Andy Carroll: Should England Forward Accept Transfer to West Ham United?

Michael Cummings@MikeCummings37World Football Lead WriterAugust 1, 2012

BALTIMORE, MD - JULY 28: Andrew Carroll #9 of Liverpool waits for play to resume against the Tottenham Hotspur during a pre-season tour friendly match at M&T Bank Stadium on July 28, 2012 in Baltimore, Maryland. The match ended in a, 0-0, draw. (Photo by Patrick Smith/Getty Images)
Patrick Smith/Getty Images

Andy Carroll has become something of a bizarro Robin van Persie, holding on tight to a club that by all accounts do not seem to want him around.

Just like RvP, though, Carroll's future is highly uncertain.

With van Persie, we're seeing a classic case of a want-away star player. After scoring a league-high 30 goals for Arsenal last season, the 28-year-old Dutch international announced in July that he would not sign a new contract with the North London club (RobinvanPersie.com).

His current deal expires after the 2012-13 season, and those two facts have combined to fuel intense speculation over RvP's future.

With Carroll, it's entirely different, yet somehow similar.

Carroll, 23, joined Liverpool from Newcastle United in a £35 million deal in 2011 (BBC Sport). Since then, he's scored six league goals and 11 in all competitions.

Video Play Button
Videos you might like

Carroll's disappointing form has mirrored that of his club. Liverpool parted ways with manager Kenny Dalglish following the 2011-12 campaign, in which the Reds finished eighth in the English Premier League.

Despite a Carling Cup title under Dalglish in February 2012, the club's owners opted for a change and hired Brendan Rodgers from Swansea City in June (ESPNSoccernet).

Rodgers' arrival heralded a new era at Anfield, an era that seemingly has little use for Carroll. A big target man who's strong in the air, Carroll wouldn't seem to fit with Rodgers' preferred style of surface-of-the-pitch passing.

Almost since Rodgers' arrival, the rumors have poured forth, with Newcastle (Newcastle Evening Chronicle) and West Ham (The Guardian) reportedly interested.

As Carroll's former club, Newcastle makes sense as a potential destination. The Magpies finished fifth in the league last season and will return to European competition this season.

West Ham, however, is another story.

Liverpool reportedly accepted West Ham's offer—£2 million up front for a season-long loan and a potential £17 million more at the end of the season if the Hammers remain in the Premier League—but Carroll rejected the move.

ESPNSoccernet explains why:

[I]t is understood that Carroll is only willing to play for a club that is competing in European competition, and Newcastle United, who had earlier seen a bid rejected, would be his preferred destination if he is forced to leave Anfield.

The story didn't end there. The Sun reported Wednesday that West Ham have offered Carroll "a mind-boggling £36 million contract." The deal would pay Carroll his current salary of £90,000 per week for eight years.

It's unknown whether such an offer would convince Carroll. But should it?

If any of the reports are to be believed, Carroll is not wanted at Liverpool. It's possible that Newcastle want him back, but West Ham clearly have a strong interest.

What's more, Carroll would get a fresh start at West Ham, where he would almost certainly receive extensive playing time. It's doubtful he would play as much this season at Liverpool or even Newcastle.

On the other hand, Carroll is a full England international, and he does have a contract. Carroll is therefore entitled to stay if that is what he wants.

So what do you think, B/R community? Should Carroll go to West Ham, go to Newcastle or stay where he is?

Let me know in the comments section, and vote in the poll at right.


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.