2012 NFL Draft: First-Round Mock & Grading Picks for the Past Decade
With the NFL Draft less than a week away, I decided to take a look at the first round selections that every team has made over the past decade. The grades for each team were determined by the players entire careers and contributions, regardless of which team those contributions were made to, as I'm grading a team's ability to find first round talent, not their ability to retain players through free agency.
Additionally, I'll provide a 2012 First Round Mock, please leave your thoughts in the comments.
Arizona Cardinals
1 of 322002โWendell Bryant, DT (12)
2003โBryant Johnson, WR (17); Calvin Pace, DE/OLB (18)
2004โLarry Fitzgerald, WR (3)
2005โAntrel Rolle, CB/S (8)
2006โMatt Leinart, QB (10)
2007โLevi Brown, OT (5)
2008โDominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB (16)
2009โBeanie Wells, RB (31)
2010โDan Williams, DT (26)
2011โPatrick Peterson, CB (5)
The past decade has seen Arizona hit first-round home runs with Fitzgerald and Peterson, but they've also drafted some real duds, like Leinart, Brown and Bryant. Since 2008, though, things seem to be on an upswing.
Cardinals fans should hope the trend continues.ย
First Round Grade: B-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 13 Riley Reiff, OT, Iowa
Atlanta Falcons
2 of 322002โT.J. Duckett, RB (18)
2003โNone
2004โDeAngelo Hall, CB (8); Michael Jenkins, WR (29)
2005โRoddy White, WR (27)
2006โNone
2007โJamaal Anderson, DE (8)
2008โMatt Ryan, QB (3); Sam Baker, OT (21)
2009โPeria Jerry, DT (24)
2010โSean Weatherspoon, LB (19)
2011โJulio Jones, WR (6)
Atlanta definitely has more hits (Duckett, Hall, White, Ryan, Weatherspoon and Jones) than misses, but they can't seem to draft and develop defensive linemen in the first round to save their lives.
With John Abraham expected to retire soon, and possibly as early as next season, the Falcons will hopefully buck that trend.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: None
Baltimore Ravens
3 of 322002โEd Reed, S (24)
2003โTerrell Suggs, OLB (10); Kyle Boller, QB (19)
2004โNone
2005โMark Clayton, WR (22)
2006โHaloti Ngata, DL (12)
2007โBen Grubbs, OG (29)
2008โJoe Flacco, QB (18)
2009โMichael Oher, OT (23)
2010โNone
2011โJimmy Smith, CB (27)
Where to start with Baltimore. In the past decade, they've drafted two guys who have won Defensive Player of the Year (Reed, Suggs) and another who might actually be the best player on defense (Ngata).
They seem to have found their franchise QB in Flacco, and two studs on the O-Line in Grubbs and Oher.
First-Round Grade: A+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 29 Jonathan Martin, OT, Stanford
Buffalo Bills
4 of 322002โMike Williams, OT (4)
2003โWillis McGahee, RB (23)
2004โLee Evans, WR (13); J.P. Losman, QB (22)
2005โNone
2006โDonte Whitner, S (8); John McCargo, DT (26)
2007โMarshawn Lynch, RB (12)
2008โLeodis McKelvin, CB (11)
2009โAaron Maybin, DE/LB (11); Eric Wood, C (28)
2010โC.J. Spiller, RB (9)
2011โMarcell Dareus, DT/DE (3)
Buffalo has struggled with their picks in the first round. Mike Williams is widely considered to be one of the bigger draft busts in the past decade. Losman and Maybin were tremendous disappointments.
On the other hand, Lynch and McGahee have been pretty good backs in the NFL, just not for Buffalo. With the strong performance by Dareus last year and the emergence of Spiller as a playmaking threat after an awful rookie campaign, maybe Buffalo, like Arizona has turned it around.
First-Round Grade: C+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 10 Michael Floyd, WR, Notre Dame
Carolina Panthers
5 of 322002โJulius Peppers, DE (2)
2003โJordan Gross, OT (8)
2004โChris Gamble, CB (28)
2005โThomas Davis, LB (14)
2006โDeAngelo Williams, RB (27)
2007โJon Beason, LB (25)
2008โJonathan Stewart, RB (13); Jeff Otah, OT (19)
2009โNone
2010โCam Newton, QB (1)
The Panthers have done a tremendous job drafting in the first round. With two of the better linemen on either side of the ball with Peppers and Gross, solid players at RB and LB and a franchise QB who just won the Offensive Rookie of the Year Award, Carolina is doing just fine.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 9 Fletcher Cox, DT, Mississippi State
Chicago Bears
6 of 322002โMarc Colombo, OT (29)
2003โMichael Haynes, DE (14); Rex Grossman, QB (22)
2004โTommie Harris, DT (14)
2005โCedric Benson, RB (4)
2006โNone
2007โGreg Olsen, TE (31)
2008โChris Williams, OT (14)
2009โNone
2010โNone
2011โGabe Carimi, OT (29)
Chicago's first-round picks have left a lot to be desired. In the past decade, their best first-round pick has been Tommie Harris. They've drafted an offensive tackle three times in the first, and they still have one of the worst offensive lines in all of football. Only last year's pick is still with the team.
First-Round Grade: D-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 19 Whitney Mercilus, DE, Illinoisย
Cincinnati Bengals
7 of 322002โLevi Jones, OT (10)
2003โCarson Palmer, QB (1)
2004โChris Perry, RB (26)
2005โDavid Pollack, LB/DE (17)
2006โJohnathan Joseph, CB (24)
2007โLeon Hall, CB (18)
2008โKeith Rivers, LB (9)
2009โAndre Smith, OT (6)
2010โJermaine Gresham, TE (21)
2011โA.J. Green, WR (4)
Though Levi Jones and Chris Perry underperformed the expectations accompanying their draft slots, Cincinnati has had a solid decade drafting in the first. They've selected a franchise quarterback, an absolute stud at receiver, two legitimate No. 1 cornerbacks and a solid up-and-coming tight end.
2009 pick Andre Smith initially looked like a bust, but has turned it around and looks like a solid starter at RT.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 17 Kendall Wright, WR, Baylor; No. 22 Stephon Gilmore, CB, South Carolina
Cleveland Browns
8 of 322002โWilliam Green, RB (16)
2003โJeff Faine, C (21)
2004โKellen Winslow, TE (6)
2005โBraylon Edwards, WR (3)
2006โKamerion Wimbley, LB/DE (13)
2007โJoe Thomas, OT (3); Brady Quinn, QB (22)
2008โNone
2009โAlex Mack, C (21)
2010โJoe Haden, CB (7)
2011โPhil Taylor, DT (21)
Winslow and Edwards were expected to take the Browns offense to the next level, but failed to do so. However, with the drafting of Thomas, Mack, Haden and Taylor, the Browns look to have made the right call with four of their last five draft picks, andย Cleveland seems to be bucking the trend of bad draft picks.ย
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 4 Trent Richardson, RB, Alabama; No. 22 Nick Perry, DE, USCย
Dallas Cowboys
9 of 322002โRoy Williams, S (8)
2003โTerence Newman, CB (5)
2004โNone
2005โDeMarcus Ware, LB (11); Marcus Spears, DE (20)
2006โBobby Carpenter, LB (18)
2007โAnthony Spencer, LB (26)
2008โFelix Jones, RB (22); Mike Jenkins, CB (25)
2009โNone
2010โDez Bryant, WR (24)
2011โTyron Smith, OT (9)
Williams, Carpenter and Jones have been relative disappointments, and while Jenkins made the Pro Bowl as an alternate in 2009, he struggled in new defensive coordinator Rob Ryan's scheme last year.
All things considered, the Cowboys have still done alright for themselves in the first round. Headlined by Ware, Newman, Bryant and last year's pick Tyron Smith, the Cowboys have been able to find stars on both sides of the ball.
First-Round Grade: B+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 14 Mark Barron, S, Alabama
Denver Broncos
10 of 322002โAshley Lelie, WR (19)
2003โGeorge Foster, OT (20)
2004โD.J. Williams, LB (17)
2005โNone
2006โJay Cutler, QB (11)
2007โJarvis Moss, DE (17)
2008โRyan Clady, OT (12)
2009โKnowshon Moreno, RB (12); Robert Ayers, DE/LB (18)
2010โDemaryius Thomas, WR (22); Tim Tebow, QB (25)
2011โVon Miller, LB (2)
Excluding 2007, from 2004 on, the Broncos have had consistently solid first rounds. Lelie, Foster and Moss definitely were not as advertised, and due to injury, the jury's still out on Moreno, though he's been very inconsistent to this point in his career.ย
When it's all said and done, though, the Broncos have drafted a franchise QB in Cutler, a franchise LT in Clady, a franchise pass-rusher in 2011 Defensive Rookie of the Year Von Miller and a receiver that most expect to explode next year with Peyton Manning throwing to him in Thomas. Those are four of the five most important positions on a team.
First-Round Grade: A-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 25 Michael Brockers, DT, LSU
Detroit Lions
11 of 322002โJoey Harrington, QB (3)
2003โCharles Rogers, WR (2)
2004โRoy Williams, WR (7); Kevin Jones, RB (30)
2005โMike Williams, WR (10)
2006โErnie Sims, LB (9)
2007โCalvin Johnson Jr., WR (2)
2008โGosder Cherilus, OT (17)
2009โMatt Stafford, QB (1); Brandon Pettigrew, TE (20)
2010โNdamukong Suh, DT (2); Jahvid Best, RB (30)
2011โNick Fairley, DT (13)
From 2002 to 2006, the Lions were the laughingstock of the NFL draft. Taking a receiver in the first round for four of five years including three in a row just indicates how poorly they evaluated players.
While Gosder Cherlius could definitely be upgraded, as bad as the Lions were at drafting before 2007, they've been just as good since, landing the best receiver in the NFL, a franchise QB and one of the best defensive tackles in the league.
First-Round Grade: C+/B-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 23ย Cordy Glenn, G, Georgia
Green Bay Packers
12 of 322002โJavon Walker, WR (20)
2003โNick Barnett, LB (29)
2004โAhmad Carroll, CB (25)ย
2005โAaron Rodgers, QB (24)
2006โA.J. Hawk, LB (5)
2007โJustin Harrell, DT (16)
2008โNone
2009โB.J. Raji, DT (9); Clay Matthews, LB (26)
2010โBryan Bulaga, OT (23)
2011โDerek Sherrod, OT (32)
Over the past decade, Green Bay has found themselves picking in the second half of the first round more often than not. And while only a few names on this list will be recognized by the average NFL fan, they've been able to identify and select solid starters at a variety of positions who have contributed to the team's success.
While Carroll and Harrell have been disappointments and Hawk hasn't lived up to his No. 5 selection, the Packers drafted the best player in the NFL with the 24th pick in 2005.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 28 Shea McClellin, OLB, Boise State
Houston Texans
13 of 322002โDavid Carr, QB (1)
2003โAndre Johnson, WR (3)
2004โDunta Robinson, CB (10); Jason Babin, DE (27)
2005โTravis Johnson, DT (16)
2006โMario Williams, LB/DE (1)
2007โAmobi Okoye, DT (10)
2008โNone
2009โBrian Cushing, LB (15)
2010โKareem Jackson, CB (20)
2011โJ.J. Watt, DE (11)
First-round picks for the Texans have fallen on completely opposite ends of the spectrum. On the good end, you've got: Andre Johnson, Williams, Babin, Cushing and Watt. On the bad end: Carr, Travis Johnson and Okoye.
Additionally, Dunta Robinson has underperformed for a No. 10 selection, and Jackson struggled mightily in his rookie year, but had a solid sophomore campaign last season.
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 26 Stephen Hill, WR, Georgia Tech
Indianapolis Colts
14 of 322002โDwight Freeney, DE (11)
2003โDallas Clark, TE (24)
2004โNone
2005โMarlin Jackson, CB (29)
2006โJoseph Addai, RB (30)
2007โAnthony Gonzalez, WR (32)
2008โNone
2009โDonald Brown, RB (27)
2010โJerry Hughes, DE (31)
2011โAnthony Castonzo, OT (22)
For a team that most think of as successfully rebuilding through the draft, the Colts have done a pretty bad job drafting in the first round over the last decade.
Freeney and Clark have been key cogs to the success of the Colts, but since 2003, the list reads a lot like a list of underperformers and busts.
First-Round Grade: C-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 1ย Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford
Jacksonville Jaguars
15 of 322002โJohn Henderson, DT (9)
2003โByron Leftwich, QB (7)
2004โReggie Williams, WR (9)
2005โMatt Jones, WR (21)
2006โMarcedes Lewis, TE (28)
2007โReggie Nelson, S (21)
2008โDerrick Harvey, DE (8)
2009โEugene Monroe, OT (8)
2010โTyson Alualu, DT (10)
2011โBlaine Gabbert, QB (10)
All in all, the Jags have done a pretty bad job drafting in the first round. Henderson was a stud for most of his career, Lewis looked like a top-five tight end two years ago and Monroe is one of the better young tackles in the league.
Otherwise, Leftwich wasn't the franchise QB the Jags thought he was and Jones, Harvey and Nelson have been pretty terrible.
Blaine Gabbert looked downright awful at quarterback last year. As Gabbert goes, so too goes Jacksonville's grade. For the time being, it's looking pretty bleak.
First Round Grade: D+/C-
2012 First Round Pick: No. 7 Quinton Coples, DE, UNC
Kansas City Chiefs
16 of 322002โRyan Sims, DT (6)
2003โLarry Johnson, RB (27)
2004โNone
2005โDerrick Johnson, LB (15)
2006โTamba Hali, LB/DE (20)
2007โDwayne Bowe, WR (23)
2008โGlenn Dorsey, DT/DE (5); Brandon Albert, OT (15)
2009โTyson Jackson, DE (3)
2010โEric Berry, S (5)
2011โJonathan Baldwin, WR (26)
Excluding 2002 and 2009, the Chiefs have been very good at drafting players in the first round. Larry Johnson was at one point the best RB in the NFL. Johnson, Bowe and Hali have all been to the Pro Bowl.
Before tearing his ACL last year, Berry looked like the best young safety in the NFL, while Baldwin looks like he'll be able to take the Chiefs offense to the next level.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 11 David DeCastro, G, Stanford
Miami Dolphins
17 of 322002โNone
2003โNone
2004โVernon Carey, OT (19)
2005โRonnie Brown, RB (2)
2006โJason Allen, CB/S (16)
2007โTed Ginn, Jr., WR (9)
2008โJake Long, OT (1)
2009โVontae Davis, CB (25)
2010โJared Odrick, DT (28)
2011โMike Pouncey, C (15)
Since taking Jake Long in 2008, the Dolphins have added some very good young players to their roster in the first round. That doesn't change the fact that they missed badly in 2006 and 2007.
Ted Ginn had no business being selected in the top 10, but the Dolphins have done a pretty good job otherwise.
First-Round Grade: B+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 8 Ryan Tannehill, QB, Texas A&M
Minnesota Vikings
18 of 322002โBryant McKinnie, OT (7)
2003โKevin Williams, DT (9)
2004โKenechi Udeze, DE (20)
2005โTroy Williamson, WR (7); Erasmus James, DE (18)
2006โChad Greenway, LB (17)
2007โAdrian Peterson, RB (7)
2008โNone
2009โPercy Harvin, WR (22)
2010โNone
2011โChristian Ponder, QB (12)
The Vikings have drafted five Pro Bowlers, including two All-Pro players in Peterson and Harvin. Many thought Ponder was a reach with the 12th pick last year, but he managed to show why he was taken so high and looks to be the QB of the future for the Vikes.
2005 was an awful draft, though, as both Williamson and James were huge busts. Kenechi Udeze had a solid rookie year for Minnesota, but struggled with injuries throughout his career and was ultimately forced to retire due to cancer and chemotherapy-related difficulties.
First-Round Grade: A
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 3ย Matt Kalil, OT, USC
New England Patriots
19 of 322002โDaniel Graham, TE (21)
2003โTy Warren, DE (13)
2004โVince Wilfork, DT (21); Benjamin Watson, TE (32)
2005โLogan Mankins, OG (32)
2006โLaurence Maroney, RB (21)
2007โBrandon Meriweather, S (24)
2008โJerod Mayo, LB (10)
2009โNone
2010โDevin McCourty, CB (27)
2011โNate Solder, OT (17)
Belichick has done a very good job drafting in the first round, and the Pats' selections are highlighted by Wilfork, Mankins and Mayo. McCourty was second in the league in INTs his rookie year and was named to both the Pro Bowl and the All-Pro team.
Though he was a very productive college RB at Minnesota, Maroney was never able to achieve consistent success in the NFL
First-Round Grade: A-
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 27 Dont'a Higtower, LB, Alabama; No. 31 Vinny Curry, DE/OLB, Marshall
New Orleans Saints
20 of 322002โDonte Stallworth, WR (13); Charles Grant, DE (25)
2003โJonathan Sullivan, DT (6)
2004โWill Smith, DE (18)
2005โJammal Brown, OT (13)
2006โReggie Bush, RB (2)
2007โRobert Meachem, WR (27)
2008โSedrick Ellis, DT (7)
2009โMalcolm Jenkins, CB/S (14)
2010โPatrick Robinson, CB (32)
2011โCameron Jordan, DE (24); Mark Ingram, RB (28)
Like the Pats and Packers, the Saints have done a good job of adding solid players to their roster year after year. Brown has shown the ability to be an elite tackle at times, and Meachem was instrumental to New Orleans' prolific offense under Drew Brees.
Smith, Ellis and Jenkins have been solid on defense. However, Sullivan was a tremendous disappointment and Bush was not worthy of the No. 2 pick.ย
First-Round Grade: B+
2012 First-Round Pick: None
New York Giants
21 of 322002โJeremy Shockey, TE (14)
2003โWilliam Joseph, DT (25)
2004โEli Manning, QB (1)
2005โNone
2006โMathias Kiwanuka, LB/DE (32)
2007โAaron Ross, CB (20)
2008โKenny Phillips, S (31)
2009โHakeem Nicks, WR (29)
2010โJason Pierre-Paul, DE (15)
2011โPrince Amukamara, CB (19)
Over the past decade, the Giants have acquired a franchise QB, a playmaking WR, two solid pass-rushers and a corner who could become among the league's best.
They missed badly with Joseph, while Ross and Shockey never became the players the Giants hoped they would.ย
First-Round Grade: B+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 32ย Coby Fleener, TE, Stanford
New York Jets
22 of 322002โBryan Thomas, DE/OLB (22)
2003โDewayne Robertson, DT (4)
2004โJonathan Vilma, LB (12)
2005โNone
2006โD'Brickashaw Ferguson, OT (4); Nick Mangold, C (29)
2007โDarrelle Revis, CB (14)
2008โVernon Gholston, DE/LB (6); Dustin Keller, TE (30)
2009โMark Sanchez, QB (5)
2010โKyle Wilson, CB (29)
2011โMuhammad Wilkerson, DE (30)
The Jets are another one of those teams that drafts either very well or very poorly in the first round. In 2006, they solidified the two most important positions on the offensive line by drafting very good players in Ferguson and Mangold, and followed that up by drafting the best corner in the NFL in 2007 (Revis).
However, Gholston is considered to be an all-time bust, and Robertson was incredibly disappointing as well. The jury is still out on Wilson and Wilkerson, and on whether or not Sanchez is the franchise QB that every team needs.
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 16 Courtney Upshaw, OLB, Alabamaย
Oakland Raiders
23 of 322002โPhillip Buchanon, CB (17); Napolean Harris, LB (23)
2003โNnamdi Asomugha, CB (31); Tyler Brayton, DE (32)
2004โRobert Gallery, OT (2)
2005โFabian Washington, CB (23)
2006โMichael Huff, S (7)
2007โJaMarcus Russell, QB (1)
2008โDarren McFadden, RB (4)
2009โDarrius Heyward-Bey, WR (7)
2010โRolando McClain (8)
If you took McFadden and Asomugha off of this list, this might read like an "all-time draft busts" list.
Russell is the biggest bust ever. Gallery has been pedestrian at the very best during his career. Huff, Washington, Buchanon, Heyward-Bey and McClain have all considerablyย underperformed their respective draft slots.ย
First-Round Grade: F/D-
2012 First-Round Pick: Noneย
Philadelphia Eagles
24 of 322002โLito Sheppard, CB (26)
2003โJerome McDougle (15)
2004โShawn Andrews, OT (16)
2005โMike Patterson, DT (31)
2006โBrodrick Bunkley, DT (14)
2007โNone
2008โNone
2009โJeremy Maclin, WR (19)
2010โBrandon Graham, DE (13)
2011โDanny Watkins, OG (23)
The Eagles' first-round picks have left a lot to be desired. Sheppard is without question the best player on this list, making two Pro Bowls while also being named to the All-Pro team twice. McDougle and Andrews were plagued by injuries and other issues, and Patterson and Bunkley have been underachievers their entire careers.
Maclin looks like a nice young receiver, though, and Graham has shown his pass-rushing ability when healthy. Watkins looked good at times last year, and will hopefully benefit from a full offseason's worth of work.
First-Round Grade: C
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 15 Luke Kuechly, LB, Boston Collegeย
Pittsburgh Steelers
25 of 322002โKendall Simmons, OG (30)
2003โTroy Polamalu, S (16)
2004โBen Roethlisberger, QB (11)
2005โHeath Miller, TE (30)
2006โSantonio Holmes, WR (25)
2007โLawrence Timmons, LB (15)
2008โRashard Mendenhall, RB (23)
2009โZiggy Hood, DT/DE (32)
2010โMaurkice Pouncey, C (18)
2011โCameron Heyward, DE (31)
Like their AFC North counterpart Baltimore, the Steelers have done a very good job drafting in the first round. They've found Pro Bowlers (Polamalu, Roethlisberger, Pouncey and Miler) a couple of All-Pros (Polamalu and Pouncey), an Offensive ROY (Roethlisberger) and a Super Bowl MVP (Holmes).
Hood and Heyward should see an increase in playing time now that Aaron Smith has been released and Casey Hampton and Brett Keisel are getting up there in age.
First-Round Grade: A/A+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 24 Dontari Poe, DT, Memphisย ย
San Diego Chargers
26 of 322002โQuentin Jammer, CB (5)
2003โSammy Davis, CB (30)
2004โPhilip Rivers, QB (4)
2005โShawne Merriman, LB (12); Luis Castillo, DE (28)
2006โAntonio Cromartie, CB (19)
2007โBuster Davis, WR (30)
2008โAntoine Cason, CB (27)
2009โLarry English, DE/LB (16)
2010โRyan Mathews, RB (12)
2011โCorey Liuget, DT/DE (18)
The Chargers struck gold with Philip Rivers in 2004, and Jammer has been solid for San Diego at corner. Mathews had a pretty good sophomore year after a frustrating rookie season. Cromartie made a trip to the Pro Bowl in 2007 and was also named All-Pro.
Merriman was a beast for three seasons and made the Pro Bowl as well as the All-Pro team from 2005-2007, but he has completely fallen off the map since. English, the man drafted to replace Merriman, has done next to nothing.
Cason and Liuget both struggled last year, and both Buster and Sammy Davis didn't pan out.
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 18 Chandler Jones, DE/OLB, Syracuse
San Francisco 49ers
27 of 322002โMike Rumph, CB (27)
2003โKwame Harris, OT (26)
2004โRashaun Woods, WR (31)
2005โAlex Smith, QB (1)
2006โVernon Davis, TE (6); Manny Lawson LB/DE (22)
2007โPatrick Willis, LB (11); Joe Staley, OT (28)
2008โKentwan Balmer, DT (29)
2009โMichael Crabtree, WR (10)
2010โAnthony Davis, OT (11); Mike Iupati, OG (17)
2011โAldon Smith, LB (7)
Since 2005, the 49ers have done an excellent job of drafting in the first round, Balmer excluded. Staley, Davis and Iupati have made the 49ers O-Line one of the best in the NFL. Willis and Smith are two of the best linebackers playing the position, and Davis is perhaps the most athletic tight end ever.
Crabtree has been disappointing thus far, but has improved every season. Still, that doesn't change the fact that Rumph, Harris and especially Woods were all pretty big draft busts.
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 30 Amini Silatolu, G, Midwestern State
Seattle Seahawks
28 of 322002โJerramy Stevens, TE (28)
2003โMarcus Trufant, CB (11)
2004โMarcus Tubbs, DT (23)
2005โChris Spencer, C (26)
2006โKelly Jennings, CB (31)
2007โNone
2008โLawrence Jackson, DE (28)
2009โAaron Curry, LB (4)
2010โRussell Okung, OT (6); Earl Thomas, S (14)
2011โJames Carpenter, OT (25)
Seattle just hasn't done a good job of drafting in the first round. Excluding Trufant, Okung and Thomas, most of their picks have gone on to disappointing careers. Tubbs showed promise in his second season, but has missed considerable time to injury.
Stevens had a decent career, albeit with far too much baggage. Jennings was a solid bust, and Jackson, Curry and Spencer have all been traded. While they've found more success with their new teams, they haven't performed as expected.
Carpenter has potential and will benefit from a full offseason.
First-Round Grade: C
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 12 Melvin Ingram, DE/OLB, South Carolinaย
St. Louis Rams
29 of 322002โRobert Thomas, LB (31)
2003โJimmy Kennedy, DT (12)
2004โSteven Jackson, RB (24)
2005โAlex Barron, OT, (19)
2006โTye Hill, CB (15)
2007โAdam Carriker, DT (13)
2008โChris Long, DE (2)
2009โJason Smith, OT (2)
2010โSam Bradford, QB (1)
2011โRobert Quinn, DE (14)
The Rams struck gold with Steven Jackson in 2004, and they hope that they've found it again with Sam Bradford, who had a nice rookie season but was injured far too often during his sophomore campaign.
Long finally broke through last year, notching 13 sacks and if Quinn can parlay the full offseason into on-field success, he and Long could form one of the more dangerous end tandems in the league.
Thomas had a short and pedestrian career at linebacker, while Kennedy, Barron, Hill and Carriker left a lot to be desired.
First-Round Grade: B (will improve dramatically if Bradford can rebound and have a solid year in 2012)
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 6 Justin Blackmon, WR, Oklahoma State
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
30 of 322002โNone
2003โNone
2004โMichael Clayton, WR (15)
2005โCadillac Williams, RB (5)
2006โDavin Joseph, OG (23)
2007โGaines Adams, DE (4)
2008โAqib Talib, CB (20)
2009โJosh Freeman, QB (17)
2010โGerald McCoy, DT (3)
2011โAdrian Clayborn, DE (20)
If Williams could have stayed healthy, the Bucs grade would be a lot higher. After setting a rookie record for most rushing yards in the first three games of a running back's career, Williams has been absolutely decimated by injuries.
Joseph is a solid guard, and McCoy and Clayborn could develop into a solid tandem on the D-Line.
Freeman looked good as a rookie, but really turned in a disappointing year in 2011.
Talib has been a very good young corner, but his off-field issues threaten to derail his promising career.
First-Round Grade: C+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 5 Morris Claiborne, CB, LSUย ย
Tennessee Titans
31 of 322002โAlbert Haynesworth, DT (15)
2003โAndre Woolfolk, CB (28)
2004โNone
2005โPacman Jones, CB (6)
2006โVince Young, QB (3)
2007โMichael Griffin, S (19)
2008โChris Johnson, RB (24)
2009โKenny Britt, WR (30)
2010โDerrick Morgan, DE (16)
2011โJake Locker, QB (8)
The two highest-drafted players in the past decade saw off-field issues threaten their career on the field, and while Young might still have a chance to turn it around, Jones is on the shortest leash in the NFL.
Haynesworth had a chance to be an all-time great before becoming a "100 Million Dollar Man" and throwing out his work ethic. Johnson will look to return to 2009 form after a disappointing 2011 season. Morgan and Britt both looked good last year before tearing their ACLs, and hope to rebound this year.
Locker flashed potential when he was on the field last year, and could very well assume the starting role this season. Griffin is a top-10 free safety who has been to two Pro Bowls and was named All-Pro in 2010.
First-Round Grade: B+
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 20 Dre Kirkpatrick, CB, Alabama
Washington Redskins
32 of 322002โPatrick Ramsey, QB (32)
2003โNone
2004โSean Taylor, S (5)
2005โCarlos Rogers, CB (9); Jason Campbell, QB (25)
2006โNone
2007โLaRon Landry, S (6)
2008โNone
2009โBrian Orakpo (13)
2010โTrent Williams, OT (4)
2011โRyan Kerrigan, LB (16)
Rest in Peace, Sean. "The Meast" was an absolute, well, beast in the secondary for Washington, and following the drafting of Landry in 2007, Redskins fans had high hopes for "Area 51." Instead, Taylor was taken far too soon and Landry is a physical specimen who has struggled in coverage.
Orakpo and Kerrigan have formed one of the best pass-rushing duos in the NFL, and Williams could easily make the Pro Bowl in 2012.
First-Round Grade: B
2012 First-Round Pick: No. 3 Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

.jpg?w=2560)

.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)


.jpg?w=2560)
