Miami Once Again Squanders Massive Talent Investment as CFB Playoff Hopes Vanish

At last, this was supposed to be the year. Everything was finally aligned. The roster. The coaching staff. The talent. Oh, the talent. And the schedule. This was supposed to be the season Miami returned to its rightful place as a dominant football power.

Instead, on the first day of November, with the first College Football Playoff Ranking yet to be released, the Hurricanes are once again left to think about lost opportunities, coaching malpractice, penalties, and enormous financial commitments that have not resulted in nearly enough moments.

There is no sugarcoating Miami football in 2025.

Not after a second loss on Saturday afternoon, this one to SMU. With that defeat, the Hurricanes essentially ejected themselves from the college football playoff discussion.

Sure, there will be other losses from teams in contention. It's hard to declare any season dead in the expanded playoff era, with so many meaningful games yet to be played. But this felt like the end of Miami's season, and it's hard to envision enough chaos for that conclusion to be any different one month more now.

Instead of looking ahead, we must first look back.

The Hurricanes' Week 1 victory over Notre Dame felt like a moment. With a revamped roster, headlined by transfer QB Carson Beck, Miami had the look of a legitimate championship contender.

In fact, this theme carried forward. Less than a month ago, Beck was the betting favorite to win the Heisman. The Hurricanes were unbeaten. The offensive and defensive lines, two major areas of focus in the offseason, looked completely reborn.

This team was rolling, and nothing could stop it. That was until Louisville beat Miami in Miami as a double-digit underdog. Beck, the team's prize addition, threw four interceptions that night.

On Saturday, Beck added two more interceptions, including a crippling turnover when his team had the ball first in overtime. The Miami defense was also flagged multiple times late in the game that allowed SMU to tie the game up.

In overtime, following the turnover, SMU methodically carved through the Miami defense when it got the ball moments later. The game ended 26-20.

That's that. Game over, season over. For the second consecutive year, Miami's playoff push ended with an emphatic thud.

George Walker/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Last season, with Cam Ward, the future No. 1 overall NFL Draft pick playing quarterback, Miami lost November football games to Georgia Tech and Syracuse to miss the College Football Playoff. Miami was a double-digit favorite in both games.

Are we starting to sense a trend?

In a season ripe with fan frustration and program unrest across so many football programs, Mario Cristobal will enter the conversation.

No, he won't be fired. We haven't gotten that deep down the rabbit hole. But given his history of bizarre in-game miscues and the suddenly growing list of ugly, season-altering losses, the conversation over his ability to take this program to the next level must start now.

The Hurricanes have stepped up in resources. They committed millions of dollars to Beck and millions more to fill holes across the roster. In fact, few teams across the country spent more than Miami did in NIL and the transfer portal in 2025.

They hired Cristobal with the intent of surrounding him with the necessary resources to win an ACC Championship and compete for national titles. They let him spend more on his coach staff,

To their credit, the program has leveled up at a time it has absolutely had to. Miami has adjusted to the modern era. They've spent where they need to spend. They looked like a program building toward a bigger season and something.

Early on, all systems were a go. Miami showed flashes of ultimately becoming that kind of program again. Against Notre Dame, there were plenty of moments. Dominant wins over South Florida and Florida took the conversation to yet another level.

Less than two months later, with four games remaining, the flashes have been replaced by disappointment and uncertainty. The questions are much deeper than 2025; Miami fans must now question what exactly things will look like in the future.

Sure, the program will continue to spend and acquire talent. Cristobal will be given the resources to find his next quarterback if he's already not on the roster.

The Hurricanes will spend more than just about everyone else yet again, but why should anyone believe that the results will be any different than what we've seen now for two seasons in a row?

In a conference seemingly lacking dominant teams—with all due respect to Georgia Tech and Virginia—this was Miami's year. With Clemson and Florida State down and out once again, the Hurricanes had all the ingredients of a total program rebirth.

But it wasn't to be. Instead of wondering where the Hurricanes will land in the postseason, we're left wondering what changes will be made to ensure this program avoids the same fate for the third consecutive year.

And, more importantly, if Miami has the right coach capable of seeing it through.