Shawn Thornton's Sucker Punch on Brooks Orpik Shows the Ugliest Side of Hockey

Jonathan WillisNHL National ColumnistDecember 7, 2013

BOSTON, MA - DECEMBER 07: Brooks Orpik #44 of the Pittsburgh Penguins is carted off of the ice on a stretcher by the medical staff in the first period after an altercation with Shawn Thornton #22 of the Boston Bruins during the game at TD Garden on December 7, 2013 in Boston, Massachusetts.  (Photo by Jared Wickerham/Getty Images)
Jared Wickerham/Getty Images

It took less than a minute for Saturday’s game between the Boston Bruins and Pittsburgh Penguins to get physical, and unfortunately for hockey fans, it didn’t stop with clean hits or fighting. Instead, the contest showcased the ugliest side of the NHL game, which everybody with interest in the sport should support abolishing. 

And once again, it was an enforcer in the starring role. 

It started with a hard check from Pittsburgh defenseman Brooks Orpik on Bruins winger Loui Eriksson. Eriksson was reaching behind his body for a puck coming off the boards and consequently was hunched over. Orpik caught him squarely with a hit.

Orpik closed on Eriksson as the puck approached him; the referee could have called him for interference given that the puck seemed to miss Eriksson's stick just as Orpik lands the hit. But given that it was a last-second bounce that kept this from being a 100 percent legal check, it would be unfair to criticize Orpik too harshly for making the hit (and after all, it was too late for him to abort after the puck slipped past).

Boston retaliated immediately, as an obviously agitated Zdeno Chara took a run at Pittsburgh’s Pascal Dupuis (which the forward barely avoided) and then engaged Chris Kunitz, taking a penalty on the play.

The concern for Eriksson was understandable. As the commentators note in the video above, he missed five games with a concussion earlier this season, courtesy of a John Scott cheap shot. Eriksson left the game and did not return. It was later determined that he suffered a concussion. 

No fan wants to see a player get injured, but if everything had ended there, this would simply have been an unfortunate result of a hard but acceptable check. Instead, things got worse.

In their first shift against each other, enforcer Shawn Thornton took a long run at Orpik (who took the hit and moved the puck) and then engaged him repeatedly. Orpik declined to fight him, so Thornton went to the box. Pittsburgh scored on the ensuing power play.

The hitting continued, escalating to a fight between Milan Lucic and Deryk Engelland that solved nothing.  

Eventually, the heated emotions led to a pair of brutal incidents on the same shift.

The first play saw James Neal knee Brad Marchand in the head while the Bruins forward was down on the ice. It’s impossible to know exactly what went through Neal’s mind on the play, but the two players do have some history with each other, and there’s no arguing the fact that Neal nailed a defenseless opponent in the worst possible spot.

The NHL’s Department of Player Safety investigated the incident, and handed down a five-game suspension for Neal.

In the next play seconds later, there’s absolutely no doubt as to intent. Shawn Thornton, the Bruins forward who averages 10 minutes in penalties for every point he’s collected over his NHL career, grabs an unsuspecting Orpik, throws him to the ice and then punches him in the face repeatedly with his gloves still on.  

The good news is that Marchand was able to return to the game. Orpik wasn’t so lucky; he was taken to Massachusetts General Hospital, where the only positive is that he was described by the Penguins as “alert and conscious.”

Orpik was released from the hospital in time to fly back to Pittsburgh with his teammates, but has been placed on injured reserve with a concussion.

It is a game that shows, yet again, why NHL enforcers are not functional as policemen.

Thornton did his best to exact what NHL Network commentator (and famous Bruins homer) Jack Edwards called “pioneer justice” on Orpik, but the Pens defenseman wasn’t willing to oblige. That cost the Bruins. Then, stymied, Thornton decided that next time around he wasn’t going to give Orpik the option and did something indistinguishable from assault.   

Some will, and have, criticized Orpik for not fighting Thornton here. But Orpik, who has all of one fight in five years, was under no obligation to ritually drop the gloves with a player who wouldn’t be in the league if not for the fact that he can go toe-to-toe with heavyweights.

And nothing Orpik did justifies Thornton’s actions. The Boston enforcer recognized that his attack on the Pens defenseman was reprehensible. 

It's hard for me to talk about right now. I can't say I'm sorry enough. I'm sure I'll be criticized, but it's true. I felt awful. It wasn't my intention. I know Brooksie. I've gotten to know him the last seven years here. I skated with him during the lockout. I texted him a couple of times. It's not what I wanted to see or anyone to see.

There simply isn’t an excuse for grabbing an unsuspecting opponent, throwing him to the ice and punching him (with hockey gloves, no less) as he lies there. The fact that Thornton is going to get a brief suspension and then return to the NHL should be a source of profound shame for the league.

Thornton’s the headliner here, but toss in a filthy play by Neal against a vulnerable opponent and a game that should have showcased the best of two of the NHL’s strongest teams instead shows the very worst of a league that seems utterly incapable of removing mindless and reprehensible violence from the game.