Stop Expecting Derrick Rose to Be Something He Never Was

Dan Favale@@danfavaleFeatured ColumnistJuly 20, 2016

NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 24:  Derrick Rose is introduced at a press conference as the newest member of the New York Knicks on June 24, 2016 in New York, NY. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and/or using this Photograph, user is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. Mandatory Copyright Notice: Copyright 2016 NBAE (Photo by Nathaniel S. Butler/NBAE via Getty Images)
Nathaniel S. Butler/Getty Images

For Derrick Rose, the 2016-17 NBA season is a chance to start over. New city. New uniform. New teammates. 

For the rest of us, his move from the Chicago Bulls to the New York Knicks is a long-overdue wake-up call—the ultimate reminder that Rose needs this clean slate. 

We assume the ACL tear in his left knee during the 2012 postseason derailed an all-time career trajectory. We rationalize the 27-year-old's future and place in the league by assuring ourselves he can be a quality point guard, maybe the outline of superstar, because of what he accomplished in 2010-11, as a 22-year-old. 

Three knee surgeries and countless injuries later, the "youngest MVP in NBA history" distinction Rose once wore like a crown has, in essence, become a multiyear millstone. Even with all that's changed, he is still linked to notoriety from his past—and bound to an unfair vision of his future.


The Real MVP?

Video Play Button
Videos you might like

MIAMI, FL - MAY 22:  LeBron James (R) #6 of the Miami Heat looks on as Derrick Rose #1 of the Chicago Bulls stands in the foregrouns in Game Three of the Eastern Conference Finals during the 2011 NBA Playoffs on May 22, 2011 at American Airlines Arena in
Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

“I think I’ve been snubbed a year or two,” four-time MVP LeBron James told the Beacon Journal's Jason Lloyd in February of his Maurice Podoloff Trophy collection. “I should have probably five or six right now, to be completely honest.” 

It doesn't take much effort to pull back James' thin veil.

He finished a distant third on the MVP ladder in 2010-11, receiving only four of a possible 121 first-place votes. Rose cornered the market with 113 first-place nods, nearly doubling the total score of runner-up Dwight Howard.

Justifications for Rose's landslide victory, in retrospect, read more like excuses.

Carlos Boozer posted the second-highest usage rate on that Bulls team! Joakim Noah appeared in just 48 games! James had two superstars, Chris Bosh and Dwyane Wade, on his side! Ugh, come on, James just secured two consecutive MVP awards; it's someone else's turn!

Yes, Rose was indispensable to that 62-win Bulls squad. They played like a top-10 offense with him on the court and devolved into a smoldering heap when he sat, with a 98.9 offensive rating that would have ranked dead last. That they finished first in the Eastern Conference at a time when the Miami Heat's villainous Big Three was supposed to steamroll the rest of the NBA played a pivotal part in Rose's ascension.

OAKLAND, CA - DECEMBER 26:  Derrick Rose #1 of the Chicago Bulls looks on against the Golden State Warriors at Oracle Arena on December 26, 2011 in Oakland, California. The Warriors won 99-91. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by
Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

But the Bulls' calling card was still their defense. They fielded the Association's best points-prevention system—one that improved when Rose stepped off the floor. He barely ranked as an above-average defender that season, according to

Historically, MVP winners dominate some of the most common statistical measuring sticks, including win shares per 48 minutes, player efficiency rating (PER) and box plus-minus (BPM)—the latter of which shows how much better the average team is per 100 possessions with a given player on the court. Rose's 2010-11 efforts never held up to that billing.

Twenty-three of the 37 MVP winners from the three-point era have finished inside the top three of each category. James led all of those subsections in 2010-11; Rose only ranked in the top three of one (BPM). His average placement across all three departments was seventh, which is the fifth-worst mark for an MVP since 1980. He's ahead of only Kobe Bryant (2008), Allen Iverson (2001) and Steve Nash (2005, 2006).

Nash's MVP seasons inoculate Rose against an even lower standing. But, unlike the rest of the field, Nash was neither a high-usage shooter nor volume scorer. He jacked fewer than 14 shots per 36 minutes during each of his MVP crusades, whereas Rose launched 19.

Take into account Nash's superior efficiency, and Rose comes off even worse. Chicago's floor general posted the fourth-lowest true shooting percentagecombined measurement of two-point, three-point and free-throw efficiency—of any recent MVP:

Two of the players behind Rose on the accuracy scale, Kevin Garnett and Michael Jordan, come with their own caveats. Jordan was 34 years old when he nabbed MVP honors in 1998; Garnett still paced the league in win shares per 48 minutes, PER and BPM for 2003-04, despite his lackluster true shooting percentage.

This shouldn't imply that Rose is, unequivocally, the most undeserving MVP in NBA history. Nash's porous defense offset a large chunk of his offensive contributions, per, and the absence of objective voting guidelines prohibit such a conclusion.

Rose's Rank Among MVPs of 3-Point Era
TS%PERWS/48Offensive BPMDefensive BPMOverall BPM
Rose's MVP Season5523.5.2085.80.15.9
MVP Rank (out of 37)343534203130

At minimum, though, Rose's MVP season is one of the least impressive. The case for picking him over James in 2011, conveniently timed narratives aside, is questionable at best, inexplicable at worst. 

Either way, his defining achievement cannot be accepted at face value, forcing us to reconsider his return and the status he's trying to recapture.


The Unending Road Back

MIAMI, FLORIDA - APRIL 07:  Derrick Rose #1 of the Chicago Bulls looks on during a game against the Miami Heat  at American Airlines Arena on April 7, 2016 in Miami, Florida.  NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and o
Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

Rose has missed 228 of a possible 394 regular-season tilts since 2011-12. He would absolutely be better than an enormous what-if now if he enjoyed a clean bill of health during that time.

But his 2010-11 season wasn't just unremarkable by historical MVP standards; it was abnormally proficient for him. 

D-Rose by the Numbers
2008-09 & 2009-1015918.352.
2013-14 and 2014-156120.848.

He flirted with picking up where he left off immediately after his MVP nod, playing through 34 of the Bulls' first 44 contests in 2011-12, while averaging 22.8 points and 8.0 assists per game on what would have been a career-best 45 percent shooting. Chicago's offense once again hummed with him and stalled without him.

So there is evidence to suggest a full-strength Rose didn't peak at 22. Blaming his demise on injuries is wholly justified. But those protracted absences and recoveries are a part of Rose's career—circumstances to which he hasn't yet adapted.

“I feel like I’m great right now,” Rose said after being traded to New York, per USA Today's Mike Coppinger. “Where I came from, as far as just getting through my rehabs and just having the opportunity to just play basketball; I feel like that’s the only thing I was missing these last couple of years was my rhythm."

Failing to recognize, admit and implement necessary adjustments has been Rose's biggest downfall in recent years. He still often functions as this score-first, drive-determined point guard, and it's not working.

A large chunk of his shot attempts continue to come inside 10 feet of the basket, but his accuracy within that area isn't nearly the same. He has traded some drives and long twos for three-pointers, but his shooting percentage from deep has cracked 33 percent just once since 2010-11.

That MVP march is still the only time Rose ranked as a plus defensive contributor. He has given up more points than he has saved in every other year, culminating with a career-worst performance in 2015-16, according to


Who Is Rose Supposed to Be Now?

NEW YORK,NY - MARCH 24: Derrick Rose #1 of the Chicago Bulls drives to the basket against the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden on March 24, 2016 in New York,New York NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and/or
Jesse D. Garrabrant/Getty Images

New York brought Rose in to steady a shaky point guard position, but is he a huge upgrade over the Jose Calderon-Langston Galloway-Jerian Grant-Sasha Vujacic foursome? Chicago's point guard rotation last season, headlined by Rose, was more efficient on both ends of the floor than New York's, according to, but just barely. 

The Knicks, unlike the Bulls, won't call on Rose to carry so much of the offense. Head coach Jeff Hornacek has surrounding weapons Carmelo Anthony and Kristaps Porzingis to justify Rose as a pass-first point guard off pick-and-rolls, drives and screens. 

Except, he may not be fully equipped to shine in that role. As the Wall Street Journal's Chris Herring explained: "Rose's ability to drive should free up shots for his teammates, but it's worth noting that among qualifying point guards who drove to the basket at least five times a game last season, Rose owned the third-lowest pass percentage, dumping the ball off just 23.3 percent of the time, according to"

Close to 83 percent of Rose's pick-and-roll possessions ended in a shot attempt last season. And he is working off the least effective offensive performance of his career, per, complete with an all-time low success rate around the rim.

Most of Rose's value now lies in name recognition. His status belies his ceiling, resting on all he once did, rather than what he's doing now.

NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 24:  Derrick Rose is introduced at a press conference as the newest member of the New York Knicks on June 24, 2016 in New York, NY. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and/or using this Photograph,
Nathaniel S. Butler/Getty Images

Expectations have regressed accordingly, just not enough. They may never move enough. They're still retreating from a position of premature optimism. That MVP victory fueled a fragile, if artificial, rise unfit to withstand this fall.

Maybe a new beginning with the Knicks, during a contract year, will help carry Rose back to prior prominence, quelling any doubts about his real place in the NBA. In the meantime, though, this change of scenery should be the impetus we need to judge him through open minds and against an unformed past, as if the MVP version of Rose never existed. 

Because, frankly, it may not have.


Stats courtesy of and unless otherwise cited. Salary information via Basketball Insiders.

Dan Favale covers the NBA for Bleacher Report. Follow him on Twitter, @danfavale.


    Healthy Steph Is Still the NBA's Best Player 🎯

    @wontgottlieb says there's no question Curry belongs at the top of the best players list going into next season

    NBA logo

    Healthy Steph Is Still the NBA's Best Player 🎯

    Will Gottlieb
    via Bleacher Report

    Top Storyline for Every Team in Orlando

    Biggest, most interesting, most important storylines before the NBA's restart 📝

    NBA logo

    Top Storyline for Every Team in Orlando

    Dan Favale
    via Bleacher Report

    10 Best NBA Teams of the 2010s

    2010s were dominated by LeBron, Steph and KD, but had the best team of the decade 📲

    NBA logo

    10 Best NBA Teams of the 2010s

    Andy Bailey
    via Bleacher Report

    How Players and Coaches Are Adapting to Their New Normal

    NBA logo

    How Players and Coaches Are Adapting to Their New Normal

    Paolo Uggetti
    via The Ringer