To Mike Huber, Aaron Judge’s decision seemed like a simple math equation. Huber, Judge’s high school football coach, had seen the offer letters flow in from the likes of Notre Dame, Stanford and UCLA. He figured that four or five years at any of those schools, plus room and board, would have to amount to nearly $1 million. But Aaron Judge didn’t want to play football, so he skirted those full scholarships in favor of a partial ride to Fresno State to play baseball.
“Those were some pretty animated conversations,” Huber says now.
Judge had grown up a baseball player, but as he’d grown into a 6'6", 205-pound sophomore at Linden (California) High School, some other coaches coveted him for their squads as well. Fortunately for Huber, he was a friend of Aaron’s adoptive parents, Patty and Wayne Judge. With their blessing, he tried out Aaron—then a pitcher—at quarterback.
McCollum and the Blazers Snapped Postseason Losing Streak for "Jennifer"
Spencer Is the Real Winner of the Boston Marathon
Stars Invest in Plant-Based Food as Vegetarianism Sweeps NBA
The NBA Got Some Wild Techs This Season
Jarrett Allen Is One of the NBA’s Hottest Rim Protectors
Wade's Jersey Swaps Created Epic Moments This Season
NBA Squads Brought the Heat with Bench Reactions This Year
Westbrook Makes History While Honoring Nipsey Hussle
Nation’s Top-Ranked H.S. Teams Will Play for a National Title
Is 20-Year-Old Undefeated Ryan Garcia Boxing's Next Superstar?
Devin Booker Makes History with Scoring Tear
29 Years Ago, Jordan Dropped Career-High 69 Points
MLB Players Are Getting Wild Inspiration for Their Cuts
Bosh Is Getting His Jersey Raised to the Rafters in Miami
Carsen Edwards Put on a Show vs. the Defending Champs
Gabe Kalscheur Is Early Breakout Star of March Madness
Barrett, Brazdeikis Lead Canadian Hoops Revolution to March Madness
UM's Ignas Brazdeikis Is the Villain of March Madness
OBJ's Trade to Cleveland Has the Browns Hyped
Steph Returns to Houston for 1st Time Since His Moon Landing Troll
But as many two-sport athletes discover, the motions for pitching and throwing a football are completely different. In football, quarterbacks rely largely on their body and their wrist. Throwing a baseball is more about shoulder strength and finger position on the ball. It’s hard to imagine now, with Judge a burgeoning star in the Bronx—leading MLB in home runs (30), slugging (.691), WAR (5.3), offensive WAR (4.8) and runs created (94)—but he did have one athletic weakness in high school. And Huber found it.
“He didn’t stick at quarterback because he couldn’t throw the ball very well,” Huber says while laughing. “We made the decision to make him a receiver, which he became prolific at. For as big as he is—he was 225 pounds at the end of his senior year—he was still lanky and really quick. He could run.”
Huber allowed Judge to develop for a year on the JV team before calling him up to varsity as a junior. As the No. 2 option behind senior Beau Slaton (who once recorded 282 receiving yards in a single game), Judge finished his junior season with 32 catches for 446 yards and four touchdowns.
“Growing up I always thought I’d be a basketball player because I was so tall,” he told a local newspaper, The Record, shortly after graduating from high school. “When it came to my junior year, I started getting a lot of letters for football. But once ... I started going to a lot of baseball camps I knew this is what I’m going to go with.”
The summer before his final season at Linden, The Record offered a prescient prediction of his upcoming football performance: “The 6'6", 205-pound senior is the biggest wide receiver in the league. If he can add strength this season, the rest of the [league] is going to have its hands full.”
And have their hands full they did. Judge set school records for single-season receiving yards (969) and touchdown receptions (17). And he did it all on just 54 catches, averaging a remarkable 17.9 yards per catch. His quarterback, Austin Alvarez, summed up the team’s offensive strategy succinctly: “We either tossed it up to Aaron or, if that didn’t work for some reason, I would run the ball.”
He was particularly prolific in the red zone, as Huber drew up a jump-pass play similar to what Tim Tebow popularized at the University of Florida. Judge would line up as a tight end and slip into the end zone, where Alvarez would heave a lob up high in the air for him. “He didn’t even have to jump very high,” Huber says. “He was a basketball player. We said, this is a rebound for you—just go up and get it. It was kind of a no-brainer to put him in that situation.”
Alvarez was also Judge’s point guard in basketball. They had both made varsity as sophomores, and that year, when Alvarez saw Judge battle with future UCLA player Reeves Nelson (who attended nearby Modesto Christian) and put up a double-double, he knew his friend was college-bound in one sport or another. In his senior season, Judge averaged 18.2 points and 12.8 rebounds a game.
“He was basically my all-around go-to guy,” Alvarez says. “I’d toss the ball up in both sports. He’d either go up and grab it in the post and get a bucket or he’d come down in the end zone for a touchdown.”
Judge would also use his size to his advantage in extracurricular athletic endeavors. At Alvarez’s house one day during his senior year, the football team thought it would be funny to have the smallest member of the team, a 5'5" corner named Cody St. John, wrestle the largest member of the team, Judge. When the match started, Judge lifted St. John up with one hand and dropped him onto the ottoman in the living room, snapping the wheels off the furniture. When they played Nerf basketball on Alvarez’s indoor hoop, Judge would dominate the games, lording over the other players trying to get to—or stop him from getting to—the eight-foot rim.
Alvarez, who also ran track, managed to beat Judge out for athlete of the year when they were juniors, but Judge swept the awards their senior season. The football, basketball and baseball teams each selected him as their MVP, and The Record named him an All-Area selection in each sport.
But by then, he’d already decided he was going to play college baseball. Even after the Oakland A’s selected him in the 31st round of the 2010 MLB draft, he didn’t waver. “I like the baseball program, I like the coaches, and I like the (school),” Judge told The Record in 2009. “They want me as a dual player, so they want me to play first base when I’m not pitching.”
Huber watched glowingly from afar as Fresno State flipped Judge from pitcher to infielder and outfielder. The only exception to his rooting interest came when Judge played winter ball in Cape Cod. Huber, a lifelong Yankees fan, would scowl when Judge sent him a picture of himself in a Red Sox cap. When the Yankees drafted Judge 32nd overall in 2013, one of the first messages Huber sent him was to burn that hat.
Although Huber remembers Judge’s parents at times wanted him to be traded—they were worried about Judge being stuck for an extended period in the minors behind Carlos Beltran—it became his dream to see Judge homer at Yankee Stadium. Once Judge was called up, it didn’t take long: He went yard in his first at-bat as a major leaguer, and the power surge hasn't let up since.
“If that had been me,” Huber says, “I would have dropped the bat and walked out of the stadium and retired a happy man.”
When the Yankees visited the A’s in June, Huber took in the game from the stands. He says he rarely speaks to Judge during the season, as he knows Judge has enough attention already. And he knows that Judge’s success is due in part to sidestepping his coach’s advice.
“I kidded him one day and said, ‘See, I pushed you so hard you made the right decision,’” Huber says. “He just laughed. Aaron could have probably played at the college level in all three sports. He certainly picked the right sport for longevity and for his body. As animated as I was about the schools coming after him and the scholarships, he stuck to his guns and did the right thing.”