Amare Stoudemire Injury: How Act of Stupidity Will Actually Help NY Knicks

Ethan Norof@ethan_norofCorrespondent IMay 1, 2012

MIAMI, FL - APRIL 28:  Forward Amar'e Stoudemire #1 (R) of the New York Knicks is defended by Forward Udonis Haslem #40 of the Miami Heat in Game One of the Eastern  Conference Quarterfinals in the 2012 NBA Playoffs  on April 28, 2012 at the American Airines Arena in Miami, Florida. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this photograph, User is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement.  (Photo by Marc Serota/Getty Images)
Marc Serota/Getty Images

Amar'e Stoudemire's decision to challenge a fire extinguisher to a fight following Game 2's loss to the Miami Heat was perplexing, vexing and left several questioning his commitment to the team.

The New York tabloids have had a field day with Stoudemire leaving the arena in a sling with his hand bandaged. The $100 million power forward is set to meet with a hand specialist on Tuesday to determine the extent of the damage.

As of now, New York appears set to enter a must-win Game 3 in Madison Square Garden without its starting power forward.

Stoudemire's absence might be a blessing in disguise at just the right time.

I'm not going to sit here and attempt to convince anyone that the Knicks have a shot in climbing out of a two-game hole to upset the heavily favored Miami Heat.

That's not happening.

But Stoudemire's absence opens things up for Mike Woodson. He won't be forced to play Anthony and Stoudemire alongside one another on the floor together; a formula that clearly isn't working for New York.

Video Play Button
Videos you might like

Instead Anthony can slide back to power forward where he was absolutely rolling at season's end without Stoudemire in the lineup.

We've seen this from 'Melo previously—when the Knicks roll out a small lineup and use Anthony at power forward, he's incredibly effective due to the mismatches he creates on the defensive side of the ball.

MIAMI, FL - APRIL 30: Carmelo Anthony #7 of the New York Knicks talks with Reverend Jesse Jackson before Game Two of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals in the 2012 NBA Playoffs against the Miami Heat at American Airlines Arena on April 30, 2012 in Miami
Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

He brings big men away from the rim, and his unique combination of size and skill allows him to either beat his man off the dribble or find the open man on the floor.

Although the loss of Iman Shumpert (torn ACL in Game 1) will force the Knicks to rely on Landry Fields and J.R. Smith more heavily, this is about Anthony.

When Stoudemire signed his five-year, $100 million contract with the team, there was no doubt about who was the alpha male on the roster.

It's been a different story ever since Anthony arrived.

This is 'Melo's team. Some will argue that it shouldn't be, but those are likely the same fans who were screaming for him to be traded before the mid-March deadline.

Stoudemire and Anthony just don't work together on the floor.

Are they friends off the court? Yes. Are they both talented players? Yes.

Does that mean they're suited to play together in the same starting lineup? Absolutely not.

I've quipped about how Stoudemire should come off the bench behind Anthony at power forward since STAT was rehabbing from his back injury, but Woodson has been adamant about starting Stoudemire as long as he's healthy.

This isn't just about the injury. This is about something much, much deeper that is happening with Stoudemire that seemingly nobody wants to admit.

MIAMI, FL - FEBRUARY 27:  Carmelo Anthony #7 and Amar'e Stoudemire #1 of the New York Knicks talk during a game against the the Miami Heat at American Airlines Arena on February 27, 2011 in Miami, Florida. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agr
Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

Stoudemire is regressing.

Sure, we see flashes of Stoudemire looking like his old self. Sometimes, we watch him come off a pick and roll and wonder why he can't be that effective all of the time.

He's not the player he was in Phoenix, but that's the version of Stoudemire New York initially paid for when the club signed him as a free agent.

Stoudemire shot less than 50 percent from the floor for the majority of the regular season.

He took a step back from the foul line for the second straight season, and Stoudemire saw a drop in his average rebounds, steals and blocks from the 2010-11 campaign.

But there's even more than that.

The Knicks have played better without Stoudemire on the floor this season.

Before anyone throws accusations of biased writing in my direction, allow me to clarify.

Stoudemire is slowing this team down.

ESPN's Tom Haberstroh paints the picture very clearly.

Here's the scoreboard with Stoudemire on the floor this season:

Knicks 3,052, Opponents 3,099 -- or losing on average by 1.3 points every 48 minutes.

With Stoudemire on the bench?

Knicks 3,406, Opponents 3,153 -- or winning on average by 7.4 points every 48 minutes.

That's nearly a 10-point swing on a full-game level. Yes, the Knicks transformed from a lottery team into an elite team when Stoudemire left the court.

After sitting out all of April with a bulging disc in his back, Stoudemire returned for the Knicks' final four regular season games.

Is it a coincidence that Anthony (who only played in three of those games) failed to score more than 20 points in two of those three contests?

Before Stoudemire's return, Anthony had scored more than 25 points in seven of his previous nine games.

And all that talk about how Stoudemire and Anthony just don't fit together? There's more to that, too.

From Haberstroh:

Playing Carmelo Anthony and Stoudemire together was a lost cause. Actually, the Knicks outscored opponents on average by 8.4 points per 48 minutes this season when Anthony played without Stoudemire.

I recognize that the Knicks are going through a lot. No Shumpert, Tyson Chandler is at less than 100 percent, a gimpy Baron Davis and Jeremy Lin still being out as well is a lot for any team to endure.

This notion that Stoudemire's absence will definitely hurt the Knicks is entirely based in opinion.

The numbers dictate otherwise.

When it comes to Anthony and Stoudemire fitting together, perhaps now is the perfect time for the Knicks to stop trying to fit the round peg in the square hole.


    76ers Need Embiid to Dominate

    Some games Philly gets the best of Embiid, some games they don't. They'll need him to show up every night to succeed

    NBA logo

    76ers Need Embiid to Dominate

    Mo Dakhil
    via Bleacher Report

    Updated NBA Playoff Picture

    Check out the best stats, highlights and where each team stands after Friday's action ➡️

    NBA logo

    Updated NBA Playoff Picture

    Joe Tansey
    via Bleacher Report

    Magic Clinch Playoff Spot, Wizards Eliminated

    NBA logo

    Magic Clinch Playoff Spot, Wizards Eliminated

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report

    Nets Clinch Playoff Spot with Blowout Win Over Kings

    Caris LeVert and Joe Harris combine for 43 pts to help Nets lock up a playoff spot

    NBA logo

    Nets Clinch Playoff Spot with Blowout Win Over Kings

    Paul Kasabian
    via Bleacher Report