The 12 Best NHL Rookies of 2009-10
The NHL nominates three finalists for each trophy they hand out tonight in Las Vegas. Three is never enough to properly do honour to all the players who could legitimately have a shot at one of these year-end trophies.
This has never been more true than this year, when Tyler Myers of the Buffalo Sabres, Jimmy Howard of the Detroit Red Wings, and Matt Duchene of the Colorado Avalanche compete for the honour of being named NHL rookie of the year and winning the Calder Memorial Trophy.
The cap-strapped NHL has seen many teams push rookies into the lineup, and a lot of those rookies have been contributing and excelling despite their inexperience. Colorado seemed ready to run with an all-rookie lineup for long stretches of the season.
Here is a deeper look at the 2009-10 rookie class and how the top dozen rookies in the league fared last year.
12. Victor Hedman—D, Tampa Bay Lightning
19 yrs old 6'6" 220 lbs. GP 74 G 4 A 16 PTS 20
Hedman came into the league touted as perhaps the most NHL-ready of last year's draft choices. He certainly was NHL-sized. He still has a huge learning curve to climb to be a top-rate NHL defenseman.
That said, he played 74 games last year and averaged over 20.5 minutes a game played. He helped stabilize what was one of the worst defenses in the NHL, and while his offensive contributions were spotty at best, expect improvement as he adjusts to NHL speed and size.
11. Dmitry Kulikov—D, Florida Panthers
19 yrs old 6'1" 183 lbs. GP 68 G 3 A 13 PTS 16
The slick-skating Kulikov showed confidence and savvy with the puck far beyond most players his age. He was a big member of another shaky Panther defense.
He missed 14 games last year with a knee injury, but look for great things from Kulikov as a sophomore.
10. James Van Riemsdyk—LW, Philadelphia Flyers
20 yrs old 6'3" 211 lbs. GP 78 G 15 A 20 PTS 35
The young power forward was a hugely anticipated addition to the lineup in Philadelphia. He got off to a hot start but couldn't maintain it through the entire NHL season.
His first season was still a good one, and he had a presence in the playoffs that needed to be dealt with. Van Riemsdyk should be a force in the league for years to come.
9. T.J. Galiardi—LW ,Colorado Avalanche
21 yrs old 6'2" 172 lbs. GP 70 G 15 A 24 PTS 39
The lean Galiardi was on a hot streak coming out of the Olympics. He was earning top-six minutes by the end of the season and killing penalties for the Avalanche. He was an important part of Colorado's drive for the playoffs.
8. Michael Del Zotto—D New York Rangers
19 yrs old 6'0" 211 lbs. GP 80 G 9 A 28 PTS 37
The soon to be 20-year-old had a great first season with the Rangers. He was thrown in the deep end, and mostly he swam. He spent a fifth of his minutes on the team's power play and played almost 19 minutes a night for what was ostensibly an entire season.
The offensively skilled Del Zotto was another rookie who started hot and cooled as the season progressed, but his 37 points were an impressive total for any rookie, let alone a defenseman.
7. Erik Karlsson—D, Ottawa Senators
20 yrs old 5'11" 165 lbs. GP 60 G 5 A 21 PTS 26
The tiny Swede played over 20 minutes a game on a defense that gave up the fourth fewest shots on goal in the league last year.
He struggled early in the season, but he's another offensively skilled, puck-moving defenseman who excelled as a rookie this year.
He managed 12 points in his last 10 regular season games and then followed that up with an impressive point-a-game performance in the Senators' first round loss to Pittsburgh.
He looks to have found his stride in the NHL and could have a breakout offensive year in 2010-11.
6. Jamie Benn—LW, Dallas Stars
20 yrs old 6'2" 185 lbs. GP 82 G 22 A 19 PTS 41
Jamie played a full season in Dallas mostly as a third line checker yet managed a solid half-point a game and 22 goals.
Benn had a solid defensive year in Dallas and probably deserves consideration as one of the top 12 defensive forwards in the league.
On a team that features former Selke Trophy winners Jere Lehtinen and Brenden Morrow, Benn led the team in takeaways with 70 (seventh best in the league) and takeaway to giveaway differential (+33). He was a big hitter and logged a lot of penalty kill minutes this year.
Look for Benn to compete for the Selke soon.
5. John Tavares—C, New York Islanders
19 yrs old 6'0" 195 lbs. GP 82 G 24 A 30 PTS 54
Young John Tavares was another preseason pick to win the Calder. He had a great offensive year despite not much of a supporting cast on the Island.
A stress fracture suffered at the World Championships didn't cause him to miss any games, but the stress of being New York's one big star seemed to tell by year end.
Still, Tavares led an improved Islander team up from the basement. Look for some talent to be added this year, and expect Tavares to be closer to a point a game player for the Islanders next year.
He'll have to work on his face-offs in the offseason as well. The rookie only won 47.5 percent of the 1,129 face-offs he took.
4. Matt Duchene—C, Colorado Avalanche
19 yrs old 5'11" 200 lbs. GP 81 G 24 A 31 PTS 55
Matt had a much easier introduction to the NHL than John Tavares did. He got to play second line center behind the established Paul Stasny in Colorado.
The Avalanche also provided him with a nice blend of talented youngsters and skilled veterans to play with, and he led all rookies in scoring last year.
He had even more trouble than Tavares did in the face-off circle. He played almost as many minutes a game as Tavares but with the deeper Avalanche lineup got almost 100 minutes less power play time over the season.
He was a key part of bringing Colorado back into the playoffs after they finished last in the West the year before.
3. Jimmy Howard—G, Detroit Red Wings
26 yrs old 6'1" 204 lbs. GP 63 W 37 GAA 2.26 SVP .924 SO 3
Howard was barely eligible this year as a rookie in Detroit. He won the starting job from Chris Osgood and carried an enormous workload as a first-time NHL starter.
His .924 save percentage was fourth best in the league, tied with Montreal's Jaroslav Halak. His goals against average was fifth best in the league. This was all on a Detroit team whose defense loosened up this year.
He also managed to outduel the highly regarded Ilya Bryzgalov in the first round of the playoffs.
After three seasons as a backup, Howard seems to have established himself as the Red Wings' goalie for the future.
2. Tuukka Rask—G, Boston Bruins
23 yrs old 6'2" 171 lbs. W 22 GAA 1.97 SVP .931 SO 5
Former Leaf pick Rask had a very similar year to Jimmy Howard in Detroit. He beat out last year's Vezina Trophy winner Tim Thomas for the starting job in Boston. He beat out the highly regarded Ryan Miller in a first round defeat of Buffalo.
While not carrying the workload of Howard, he managed to lead the league in GAA and save percentage.
Rask was the difference between winning and losing for a Boston team that couldn't buy an extra goal this year and gave up a middle of the league 29.8 shots against per game.
Rask definitely should have been one of the NHL's final three nominees for rookie of the year.
1. Tyler Myers—D, Buffalo Sabres
20 yrs old 6'8" 220 lbs. GP 82 G 11 A 37 PTS 48
The towering Myers came into the league like a latter-day Larry Robinson. Robinson took a few years to get his legs under him and find his offensive chops. Myers has stepped right in and replaced Jaroslav Spacek's missing offense.
The big youngster played a full season and almost 24 minutes a game. His intimidating presence and offense make him a Zdeno Chara-like player.
His league-leading 94 giveaways are cause for concern, but he's sure to tighten up that aspect of his game with experience. The big man was a huge shot blocker this year as well.
Tyler Myers should win this year's Calder Memorial Trophy.