Jeremy Mayfield: Guilty, Broke, or Just Plain Finished?

Charles AllenCorrespondent IMay 18, 2010

TALLADEGA, AL - APRIL 24:  Jeremy Mayfield, driver of the #41 All Sport Body Quencher Toyota, waits in the garage area during practice for the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Aaron's 499 at Talladega Superspeedway on April 24, 2009 in Talladega, Alabama.  (Photo by Jerry Markland/Getty Images for NASCAR)
Jerry Markland/Getty Images

The case of suspended NASCAR driver Jeremy Mayfield was dismissed on Tuesday. Judge Graham Mullen, who has overseen the case from its onset, decided that the evidence was just not substantial.

Mayfield was initially suspended indefinitely after failing a drug test last year during the spring Richmond weekend and had steadfastly denied ever taking illegal substances.

His legal team was able to produce enough doubt of the results that his suspension was temporarily lifted, but Mayfield never attempted to race. Another failure led to the suspension being reinstated, and a somewhat chaotic war of words ensued.

Throughout the course of the last year, Mayfield has stood by his claims and accused NASCAR of defamation. In retaliation, NASCAR obtained sworn affidavits from various individuals claiming to have witnessed drug use by Mayfield. Once again, the fallout would reach soap opera status.

Mayfield's former stepmother, who was one of the witnesses, was arrested at Mayfield's home while intoxicated. His former brother-in-law, David Keith, was suspended by NASCAR for violating the substance abuse policy. Mayfield claimed to have taken numerous drug tests on his own with no trace of drug use in his system and vowed that his name and reputation would be cleared in the end.

As the case took many different directions, one thing became obvious: Guilty or not, Jeremy Mayfield did not have the financial means to battle a major organization determined to uphold its reputation. He was forced to sell off much of his personal property, IRS liens were filed for delinquent tax payments, and his original legal team sued to recover legal fees that had gone unpaid.

While many quickly dismissed Mayfield as a drug abuser, others wondered if the possible conspiracy theories could really be possible. Sure, Mayfield had a reputation for burning bridges throughout his 17-year career, but was he merely being made an example of to benefit NASCAR's new drug policy? Did he anger the wrong person somewhere along the way?

His insistence that justice would be served led to a mix of differing opinions, and many thought the case would go to Federal court later this year.

While the dismissal came as a surprise, the reasons given for it were legitimate. As a NASCAR driver/car owner, Mayfield signed documents stating that he and his team would comply with the rules set forth by NASCAR. He also acknowledged that an individual could not sue the sanctioning body based on the results of such testing. There was also not enough solid evidence to satisfy his claims of defamation.

While no comment had been made by Mayfield or his representatives as of this article, his vehement denial and vow to fight until the bitter end to clear his name will now be questioned. Is he going to appeal the decision or simply ride away into the sunset? Have NASCAR's tremendous resources crippled the little man fighting to defend himself, or is he truly guilty?

I have personally been a fan of Mayfield since 1996 and have a sense of loyalty, but reality has set in. No longer will Jeremy Mayfield be seen racing on Sunday afternoons. No more souvenirs, and certainly no mention of a 17-year career in which moderate success was achieved. Jeremy Mayfield will be erased from NASCAR history.

While the entire situation was bizarre to say the least, one still must ask these questions: Why not just admit guilt, attend a NASCAR rehabilitation program, and be racing within a few short months? Why deplete the resources gained through years of hard work? Why would Jeremy Mayfield literally watch his entire life go up in smoke?

This seems like the logical path, though the entire case has defied logic. Whether Mayfield has quietly disappeared, run out of money, or just given up a fight he was likely to lose may never be known. The manner in which we got to this point will be remembered as a terrible case of mudslinging and back and forth negativity.

If this is the end, I hope that both parties are able to recover and that fans can remember the good done on both ends. NASCAR is an organization built on community service and goodwill toward their fans. The same can be said of Mayfield. Unfortunately for him, these contributions will likely be overlooked.