2011 NHL Season: Projecting the Top 20 Defencemen

1 of 22

NASHVILLE, TN - APRIL 24: Cam Fowler #4 of the Anaheim Ducks carries the puck in front of Matt Halischuk #24 of the Nashville Predators in Game Six of the Western Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Bridgestone Arena on A

Cam Fowler will be among the top-20 NHL defencemen soon, but not in 2011-12
Frederick Breedon/Getty Images

The NHL blue line is defined by players at the top. Teams who rely on those players most are the ones that succeed.

Of the 16 playoff teams last season, only Anaheim did not have a defenceman lead its team in minutes per game. Even though the forward they put on the ice more than any defenceman was Hart Trophy winner Corey Perry, they went 2-4.

Half of the playoff teams had only one or two defenceman on the ice in each game more than their top forward. Their combined record was 44-47 (.484) overall and 7-9 (.438) in series. Those that had at least three defencemen at the top went 43-38 (.606) overall and 8-5 (.615), including both Stanley Cup finalists.

Thus in last season's playoffs, a team that leaned on three defencemen more than any other player won their series 20 percent more often than those that did not. But was this a one-year anomaly?

Since the lockout, teams with defencemen who play over 25 minutes a game in the playoffs have a 94-79 series record (.543), while those who did not went 19-27 (.413), winning 13 percent less often. Nine of the 12 conference champions, and seven of the last eight, have had a player they leaned on that heavily.

In other words, no one has more time to affect a game than an elite player on the blue line, and without one, no blue line is elite. Unless a player is good enough to be an asset on both the power play and penalty kill, they are not an elite player.

Based on their performances last season, their age and supporting cast, I project the following defencemen to be the 20 best in the league in 2011-12...

20: P.K. Subban

MONTREAL, CANADA - APRIL 26: P.K. Subban #76 of the Montreal Canadiens looks to make a pass from the far boards in Game Six of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals against the Boston Bruins during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at the Bell Centre on A

Phillip MacCallum/Getty Images

P.K. Subban should continue to mature as a person and as a player over the season. This will allow him to improve over his already impressive 2010-11 numbers (77 GP, 14 G, 24 A, -8, 124 PIM, 22:16 TOI) that show he is already a two-way force.

19: Kris Letang

TAMPA, FL - APRIL 25: Kris Letang #58 of the Pittsburgh Penguins checks Sean Bergenheim #10 of the Tampa Bay Lightning in Game Six of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at the St. Pete Times Forum on April 25, 20

Eliot J. Schechter/Getty Images

Kris Letang already has a Stanley Cup and is just 24 years old. Yet he has had three seasons in a row with fewer than 10 games missed and at least 27 points. Last season, he had 50 points, a plus-15 rating and over 24 minutes per game.

18: Niklas Kronwall

DETROIT - MAY 4: Niklas Kronwall #55 of the Detroit Red Wings waits for a face off against the San Jose Sharks in Game Three of the Western Conference Semifinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs on May 4, 2011 at Joe Louis Arena in Detroit, Michig

Jamie Sabau/Getty Images

Niklas Kronwall's physical style of play has taken its toll on the 30-year-old in recent years, as he has missed 72 games over the last five seasons. However, two of his last three seasons were at least 77 games long, so I am projecting relative health.

Kronwall balances his physicality with discipline and offensive productions, scoring nearly a point per two games over his career. Last season, he played in 77 games, registered 37 points, had a plus-five rating and just 36 PIM. He knows how to win big games, earning a Stanley Cup, Olympic gold medal and two conference championships.

17: Tyler Myers

PHILADELPHIA, PA - APRIL 26: Tyler Myers #57 of the Buffalo Sabres controls the puck against Daniel Carcillo #13 of the Philadelphia Flyers in Game Seven of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Wells Fargo Cent

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

Tyler Myers is set to begin just his third year in the league, and already the former Calder Trophy winner is an elite two-way player. Missing just two games over his first two years, he has scored over a point per two games, finished in the plus both seasons and registered just 72 PIM.

As he develops his game and his body, he will be a regular Norris Trophy Finalist. This year, he already has a good chance at making the All-Star Game.

16: Alexander Edler

BOSTON, MA - JUNE 13: Alexander Edler #23 of the Vancouver Canucks skates with the puck during Game Six of the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Final at TD Garden on June 13, 2011 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

Elsa/Getty Images

Alexander Edler missed over a third of the season last year, and he might have been already considered among the league's elite had he not been injured. The 25-year-old has never finished in the negative for plus-minus rating, and shows discipline to stay out of the box as well, with just 64 PIM to 75 points in 127 games over the past two seasons.

15: Dion Phaneuf

TORONTO, CANADA - SEPTEMBER 19: Dion Phaneuf #3 of the Toronto Maple Leafs roughs up Chris Neil #25of the Ottawa Senators during preseason NHL action at the Air Canada Centre September 19, 2011 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Abelimages/Getty Image

Abelimages/Getty Images

Dion Phaneuf is still one of the more physical players in the league, yet has missed just 22 games in six seasons. He has also never failed to score 30 points, and at just 26 years old, he should bounce back from his worst season (66 GP, 30 pts., -2, 88 PIM).

14: Mike Green

WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 13: Mike Green #52 of the Washington Capitals hits Marian Gaborik #10 of the New York Rangers in Game One of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Verizon Center on April 13, 2011 in Washin

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

Mike Green is known mostly for his offence, but is just big enough and skates well so as not to be a defensive liability. He will turn 26 at the start of the season, so his best days should remain ahead.

His biggest problem is injuries, as he missed 33 games last season and 21 more in the two years prior. With upgrades to the team's defence, he should be able to see his 25:11 TOI decrease, as he is used less in his own end and more on the attack. Expect a return to closer to the point per game days of the previous two years than last year's rate of half that.

13: Keith Yandle

GLENDALE, AZ - APRIL 20: Keith Yandle #3 of the Phoenix Coyotes skates with the puck in Game Four of the Western Conference Quarterfinals against the Detroit Red Wings during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Jobing.com Arena on April 20, 2011 in Glen

Christian Petersen/Getty Images

Keith Yandle had a breakthrough season in 2010-11. This season, he will have less team support, putting him in for more situations but also drawing the attention of the opposition more. Because of the amount they will go through him offensively, he should improve on last year's five points per seven games and over 25 minutes of ice time, but his plus-12 rating will take a hit.

12: Jack Johnson

LOS ANGELES, CA - APRIL 25: Jack Johnson #3 of the Los Angeles Kings controls the puck as Scott Nichol #21 of the San Jose Sharks looks to take possesion in the first period of game six of the Western Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley

Harry How/Getty Images

Jack Johnson's 42 points were a mild improvement over the previous season offensively, but I expect this 24-year-old to focus his attention on the defensive end. He has the physique and skill-set to be a shut-down defender, but has never finished a season in the plus. His minus-21 last season was due in large part to facing the other team's top line, but he is also on the ice in scoring situations and should see a new career high for points and plus-minus.

11: Dan Boyle

VANCOUVER, CANADA - MAY 24: Dan Boyle #22 of the San Jose Sharks controls the puck in Game Five of the Western Conference Finals against the Vancouver Canucks during the 2011 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Rogers Arena on May 24, 2011 in Vancouver, British Colu

Harry How/Getty Images

At 35 years old, Dan Boyle's best days are supposed to be behind him. However, last season he played the second-most minutes in the league and registered 50 points in 76 games. His skating ability is crucial to San Jose's puck possession, as he is often left to get the puck out of his own end.

While Boyle's skating, knowledge and hustle makes him a good defender, his lack of size and proclivity to join the rush necessitate being paired up with a stay-at-home defender like Douglas Murray to avoid assignment break-downs. With the addition of Brent Burns, Boyle will likely play fewer minutes in his own end and do what he does best, which is quarterbacking the power play and other offensive zone sets, keeping his scoring near last year's levels.

10: Dustin Byfuglien

MONTREAL, CANADA - MARCH 29: Carey Price #31 of the Montreal Canadiens watches the rebounding puck on an attempt by Dustin Byfuglien #33 of the Atlanta Thrashers during the NHL game at the Bell Centre on March 29, 2011 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. (Phot

Richard Wolowicz/Getty Images

One of Dustin Byfuglien's best assets is his versatility. He can play forward and is among the best in the league at crowding the net. He can play on the blue line and be responsible and physical defensively.

Either way, he scores points. Last season, Byfuglien scored 53 in 81 games with just a minus-two rating on a struggling team. While the excessive travel of Winnipeg will hurt all players on the team, the energy from the city getting a team back should make up for it at home. Expect him to perform at least equal to last year in almost every statistical category.

9: Chris Pronger

PHILADELPHIA, PA - APRIL 30: Chris Pronger #20 of the Philadelphia Flyers hits Zdeno Chara #33 of the Boston Bruins in Game One of the Eastern Conference Semifinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at the Wells Fargo Center on April 30, 2011 in Ph

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

Chris Pronger is beginning to wear down. His heavy workload showed in the 2010 Stanley Cup Finals, where he was owned by Chicago's forwards. Last season, he missed 32 games and his minutes were reduced.

However, Pronger defends the real estate in front of the net as well as anyone in the league outside of Zdeno Chara. He is still an intimidating presence, and still a great passer, allowing him to put up a point per two games for 12 consecutive seasons. He may fall short of that mark next season, but not by much.

8: Ryan Suter

VANCOUVER, CANADA - MAY 7: Jannik Hansen #36 of the Vancouver Canucks tries to get past Ryan Suter #20 of the Nashville Predators during the third period in Game Five of the Western Conference Semifinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs on May 07,

Rich Lam/Getty Images

Ryan Suter is half of the one-two punch that earned Nashville its first playoff series win. And at 26, he should continue to grow as a player.

Over the last three seasons, Suter has scored more than a point per two games (39 in 70 games last season) but he is an asset on both ends of the ice. Not only can he advance the puck out of his zone, but he can protect it without spending too much time in the penalty box (54 PIM last season).

7: Nicklas Lidstrom

DETROIT, MI - MARCH 30: Nicklas Lidstrom #5 of the Detroit Red Wings looks on the St. Louis Blues at Joe Louis Arena on March 30, 2011 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images)

Gregory Shamus/Getty Images

There is little reason to think Nicklas Lidstrom's days are numbered by anything more than his own decision to retire soon. The 41-year-old has only once missed more than six games in a season, and won his seventh Norris Trophy last season, all after the age of 30.

However, he probably should not have won it. He finished below even for the first time in his 19-year career, and played fewer minutes than 39 other defencemen around the league. While he was third among NHL defencemen in points per game, his 62 points in 82 games were 13 more than the previous season. That represents a more likely result in 2011-12.

6: Brent Seabrook

CHICAGO, IL - APRIL 24: Brent Seabrook #7 of the Chicago Blackhawks fires the puck against the Vancouver Canucks in Game Six of the Western Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at the United Center on April 24, 2011 in Chicago

Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

Brent Seabrook shouldered much of the load with the mass exodus of the Stanley Cup champion roster of 2010. He played over 24 minutes on average in every game and finished even against other teams' best forwards for a team that finished 15th in record and spent only 47 minutes in the penalty box all season.

He also is developing his offensive game, scoring 48 points last season. With the loss of Brian Campbell, he will need to play more minutes and do more scoring in 2011-12.

5: Drew Doughty

SAN JOSE, CA - APRIL 23: Drew Doughty #8 of the Los Angeles Kings in action during their game against the San Jose Sharks in game five of the Western Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at HP Pavilion on April 23, 2011 in Sa

Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

Drew Doughty is in a contract dispute. There are questions about his satisfaction and commitment with the Los Angeles Kings. But I expect him to miss minimal time, and by the time he turns 22 mid-season, he will be no worse than the fifth best defenceman playing on any given night.

In three seasons, Doughty has missed only seven games and has scored 126 points. He averaged the fifth-most minutes in the league last season and put up 40 points and a plus-13 rating playing for a defensive-minded team. With more offensive support this season, everything but his time on ice (25:38) should go up.

4: Brent Burns

ST PAUL, MN - MARCH 22: Brent Burns #8 of the Minnesota Wild skates against the Toronto Maple Leafs at the Xcel Energy Center on March 22, 2011 in St Paul, Minnesota. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

Brent Burns is the total package. He has skating ability, skill, size and toughness. At just 26 years old, he will only get better.

Burns managed 46 points in a bounce back season after missing 23 and 35 games the previous two years. He also has 133 points in his last 268 games playing for one of the worst scoring teams in the league. Expect him to break out now that he is with one of the most high-powered offences in the NHL under coach Todd McLellan.

3: Duncan Keith

CHICAGO, IL - APRIL 24: Corey Crawford #50 of the Chicago Blackhawks knocks the puck between the legs of teammate Duncan Keith #2 against the Vancouver Canucks in Game Six of the Western Conference Quarterfinals during the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at

Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

Duncan Keith is one of only three active players with a Norris Trophy to his name in this millennium. Like Seabrook, he took on a heavy burden in 2010-11 with the loss of so many players, leading the league in minutes at just under 27 per game while playing in every game.

His offensive production suffered, but he still put up 45 points while finishing minus-one with just 22 PIM. Just like Seabrook, he will continue to have to carry big minutes with the departure of Campbell, but should be able to handle it while seeing his scoring increase by about a third.

2: Shea Weber

BALTIMORE, MD - SEPTEMBER 20: Shea Weber #6 of the Nashville Predators checks D.J. King #17 of the Washington Capitals at the 1st Mariner Arena on September 20, 2011 in Baltimore, Maryland. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

A record-setting contract for a defenceman his age might be too much for many players to handle. But while Weber is barely old enough to legally drink in the United States, he is the team captain and has handled heavier pressure just being asked to carry that franchise.

With Ryan Suter to help carry the load, the defenceman should be able to handle the loss of more talent as he does every year. An absolute beast on both ends of the ice, he played the eighth most minutes in the NHL last season and tabulated 16 goals, 32 assists, a plus-seven rating and just 56 PIM. While his time on ice may not increase, his best days are ahead of him and he should produce at least as much offensively in 2011-12.

1: Zdeno Chara

VANCOUVER, BC - JUNE 15: NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman presents the Stanley cup to Zdeno Chara #33 of the Boston Bruins after defeating the Vancouver Canucks in Game Seven of the 2011 NHL Stanley Cup Final at Rogers Arena on June 15, 2011 in Vancouver, B

Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

Zdeno Chara was the most dominant defenceman over the entire ice last season, finishing 19th in scoring and best in the league in plus-minus. For a hulking and intimidating defender out there against the league's best on a defensive-minded team, finishing top-20 in either is an accomplishment.

At 34 years old, Chara still has mileage left on his skates. He has missed just 12 games in five seasons in Boston and played more minutes than all but five players last season. He has been a model of consistency, scoring at least 44 points in each of his last four seasons while keeping penalty minutes below 100 in each of the last three.

With the Bruins blue line being among the deepest in the league, he may have minutes reduced slightly and he may well fall just short of his 44-point mark, but there will still be no better all-purpose defenceman.

Begin Slideshow