NFLNBAMLBNHLWNBASoccerGolf
Featured Video
Ohtani Little League HR 😨

Yasiel Puig and the 20 Most Impressive All-Time Starts to an MLB Career

Ely SussmanMay 31, 2018

Yasiel Puig's Major League Baseball career is off to an impressive start, though this is hardly the first time we've seen immediate dominance from a young player. In past generations and even recently, rookies have enjoyed comparable success following their initial call-up.

Entering June 25, Puig is 20 games into MLB life. The sample isn't insignificant, but anything smaller would be.

Therefore, the individuals on this list—those who wowed us as fantastic freshmen—made it because they maintained a high quality of performance for at least as long as Puig has. For starting pitchers and relievers, we looked at career-opening stretches of at least five and 10 games, respectively.

Many of the truly timeless first-year performances began with awkward swings and shaky command. Even Ryan Braun and Ted Williams, who finished with fantastic numbers, dealt with dry spells during series early in their careers.

They failed to make the cut.

Still, the typical baseball fan shouldn't have much trouble recognizing these 20 names. They hogged headlines for weeks, months or even an entire season before finally cooling off.

All game logs and monthly splits provided by Baseball-Reference.com.

Impressive Rookies*

1 of 21

Many of us conveniently forget that players like Fred Lynn, Buster Posey, Mike Trout and Fernando Valenzuela were rookie sensations in their second major league seasons.

Major League Baseball is weird like that, allowing youngsters to retain their prospect status if they don't see enough plate appearances, innings pitched or days on the active roster.

Of course, players who lucked out in such a way and had an entire offseason to fine-tune their bodies and game plans were not considered for this article. We're only interested in those who truly surged out of the starting gate.

20. Vince Coleman (St. Louis Cardinals, 1985)

2 of 21

Stealing 21 bases as a rookie is a great accomplishment.

By doing so through only 20 career games, Vince Coleman earned inclusion on this prestigious list. He also proved to be an effective outfielder with two assists during those first few memorable weeks.

The 1985 St. Louis Cardinals actually limped to an 8-12 record despite his individual efforts.

However, Coleman remained in the leadoff spot throughout the season as they finished with 101 wins and the National League pennant.

1985 game log (April 18-May 9)

Apr 18STL MONL,1-740100001002.333.500.333.833
Apr 19STL PITW,5-451411020000.625.6671.0001.667
Apr 20STL PITW,4-340000000000.417.462.6671.128
Apr 21STL PITW,6-051200002003.467.556.6671.222
Apr 22STL NYML,6-751100020000.400.478.5501.028
Apr 23STL NYMW,8-351100010020.360.429.480.909
Apr 24STL NYMW,5-141100000001.345.406.448.855
Apr 25STL@MONL,2-440100000002.333.389.424.813
Apr 26STL@MONL,5-1051110001022.324.390.432.823
Apr 27STL@MONL,3-840000000010.293.356.390.746
Apr 28STL@MONL,3-551100001001.289.360.378.738
Apr 30STL LADW,6-151210000011.300.364.400.764
May 1STL LADL,1-251101000020.291.350.418.768
May 3STL SFGW,8-152210001102.305.369.441.810
May 4STL SFGW,6-452200001013.317.386.444.830
May 5STL SFGL,0-540200000020.328.392.448.840
May 6STL SDPW,5-241100000012.324.385.437.821
May 7STL SDPL,2-1250000000011.303.361.408.769
May 8STL@LADL,2-540100000020.300.356.400.756
May 9STL@LADW,5-451110010021.294.348.400.748

19. Brad Ziegler (Oakland Athletics, 2008)

3 of 21

Talk about an unlikely success story.

Brad Ziegler began his professional career at 23 years old, and prior to 2007 (his age-27 campaign), the right-hander was just a mediocre starter in the minors.

He rose quickly when he dropped his arm angle and learned to embrace relief work.

According to FanGraphs, Ziegler was reliant on an 85 mile-per-hour fastball as a rookie, throwing it 86.6 percent of the time. Yet his great location and tricky release point enabled an outstanding streak.

He opened his Oakland Athletics career with 39 consecutive innings of scoreless pitching before B.J. Upton ruined everybody's fun on August 14. An unsustainable BABIP had a lot to do with it, but so did Ziegler's remarkable ability to induce ground balls.

2008 game log (May 31-August 12)

May 31OAK@TEXL,4-80.11000000.00510
Jun 3OAK DETW,5-41.20000000.002741
Jun 4OAK DETW,10-21.01000000.001121
Jun 7OAK LAAL,3-51.21000200.001622
Jun 8OAK LAAW,7-31.20001000.001821
Jun 12OAK NYYL,1-41.00000000.00930
Jun 14OAK@SFGW,4-00.21000000.00930
Jun 18OAK@ARIL,1-111.02000000.001222
Jun 19OAK@ARIL,1-21.11001000.001431
Jun 20OAK FLAW,7-60.12000000.001421
Jun 21OAK FLAL,4-60.20000000.001120
Jun 27OAK SFGW,4-10.20000100.00601
Jun 29OAK SFGL,1-111.00000100.00911
Jul 1OAK@LAAL,3-52.00000300.002430
Jul 4OAK@CHWW,7-11.00000100.001311
Jul 7OAK SEAW,4-32.01000000.002141
Jul 10OAK SEAW,3-21.01002000.002231
Jul 12OAK LAAL,1-41.10000100.001312
Jul 13OAK LAAL,3-40.10000000.00110
Jul 19OAK@NYYL,3-41.00001100.001820
Jul 22OAK@TBRW,8-12.02001000.003762
Jul 25OAK TEXL,6-141.11000000.001323
Jul 27OAK TEXW,6-52.02000300.002731
Jul 30OAK KCRL,3-43.02001100.003170
Aug 1OAK@BOSL,1-22.01001100.002933
Aug 5OAK@TORL,3-42.00001000.002050
Aug 7OAK@TORL,4-61.02000000.001932
Aug 8OAK@DETW,4-22.00002200.003021
Aug 12OAK TBRW,2-11.00000000.001122

TOP NEWS

Washington Nationals v Los Angeles Angels
New York Yankees v. Chicago Cubs

18. Terry Pendleton (St. Louis Cardinals, 1984)

4 of 21

Terry Pendleton was called up for the St. Louis Cardinals the year before Vince Coleman, seizing the third baseman's job and a spot in the middle of the batting order.

The Cards waited until the second half of 1984 to recall the short switch-hitter from the minors, and he made them regret not doing it sooner.

Pendleton didn't hit for much power until later in his career, but he sure could put the bat on the ball. He struck out only three times through his first 65 MLB plate appearances. His batting average didn't drop below .400 until the middle of August.

1984 game log (July 18-August 7)

Jul 18STL SFGW,8-46130001100.600.667.6001.267
Jul 19STL LADL,0-103011000000.500.556.6251.181
Jul 20STL LADW,10-54121000010.500.538.6671.205
Jul 21STL LADL,1-34010000000.438.471.5631.033
Jul 22STL LADW,7-64120001000.450.476.5501.026
Jul 23STL@NYML,3-45010000010.400.423.480.903
Jul 24STL@NYML,8-95120000110.414.452.483.934
Jul 25STL@NYML,3-94000000100.375.429.438.866
Jul 27STL@PITW,3-25040000000.432.475.486.961
Jul 28STL@PITW,5-14130001001.463.500.5121.012
Jul 29STL@PITW,4-34210001000.444.479.489.968
Jul 30STL NYMW,3-14010001001.438.462.479.941
Jul 31STL NYMW,6-34230000000.462.482.500.982
Aug 1STL NYMW,11-25231001101.482.508.5361.044
Aug 2STL PHIL,2-34000000000.450.477.500.977
Aug 3STL PHIW,4-34210000011.438.464.484.948
Aug 4STL PHIW,3-24030001001.456.479.500.979
Aug 5STL PHIL,3-64110000001.444.468.486.954
Aug 6STL PITL,2-34000001010.427.444.467.911
Aug 7STL PITW,2-14020101000.430.447.494.941

17. Austin Jackson (Detroit Tigers, 2010)

5 of 21

If 2010 Rookie of the Year voters hadn't been so mesmerized by Neftali Feliz's saves total, the hardware would have gone to Austin Jackson.

He set an embarrassing major league record by striking out in 19 straight games to begin his career, but Jackson did reach base in 29 of his first 30 contests.

By the second week of May, the 23-year-old ranked atop the American League in batting and had Ben Shpigel of The New York Times writing a feature about him.

Defense was another one of Jackson's strengths. He possessed game-changing range in center field.

2010 game log (April 5-May 9)

Apr 5DET@KCRW,8-45111001020.200.200.400.600
Apr 7DET@KCRL,2-35020100020.300.300.600.900
Apr 8DET@KCRW,7-35122001010.333.333.6671.000
Apr 9DET CLEW,5-24210001111.333.368.611.980
Apr 10DET CLEW,4-25000000020.261.292.478.770
Apr 11DET CLEW,9-86120000211.296.367.481.848
Apr 12DET KCRL,5-105120000010.313.371.469.840
Apr 13DET KCRW,6-55111001110.306.375.472.847
Apr 16DET@SEAL,3-114120000010.325.386.475.861
Apr 17DET@SEAL,2-45010000020.311.367.444.812
Apr 18DET@SEAW,4-25130101010.340.389.500.889
Apr 19DET@LAAL,0-24010000020.333.379.481.861
Apr 20DET@LAAL,5-65110000131.328.381.466.846
Apr 21DET@LAAW,4-34000000130.311.373.443.816
Apr 22DET@LAAW,5-45010000110.308.375.431.806
Apr 23DET@TEXL,4-55110000030.300.364.414.778
Apr 24DET@TEXW,8-45120000020.307.366.413.779
Apr 25DET@TEXL,4-84121011010.316.372.468.840
Apr 26DET@TEXW,8-65120000120.325.385.470.854
Apr 27DET MINL,0-24000000100.314.379.453.832
Apr 28DET MINW,11-65321000100.322.390.467.857
Apr 29DET MINW,3-04120001001.330.394.468.862
Apr 30DET LAAW,10-65250000001.364.422.495.917
May 1DET LAAW,3-25110000010.356.412.481.893
May 2DET LAAW,5-15031001010.367.420.495.916
May 3DET@MINL,4-105131101000.377.427.526.954
May 4DET@MINL,3-44110000100.376.430.521.951
May 5DET@MINL,4-55010000010.369.421.508.929
May 8DET@CLEW,6-45121000011.370.420.512.932
May 9DET@CLEL,4-75220000010.371.420.508.927

16. Joba Chamberlain (New York Yankees, 2007)

6 of 21

Joba Chamberlain has already faded from greatness to mediocrity, but we shouldn't forget how truly dominant he was initially.

Four months into his first professional season, the pudgy right-hander was promoted to the New York Yankees. It took only a handful of appearances for him to progress from a mop-up role to Mariano Rivera's setup man.

Tyler Kepner of The New York Times introduced us to the "Joba Rules," which instructed manager Joe Torre to keep him well-rested.

Chamberlain made only one mistake during the 2007 regular season that Mike Lowell deposited over the Green Monster at Fenway Park.

In the ensuing playoffs, he famously struggled due to factors that were beyond his control, per John C. Kuehner of The Plain Dealer.

2007 game log (August 7-September 30)

Aug 7NYY@TORW,9-22.01002200.003322
Aug 10NYY@CLEW,6-12.00000400.002111
Aug 13NYY BALW,7-61.00000200.001410
Aug 17NYY DETW,6-11.01000100.001003
Aug 19NYY DETW,9-31.00000200.00901
Aug 22NYY@LAAW,8-21.01000300.001510
Aug 24NYY@DETL,6-91.00000100.001002
Aug 28NYY BOSW,5-31.01001200.001902
Aug 30NYY BOSW,5-01.11001000.001823
Sep 5NYY SEAW,10-21.00000000.001112
Sep 7NYY@KCRW,3-22.02000100.002925
Sep 12NYY@TORW,4-11.21101200.003541
Sep 16NYY@BOSW,4-32.02110310.503023
Sep 19NYY BALW,2-10.10000100.49400
Sep 21NYY TORL,4-52.00001400.443002
Sep 23NYY TORW,7-51.10000300.421610
Sep 26NYY@TBDW,12-41.01000100.401412
Sep 27NYY@TBDW,3-11.01000200.382002
Sep 30NYY@BALW,10-40.10000000.38510

15. Dennis Eckersley (Cleveland Indians, 1975)

7 of 21

Dennis Eckersley uncharacteristically demonstrated poor command during his first summer in the big leagues.

He issued 13 walks through April and May alone. Keep in mind, this Hall of Famer would later pitch eight separate seasons in which he finished with lower totals.

However, the Cleveland Indians didn't waste much time moving Eckersley to the starting rotation so that they could reap more benefits from his overpowering repertoire.

The 20-year-old eventually had to suck up several rough outings, but the beginning of that campaign was magical.

1975 game log (April 12-May 31)

Apr 12CLE@MILL,5-61.21001100.0013 
Apr 20CLE MILW,7-40.11001000.0010 
Apr 28CLE@NYYL,1-62.03100000.0014 
May 1CLE@BOSL,6-71.00001200.0001 
May 2CLE BALW,4-32.13002200.0022 
May 4CLE BALW,4-32.01002200.0013 
May 5CLE BOSL,5-71.20001200.0031 
May 13CLE@MINW,3-23.00001400.0014 
May 16CLE@CHWL,2-30.00001000.0000 
May 18CLE@CHWW,7-60.10000100.0000 
May 25CLE OAKW,6-09.03002600.0081485
May 31CLE@OAKW,4-19.06111500.2851775

14. Brett Lawrie (Toronto Blue Jays, 2011)

8 of 21

If not for a rash of injuries, perhaps Brett Lawrie would have already developed into an All-Star.

Let's rewind to 2011, when Lawrie was the American League's fifth-youngest player. During a four-week stretch, he was arguably its most unstoppable individual, too.

Earlier that season, in the notoriously hitter-friendly Pacific Coast League, Lawrie batted .353/.415/.661 with 18 home runs in 69 games.

2011 game log (August 5-September 1)

Aug 5TOR@BALW,5-44020001010.500.500.5001.000
Aug 6TOR@BALL,2-63010000010.429.429.429.857
Aug 7TOR@BALW,7-24220011000.455.455.7271.182
Aug 9TOR OAKL,1-43000000020.357.357.571.929
Aug 10TOR OAKW,8-44221014010.389.389.7781.167
Aug 11TOR OAKL,3-104000000110.333.364.6671.030
Aug 12TOR LAAL,1-53011000100.348.400.6961.096
Aug 13TOR LAAW,11-24020100000.370.414.7411.155
Aug 14TOR LAAW,5-44011001001.355.394.7101.104
Aug 15TOR@SEAL,5-64110011020.343.378.7431.121
Aug 16TOR@SEAW,13-75230001100.385.429.7441.172
Aug 17TOR@SEAW,5-14000000100.357.413.6901.104
Aug 18TOR@OAKW,7-04121001100.378.440.7111.151
Aug 19TOR@OAKL,0-24010000020.367.426.6731.099
Aug 20TOR@OAKL,1-53000000010.346.404.6351.038
Aug 21TOR@OAKW,1-03000000000.327.383.600.983
Aug 23TOR KCRL,4-63000000010.310.365.569.934
Aug 24TOR KCRW,4-33120112000.328.379.6561.035
Aug 25TOR KCRL,6-94120101010.338.386.6771.063
Aug 26TOR TBRL,1-64110011020.333.378.6961.074
Aug 27TOR TBRL,5-64110100020.329.372.6991.070
Aug 28TOR TBRL,0-124020000010.338.378.6881.066
Aug 29TOR TBRW,7-35010000112.333.379.6671.046
Aug 30TOR@BALL,5-65110013010.329.380.6821.063
Aug 31TOR@BALW,13-05011001110.326.381.6741.056
Sep 1TOR@BALW,8-65231012001.340.392.7131.105

13. Walter Johnson (Washington Senators, 1907)

9 of 21

Walter Johnson—often referred to as "The Big Train"—is widely considered one of the best pitchers in the history of the sport. Fittingly, he started off strong at the ripe age of 19.

We do not have game logs or splits from the 1907 season, but there's plenty to like about his overall stats.

Of Johnson's 12 starts, 11 were complete games (two shutouts). He accounted for 2.7 WAR—the third-highest total on the Washington Senators, per Baseball-Reference.com—despite waiting until August 2 to debut.

With enough innings to qualify, he would have finished second in the American League in strikeout rate, fourth in earned run average and 10th in WHIP.

12. Jered Weaver (Los Angeles Angels, 2006)

10 of 21

Believe it or not, there was a time when the Los Angeles Angels had a respectable bullpen. That's why, in 2006, they didn't feel pressure to stretch out Jered Weaver into the later innings.

He went 4-0 with a 1.37 ERA before the Angels optioned him back down to Triple-A. Then, he awkwardly replaced Jeff Weaver, his older brother, in the starting rotation when L.A. traded him to the St. Louis Cardinals.

The next nine starts were equally impressive. Weaver carried a 3.38 strikeout-to-walk ratio and .540 OPS against through August 24.

On that date, he finally suffered a loss despite six innings of one-run ball.

2006 game log (May 27-August 24)

May 27LAA BALW,10-17.03001500.009781175
Jun 2LAA@CLEW,10-36.14222801.359941063
Jun 7LAA@TBDW,6-26.04220421.869221660
Jun 13LAA KCRW,4-17.05101501.379941769
Jul 3LAA@SEAW,7-17.05111901.3511161171
Jul 8LAA@OAKW,6-47.02002501.129561176
Jul 23LAA@KCRW,3-16.23114401.1510181064
Jul 29LAA@BOSL,6-76.27332401.519851750
Aug 3LAA TEXL,6-76.08331301.81106121146
Aug 8LAA@CLEW,5-45.26442312.2010221742
Aug 13LAA@NYYW,5-36.03113812.141047467
Aug 18LAA SEAW,3-07.03001701.9510361077
Aug 24LAA BOSL,1-26.04111611.9210731265

11. Jason Heyward (Atlanta Braves, 2010)

11 of 21

The consensus top prospect entering the 2010 season, Jason Heyward did not disappoint.

The video shows his first MLB plate appearance, which ended in a majestic home run. He would slug seven more of them before a groin injury interrupted the good vibes.

Heyward spoke with the MLB Network about his All-Star-worthy first half. Those first 26 contests were unforgettable—seldom do rookies demonstrate such patience at the plate upon being called up.

2010 game log (April 5-May 5)

Apr 5ATL CHCW,16-55220014010.400.4001.0001.400
Apr 7ATL CHCW,3-23011001020.375.375.8751.250
Apr 8ATL CHCL,0-24000000010.250.250.583.833
Apr 9ATL@SFGL,4-56000000140.176.222.412.634
Apr 10ATL@SFGW,7-25230012200.300.391.6501.041
Apr 11ATL@SFGL,3-64110011010.292.370.7081.079
Apr 12ATL@SDPL,2-174000001210.269.387.6541.041
Apr 14ATL@SDPW,6-14010001020.267.371.600.971
Apr 15ATL@SDPW,6-24122002100.303.410.6671.077
Apr 16ATL COLW,9-55120000010.316.409.6321.041
Apr 17ATL COLL,0-43000000120.300.404.6001.004
Apr 18ATL COLW,4-35010003210.302.423.5811.004
Apr 20ATL PHIW,4-34110011010.298.411.6171.028
Apr 21ATL PHIL,0-23000000110.286.407.592.999
Apr 22ATL PHIL,3-84000000010.269.397.558.955
Apr 23ATL@NYML,2-54000000030.250.373.518.891
Apr 24ATL@NYML,1-34010000110.254.380.508.889
Apr 25ATL@NYML,0-12000000000.246.370.492.862
Apr 26ATL@STLL,3-44000000110.234.364.469.832
Apr 27ATL@STLL,4-54000000110.224.358.448.806
Apr 29ATL@STLL,4-104120011000.239.365.493.858
Apr 30ATL HOUW,4-24110012010.240.360.520.880
May 1ATL HOUW,10-15120011100.256.383.564.947
May 2ATL HOUW,7-14221003000.272.388.580.968
May 4ATL@WSNL,3-64120011200.289.412.6271.038
May 5ATL@WSNW,7-61000000000.286.408.6191.027

10. Hideo Nomo (Los Angeles Dodgers, 1995)

12 of 21

Hideo Nomo obliterated the National League through the first half of his rookie season, as the U.S. was slow to adjust to his quirky delivery.

The 26-year-old surrendered a single hit against the Barry Bonds-led San Francisco Giants in his MLB debut. He rolled into the All-Star break with an unbelievable .158 batting average against.

Only the Colorado Rockies—who averaged nearly seven runs per game at home that summer—tagged Nomo for more than three earned runs during that fiery 13-start stretch.

The Los Angeles Dodgers have relied on many outstanding pitchers in the past, but few of them ever enjoyed a month that rivaled Nomo's June 1995. Lasting more than 8.1 IP per outing (including two complete games), he maintained a 0.89 ERA and .426 OPS against with a 60/16 K/BB.

1995 game log (May 2-July 5)

May 2LAD@SFGL,3-45.01004700.00910868
May 7LAD@COLW,12-104.29772736.52978823
May 12LAD STLW,8-44.00317505.27945452
May 17LAD PITL,2-37.020031403.481073584
May 23LAD@NYMW,6-46.08432713.7110691047
May 28LAD@MONL,1-56.14337903.821237755
Jun 2LAD NYMW,2-18.02113613.2912261477
Jun 7LAD MONW,7-18.06114412.94 151166
Jun 14LAD@PITW,8-58.063221602.8412541074
Jun 19LAD@STLW,5-28.13213802.6210891276
Jun 24LAD SFGW,7-09.020031302.3012841293
Jun 29LAD COLW,3-09.060011302.0511291187
Jul 5LAD@ATLL,1-47.021151001.9912061074

9. Yasiel Puig (Los Angeles Dodgers, 2013)

13 of 21

To fully understand why Puigmania is exploding, you really need to watch this phenom in action.

Thankfully, MLB.com already has a month's worth of interviews and highlights from his first 20 games in the majors.

Puig's unprecedented production (per SB Nation's Bill Parker) makes him a legitimate candidate for All-Star selection. If it continues further into the summer, he'll be a dark horse in the NL MVP race.

2013 game log (June 3-24)

Jun 3LAD SDPW,2-14020000000.500.500.5001.000
Jun 4LAD SDPW,9-74231025000.625.6251.5002.125
Jun 5LAD SDPL,2-64000000020.417.4171.0001.417
Jun 6LAD ATLW,5-04120014010.438.4381.0631.500
Jun 7LAD ATLW,2-14110011100.421.4501.1051.555
Jun 8LAD ATLL,1-24020000010.435.4581.0001.458
Jun 9LAD ATLL,1-85031000000.464.483.9641.447
Jun 10LAD ARIL,4-54030000010.500.515.9381.453
Jun 11LAD ARIW,5-33100000010.471.500.8821.382
Jun 12LAD ARIL,6-81110000000.486.514.8861.399
Jun 14LAD@PITL,0-34020000010.487.512.8461.358
Jun 15LAD@PITW,5-35010000010.455.478.7731.251
Jun 16LAD@PITL,3-64130000011.479.500.7711.271
Jun 19 (1)LAD@NYYL,4-65121000010.472.491.7551.246
Jun 19 (2)LAD@NYYW,6-05320011011.474.500.7891.289
Jun 20LAD@SDPL,3-65110011030.452.477.7901.267
Jun 21LAD@SDPL,2-54120000000.455.478.7731.251
Jun 22LAD@SDPW,6-15000000220.435.473.7391.212
Jun 23LAD@SDPW,3-14010000010.425.462.7121.174
Jun 24LAD SFGW,3-14130012000.442.476.7531.229

8. Francisco Rodriguez (Anaheim Angels, 2002)

14 of 21

Francisco Rodriguez impressed the Anaheim Angels so much in September 2002, they decided to keep him around for their playoff run.

His rookie season was unique in that it was mainly comprised of October experience.

Putting it all together, K-Rod was magnificent: 24.1 IP, 13 H, 4 ER, 7 BB, 41 K. That translates to a 1.48 ERA and 0.82 WHIP, all while appearing in the most important games of the entire season.

He even struck out the side during Game 7 of the World Series.

2002 regular season

Sep 18ANA@OAKL,4-71.01000200.001602
Sep 19ANA@OAKL,3-51.00000300.001300
Sep 21ANA@SEAL,4-60.20000200.00800
Sep 25ANA@TEXL,3-40.20002100.001510
Sep 27ANA SEAL,6-72.12000500.003802

 

2002 postseason

ALDS g2Oct 2ANA@NYYW,8-62.02220119.003332
ALDS g3Oct 4ANA NYYW,9-62.00000404.502402
ALDS g4Oct 5ANA NYYW,9-51.20002303.183011
ALCS g2Oct 9ANA@MINW,6-31.21001302.452702
ALCS g3Oct 11ANA MINW,2-11.00000202.161101
ALCS g4Oct 12ANA MINW,7-11.01000201.931311
ALCS g5Oct 13ANA MINW,13-50.20001001.801711
WS g2Oct 20ANA SFGW,11-103.00000401.382632
WS g4Oct 23ANA@SFGL,3-42.02100201.203021
WS g6Oct 26ANA SFGW,6-52.24220412.044622
WS g7Oct 27ANA SFGW,4-11.00001301.931600

7. Joe DiMaggio (New York Yankees, 1936)

15 of 21

Before calming down in September, Joe DiMaggio was a legitimate MVP candidate.

He had legged out 15 triples in 112 games. Nearly as many walks as strikeouts, too.

Amazingly, DiMaggio did not miss a single inning during that stretch. Toward the end of it, he took on additional responsibility as the New York Yankees center fielder.

He was their second-best offensive player between May and September. That's high praise on a team that scored 1,065 runs with Lou Gehrig as it's No. 1 guy.

1936 monthly splits (May-August)

May261303048154428238.381.400.6591.059
June261272742103629045.344.365.623.988
July301453139736261117.300.364.538.902
August30142234885927045.348.366.6741.040

6. Willie McCovey (San Francisco Giants, 1959)

16 of 21

Willie McCovey was a unanimous Rookie of the Year selection despite participating in only 52 games. 

Since the award's inception in 1947, there have been 132 winners across the American and National Leagues. No other position player has ever received the honor without taking the field at least 100 times.

That obscure bit of trivia attests to how well McCovey performed for the 1959 San Francisco Giants.

His 1.085 OPS was 121 points better than that of all-time great teammate Willie Mays. His 22-game hitting streak, which spanned from August 17 until September 10, still stands as a rookie record for the franchise.

1959 monthly splits (July-September/October)

July28350203001.625.6251.1251.750
August2711515383282221018.373.443.6761.120
Sept/Oct239614256151301217.305.396.585.981

5. Tom Seaver (New York Mets, 1967)

17 of 21

Finishing with a winning record on a 1967 New York Mets squad that averaged barely three runs per game says a lot about Tom Seaver.

He excelled from start to finish, but particularly through the schedule's first three months.

Of his 11 starts immediately before the All-Star break, eight of them were complete games. Seaver helped his own cause with the bat and sported a respectable .225/.354/.275 slash line by mid-summer.

Shea Stadium attendance typically spiked when Seaver took the mound, so even though the team wasn't competitive, he still dealt with pressure.

1967 game log (pre-All-Star break)

Apr 13NYM PITW,3-25.16224803.385352
Apr 20NYM CHCW,6-17.18110502.138863
Apr 25NYM@CHCW,2-110.04101501.19131286
Apr 30NYM@CINL,2-36.07331211.889547
May 5NYM HOUW,3-29.09223511.91111263
May 12NYM@STLL,5-73.06223002.214236
May 17NYM@ATLL,3-48.07442632.5961156
May 22NYM LADW,5-29.05222722.5071374
May 27NYM ATLW,4-36.06321202.547751
Jun 1NYM@HOUL,1-48.08434412.6481052
Jun 6NYM@PITW,1-06.04002402.437666
Jun 13NYM CINW,7-39.08320612.3991267
Jun 18NYM CHCL,3-49.08443312.54131055
Jun 24NYM@ATLW,9-19.05112212.4191573
Jun 28NYM PHIL,5-66.110552312.686934
Jul 3NYM SFGW,5-39.07332712.7081066
Jul 8NYM ATLW,3-29.06223712.6581071

4. Albert Pujols (St. Louis Cardinals, 2001)

18 of 21

Albert Pujols led the 2001 St. Louis Cardinals to their first win of the season on April 6, which marked the beginning of a 23-game hitting streak. (Take that, Willie McCovey!) Perhaps most impressive is that he kept focused while rotating between four different defensive positions.

Clearly, July was his weakest month, but a league-average OBP and 11 XBH doesn't really count as a slump.

According to Baseball-Reference.com, Pujols cracked the top 10 in numerous National League categories: WAR, OPS, batting average, runs batted in and games played, to name a few. All that added up to a fourth-place finish in NL MVP voting.

The rookie campaign ended on a sour note, unfortunately, as he virtually disappeared during the ALDS.

2001 monthly splits (full season)

April/March241021834818270718.370.431.7391.171
May2811716332082401216.333.402.596.998
June271131732615150129.330.402.567.969
July24999217041201017.241.333.460.793
August30127324216162511414.375.441.6961.137
Sept/Oct2811820328162701419.311.398.583.981

3. Dwight Gooden (New York Mets, 1984)

19 of 21

In 1985, Dwight "Doc" Gooden enjoyed one of the best individual seasons in baseball history—but 1984 was awfully special, too.

His 11.4 K/9 established a major league record. Only Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Nolan Ryan and Kerry Wood have surpassed it since.

Gooden bounced back quickly from his most brutal outings. Otherwise, we wouldn't have taken his entire season into consideration.

He saved his best for last with nine consecutive starts of at least nine strikeouts (105 K in 76.0 IP). That outstanding period included three complete-game shutouts and an inhuman .411 OPS against.

1984 monthly splits (full season)

April/March113.104020.117127010261.32811.5
May324.065131.0221414115471.19413.6
June221.996145.1311110115401.0157.9
July312.585038.1311211217491.25211.5
August423.296241.036161536521.02411.4
Sept/Oct411.295342.02476010620.81013.3

2. Ichiro Suzuki (Seattle Mariners, 2001)

20 of 21

Both Fred Lynn and Ichiro Suzuki were "rookies" entering their AL MVP campaigns, but only the Japanese free agent had zero previous major league experience.

Suzuki's consistency was ridiculous, with 30-plus hits in all six months.

Moreover, he proved to be a hyper-aggressive baserunner and excellent defensive outfielder. Never has such a wiry human being been so intimidating.

2001 monthly splits (full season)

April/March25120173931211548.336.358.431.789
May2713229471140141236.379.409.532.941
June251222438411111064.330.361.409.769
July271211830623129511.268.308.438.746
August281302051700176612.429.461.487.948
Sept/Oct251131937302414612.349.384.434.818

1. Mark Fidrych (Detroit Tigers, 1976)

21 of 21

It's difficult to imagine today's MLB fans swooning over a rookie player the same way we did for Mark Fidrych way back when.

Ironically, he had the shortest career of anybody on this list.

At 21 years old, Fidrych carried the Detroit Tigers. He had defeated 10 of the 11 other AL teams by July 20, the only exception being the Chicago White Sox, who he hadn't faced.

The Tigers spaced out his appearances in April and May, but then greedily began using him on three days' rest. That contributed to some uneven results as the season wore on.

Regardless, Fidrych had a knack for inducing ground balls and staying in games until the beautiful—though sometimes bitter—end. If WAR and strikeout-to-walk ratio mean anything (and they do), he might have been robbed of the 1976 AL Cy Young Award.

1976 game log (April 20-July 20)

Apr 20DET@OAKL,5-60.0100000---00
May 5DET MINL,2-81.02000100.0011
May 15DET CLEW,2-19.02111500.90166
May 25DET@BOSL,0-28.06222111.50199
May 31DET MILW,5-411.011444812.17167
Jun 5DET@TEXW,3-211.07221802.02169
Jun 11DET CALW,4-39.09310401.84139
Jun 16DET KCRW,4-39.05322201.86149
Jun 20DET@MINW,7-37.19336202.07107
Jun 24DET@BOSW,6-39.07332422.181116
Jun 28DET NYYW,5-19.07110212.051411
Jul 3DET BALW,4-09.04003401.85149
Jul 9DET KCRL,0-19.09111201.78147
Jul 16DET OAKW,1-011.07004601.60158
Jul 20DET@MINW,8-39.010332201.711310
Ohtani Little League HR 😨

TOP NEWS

Washington Nationals v Los Angeles Angels
New York Yankees v. Chicago Cubs
New York Yankees v Tampa Bay Rays
New York Mets v San Diego Padres

TRENDING ON B/R