Michael Vick vs Tony Romo: Which QB Is Riskier Fantasy Football Starter?

Now that quarterbacks Tony Romo and Michael Vick are both playing in their respective games this weekend, fantasy owners can breathe a sigh of relief. Though they are taking the field, however, doesn't mean that the quarterbacks don't carry with them significant risk. Weighing the evidence of both injuries, I believe Romo is the riskier fantasy football start.

While Vick has progressed through the NFL's battery of concussion tests on his path to be cleared to play against the New York Giants and thus is asymptomatic, Romo's broken rib and punctured lung has no associated guidelines to determine if he's healthy enough to play. If Vick continued to have pain related to his injury, he'd be forced to sit. With Romo, who is likely still in pain, he can play regardless.

Romo will be taking the field against a Washington Redskins defense gunning for his injured ribs. While the hole in his lung has healed, it is probable his rib is still broken and causing him significant pain.

Even with cortisone shots, Romo's mobility will be limited on Monday night. Further, he runs a risk of re-injury that is greater than Vick. Just one hit to the ribs, and Romo might have to exit the game. Types of hits that Vick could easily manage will become a greater concern for Romo, just based on the nature of his injury.

It is doubtful that, even if Romo remains in significant pain on Monday, he will sit. The Dallas Cowboys are facing a division rival who, with a win, will lead the NFC East with a 3-0 record.

A Cowboys loss would put the team in a very real hole when it comes to the pursuit of winning their division, even if it is only Week 3.

If you're an extremely fortunate fantasy GM with both Romo and Vick as your quarterback options, then Vick is easily the less risky play. However, in reality, very few fantasy owners are in that situation.

Depending on your depth at the position, sitting Romo might be a good idea. However, if you have no better option, go ahead and start him this week. While it is a major risk, if he's willing and able to play, he's guaranteed to benefit your team. Just keep in mind he may not do so for a full four quarters.