Has Darren Huckerby Overstayed His Welcome?

When the former Norwich City stand-out came into the MLS in July of the 2008 season to play for the struggling San Jose Earthquakes, he was unknown to most and ready to make his name known. And boy did he ever.

Catching the hearts of San Jose fans, Huckerby played only half of the MLS season, but captured the highest goal total on his own team, won team MVP, and Newcomer of the Year for 2008.

It seemed that with his addition, the contributions of mid season pick-up Scott Sealy, and rising talent Shea Salinas would springboard the expansion 'Quakes into a successful 2009 season and beyond.

Unfortunately, this was not the case. Most noticeably, the contributions of Darren Huckerby have fallen short. Some can blame his right thigh strain earlier in the season that caused him to miss a handful of games during the opening third of 2009.

A combination of his poor in-game decisions and the league's ability to adapt to his explosive left-wing play have brought about the demise of Huckerby and the 'Quakes this season.

Furthermore, as the team MVP, Huckerby gathered huge expectations from a fan base that lost their successful MLS franchise to Houston after the 2005 season. Recently, it appears that his performance has been less than satisfactory. Unfortunately, he has continued to receive extended playing time and hype from the organization.

With only two goals and two assists so far this season, his success has dwindled. He has underperformed, regardless of what excuse is made by fans, coaches, etc. I'm almost ready to say that he is past his prime in this league.

In recent games, his contributions to the team have been limited to a few selected attacks down the left wing and his ability to draw a foul or two, giving the 'Quakes some dangerous set pieces—nothing compared to his impact in 2008.

His ability to obliterate teams' defense from the outside and create scoring chances for his team have been lost in the glory of his MLS rookie season. He's 33, and maybe his best years are behind him.

As a fan, and someone that wants the best for this team, it only seems right to move on. His finishing has suffered, his impact has lessened, and he is no longer the threat that he was last season.

I believe it's time for fan favorite, rising star, and Furman graduate Shea Salinas to see time on the field. He's 23 and his Huckerby-of-old explosiveness and quick feet are a few sparks the 'Quakes need in the coming seasons to make this club a powerhouse like they were years ago.