Predictions, Predictions...and More 2009 Baseball Predictions

Ed DuffyContributor IApril 5, 2009

With the opening pitch of the 2009 season just hours away, why not drop in my two cents on what will happen, who will happen, and who won't.  So, one man makes his picks on the 2009 season.


1.      Kevin Youkilis, 1b, Boston: Youk went from an on-base machine to a power hitter (29 HRs) who still gets on base close to .400.

He will bat fourth in this powerful lineup and have protection in front and behind. A career year awaits.

2.      Miguel Cabrera 1b, Detroit

3.      Carl Crawford, OF, Tampa Bay


1.      Albert Pujols, 1b, St. Louis

Tough to pick against this guy as long as his healthy. His team around him should be improved enough to contend for a wild card, and that will make him the favorite.

2.      Jose Reyes, SS, NY Mets

3.      Jimmy Rollins, SS, Philadelphia

AL Cy Young

1.      Roy Halladay, Toronto  

This is the fairest award in the sense that your team does not have to be the best to win. Halladay is the best.

2.      Jon Lester, Boston

3.      Matt Garza, Tampa Bay

NL Cy Young

1.      Johan Santana, NY Mets   

Like Halladay, this guy is simply the best and should have a better bullpen to support him this year.

2.      Cole Hamels, Philly

3.      Brandon Webb, Arizona

AL Rookie

1.      Matt Weiters, C, Baltimore

Like Longoria last year, he starts the season in the minors, but expect him up soon and expect a star. Think Joe Mauer with more pop.

2.      David Price, SP, Tampa Bay

3.      Travis Snider, OF, Toronto

NL Rookie

1.      Pablo Sandoval, 3b-C, San Francisco

He came up late last year and impressed with his versatility, as well as his big bat. A natural born hitter.

2.      Tommy Hanson, SP, Atlanta

3.      Jordan Schaeffer, OF, Atlanta

AL Manager

1.       Eric Wedge, Cleveland

The Indians win the Central after a bad 2008, and Wedge goes from one of the underrated mangers in the game to one of the best.

2.      Terry Francona, Boston

3.      Trey Hillman, Kansas City

NL Manager

1.      Tony La Russa, St Louis

A lot is keyed to Cris Carpenter coming back and solidifying the pitching staff, as well as Ryan Ludwick proving he was not a fluke. Still, La Russa always gets his teams to play at their best.

2.       Bobby Cox, Atlanta

3.       Bruce Bochy, San Francisco

AL Comeback Player

1.      John Smoltz, SP, Boston

The Red Sox are going very slow with Smoltz and all spring he chomped at the bit. He should make his first start sometime late May or early June and there is no question what he can bring if he stays healthy through October.

2.      Travis Hafner, DH, Cleveland

3.      Rocco Baldelli, OF, Boston

NL Comeback Player

1.      Chris Carpenter, SP, St. Louis 

He has always been among the best when healthy and looked to be all spring. As a matter of fact, he looked dominant. He may be more of a key to any team’s success than any other player in the Major leagues.

2.      Jeff Francoeur, OF, Atlanta

3.      Rickie Weeks, 2B, Milwaukee

AL Breakout Non-Rookie

1.      Jacoby Ellsbury, OF, Boston

He had an excellent rookie year, finishing third in the ROY balloting and now stands ready to add more pop to go along with his blazing speed. Also, he won’t have to look over his shoulder at Coco Crisp.

2.      Billy Butler, OF-DH, Kansas City

3.      Alex Gordon, 3B, Kansas City

NL Breakout Non Rookie

1.      Ryan Zimmerman, 3B, Washington

He missed nearly two months last season and had nobody around him in the lineup. This year, healthy, and with a bit more support, he joins the ranks of the elite. Expect 30-100-.310.

2.      Stephen Drew, SS, Arizona

3.      Chris Iannetta, C, Colorado

AL Bust

1.      AJ Burnett, SP, NY  

This guy is off one year and on the next, and guess what year this is? This is one category you hate to pick and hate to be right, but…

2.      Cliff Lee, SP, Cleveland

3.      Matt Holliday, OF, Oakland

NL Bust

1. Manny Ramirez, OF, LA

Now that he has his contract, let's see how Man-Ram behaves. He will still put up numbers, but the expectations are ridiculous.

2. Francisco Rodriguez, RP, NY

3. Carlos Marmol, RP, Chicago

AL Surprise Team: Kansas City Royals

They will not be a playoff team, but will show up as the most improved team in the AL, as Butler, Gordon and Teahen lead the offense and the young pitchers continue to grow. Greinke may emerge as a serious CY candidate.

NL Surprise Team: Cincinnati Reds  

Although I’m not a big fan of Dusty Baker, the Reds young talent is very impressive and Alex Gonzalez should be back healthy to solidify the infield defense.

Votto, Bruce, Phillips, Volquez, Cueto are all future stars. Actually, Phillips is already there.

AL Playoff Teams

East   Boston

Central   Cleveland

West   LA Angels

Wild   Tampa Bay

NL Playoff Teams

East   Philly

Central   Chicago

West   Arizona

Wild   NY Mets


    Report: Ramos, Mets Agree to 2-Year, $19M Contract

    MLB logo

    Report: Ramos, Mets Agree to 2-Year, $19M Contract

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Manny Machado Meeting with Yankees Wednesday

    MLB logo

    Report: Manny Machado Meeting with Yankees Wednesday

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Red Sox Have MLB's Highest Luxury Tax at $11.9M

    MLB logo

    Red Sox Have MLB's Highest Luxury Tax at $11.9M

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Nats, Adams Agree to 1-Yr/$4M Deal

    MLB logo

    Report: Nats, Adams Agree to 1-Yr/$4M Deal

    Paul Kasabian
    via Bleacher Report