UCB Project: Top 5 Stories of 2009

2) Terrific Tossing

It's rare enough that there is a Cy Young caliber season in St. Louis.  Chris Carpenter won the first such award since Bob Gibson a few years back, which indicates just how long it has been.  So to have two Cy contenders going in the same rotation was a spectacular part of 2009.

I'm a huge pitching fan, so it was wonderful to see Carp and Adam Wainwright matching each other every time out, throwing up low scoring games right and left.  Either one of them would have been worthy of winning the award, though it went to Tim Lincecum of the Giants.

Those two weren't the only stars on the mound, though.  Joel Pineiro had a career year, relying on the ground balls from his sinker to put himself in position for a large contract.  Ryan Franklin inherited the closer role early and, until the last part of the season, really claimed it as his own, locking down games on a regular basis.  Even middle relief shined, as Trever Miller and Blake Hawksworth were reliable after the starters left the game, which was rarely before the seventh inning.

3) Awesome Albert

Some teams, having a player win the MVP would rank much higher up on the list.  In St. Louis, Albert Pujols not winning the award would have a bigger impact.  All Albert did was carry this team offensively until help arrived from the midseason acquisitions.   His final line of .327/.443/.658 with 47 homers and 135 RBI put him in the top three in all the traditional Triple Crown marks, even with the fact that he didn't hit a home run after September 9^th.

The other part of the Pujols story was the continuing discussion about an extension for the franchise player.  No negotiations were undertaken, even though the fan base clamored for it.  Pujols came out and said that he didn't need an extension right now, which provoked much discussion and worry.  He clarified that remark by saying the team needed to focus elsewhere, which provoked much discussion and worry.  Until he puts his signature on a long-term deal with the club, almost anything he does will provoke much discussion and worry.

4) Dodgers Deal Defeat

After looking like the best team in the National League soon after the acquisition of Matt Holliday, the Cardinals struggled in September, losing five of their last six going into postseason play.  While some hoped that they would flip a switch and get back to that winning team, it never happened.

The team in NLDS against the Dodgers wasn't anything like the team from late July that was firing on all cylinders.  Chris Carpenter picked the worst time to have his worst game and the only Cardinal rally in Game 1 was snuffed out by a double play.  Adam Wainwright looked to have Game 2 won, until Ryan Franklin and Matt Holliday combined to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.  In the 2-0 hole, the team didn't seem to show up when the series shifted back to St. Louis, getting down early and never really making a comeback.  A disappointing end to a stellar season.

5) Skip to Second

It was stunning when the Cardinals released Adam Kennedy right before spring training began in 2009.  Most observers figured that St. Louis would be in the market for a second baseman, but instead transplanted outfielder Skip Schumaker to the slot.  While early returns defensively were brutal, Schumaker continued to hit at his regular pace and gradually the defense improved.  While it's unlikely that Skip will ever win a Gold Glove at second, he is going to be one of the rare players in recent history to hold that job for the Cardinals for more than one season.  His progress and attitude in the shift were overlooked somewhat as the season went on, but were definitely noteworthy.

A lot of other things could have made the list, such as the pursuit of Matt Holliday this offseason or the unlucky season that Kyle Lohse had, but I think these are the top stories to take away from 2009.  Now, what will 2010 bring?