might say it doesn't bother him, it has to come to a head at some point.

Reason Why Not No. 3: Rodgers Will Have To Answer Questions About...Him

6 of 12

    Streeter Lecka/Getty Images

    Then again, Rodgers will be asked about you know who.  Fact is, it's the Packers first Super Bowl since No. 4 was flinging passes to Antonio Freeman and Robert Brooks, and a win would be the first since the Texting Wonder ran around with his helmet in his hand in the Superdome.  So all the questions about replacing Favre, will be back in some form this week.  And Rodgers will have to deal with that as well.

Reason Why No. 2: Rodgers Is Facing The Lesser Secondary

7 of 12

    Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

    No offense to the Pittsburgh Steelers defensive backs, especially Troy Polamalu, but the Steelers can be beaten through the air.  Tom Brady proved as much earlier this season.  Ike Taylor and Bryant McFadden are going to have a hard time being able to contain the Packers' wide receivers, and while they have played phenomenal defense this postseason, Rodgers is by far the best quarterback they've faced since Tom Brady.

Reason Why Not No. 2: Roethlisberger Torched The Packers Secondary Last Year

8 of 12

    Jared Wickerham/Getty Images

    But lest we forget last season, when these two had the Game of the Year.  Roethlisberger and Rodgers threw the ball up-and-down the field, with Rodgers throwing for 383 and three touchdowns.  But Roethlisberger did him one better, throwing for 503 yards and three touchdowns, including the game-winning score to Mike Wallace with no time left on the clock.  He's beaten these Packers before, he can do it again.

Reason Why No. 1: Rodgers Makes Precision Throws

9 of 12

    Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    Aaron Rodgers is completing passes the last few weeks at a clip that's almost outstanding.  He does it by being a great pocket presence and sense of where the ball needs to be and when it needs to be thrown.  Rodgers is very good at standing in and delivering a strong ball.  His throws are always on a rope and he's extremely accurate, which makes him very tough.

Reason Why Not No. 1: It's Better To Be Lucky Than Good

10 of 12

    Nick Laham/Getty Images

    In this case, I'm using lucky as a compliment.  Don't get me wrong, Roethlisberger is very good.  But he creates his own luck.  His strong body and his ability to extend the play and outlast the pass coverage makes him very tough.  Roethlisberger makes good throws, but he's very much like Tony Romo.  He's best and he has the most success when he can extend the play, get out of the pocket and exploit the broken coverage to make a play.  It's not the best-looking scheme, but it works.

And The Verdict Is...

11 of 12

    Al Bello/Getty Images

    This is so tough to call because both these quarterbacks are near the top of the league and both have the propensity to put up monster games. 

    Rodgers will be under the worldwide stage for the first time, and while I don't think he would be rattled by that type of pressure, the Super Bowl is a different animal and he'll have more eyes on him than ever before. It may be somewhat cliche, but it can't be discounted either.

    Meanwhile,  for all this talk about how Roethlisberger is one of the best ever with a win, take a look at his actual numbers in his two Super Bowls:

     

    Super Bowl XL: 9-for-21, 123 yards, two interceptions

    Super Bowl XLIII: 21-for-30, 256 yards, one touchdown, one interception

     

    Combined those numbers read out to 30-for-51 (58 percent completion percentage), 379 yards, one touchdown and three picks. Not exactly stellar.

    That being said, I've learned in big games, it's hard to bet against Roethlisberger, who just seems to find ways to win.  So with that being said, expect Aaron Rodgers to outplay Roethlisberger stat-wise, but expect Big Ben to get his third ring.


12 of 12