Sabres Rebooted: How the Jack Eichel Trade Reinvigorated a Formerly Lost Franchise

BUFFALO, N.Y. – The first and last question asked after any sports trade is “Who won the deal?”

Nov. 4 will be the one-year anniversary of when the Buffalo Sabres traded Jack Eichel and a conditional third-round pick in 2023 to the Vegas Golden Knights for Alex Tuch, Peyton Krebs, a 2022 first-round pick (Noah Östlund), and a 2023 second-round pick. Both teams have to feel good about the returns so far.

Eichel has put up 10 points (four goals, six assists) in 10 games this season. Meanwhile, the Sabres should be thrilled with the haul of young players and picks they received.

That the Sabres can claim success after giving up the best player in the trade shows how well they did. Being handed the reins of a team whose best player wants out isn't ideal, but first-time general manager Kevyn Adams saw it as an opportunity for a fresh start.

"The day that trade was made, 100 percent of my attention and focus was on who we got in the trade and what we need to do here to be better," Adams said. "The reality is, you have to have players that believe in what you're doing as an organization and truly want to be part of it. And those two players in particular [Tuch and Krebs]—and I'll say Noah Östlund because now that we've drafted him—they fit that. And that, to me, was a really important part of this."

For Buffalo, it meant cutting the final ties to an era that began with losing for the purpose to improve lottery chances and jump-start a return to glory with elite talent. Sam Reinhart and Rasmus Ristolainen were already gone. Moving Eichel to Sin City meant virtually every major tie to the pre-Adams regimes was cut.

The Sabres were no longer putting the hopes of returning to the postseason for the first time since 2011—and the dreams of winning the Stanley Cup—all on the back of one player. Eichel was a dynamo capable of swinging a game by himself.

That approach didn’t work for the Sabres, though, because they lacked depth all over the roster. Instead, they decided to try assembling a more complete team, and Tuch gave them the spark they needed in the face of extreme change.

Tuch is a power forward the likes of which the Sabres haven’t had in ages. Nothing excites a Buffalo crowd more than a guy who can crunch opponents along the boards and fill the net.

"Something that he brings that's a little different is just as his size and his strength," teammate Tage Thompson said. "He's a beast out there, and combined with his speed, I think it catches a lot of people by surprise. They think they’ve got a lot more time with the puck and then he's right on you, which is good for us because we get the puck back quicker and then we get to go play offense."

In 50 games with the Sabres last season, Tuch had 12 goals and 38 points. He's off to a hot start this season, as he's tied with Thompson, Victor Olofsson and Rasmus Dahlin for the team lead in goals with six. He’s third on the team in points with nine, behind Thompson and Dahlin (12).

That’s the kind of impact the Sabres hoped he would provide with more ice time and opportunities than he had in Vegas.

"(Tuch) is clearly a player that other guys identify within the locker room as already a great, elite talent in the NHL, and the potential to be extremely impactful where we envision he can get to, that's clear and evident," Sabres head coach Don Granato said. "It's nice to have another player that comes in with that talent and that experience and still feels like a young guy. That's a great combination of everything."

In Vegas, Tuch was a young player in a sea of outstanding skilled veterans. The move to Buffalo turned him into one of the Sabres' most experienced veteran players at age 26.

"I was the youngest guy on the team (in Vegas), or at least when it came to games played, so I was pretty much a rookie for three years," Tuch said. "Now, it's crazy to be in the upper echelon in age on a team and you have all these younger guys below you."

Fans took to Tuch’s on-ice leadership immediately, and his teammates were right there with them. What’s more, neither Adams nor Granato asked him to adjust his affable, gregarious and fun-loving nature to act more like a leader.

It turns out that having him be himself is the exact kind of leader they needed. How he carries himself is infectious.

"He's a great guy," Thompson said. "He's always in a good mood, so whether you're having a good or a bad day coming to the rink, he's always buzzing around. So it's good for the atmosphere in the room, and I think that translates onto the ice as well."

The addition of Krebs provided Buffalo with another offensively gifted player. Not since 2006 have the Sabres had so many young, skilled players, each of whom has distinct talents.

The 21-year-old Krebs' passing and vision is what allows him to stand out among the snipers, danglers and net crashers.

"That's a guy that no matter where I put him, on wing or at center, anybody and everybody's excited that he's on his line," Granato said. "They just believe that he can get them the puck, that he's going to make plays. And he's a fun guy to play with because he's creative."

Buffalo's lack of secondary scoring behind Eichel was glaring whenever he didn't produce. If he had an off night, the Sabres were virtually doomed to lose.

That’s no longer a problem. They can spread the wealth among a few lines.

"One of the things that we spent a lot of time working on was, how do we make sure any deal we make is looking at the long term, not doing something reactionary, or with a short-term focus," Adams said. "That's why it was so critical for us in that deal with Alex that he's in the prime of his career and he had term on his contract. You get Peyton, who's in his first year of an entry-level [contract] that we think is going to be a really good player for us, and he has been, and he will continue to get better."

Minding the here and now as well as down the road is the key point of what it means to be an NHL general manager. The Sabres as previously constructed weren’t in position to immediately challenge for the Stanley Cup.

Right now, things are trending up. The Sabres are 6-3-0 with 12 points through nine games. It took them 11 games to reach 12 points last season.

They're taking baby steps, but with huge leaps in progress for their most important players.

"It's exciting to be part of something that's getting better every day," Krebs said. "It's been a lot of fun, and I'm excited to see where we go from here."