It's every fan's worst nightmare.
There's a player on the ice for your team. He is highly regarded around the league, paid like a superstar and a total fan favorite. The only problem is, you cannot figure out why.
Every team has a player or two who is overrated by some or all of the fanbase and/or the hockey world in general.
Perhaps it's a player who puts up numbers but does so only because of the players around him. Maybe a player is overrated because he fails to contribute in all three zones of the ice.
Whatever it may be that causes a team's pricey skater to be overrated, there is rarely a consensus on the issue.
From my point of view, here is the most overrated player on each NHL team. Feel free to let me have it and get the discussion going. That's the best way to cope with these issues.