Fantasy Football Start 'Em or Sit 'Em: Week 4: Vick, Colston, Leshoure & More

Eric StashinSenior Writer INovember 4, 2016

LANDOVER, MD - SEPTEMBER 23:  Andy Dalton #14 of the Cincinnati Bengals throws a pass against the Washington Redskins during a game at FedExField on September 23, 2012 in Landover, Maryland.  (Photo by Patrick McDermott/Getty Images)
Patrick McDermott/Getty Images

Trying to decide who you should start or sit this week? Let’s take a look at a few potential decisions owners have and try to sort through them:




Andy Dalton—Cincinnati Bengals—at Jacksonville 

It is the second consecutive week that Dalton finds himself on the start list.  That’s what happens when you have thrown for 867 yards, six TDs and three INTs over the first three weeks of the season and face a Jaguars defense that is in the bottom half of the league in passing yards allowed (258.0 passing yards/game).  He has thrown for three TDs in each of the past two games, and with A.J. Green and Andrew Hawkins in place, there is no reason to think that he can’t continue to thrive.



Michael Vick—Philadelphia Eagles—vs. New York Giants

He is taking a beating and turning the ball over, which really doesn’t bode well when you are getting set to take on arguably the best defensive front in the NFL. Eagles quarterbacks have already been sacked nine times, while Vick has thrown six interceptions and fumbled the ball five times (losing three of them).

It wouldn’t be surprising to see the team attempt to go more run oriented to try to limit the damage he causes and give him a better opportunity. However, by doing that they also are limiting his potential value.


Running Backs


Cedric Benson —Green Bay Packers—vs. New Orleans

While both teams have a lot to play for, the Packers do appear to be in a better position after the way they lost on Monday night. While the passing attack is generally the focus, you have to think that they will look to exploit a Saints rushing defense that has allowed a staggering 215 yards per game over the first three weeks. While Benson has been up and down this season, the matchup is way too appealing to have him on your bench.


BenJarvus Green-Ellis—Cincinnati Bengals—at Jacksonville

The Jaguars have been a poor rushing defense, allowing 154.3 yards per game. Granted, the Bengals can easily feature more of a passing attack (led by Andy Dalton and A.J. Green), but you have to think that Green-Ellis is going to get a chance against a poor defense. He has scored in two of the first three weeks, so at the very least you have to think he can rush for 50-plus yards and a score. That alone makes him a good option, but the potential is there for a much bigger day than that.


Mikel Leshoure—Detroit Lions—vs. Minnesota

He clearly appeared to be the feature back in Week 3, with Kevin Smith completely falling off the radar. There is a little risk here because the team’s plans are not completely known, but it wouldn’t be a surprise to see Leshoure featured heavily, especially with Matthew Stafford a bit banged up.



Ahmad Bradshaw—New York Giants—at Philadelphia

Will he be the featured back? The emergence of Andre Brown certainly casts some doubt on that question. At the very least you have to think that the duo is going to share carries in order to keep Bradshaw healthy. As part of an offense that is dynamic in throwing the football, that puts Bradshaw at too much of a risk to trust


Chris Johnson—Tennessee Titans—at Houston

Everyone’s favorite whipping boy at this point, Johnson has frustrated owners like no other. As a FLEX option, I am not about to say that I wouldn’t consider him. But with the way he has struggled and taking on a Houston defense that is allowing 67.7 rushing yards per game (and have yet to allow a rushing touchdown), I would definitely go with a safer option.


Wide Receivers (Two-Receiver Formats)


Stevie Johnson—Buffalo Bills—vs. New England

With the ground game in question, the Bills draw a Patriots defense that s allowing 262 passing yards per game, putting them in the bottom 10 of the league. As it is, Johnson has scored in all three games this season and has a TD in three of his past four meetings with the Patriots.



Marques Colston—New Orleans Saints—at Green Bay

The foot injury is clearly a problem, as he has managed just 10 catches for 160 yards. Yes, there is potential, but the Saints also have numerous other options to depend on. While I wouldn’t ignore him in deeper formats, there is a bit too much risk involved in shallower ones.


Wide Receivers (Three-Receiver Formats)


Denarius Moore—Oakland Raiders—at Denver

With Darrius Heyward-Bey out and the chance that Brandon Myers is forced to miss the game as well, this could easily be the week for Moore to shine. I mean, Oakland has to throw the ball somewhere, right? The Broncos have allowed eight passing touchdowns, so the matchup is right there to go along with opportunity.



Justin Blackmon—Jacksonville Jaguars—vs. Cincinnati

We all know the potential, but until he actually shows us something, it is impossible to trust him. Just keep him stashed for now.


Make sure to check out the rest of our Week 4 rankings: