Twitter Erupts over Scouting Reports, Shows Downside of Longer NFL Draft Process

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Twitter Erupts over Scouting Reports, Shows Downside of Longer NFL Draft Process
Charles Krupa/Associated Press

Thanks to a scheduling conflict at Radio City Music Hall in New York City, the 2014 NFL draft begins on May 8, a full two weeks later than usual.

It's created a dilemma for NFL scouts and teams, so much so that some teams have given scouts time off for fear that they will "over-analyze" prospects.

Well, draftniks are taking no such vacation, and as writers and pundits far and wide scrutinize prospects to the point of five steps past nitpicking, "silly season" has hit a new high (or low, depending on how you look at it).

And it appears the Twitterverse has just about had it.

The latest scout to draw the ire of social media is no stranger to controversy. This time, NFL.com's Nolan Nawrocki has come under fire for his scouting reports on a number of players, including Minnesota defensive tackle Ra'Shede Hageman:

It's that first sentence that's getting Nawrocki in trouble, and as Bleacher Report NFL National Lead Writer Mike Freeman pointed out, Hageman's profile wasn't the only one that started out that way:

OK. They have kids. So do quite a few people. Parents too. Brothers and/or sisters. An alcoholic cousin who always figures out where the family reunion is despite no one telling him.

Ryan Burns pointed out the contrast in the profile introductions for those players and Fresno State quarterback Derek Carr:

However, Nawrocki saved his best hatchet-job for former Oregon tight end Colt Lyerla, who admittedly has more red flags than a Beijing souvenir shop:

Grew up poor in an unstable environment. Parents divorced when he was 9. Mother was on disability and unable to provide adequate structure, discipline and guidance, oftentimes relying on coaches to keep Colt in line, according to a September 2012 article in the Oregonian. Father moved to Hawaii during Colt's high school years and missed all his games from his sophomore year on. Consequently, Colt skipped stretches of class and was absent for meetings and practices, incurring suspension.

That's the first paragraph, and it did not go unnoticed:

At this point, it's worth noting that Nawrocki was the pundit who wrote this of Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel:

Has not developed a reputation as a worker or for doing the extras. Suspect intangibles -- not a leader by example or known to inspire by his words. Carries a sense of entitlement and prima-donna arrogance seeking out the bright lights of Hollywood.

As Bleacher Report's Michael Schottey pointed out last year after Nawrocki savaged quarterback Geno Smith, this is an old song:

It got Nawrocki blasted by Bleacher Report NFL National Lead Writer Matt Miller then:

And this year's nonsense is getting Nawrocki blasted now:

However, it's not only scouts who live under bridges and terrorize billy goats who seem to have developed a case of the vapors as the draft nears.

Even ESPN's Mel Kiper, one of the most respected draftniks in the business (Don Draftnik, "The Godfather," if you will), isn't immune to the yips.

In Kiper's latest mock draft (subscription required), the coiffed one has Texas A&M tackle Jake Matthews as the third player at his position selected in the first round of May's draft, behind Auburn's Greg Robinson and Michigan's Taylor Lewan.

Kiper touted Lewan's "mean streak:"

Well, given the penalties and assault charges, it's hard to argue that.

Mind you, this isn't to say that Lewan isn't a first-round pick. But, until recently Matthews and Robinson were the near-universal top two at offensive tackle in this year's draft.

Miller warned that if Lewan does leapfrog Matthews, fans at this year's Bleacher Report live coverage of the NFL draft might want to keep their heads on a swivel:

And never mind poor Teddy Bridgewater:

There hasn't been a prospect take more of a beating for less of a reason over the past month than the Louisville quarterback. Once considered the favorite to be drafted first overall, many pundits are now predicting that Bridgewater will drop out of the first round altogether:

Why? One bad pro day.

After struggling during his workout at Louisville, Bridgewater has been picked apart in recent weeks by scouts who appear to have suddenly realized Bridgewater isn't as good as they thought he was just a few weeks ago.

His hands are too small. His frame is too slight. His arm isn't strong enough.

Oh, and he doesn't have the right "face," either:

The bash-fest on Bridgewater, much like Nawrocki's comments, have been met with a healthy dose of sarcasm in some parts of the Twitterverse.

Even more sarcasm from Bleacher Report AFC West Lead Writer Christopher Hansen:

And just flat-out incredulity from Bleacher Report's Aaron Nagler:

None of this is to say that character concerns aren't a concern for NFL teams. Of course they are.

Should the NFL draft be moved back to the last weekend in April?

Submit Vote vote to see results

However, having a kid or growing up poor aren't character concerns any more than "prima-donna arrogance seeking out the bright lights of Hollywood" is legitimate analysis and not trollish hyperbole.

Also, changing your mind on a prospect is fine. Changing it after one poor workout? Getting shakier. Changing it for no other reason than to change it? Well that's just silly.

Now, this may all be much ado about nothing, as the draft very rarely unfolds like we think it will. And in an age where fans of the NFL devour information at an incredible pace there's more pressure on sports writers and bloggers than ever to keep that info coming.

Unfortunately, the extra two weeks of info we're getting this year shows that in some cases, more is most certainly not better.

Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go research how good Blake Bortles is at Candy Crush.

Because that's important.

Load More Stories

Follow B/R on Facebook

Out of Bounds

NFL Draft

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.