Washington Capitals' Donald Brashear Receives Six-Game Suspension

Dave Nichols@@DaveNicholsDSPSenior Analyst IApril 27, 2009

NEW YORK - FEBRUARY 11:  Colton Orr #28 of the New York Rangers fights with Donald Brashear #87 of the Washington Capitals on February 11, 2009 at Madison Square Garden in New York City, New York.  (Photo by Nick Laham/Getty Images)

Washington Capitals winger Donald Brashear was given a one-game suspension for his pregame altercation with New York's Colton Orr, and a five-game suspension for a "shoulder hit to an unsuspecting player", Blair Betts, according to Collin Campbell, NHL Senior Executive Vice President of Hockey Operations.

Betts has a fractured orbital bone and is out indefinitely.

Brashear's suspension will be served beginning tomorrow night when the Capitals meet the Rangers in Game Seven of the series. The suspension will extend through the Capitals' next five 2009 playoff games, the 2009-10 regular season, or both, as circumstances warrant.

While it's fairly obvious the check was late, it's otherwise a perfectly legal shoulder check. Brashear's elbow comes up after the contact, it's not what initiated the contact. Brashear also obviously wanted to go after Aaron Voros, but Voros went straight to the bench and Betts was the next Ranger in the area.
The hit was vicious and late, but was it illegal? Neither referee on the ice thought sothe only penalty on Brashear was for the roughing with Paul Mara after the play. Could it be that the resulting injury made the act less defensible in the mind of Collin Campbell?
That's not right.

Betts was seriously injured on the play, but you know what could have avoided this? Betts keeping his head up. He had just dumped the puck and turned to go to the bench. He let his guard down in what has been a very tight-checking series.

Here's another quote from Campbell:

"It is also my opinion that the hit was delivered late and targeted the head of his opponent, causing significant injury."

"Targeted the head"? You mean like Orr clothes-lining Alexander Semin in Game Five?

Let's parse the last part of the quote: "causing significant injury." He did not say "with the intent to cause serious injury." Campbell effectively admits, in his choice of words, that he is penalizing Brashear for causing the injury, not for his intent. Again, this is wrong. It's not how the rule is supposed to be upheld.

If Betts was simply dazed, or even concussed, but not had his orbital bone broken, would we still be taking about five games?

While we're on the subject of "cheap shots", was this any worse than Brandon Dubinsky boarding Mike Green from behind? Dubinsky was given 14 penalty minutes, including a game misconduct.

Was Brashear's hit worse than Sean Avery butt-ending Milan Jurcina in Game Four, bloodying his nose and cheek? Or Avery high-sticking Brian Pothier in the same game, a player just returning from missing a year with concussion symptoms?
In both instances, Avery not only intended to injury, but in the butt-end instance, actually did injure. Shouldn't Avery, by Campbell's own carefully chosen words, be suspended for his hit on Jurcina in that case?

Wait, though. Game Four wasn't on NBC.

Or is this a case of Campbell caving in to Glen Sather's ridiculous e-mail after his coach's heinous actions in Game Five, where John Tortorella threw a water bottle into a group of fans, injuring a woman, and brandishing a stick in the direction of fans?

Tortorella received a one-game suspension, but Sather's long-winded letter, a letter he allowed published in the media, accused the Verizon Center staff of allowing mistreatment of the Rangers coaches and players. Basically, the fans were calling the players and coaches names, and Tortorella responded by throwing things into the stands.

So was Brashear's suspension affected by Sather's public letter of condemnation and the media attention it has received? It would appear so, since the on-ice officials didn't think the hit warranted a penalty.

"Make-up" calls happen all the time in hockey. This one is simply ridiculous.

slash iconYour sports. Delivered.

Enjoy our content? Join our newsletter to get the latest in sports news delivered straight to your inbox!