Why Retaining Chris Johnson Would Be a Horrible Move for the Tennessee Titans

Gary Davenport@@IDPSharksNFL AnalystFebruary 5, 2013

NASHVILLE, TN - DECEMBER 30:  Chris Johnson #28 of the Tennessee Titans rushes against the Jacksonville Jaguars at LP Field on December 30, 2012 in Nashville, Tennessee.  (Photo by Frederick Breedon/Getty Images)
Frederick Breedon/Getty Images

It's been quite a few years since the glory days of the Tennessee Titans, and ever since coming up a yard short in Super Bowl XXXIV, the team has been trying to recapture that magic.

A 6-10 season in 2012 was a significant step back in that regard and now it appears that a foolish financial decision may set the team back even further.

As Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports reports, the team is expected to exercise running back Chris Johnson's $10 million contract for 2013, $9 million of which becomes guaranteed this week.

Mind you, the 27-year-old remains a very good NFL running back. Johnson's 1,243 rushing yards in 2012 was the fifth time in five NFL seasons that he has eclipsed 1,000 yards on the ground.

That total ranked ninth in the NFL in 2012, but when you compare Johnson's yardage and compensation relative to the NFL's other top running backs, you begin to see where the problem lies.

2012 salary data courtesy of spotrac.com and Rotoworld


2012 Rushing Yards

2013 Salary

“Cost Per Yard”

Adrian Peterson


$10 million


Alfred Morris




Marshawn Lynch


$7 million


Jamaal Charles


$1.75 million


Doug Martin




Arian Foster


$5.25 million


Stevan Ridley




C.J. Spiller


$2.6 million


Chris Johnson


$10 million


Frank Gore


$3.3 million


As you can see, using 2012 production and 2013 salary as benchmarks, Johnson offers by far the worst return on investment of any of the NFL's top 10 rushers from a season ago.

In fact, four of the eight players who rushed for more yardage in 2012 make at least four times less per yard than Johnson does.

In other words, Chris Johnson is grossly overpaid.

It gets even worse when you look at Johnson through the lens of the running back grades at Pro Football Focus. Of the 59 running backs that PFF graded in 2012, Johnson ranked 58th, ahead of only Darren McFadden of the Oakland Raiders.

This is a mess that the Titans got themselves into. Johnson held out before the 2011 season, searching for the big payday that eluded him after he rushed for over 2,000 yards in 2009.

The Titans caved and it's a decision they've regretted ever since.

In each of the past two seasons, Johnson has gotten off to miserable starts and a back who once exploded through holes now spends far too much time dancing around behind the line of scrimmage.

Johnson's supporters will no doubt point to that line as part of the problem, and you'll get no argument here. In October, PFF ranked Tennessee's offensive line 19th in the NFL and the guard position is a particularly sore spot.

However, overpaying a running back doesn't solve that issue. It aggravates it. You can't fix the lousy offensive line because you're throwing money away on a running back.

I also get that the Titans are in a tough spot here. Overpaid as he may be, Chris Johnson is still the team's best playmaker on an offense lacking them and the odds of him taking a pay cut are probably slim to none—especially with the 2011 holdout still fresh in his mind.

However, when a team is rebuilding, sometimes tough decisions need to be made in the interest of moving forward.

Tennessee needs to approach Johnson and give him a simple choice: Restructure the deal, take a pay cut or take a hike.

Many fans may not like it, but it would be progress.

It's either that or the team can write the check and keep Chris Johnson as well as those fans happy.

Al least until another 6-10 season comes to an end.


    Franchise Records That Could Be in Danger in 2019

    Tennessee Titans logo
    Tennessee Titans

    Franchise Records That Could Be in Danger in 2019

    Music City Miracles
    via Music City Miracles

    Ranking NFL's Top Receiving Corps

    Tennessee Titans logo
    Tennessee Titans

    Ranking NFL's Top Receiving Corps

    Brent Sobleski
    via Bleacher Report

    NFL Rookies Already Turning Heads This Offseason

    NFL logo

    NFL Rookies Already Turning Heads This Offseason

    Gary Davenport
    via Bleacher Report

    Pacman Retires After Long, Strange Career

    Tennessee Titans logo
    Tennessee Titans

    Pacman Retires After Long, Strange Career

    Timothy Rapp
    via Bleacher Report