50 Biggest Fantasy Football Disappointments of the First Quarter of the Season

Wes StueveContributor IIIOctober 5, 2012

50 Biggest Fantasy Football Disappointments of the First Quarter of the Season

0 of 50

    Every year in the NFL, a few guys come up way short of expectations. This affects the actual NFL teams, of course, but it kills our fantasy football teams.

    Often, this disappointing production isn't necessarily the player's fault, but in fantasy football, no one cares. For whatever reason, be it injury, team talent or a player's own struggles, he fails to put up the expected numbers.

    These are the guys every fantasy owner hates to have, and we've all had them. Who are 2012's disappointing fantasy football players? Read on to find out.

50. Matthew Stafford, QB, Detroit Lions

1 of 50

    Frequently one of the top quarterbacks taken in fantasy football, Matthew Stafford has disappointed thus far.

    His play has taken a clear step back from 2011, and it's showing in his fantasy points. Many quarterbacks have outperformed Stafford.

49. Kenny Britt, WR, Tennessee Titans

2 of 50

    Thus far, Kenny Britt has just 60 receiving yards. He has struggled with injuries and hasn't impressed when on the field.

    At this point, Britt seems unlikely to contribute much throughout the entire season.

48. Greg Little, WR, Cleveland Browns

3 of 50

    Through four weeks, Greg Little has just 11 receptions for 151 yards. Little wasn't exactly expected to dominate, but many had expectations of a solid season.

    Right now, Little is showing no signs of making that happen.

47. Marques Colston, WR, New Orleans Saints

4 of 50

    Marques Colston's 313 yards aren't terrible, but he has just one touchdown and 19 receptions. That's a well-below-average pace for Colston.

46. Roy Helu, RB, Washington Redskins

5 of 50

    In three games, Roy Helu had just two carries. Helu is now out for the season, so he won't be turning it around in 2012.

    The Redskins running back situation was always complicated, but Helu didn't come close to meeting expectations.

45. Coby Fleener, TE, Indianapolis Colts

6 of 50

    Many expected Andrew Luck to lean on Coby Fleener early, but Fleener hasn't done much thus far.

    In fact, Fleener has barely impacted Indianapolis' offense at all, gaining just 98 yards through three games. 

44. Pierre Thomas, RB, New Orleans Saints

7 of 50

    A healthy Pierre Thomas was expected to put up decent production as New Orleans' starting running back.

    However, Thomas hasn't touched the ball all that often and has made virtually zero fantasy impact. 

43. David Wilson, RB, New York Giants

8 of 50

    Many were excited about the explosive upside of rookie David Wilson, especially with Ahmad Bradshaw battling injuries.

    However, Wilson has carried the ball just six times, fumbling once. No one expected huge production, but Wilson has failed to meet even the modest expectations set for him.

42. Pierre Garcon, WR, Washington Redskins

9 of 50

    Having played in just two games due to injury, Pierre Garcon has failed to make a fantasy impact.

    He still could as the year goes on, but Garcon's first four games were certainly disappointing. 

41. Stevie Johnson, WR, Buffalo Bills

10 of 50

    Through four games, Stevie Johnson has just 195 receiving yards on 15 receptions.

    Ryan Fitzpatrick certainly has hindered Johnson's production, but he was expected to put up better stats than this.

40. Dustin Keller, TE, New York Jets

11 of 50

    A starting fantasy football tight end for many, Dustin Keller has recorded just one catch in 2012.

    He has missed time due to injury, but that doesn't make his lack of production any less disappointing.

39. Justin Blackmon, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars

12 of 50

    Few expected Justin Blackmon to be a fantasy star in his rookie year, but his 10 catches for 79 yards have disappointed even his biggest skeptics.

    It's looking like Blackmon simply isn't playable in his first NFL season.

38. LeGarrette Blount, RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

13 of 50

    Even with Doug Martin starting, LeGarrette Blount was expected to get some carries, especially in the red zone.

    However, Blount has gained just 44 yards on 13 carries, showing his lack of fantasy value. 

37. Peyton Hillis, RB, Kansas City Chiefs

14 of 50

    With Jamaal Charles coming off a torn ACL, many expected Peyton Hillis would steal some carries. That hasn't happened yet, and Hillis probably isn't even worth a roster spot.

    The former Brown isn't getting enough touches, and he is already dealing with injury issues himself.

36. Jon Baldwin, WR, Kansas City Chiefs

15 of 50

    Some, including myself, were expecting a breakout year from Jon Baldwin. Through four games, though, Baldwin has just 148 yards.

    The Chiefs' poor quarterback play hasn't helped, but Baldwin simply isn't there yet. 

35. Cam Newton, QB, Carolina Panthers

16 of 50

    Though he hasn't been bad per se, Cam Newton has still disappointed some.

    Many expected Newton to actually improve upon his incredible rookie campaign, but his numbers have taken a slight step back. Newton isn't the top fantasy performer we hoped he would be. 

34. Adrian Peterson, RB, Minnesota Vikings

17 of 50

    As soon as it was known Adrian Peterson would start the season, he was met with huge expectations.

    Peterson hasn't been bad, either, but he hasn't been great. There is definite room for improvement.

33. Rob Gronkowski, TE, New England Patriots

18 of 50

    Rob Gronkowski's 2012 stats aren't even comparable to his 2011 numbers. It's still early, but as of now, Gronkowski isn't catching as many passes for as many yards or as many touchdowns.

    In other words, he's taken a step back in every area. 

32. Beanie Wells, RB, Arizona Cardinals

19 of 50

    Prior to suffering a turf toe injury, Beanie Wells had just 76 yards through three games.

    No one should have expected great things from Wells, but there was the potential to repeat his 2011 numbers (1,047 yards, 10 TDs). Wells showed no signs of coming close to that.

31. Denarius Moore, WR, Oakland Raiders

20 of 50

    Denarius Moore was expected to bust out as Oakland's No. 1 wideout, but his 12 catches and 183 yards are far from No. 1 production.

    Moore has battled injuries, but his performance still fails to match the hype.

30. Jay Cutler, QB, Chicago Bears

21 of 50

    There were some expecting a great fantasy football season from Jay Cutler, but his early results have been downright terrible.

    Cutler is throwing interceptions at his usual rate, and his touchdowns are down. He's simply been unplayable.

29. Trent Richardson, RB, Cleveland Browns

22 of 50

    Trent Richardson has looked great, but the anemic Cleveland offense has killed his production. He simply has no holes to run through.

    Some may have drafted Richardson in the first round, and he hasn't justified that.

28. Jimmy Graham, TE, New Orleans Saints

23 of 50

    Expected to put up wide receiver-type production, Jimmy Graham has struggled some.

    He has failed to take over games and isn't producing at an elite level. Given his draft status, Graham is coming up way short. 

27. Michael Vick, QB, Philadelphia Eagles

24 of 50

    Michael Vick has been better in fantasy football than in real life, but he has still disappointed.

    Predicted to have a rebound year, Vick has struggled with interceptions while not making as many game-breaking plays as usual. 

26. Wes Welker, WR, New England Patriots

25 of 50

    Wes Welker is still racking up yards, but his catches are way down. With just 25 catches through four weeks, Welker isn't on pace for another 120-catch season.

    More important, Welker has yet to haul in a single touchdown as well. 

25. Rashad Jennings, RB, Jacksonville Jaguars

26 of 50

    Before Maurice Jones-Drew ended his holdout, Rashad Jennings was expected to have a big year.

    Even after Jones-Drew returned, though, many thought the two would split carries. This hasn't happened, and Jennings has been useless in fantasy.

24. Fred Davis, TE, Washington Redskins

27 of 50

    In 2011, Fred Davis was excellent despite playing in just 12 games. Thus far in 2012, though, Davis has struggled to meet expectations. He has caught just 15 passes and scored no touchdowns. 

23. Jordy Nelson, WR, Green Bay Packers

28 of 50

    Jordy Nelson's 21 catches for 260 yards have certainly come up short of 2011's standards. Nelson's 2011 campaign seemed like a bit of a fluke, but he's still off to a slow start.

    Many drafted Nelson hoping for a repeat season, and that hasn't happened.

22. Jermichael Finley, TE, Green Bay Packers

29 of 50

    Jermichael Finley disappointed last year, but many predicted a breakout 2012. Finley's 187 yards is far from impressive, though. Tight ends drafted later have outperformed the Green Bay star.

21. Doug Martin, RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

30 of 50

    Doug Martin has received nearly all of Tampa Bay's carries, but his overall numbers are still lacking (247 yards, one touchdown).

    A popular Rookie of the Year pick, Martin hasn't produced much, letting down many fantasy owners in the process. 

20. Hakeem Nicks, WR, New York Giants

31 of 50

    When on the field, Hakeem Nicks has played quite well. However, a knee injury has sidelined him, and injuries are an all too real part of fantasy football, as any Nicks owner can attest to.

19. Ryan Mathews, RB, San Diego Chargers

32 of 50

    We knew Ryan Mathews would likely miss the first couple of games to injury, but his play since returning has fallen well short of expectations for the former first-rounder.

    Mathews has just 105 yards and no touchdowns through two games.

18. Andre Johnson, WR, Houston Texans

33 of 50

    When healthy, Andre Johnson is undoubtedly an elite wideout. It hasn't shown in numbers yet, though, as Johnson has picked up just 268 yards and 16 catches through four weeks.

    We all know Johnson is capable of much more. 

17. DeMarco Murray, RB, Dallas Cowboys

34 of 50

    A popular somewhat-sleeper pick, DeMarco Murray has averaged just under 60 yards a game through four weeks.

    Murray was expected to be a focal point of Dallas' offense, and that simply hasn't happened. The former Oklahoma Sooners star has failed to live up to the hype thus far.

16. Julio Jones, WR, Atlanta Falcons

35 of 50

    Prior to the 2012 season, the world was abuzz with Julio Jones hype, many ranking him above stars such as A.J. Green.

    Four weeks and 219 yards later, those projections are looking a bit silly. Jones hasn't been terrible, but he's far from the sky-high preseason expectations.

15. Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Arizona Cardinals

36 of 50

    Larry Fitzgerald was once again ranked as one of the top wideouts in the league heading into the season.

    Through four weeks, though, Fitzgerald has 12 catches for 245 yards. That's not bad, but it isn't exactly Fitzgerald-type production either.

14. Jonathan Stewart, RB, Carolina Panthers

37 of 50

    Injuries have sidetracked Jonathan Stewart's 2012 season somewhat, and he has picked up just 91 yards through the quarter mark of the season.

    We knew Stewart would split carries, but this is still much worse than projected. Owners of both Stewart and DeAngelo Williams have been disappointed early.

13. Dez Bryant, WR, Dallas Cowboys

38 of 50

    Dez Bryant is incredibly talented, but he hasn't yet broken out. Some thought this would be his year, but this hasn't happened through four weeks.

    Owners who took a chance on Bryant early have no doubt been left with a sour taste in their mouths. 

12. Aaron Rodgers, QB, Green Bay Packers

39 of 50

    The top-drafted quarterback, Aaron Rodgers has produced but not at a level worthy of his draft status. In fact, many late-round quarterbacks have outproduced Rodgers through four weeks.

    The Packers' star signal-caller simply hasn't thrown many touchdowns (seven) or picked up a ton of yards (1064). 

11. Aaron Hernandez, TE, New England Patriots

40 of 50

    An ankle injury sidelined Aaron Hernandez for two weeks, but his six catches for 59 yards are disappointing nonetheless.

    A versatile player, Hernandez hasn't picked up enough catches or yards to be nearly worthy of his draft status.

10. Antonio Gates, TE, San Diego Chargers

41 of 50

    Entering 2012, fantasy football owners were hoping for the old, healthy Antonio Gates. Instead, they've gotten the new, injured Gates.

    Gates' 124 yards are downright bad, and he hasn't been close to a starting tight end thus far.

9. Ahmad Bradshaw, RB, New York Giants

42 of 50

    Through four weeks, Ahmad Bradshaw has just 133 yards. No one really expected great things from Bradshaw, but he was thought to be a capable starter.

    So far, that simply hasn't been the case, and Bradshaw should be on your bench.

8. Jeremy Maclin, WR, Philadelphia Eagles

43 of 50

    He hasn't yet had a 1,000-yard season, but Jeremy Maclin was a highly sought after wide receiver in fantasy drafts.

    Dealing with some injuries, though, Maclin has put up just nine catches for 126 yards. That is horribly disappointing for someone some analysts thought might be a No. 1 wideout in 2012.

7. Greg Jennings, WR, Green Bay Packers

44 of 50

    Dealing with a pesky groin injury, Greg Jennings has picked up just 12 catches for 78 yards. That is horrific for someone considered one of fantasy football's safest wide receivers.

    Jennings, like many Packers, hasn't met expectations. 

6. Steven Jackson, RB, St. Louis Rams

45 of 50

    Through four weeks, Steven Jackson had just 195 yards on the ground. And no touchdowns. Jackson has been incredibly consistent through the years, but his 2012 season has been downright bad.

    He isn't putting up points for anybody. 

5. Fred Jackson, RB, Buffalo Bills

46 of 50

    Fred Jackson, a 2011 fantasy football star prior to his injury, has produced almost nothing in 2012. Jackson's 44 rushing yards are virtually negligible, though injury has sidelined him.

    Jackson wasn't usually a first-round pick, but he was expected to still be quite good.

4. LeSean McCoy, RB, Philadelphia Eagles

47 of 50

    One of fantasy football's top overall picks, LeSean McCoy has been gaining yards, just not scoring touchdowns.

    In 2011, McCoy crossed the goal line 20 times. He's done it just once in 2012. No running back with so few touchdowns will add much fantasy value.

3. Darren McFadden, RB, Oakland Raiders

48 of 50

    Another highly-drafted player, Darren McFadden has just 201 rushing yards and a single touchdown.

    This distinct lack of production has no doubt cost many owners otherwise-winnable games. McFadden hasn't been hurt either, just unproductive. 

2. Matt Forte, RB, Chicago Bears

49 of 50

    Highly drafted because of his running and receiving ability, Matt Forte has produced little fantasy value.

    His 163 rushing yards and one touchdown make that quite clear. Forte has been outproduced by running backs across the league who were available much later in fantasy drafts.

1. Chris Johnson, RB, Tennessee Titans

50 of 50

    Who else? Chris Johnson has been distinctively unproductive, which goes hand in hand with his poor play. Johnson has ran for just 186 yards and hasn't entered the end zone a single time.

    A frequent top pick, Johnson could hardly have lived up to his draft status any less.