NFL
HomeScoresDraftRumorsFantasyB/R 99: Top QBs of All Time
Featured Video
Most Interesting QB Rooms 🤔

NFL Draft Busts vs. Steals From WhatIfSports.com

Jake WestrichApr 19, 2010

One of my favorite reads as a child was the, "Choose Your Own Adventure," series. As your mind became entangled in the mystery, it was up to you, the reader, as to determine what happened next.

Jump ahead to page 67 and it's doom and gloom, but jump ahead to page 58 and you are the hero of the day.

When it comes to choosing your own adventure in the what-if world of sports, the NFL Draft is Exhibit A, B and C.

TOP NEWS

2027 NFL Mock Draft 🔮

Colts Jaguars Football

Colts Release Kenny Moore

Rams Seahawks Football

Projecting Every NFL Team's Starting Lineup 🔮

General managers and directors of player personnel write their own narrative with every selection, trade and multi-million dollar signing.

What-if's Exhibit A

San Diego selected Ryan Leaf Second overall in '98

Think about the San Diego Chargers and how they came to acquire one of the biggest busts in NFL Draft history.

Sure, everybody knows the name Ryan Leaf , but it's what the Bolts gave up to sign him. Their front office skipped ahead to page 67 and forgot to keep their finger on the previous page as a placeholder.

They traded up to pick him at two after Peyton Manning was selected first overall. The Colts' management, on the flip side, flipped to page 58.

Each year in late April, NFL fans become the Siskel and Ebert of their passion for a weekend.

The thumbs up, thumbs down critique of their favorite teams' recruitment embodies a storyline all itself. One that continues to second-guess itself. The what-if draft picks of the past 30 years have evolved into a cyber-world unknown adventure.

The internet is littered with dozens of lists rattling off the biggest NFL Draft day busts. Further down the page you will find lists of late round steals that allow those same general managers and scouts to snicker with internal satisfaction.

Did they know something, the other teams didn't? Probably not, considering everybody and their mom skipped over Tom Brady until the sixth round of the 2000 draft. How many of those front office wizards thought Brady would end up like Leaf or worse? Instead, it's page 58 for the Patriots.

It would be too easy to create Whatifsports.com's own list of NFL Drafts busts and steals, so we are taking it to the next level and giving YOU the opportunity to create you own NFL Draft Day Dream Team Roster .

NFL Draft Steals93.835.2Boxscore
NFL First Round Busts6.217.2Simulate Game

We loaded up our rosters full of First Round Busts and Late Round Steals to get the creative juices flowing.

Whatifsports.com drafted the players based on their best season in the NFL. We had to dig deep, but did manage to find Tim Couch 's "best season" with the Browns.

It's not so much the results of the 1001 Draft pick simulations I want you to pay attention to, but to check out the names on the rosters.

If you want to simulate the two teams yourself, click on the Simulate Game option in the table. You will have the opportunity to set your own depth chart. So, if you want to avoid the Draft steal Tom Brady and start Bart Starr , you have the power. If you want Leaf to hold a clipboard while Akili Smith takes the snaps, you have that option.

Whatifsports.com's NFL Draft rosters are not set in stone. You can create you own with the Dream Team feature for FREE .

Make sure to continue the conversation in our newly created 2010 NFL Draft Forum . In the forum you can brag and/or blast your favorite NFL team's past and present NFL Draft selections.

What page will you land on?

Most Interesting QB Rooms 🤔

TOP NEWS

2027 NFL Mock Draft 🔮

Colts Jaguars Football

Colts Release Kenny Moore

Rams Seahawks Football

Projecting Every NFL Team's Starting Lineup 🔮

Mississippi Football

Rookie WRs Who Will Outplay Their Draft Value 📈

Packers Bears Football

Ranking 1st-Time MVP Contenders 🏆

New 2026 NBA Mock Draft 🔮
Bleacher Report2w

New 2026 NBA Mock Draft 🔮

Projecting who Charlotte would select with a top pick 📲

TRENDING ON B/R