.png?w=1280 "NHL Trade Grades")
NHL Trade Grades for Rangers-Golden Knights Deal for Pavel Dorofeyev
The Rangers needed something big after a terrible season that left the team with zero direction. They were not in on the big names available — Brady Tkachuk and Dylan Larkin among them — and it was becoming increasingly unclear where the infusion of talent would come from.
Dorofeyev is a big move, and it comes out of nowhere.
Is this bold move a step in the right direction for the Rangers, who have holes at many positions? Why are the Vegas Golden Knights, who love to contend and hate draft picks, moving out a player in his prime years?
Let's analyze what this move indicate for both the Rangers and Golden Knights
New York Rangers
1 of 2
The Rangers have a lot of boxes they need their acquisitions to check. This organization desperately needs high-end talent, goal-scoring ability, and youth.
Dorofeyev is a match for all three. The Russian winger scored 37 goals last season, beating a career-high of 35 from the season before. Dorofeyev is good at getting open in scoring positions and then absolutely ripping it. His release is elite. He's the ultimate trigger man on the power play, but he's not someone who needs to wait along the perimeter to rip one-timers. He'll anticipate puck movements and battle to get into openings in the slot to score, including at five-on-five.
There are limitations to his game. He's someone who best operates off the puck. He won't drive possession by creating zone entries or holding pucks in the offensive zone. To his credit, he's not a defensive liability, but he won't be a player sent over the boards for defensive shifts, nor will he amaze anyone with meaningful physical play.
Those limitations raise questions about where he fits in the Rangers' puzzle. This team badly needs players who can drive possession and dictate play with the puck at even strength. Dorofeyev is neither of those archetypes. Last season, Dorofeyev played on a line with Mitch Marner, an elite needle-mover. The Rangers don't have any sort of player who can match that. And if the Rangers don't add some defensemen who can move the puck up the ice, then he won't get the opportunities to produce.
This also creates a bit of a mess on the power play, where he needs to play in order to thrive. Who will come off the top PP unit to make room for him? If this shifts Gabe Perreault or Alexis Lafreniére back to PP2, then that's a problem.
He's not a perfect player for the Rangers, but it's hard to complain about adding a soon-to-be 26-year-old first-liner who scores 35-plus goals. Especially at the cost of 26th overall, 92nd overall, and a protected 2028 first-round pick.
The reported seven-year contract, worth $11 million annually, is also about on par with what Dorofeyev provides and will take him to age 33.
It's a good first step for the Rangers, but they still have a lot of questions to answer before they have this ship turned around.
Grade: B+
Vegas Golden Knights
2 of 2
Losing Dorofeyev is painful for Vegas. He was a major contributor to the team's run to the Stanley Cup Final, scoring 12 goals in 22 playoff games. He was an ideal player to take advantage of the team's stable of playmakers. So what's going on here?
It's a simple math problem. Dorofeyev is a restricted free agent and due for a seismic raise from his $1.84 million cap hit in 2025-26. A raise by roughly $9 million, in fact. Vegas is working with less than $5 million in cap space at the moment, with some depth holes to fill. To keep him would have required moving out several other players. With Mitch Marner and Mark Stone at the top of the lineup, he was apparently a player management identified as one they could live without going forward.
Vegas acquires three draft picks here, including two first-round picks. I consider myself skeptical they'll be keeping both of those firsts. Vegas historically has taken the Mikal Bridges approach to the draft. They're hungry to win a second Stanley Cup, and their run this past season will only boost that ambition.
They woke up today with just one first-round pick in the next three drafts (2028). Now they own three. What comes next? Is it Dylan Larkin from Detroit? Zach Werenski from Columbus? Pick any remotely notable name connected to the trade market, and that player could now be Vegas-bound. There's another part of this equation we need to see before fully understanding what Vegas is doing here.
Grade: A-
