“I still feel I can play and contribute to a team,” Primeau told the Sun. “Hopefully someone steps forward and gives me a chance.”
“My ultimate wish is to come back to Toronto for another season and be a veteran (presence) to help the younger guys. But it seems to be looking dimmer and dimmer as the days go on.”
With the Maple Leafs becoming a younger team each year and very unlikely to win the Stanley Cup this season, is it really fitting for a 15-year veteran who has never won a Stanley Cup to return to Toronto?
The Maple Leafs have too many bottom-six forwards (which Primeau is) for him to fit on the roster. Even if he were to play on the wing, he still wouldn’t fit. Colby Armstrong, Luca Caputi, Colton Orr, Mike Brown, and Fredrick Sjostrom all have more important roles with the Maple Leafs, and add just as much grit, if not more.
At age 35, if Primeau were to return to the Maple Leafs, he would be the oldest player on the roster (current oldest player is Jean-Sebastien Giguere at age 33) and the oldest forward on the roster by seven years.
Not just that, but the signing of Primeau would also take away crucial cap space from general manager Brian Burke, who is currently trying to use that cap space, and possibly Tomas Kaberle, to fill the forward hole in the Maple Leafs lineup.
With that being said, not only would returning to Toronto be a poor career decision by Primeau, but it would also be a poor decision by Burke, who already has enough veterans on the roster.
Primeau has scored just 194 points (69 goals, 125 assists) in 774 regular season games. Three of those goals and five of those assists came in 54 games with the Maple Leafs in 2009-2010. He was acquired from the Calgary Flames in July of 2009 along with a 2011 second-round draft pick for Anton Stralman, Colin Stuart, and a 2012 seventh-round draft pick.