Ted Williams' 1941 Season Is MLB's Most Underrated of All Time

Matthew Melton@mcmelton314Contributor IIIJune 21, 2012

BOSTON - AUGUST 22, 1958:  (FILE PHOTO) Baseball legend Ted Williams (1919 - 2002) of the Boston Red Sox holds a baseball bat at Shriner's Day in Fenway Park August 22, 1958 in Boston, Massachusetts. The 83-year-old Williams, who was the last major league player to bat .400 when he hit .406 in 1941, died July 5, 2002 at Citrus County Memorial Hospital in Florida. He died of an apparent heart attack.  (Photo by Getty Images)
Getty Images/Getty Images

“If I had known hitting .400 was going to be such a big deal, I would have done it again.”

In 1991, when Ted Williams spoke those words, it was the 50th anniversary of his magical 1941 season. It makes me laugh picturing Teddy Ballgame consider the possibility that he could have pocketed a handful of .400 seasons, if only he cared enough to have tried.

I could list the stats from the back of his baseball card that season, but the important thing to remember about the most underrated season in baseball history is that Ted Williams did not win the MVP the year he hit .406.

Let me repeat that. Ted Williams did not win the MVP the year he hit 45 points higher than his closest competition.

He did not win the MVP when an average day meant going 2-for-5 at the plate. He did not win the MVP, even though he led the league in runs, home runs, walks, OBP and SLG—and by margins that bring the phrase “lap the field” to mind.

He did not win the MVP even though he refused to take a seat on the last day of the season, with a batting average of .39955, good enough for MLB to write in the record books as .400. He only went on to play both games of a double-header that day and batted a measly 6-for-8. I have a feeling there is a line in there somewhere about a true MVP putting the team ahead of the individual, even on the last day of a lost season.

I’d like to think that the voters passed on Ted Williams because he was a young 22-year-old playing for a cursed Red Sox franchise that finished 17 games back in the American League.

I’d like to think the voters felt “The Kid” had to pay some dues before tying his name to an award that only Jimmie Foxx and Tris Speaker had won for the city of Boston. I’d like to think all of that, but we all know why Ted Williams didn’t win the 1941 MVP…

There was that guy on that one New York team who decided to get base hits in a bunch of consecutive games.

I get it. What a joy it must have been for baseball fans to watch Joe DiMaggio and Ted Williams at the top of their games. What I don’t get is how DiMaggio’s accomplishment is seen as the greatest ever (by far, it seems), and Williams’ is, well, not?

With all the attention the steroid era brought to home runs and all the attention Moneyball brought to the “base on balls,” we forget that a batter’s main objective is to get a hit.

I can’t imagine any batter walks to home plate with the intention of working four balls from the pitcher and taking his base. Sometimes a walk is necessary, and if it happens, you take your base, but hitters only want to do one thing when the ball leaves the pitcher’s hand—get a hit. Not for one game, not for five or 10 games, not even for “56”—but in every single at-bat of every single game.

BOSTON - CIRCA 1955:  (UNDATED FILE PHOTO) Baseball legend Ted Williams (1918 - 2002) of the Boston Red Sox  swings a bat in this portrait circa 1955. The 83-year-old Williams, who was the last major league player to bat .400 when he hit .406 in 1941, die
Getty Images/Getty Images

It’s worth noting that the 1941 season was not a breeze for Williams. He began the season with a broken bone in his right foot and missed most of April. That must have really upset him, because all Williams did was hit .436 in May. He then re-injured his foot after the All-Star Game, causing him to miss another 12 days, which he promptly followed by going 12-for-22 in his return to the lineup.

Don’t get me wrong—DiMaggio hit an awesome .408 during his 56-game hitting streak, but Williams hit .412 during that same stretch. In fact, he started his own hitting streak the same day DiMaggio began his, and Williams hit .489 during those 23 games.

Don’t you wonder if Williams purposely stopped his own streak, because he didn’t want to offend the greats of the game’s past by coming oh-so close to a .500 average? 

Shockingly, back in 1941, MLB counted sacrifice flies as at-bats. That meant that under today’s standards, Williams' actual average is several points higher (maybe as high as .419) depending on how certain at-bats would be scored.

Ted Williams’ 1941 season is so under-appreciated that we don’t even really know his true batting average. We just know it begins with a four.

COOPERSTOWN, NY - JULY 25:  A statue of Ted Williams is seen at the National Baseball Hall of Fame during induction weekend on July 25, 2009 in Cooperstown, New York.  (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)
Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

Maybe it is all Williams' fault. As noted here, Williams was likely to say his 1957 season was his best season. That was the year he finished hitting .388, one month after blowing out 39 candles on his birthday cake.

The very best seasons of Rod Carew, George Brett and Tony Gwynn were the only ones in the modern era good enough to stand next to a 39-year-old Ted Williams.

If there was ever going to be a Mount Rushmore of hitters, those three are all certainly in the conversation. Just make sure you have four or five profiles of the Splendid Splinter in place before you begin to carve anyone else's.

In the end, I suspect that Ted Williams’ 1941 season will only gain proper appreciation with each passing year, just as it has over the last 70. It had been the 28th time a hitter cracked the .400 barrier, so no one could really be expected to understand the magnitude of such an accomplishment.

It may take a few more generations of baseball fans to come and go before the most under-appreciated season in baseball history gets its just due. Those same future fans that will be trained to marvel at someone hitting .300 for a season, but when they open their iPad 17s to Ted Williams’ 1941 season page, my hope is that they will see what I see—the last time we witnessed a hitter compile a perfect season.


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.