It had everything in the latter innings: great defensive plays, big hits (although not enough), and some stellar clutch pitching by the greatest relief pitcher in baseball history, Mariano Rivera.
With the Boston Red Sox blowing a lead in Colorado and Tampa Bay's starting pitching continuing to crumble, the Yankees had an opportunity to pick up another full game on both their closest division rivals.
At this point, they were playing with house money.
A nice eighth inning rally scored the tying run on Alex Rodriguez' sacrifice fly. And it all happened without the benefit hit, the Yankees' second such inning of the game.
Simultaneously, the game was utopia and a virtual disaster for the sabermetric crowd. The Yankees "didn't make outs" on 23 of their 47 plate appearances, generating 13 walks and ten hits plus A-rod's sac fly.
But while their on-base percentage was about .500 for the evening, they were terrible in getting hits with runners in scoring position. Robinson Cano, their best hitter this year, had multiple opportunities to drive in runs, but he could not do the job. They hit into five double plays. It happens.
But it shows the RBI stat can be a big deal and is very important.
Joe Girardi saw an opportunity to steal a game in the standings and went for it. Again, he was playing with house money. What helped was that the Yankees have an off-day on Thursday, and Rivera would have an extra day to rest.
The manager brought Rivera into a tie game, something he rarely does. Not bringing in Rivera in a tie game earlier this season at Toronto cost the Yankees a chance at winning another contest.
(Isn't the image above this piece priceless? It is from last night's game, and it shows Girardi leaving the mound basically saying, "I've done my job, no need to say anything else. You do your job and go get 'em, Mo.")
Instead of Rivera in the 14th inning of that game, Girardi used Chad Gaudin (who stinks) and the waiver wire pick-up only needed nine pitches to lose that game.
But Girardi used his biggest bullpen chip at Arizona, and Rivera used his Houdini escape tricks to help seal another Yankee win.
And now they have a 2.5-game lead on both Boston and Tampa Bay.
OTHER THOUGHTS ON LAST NIGHT'S GAME
While Girardi did make a good move by having Rivera in the tie game, he did (and almost did) make some head-scratchers.
1) Why did Girardi pinch-run for Nick Swisher in the ninth inning? Is Kevin Russo that much of a burner that he is significantly faster than the Yankee right fielder? And why put in Chad Huffman to play right field, essentially burning three guys on one play?
Girardi might have been better off sticking with Swisher (since he was not the tying run) and keeping the extra position players. Remember that the Yankees had already used Colin Curtis (a great kid by the way) earlier to hit for Javier Vazquez.
The game might have gone into further innings, but....
2) The Yankees didn't seem like they wanted more extra innings. That is the reason they went for broke and brought the infield in with the bases loaded and no outs in the bottom of the 10th.
The normal move would be to play the infield back for the double play, give up the tying run and then try and get out of the inning with the next batter.
By using almost his entire bullpen during Monday and Tuesday night's games and burning Damaso Marte, David Robertson, Joba Chamberlain, and now Mo in the current game, Girardi likely wanted to win the game there in the 10th or lose it there in the 10th.
He did not want an 11th inning.
3) I would have blown a gasket if Girardi brought in Boone Logan (who was warming up) in for Rivera in the last of the 10th inning. You don't need to pinch-hit for Mo in that spot already up a run.
I would rather go into the bottom of the 10th with a one-run lead and Rivera on the mound than try to extend the lead with a pinch-hitter and put Logan on the mound.
4) But if you are going to use a pinch-hitter, why use Ramiro Pena? He is your last position player, and you have no one else to back up Francisco Cervelli in case he gets hurt.
Remember that Girardi had used Jorge Posada to pinch-hit in the eighth inning.
That is why burning up all your players for unnecessary pinch-running stunts causes you to lose your bench quickly.
And that is why I always like to have only 11 pitchers at the most and more position players, especially when playing in National League parks.
But if you are going to use a pinch hitter for Rivera (now batting in the No. 2 spot), why not use C.C. Sabathia?
He loves hitting, is pretty good at it, and you don't use your last bench player IN CASE the game goes longer than the 10th inning.
Sabathia is actually a better hitter than Ramiro Pena, anyway.
But as I said earlier, Girardi was playing with house money, as Boston and Tampa already lost, and he was going to win the game in the 10th or lose it there.
He did win it by making his best move of the night (and maybe the season) by bringing in Mariano Rivera to pitch the bottom of the ninth inning in a tie game.