San Francisco Giants All-Time 25-Man Roster

Zack FarmerCorrespondent ISeptember 10, 2010

San Francisco Giants All-Time 25-Man Roster

0 of 25

    SAN FRANCISCO - SEPTEMBER 26:  Barry Bonds #25 of the San Francisco Giants looks on during his game against the San Diego Padres during a Major League Baseball game on September 26, 2007 at AT&T Park in San Francisco, California.  (Photo by Jed Jacobsohn/
    Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    It's time to make the cuts. Spring training is over, the contracts have been signed. Now it's time to play some ball.

    But who should actually play? There have been a lot of great players in San Francisco Giants history.

    Bonds, Mays, McCovey, Cepeda.

    The list goes on endlessly. But let's cut it down to the best 25. How would you put a roster together?

    How many pitchers do you carry? How many lefties?

    I need a backup catcher, don't I?

    No matter how you build a team, you need to have a solid base and a pitching staff that will carry you the distance.

    This will illustrate the entire pitching staff, bench, and starting lineup.

    Let's see what it looks like.

The Ace: RHP Juan Marichal

1 of 25

    Juan Marichal is, undoubtedly, the best pitcher in SF Giants history.
    Juan Marichal is, undoubtedly, the best pitcher in SF Giants history.

    He may never have won a Cy Young but he was just as dominant as anybody in baseball history.

    Juan Marichal had six seasons where he won 20 or more games. He had five seasons of 20 or more complete games.

    He took part in nine All-Star games.

    Probably most famous for his high leg kick, most knew from the beginning that he was something special.

    In his first start in 1960, he one-hit the Philadelphia Phillies while striking out 12 batters.

    He never looked back.

Starting Pitcher No. 2: RHP Gaylord Perry

2 of 25

    Master of the spitball, Gaylord Perry is one of the greats.
    Master of the spitball, Gaylord Perry is one of the greats.Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

    The saying goes, "If you're not cheating, you're not trying." No truer words were spoken, especially when referring to Gaylord Perry.

    Infamous for the spitball, Perry was one of the more creative guys on the mound.

    Spit, Vaseline, dirt, anything he could get his hands on were probably used on the baseball. Though umpires never found anything. Huh, go figure.

    It was his style and it was a style that worked. He had a career 2.96 ERA and was an All-Star twice while in San Francisco.

    His breakout season was in 1966 when he finished 21-8 with a 2.99 ERA.

Starting Pitcher No. 3: RHP Tim Lincecum

3 of 25

    Two Cy Youngs? Hard to argue.
    Two Cy Youngs? Hard to argue.Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    Though he is still building his legacy, it is hard to argue with two straight Cy Young Awards.

    Tim Lincecum has awed baseball fans everywhere with his diminutive frame and electric stuff. During his first full season, Sports Illustrated dubbed him "The Freak."

    Those in San Francisco had already started to label him, "The Franchise."

    Not since Juan Marichal had Giants fans seen a pitcher become this dominant this quickly.

    He has a career 3.09 ERA.

Starting Pitcher No. 4: LHP Vida Blue

4 of 25

    One of the best lefties in history: Vida Blue.
    One of the best lefties in history: Vida Blue.Getty Images/Getty Images

    In two different stints with the Giants, Vida Blue went 72-58 with a 3.52 ERA.

    His total numbers are misleading, though. During his first stint with the team, he was that Hall of Fame pitcher.

    In his first stint, he spent four seasons with the Giants from 1978-1981. In that first season, he went 18-10 with a 2.79 ERA.

    He made the All-Star team three times.

    His second tour of duty were the final two seasons of his career. He went 18-18 with a 3.81 ERA.

Starting Pitcher No. 5: RHP Jason Schmidt

5 of 25

    As dominant as anybody in the game while in San Francisco.
    As dominant as anybody in the game while in San Francisco.Lisa Blumenfeld/Getty Images

    Jason Schmidt's time in San Francisco was short but it was very memorable.

    First memory that comes to mind is Schmidt walking into Yankee Stadium and shutting down that lineup. He turned so many heads that day, many of them were getting dizzy.

    He threw eight innings allowing three earned runs while striking out 13.

    His best season was in 2003 when he finished 17-5 with a 2.34 ERA. He even collected 18 wins in the 2004 season when the Giants were one game out of the playoffs.

Bullpen: LHP Kirk Rueter

6 of 25

    As crafty as anybody: Kirk Rueter.
    As crafty as anybody: Kirk Rueter.Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

    There is nothing flashy about "Woody."

    He doesn't throw hard. He doesn't have a top-notch pitch of any kind.

    Kirk Rueter is the crafty lefty. He is the winningest left-handed pitcher in San Francisco history.

    But where he made his name was not in the regular season. He was, oddly enough, better in the postseason.

    Rueter has a career 4.27 ERA in the regular season. His postseason ERA? 3.79.

    He also has a 2.70 ERA in the World Series.

    Woody came up big when it mattered most.

Bullpen: LHP Mike McCormick

7 of 25

    Mike McCormick and Tim Lincecum are the only SF Giants to win a Cy Young.
    Mike McCormick and Tim Lincecum are the only SF Giants to win a Cy Young.

    He was the last Giants pitcher to win the Cy Young before Tim Lincecum did it twice.

    Mike McCormick pitched 11 seasons for the Giants but only nine of them in San Francisco. He was the San Francisco Giants winningest left-handed pitcher before Kirk Rueter passed him.

    In San Francisco, he went 104-94 with a 3.68 ERA.

    His best season, obviously, was his Cy Young year in 1967. He finished with a NL-best 22 wins and a 2.85 ERA. McCormick also threw five shutouts that season.

    It was a banner year for McCormick.

    Only twice did McCormick finish with an ERA higher than 4.00.

Bullpen: RHP Matt Cain

8 of 25

    Cain has been a consistent performer for the Giants since his call-up five years ago.
    Cain has been a consistent performer for the Giants since his call-up five years ago.Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    Young and strong. Country strong.

    Matt Cain has gotten better every year he has been in the majors. He, too, is still working on his career but he has been one of the more consistent pitchers over the past three seasons.

    His win-loss record does not tell the story.

    He has a 3.47 career ERA. With that ERA, you would think the person would have a winning record. Cain is 55-61. But, like I said, there is still lots of time to change that.

    When I look at the Giants right now, if I had to win one game, I'd put Cain on the mound.

Bullpen: RHP Rod Beck

9 of 25

    Rod Beck was the best closer in Giants history, that is, until Robb Nen arrived.
    Rod Beck was the best closer in Giants history, that is, until Robb Nen arrived.Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

    Rod Beck was the best closer in Giants history until Robb Nen showed up. But that does not take away the memories of "Shooter."

    In 1997, his three innings of work during the Brian Johnson game possibly saved the Giants season.

    He had 37 saves that season with a 3.47 ERA.

    His best with Giants was in 1993 when he set a team record with 48 saves and a 2.16 ERA. That saves record still stands today.

Bullpen: RHP Brian Wilson

10 of 25

    Few more dominant in the game right now than Brian Wilson.
    Few more dominant in the game right now than Brian Wilson.Jeff Gross/Getty Images

    Brian Wilson has very quickly become one of the more dominant closers in the game. Scary thing is he's still learning how to really pitch.

    He is just now learning how to control his pitches. Wilson is coming into his own before our eyes and the prospects look very good.

    It might be a bit premature to add him to this roster but he is one I would not doubt when the game is on the line.

    His ERA has dropped each of the last three seasons, from 4.62 to 2.74 to 1.85. Already a two-time All-Star, Wilson will be very good for a long time.

Closer: RHP Robb Nen

11 of 25

    Unfortunately, this was one of the last times we saw Robb Nen throw.
    Unfortunately, this was one of the last times we saw Robb Nen throw.Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    Deep Purple's "Smoke on the Water" blaring out of the speakers meant one thing.

    Game over.

    Robb Nen is the best closer in the team's history. He has the record for most saves by a Giant and literally gave his arm to help the team win a World Series.

    The upper-90s fastball and low-90s slider made him almost unhittable.

    He also carried a presence on the mound. Many times hitters knew what was coming but couldn't do anything about it.

    Nen's slider wasn't quite Hoffman's changeup but it was more than effective.

    He averaged just over 41 saves per season as a Giant with a 2.43 ERA.

Bench: INF Robby Thompson

12 of 25

    20 Apr 2000:  Robby Thompson #5 of San Francisco Giants coaches first base during the game against the Cincinnati Reds at Cinergy Field in Cincinnati, Ohio. The Reds defeated the Giants 11-1. Mandatory Credit: Harry How  /Allsport
    Harry How/Getty Images

    Good middle infielders are hard to come by. Especially middle infielders who help turn the franchise around.

    Robby Thompson, along with Will Clark and Matt Williams, helped the Giants fans remember the glory years. They gave them hope.

    He spent all of his 11 seasons with the Giants and would do whatever was needed.

    He was not afraid to be hit and was hit often.

    Steal a base? He could to that.

    His best season came in the 1993 season when he hit .312 with 19 home runs and 65 RBIs. His OPS that year? .870.

Bench: C Benito Sanitago

13 of 25

    Benito Santiago resurrected his career in San Francisco.
    Benito Santiago resurrected his career in San Francisco.Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    The Giants have not had any great catchers. With that said, the backup is Benito Santiago.

    Not many catchers are able to throw runners out from their knees.

    Benito can.

    There are not many catchers who have been the MVP of a league championship series.

    Benito has.

    Though his time in San Francisco was brief, he had a much-needed impact on a team that reached the World Series.

Bench: 1B Will Clark

14 of 25

    "The Thrill" made baseball relevant again in San Francisco.
    "The Thrill" made baseball relevant again in San Francisco.Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

    Will Clark is one of the biggest reasons for the Giants resurrection in the late 1980s.

    He brought energy to a team that desperately needed a kick in the you know where. In only his second season, Clark had the Giants in the playoffs.

    His 35 home runs and 91 RBIs got the Giants franchise back on track. He did have help from a few other people on this list, but the energy came from this guy.

    The Thrill had as smooth a swing as a person would ever see. His career .303 batting average is a testament to that.

Bench: OF Kevin Mitchell

15 of 25

    Brute strength = Kevin Mitchell.
    Brute strength = Kevin Mitchell.Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

    Power, speed, and a guy who will barehand a fly ball for ya'. That's Kevin Mitchell.

    In 1989, Mitchell was everything the Giants could hope for and more.

    He hit 47 home runs and drove in 125 runs. His 1.023 OPS led the league and it was good enough to get the MVP.

    The MVP of a World Series team has to be pretty good.

Bench: OF Felipe Alou

16 of 25

    Felipe Alou may not have the flash or numbers of some of the other guys on this list but he was just as crucial to the Giants' success.

    His best season was in 1962 and helped the Giants make it to the World Series. Alou posted 25 home runs and a career-high 98 RBIs.

    Alou would do anything to help the team out. Whether it was moving runners over, stealing a base, or hitting a home run, Felipe wanted to win.

Bench: UTL Orlando Cepeda

17 of 25

    "The Baby Bull" was otherworldly at the plate.
    "The Baby Bull" was otherworldly at the plate.Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    Orlando Cepeda burst onto the scene in San Francisco and lit the town of fire.

    He was the Rookie of the Year and then followed that performance by being selected to the All-Star team six straight times.

    His best season came in 1962 when he hit 46 home runs and drove in 142 runs. He led the league in both categories but somehow did not win the MVP.

    How do you put a Hall of Famer on the bench?

    He would be the type of player to give relief to anybody who needed it. Much like the way the Giants currently use Juan Uribe.

    He is always in the game but at a different position. Orlando's versatility plays to that.

Leading Off: SS Rich Aurilia

18 of 25

    Rich Aurilia is the best offensive option at the position the team has ever had.
    Rich Aurilia is the best offensive option at the position the team has ever had.Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    San Francisco has not seen a more offensively gifted shortstop than Rich Aurilia.

    Between 1999 and 2003, Aurilia averaged 21.4 home runs and 75 RBIs. This earned him a spot on the 2001 All-Star team.

    He always hit the ball hard and even harder whenever a pitcher threw the ball up and in.

    When the ball came up and in, he would glare back at the pitcher as if to say, "The next pitch you throw, I am hitting through the fence."

    Yes, I said through the fence.

    Many times he would absolutely pound the ball after that.

    The most offensively consistent shortstop the Giants have ever had.

Batting Second: LF Barry Bonds

19 of 25

    Barry Bonds is the greatest hitter of his generation.
    Barry Bonds is the greatest hitter of his generation.Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    PEDs aside, Barry Bonds is the greatest player of this generation.

    Eight Gold Gloves.

    Single-season and all-time home run king.

    Seven MVP awards. 11 Silver Sluggers.

    762 home runs, over 500 stolen bases. The only member of the 400-400 and 500-500 club.

    And the list goes on.

    Bonds was more feared by opposing pitchers and managers than anybody in baseball history. Never before had I seen a single player change another player's career so significantly. Without Bonds, I do not think Giants fans have the conversation about Jeff Kent and his place in history.

Batting Third: CF Willie Mays

20 of 25

    Years later, Willie Mays still deemed one of the best five players of all-time.
    Years later, Willie Mays still deemed one of the best five players of all-time.Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

    The greatest five-tool player in history.

    A dynamic center fielder, perennial All-Star, and a game changer.

    He could hit a home run, give your team the lead. He might steal a base to get in scoring position. Or he would make an amazing catch and then throw out the runner trying to advance.

    That is who Willie Mays was.

    660 home runs, over 3,000 hits, more than 300 stolen bases. 24 All-Star appearances.

    The Giants had many players who had a great combination of speed and power but none greater than Mays.

Batting Fourth: 1B Willie McCovey

21 of 25

    This man was the most feared player in baseball history until Barry Bonds stepped onto the field.

    When people heard the sound of the ball come off of Willie Mac's bat, they ducked and feared for their life. He hit the ball that hard.

    He caused the loudest out in World Series history. His liner to end the 1962 World Series is still talked about.

    521 home runs and 1555 RBIs between San Francisco and San Diego.

Batting Fifth: 2B Jeff Kent

22 of 25

    The most prolific hitter at his position: Jeff Kent.
    The most prolific hitter at his position: Jeff Kent.Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    Second basemen shouldn't hit like this. There hadn't been a offensive threat at this position like Kent since Joe Morgan.

    His hard-nosed and standoffish approach did rub some people the wrong way but you could never argue with the results.

    In his six seasons with the Giants, he totaled six seasons of 100 or more RBIs, three seasons of 30 or more home runs, won a MVP, and became the greatest hitting second baseman of all time.

    He was the model of consistency in San Francisco and will drive in runs behind Willie Mac.

Batting Sixth: 3B Matt Williams

23 of 25

    Fan favorite who was smooth at the plate and with the glove.
    Fan favorite who was smooth at the plate and with the glove.

    The guy the Giants traded for Jeff Kent is in the six-hole.

    When Matt Williams was good, there was not a better hitter in the majors. Most fans think about what could have been in the 1994 season when the strike cut Williams's season short.

    He had 43 home runs and was on pace to catch Roger Maris.

    His glove was just as smooth. He collected four Gold Gloves over his 17-year career.

    He helped the Giants reach the postseason twice and win 103 games in 1993.

    378 HR and 1,218 RBIs. Pretty good.

Batting Seventh: RF Bobby Bonds

24 of 25

    SAN DIEGO, CA - MAY 4, 1995:  (FILE PHOTO)  Coach Bobby Bonds of the San Francisco Giants gives instructions to his players during a game against the San Diego Padres at Jack Murphy Stadium May 4, 1995 in San Diego, California.  The Giants won the game 5-
    Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

    Versatile, fast, powerful. All these words could describe Bobby Bonds.

    He is one of only four players in the 300 HR, 300 SB club. Two of the others are in this lineup.

    Bonds hit 30 or more home runs six times and had 30 or more stolen bases 10 times.

    Arguably, his best season as a Giant was the 1973 season when he had 39 home runs, 96 RBIs, and 43 stolen bases. He came in third in the MVP voting and won a Gold Glove.

    The only downside to Bonds were his strikeout numbers. He averaged over 150 strikeouts per season.

Batting Eighth: C Bob Brenly

25 of 25

    Once again, the Giants have never had a great catcher. But no catcher in Giants history was as good for as long as Bob Brenly.

    If he had played all 162 games in a season, his average numbers would have been 17 home runs and 62 RBIs. From the catcher, I'd take that.

    He also handled pitching staffs that included the likes of Mike Krukow, Atlee Hammaker, and Dave Dravecky.

    Handle the staff and have some pop with the bat. That's what your catcher should do and Brenly did just that.